To be fully honest, this was the main purpose of my visit to Whidbey (for at least 2 out of the 3 times I've visited so far). Praised as the "Best Pie Place" in Seattle, I had to see for myself what their pies were like. Situated in Langley, its a small storefront that is connected to a similarly sized cafe. In front there are some parking spots that usually aren't full. They sell pies by the slice, whole pies, and there are even frozen whole pie options available in the freezer. There is complimentary water but not much seating options. The pies are baked daily I believe BUT if you have the chance to get one of the freshly baked pies (only been on the shelf an hour or so), you'll get some of the most beautiful crust experiences. All 3 times I've been I've reached for the Marionberry pie and every single time it's been a hit for whoever I end up bringing here. They have gluten free options for the pies as well but there is no guarantee that there would be a gluten free option for every pie-- I could be wrong on that, I would recommend calling in advance. A wonderful little pie store for a lovely little town, I would definitely come back again! The first time I asked the person behind the counter about the flavor profile of their Marionberry and their seasonal flavor, they were super helpful and descriptive. I saw that they now sell their pies through retailers now which would let me have their pies without having to travel as far. Love the pie here and love the ambiance of this small store! read more

Whidbey Pies - Desserts Near Me - Langley, Washington

I swung by the small downtown shop expecting big things, and Whidbey Pie certainly looks the part: a compact, friendly storefront selling whole pies and slices in classic flavors (apple, blueberry, mixed berry, and strawberry-rhubarb). I ordered a slice of apple pie; the staff kindly offered to warm it up, which was a thoughtful touch and appreciated on a cool island afternoon. The slice arrived warm and comforting -- flaky crust, tender apple filling, and a pleasant cinnamon note. It wasn't a showstopper for me and felt a little overhyped compared with the glowing word-of-mouth, but it was a solid, satisfying pie slice that hits the nostalgic notes you want from a bakery apple pie. If you're touring downtown and want a convenient, friendly spot for pie by the slice (or to take a whole pie home), Whidbey Pie is worth a stop. If you expect an unforgettable culinary revelation, temper expectations -- it's reliably good rather than transcendent. read more

See all

I actually found this bakery on TikTok and was excited to check it out. The staff was friendly, and the shop was welcoming. I was expecting a larger selection based on what I'd seen online, but they had fewer options than I anticipated. I tried one of the pies, and it just wasn't my favorite. It had a sour flavor that wasn't really for me, although that could just come down to personal taste since I'm not much of a pie person. Overall, it was still a nice visit with friendly service. read more

Was visiting on a day trip and wanted some dessert so stopped by Whidbey Pies. They sell by the slice and also by the pie. We ended up getting a whole Marionberry and apple pie and shared them between our group. There's a coffee shop right next door as well if you want some coffee to go with your fresh pie. Cute store and friendly staff (possibly owner). read more

See all

A must try! I was always kind of "meh" with pies but the first time I tried one of these, I finally understood. The caramel apple is my families favorite for fall and I love the strawberry rhubarb, but you really can't go wrong with any of the flavors. The crust is delicious and so is the filling! You can taste that they are made locally with quality ingredients and are 100x better than the mass produced ones. I also love that all of their packaging is compostable! You can get pies from their Langley store or at the Greenbank farm! They have them in a few other stores as well. I could honestly eat a slice every single day and I would never get tired. I recommend Whidbey Pies to everyone and love to bring them to holidays or parties so more people can try them! read more

These aren't pies like your mom made, they're likely better. One of the best cherry pies I've ever had, rhubarb, marionberry... Sure the fillings are great, but crucially the crust is light and flaky. Love these pies! read more

Not my first time eating Whidbey Pies, but it was my first time at this little location- I really should have bought a whole pie for Thanksgiving- but instead I bought a slice of pear-cranberry pie. Omgoodness- it was delicious and very similar to apple pie. Shockingly so. Since I didn't buy a whole pie, I had to bake my own- but this is definitely a wonderful substitute if you don't bake! Highly recommend!! read more

See all

We picked up a strawberry rhubarb pie that was amazing!! A tad on the pricey side for a pie but for our vacation or a special occasion I'd certainly buy other pies. My brother had a slice of the classic cherry pie and each of us who tasted it found it delightful! read more

Amazing gluten free pie! What an amazing treat as most places don't have gf. A must stop!

Whidbey Pies knows how to make a delicious treat! The marionberry was our favorite; absolutely delicious!

Overall good flavor. Disappointed with the thickness and texture of the crust and the filling did not look like pictures on their website. read more

Whidbey Pies - Marionberry - Desserts Near Me - Langley, Washington

It's finally time to come forth to say that Whidbey Pies have consistently gone downhill since new owners took over. We ordered both an apple pie and pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving. The apple was tasteless and had the texture of runny apple sauce, not one guest finished their slice and the remainder went into the garbage. The pumpkin had way too much spice that completely over powered it but the grandkids did eat the crust. Unfortunately our Holiday tradition with Whidbey Pies has come to an end. read more

Came here to try out one of their pies. We got the strawberry rhubarb pie and it was very good. I thought it had good filling and the pie crust was good too. The people working here were also very friendly. I would come back here again. read more

See all

My family have been going to WHIDBEY PIES for years. WHIDBEY PIES are consistently good, well filled with the listed ingredients and DELICIOUS! At their store or on your local grocery shelves you can choose WHIDBEY PIES and know your family will be happy. read more

The famous Whidbey Pie in Whidbey!! I've had them from the Met market before and they are always everyone's favorite. So glad to made it in person to their Whidbey location and met the pie master Bob! He's so nice!! Pies are delicious and oh so good!! They currently have Rhubarb, Strawberry Rhubarb, Cherry, Granny Smith apple and Marion Berry. You can also do take and bake pies too. The shop is so cute, bright and happy. And dog friendly! Baci loved Bob!! He was so nice. I got Marion Berry and it was chef kiss! So good, got strawberry rhubarb to go as well! So glad to made it to my favorite pie shop! Delicious fun stop. Woot woot. We love Whidbey pies! read more

See all

On our first visit to Whidbey Island, we saw this cute little pie store and decided to get some pies. We got slices of triple berry, marionberry and cherry. All were delicious, the crust was perfect! The owner/manager there was so kind and helpful. My son said this was the best pie he's ever eaten. Place is dog friendly and connects to a coffee shop that offers free whipped cream on top. We will visit again when we are in the area! read more

I've tried two flavors of Whidbey Pies, Strawberry Rhubarb and Granny Apple. I like the pie fillings well enough, but they need to work on their crusts. The crust are too thin and they are not flaky. . read more

Whidbey Pies - Desserts Near Me - Langley, Washington

We buy these all the time in Issaquah. Oh my goodness when you buy them made that day they are amazing so much fruit and perfect crust. Service was excellent and the woman was very patient with my husband and three sons asking a lot of questions. We bought three pies Yum. read more

There are not enough stars in this world to capture the experience of a cup of coffee here and a slice of marionberry pie just out of the oven. This place is an absolute gem... totally timeless. The kind of establishment that puts the world on pause in the best way. read more

The best pie in the NW, maybe the country. This shop alone is worth a ferry ride to Langley. Everyone is nuts for the delicious Marionberry, but don't miss the rhubarb pie when in season. read more

Have you ever driven almost two hours plus a ferry ride to get a pie? We did. Well worth it for the mouthwatering seasonal Huckleberry pie. We called ahead to reserve one, as the supply was limited. Their other pies looked amazing too, but the Huckleberry was the best pie we ever ate. Something for you (and us) to plan for next fall. read more

Though we have seen and tried Whidbey Pies in stores like Met Market, I had never actually visited their location and had a slice there. On Saturday we had an opportunity to do that -- and we were not disappointed! My wife had the Marionberry and I had Spiced Apple Cider (an apple pie). I liked Whidbey Pies when I bought them in the stores but this was a whole other experience. The fruit tasted so fresh and the crust was the perfect combination of buttery and flakiness. If you happen to be on Whidbey Island, take some time to have a slice of fresh pie! read more

Delicious pies. The crust is outstanding. It is hard to believe that they have such tasty crumbly crust. Their blackberry pie is one of the best I have ever had. read more

Best pies ever!!!!! We come from Las Vegas just to get these pies. You can tell they're made with love and by pie bakers who care about their product. The only problem is stopping at one slice. read more