There's no reason for you to ever go here. I have given my star rating a lot of thought, and although this was going to be a three-star rating in the middle of my meal last night, the more I thought about it, the fewer stars I wanted to give. People come to this area for a good seafood meal and dining experience. You can find much, much better elsewhere. Why should I encourage you to go here with even TWO stars? This ONE STAR rating is my attempt to plead with you to spend your money elsewhere.
The Hoff and I went here for dinner our first night, and it was the biggest disappointment of the Magical Mystery Trip. I came here anticipating a great experience given the reviews I read. The atmosphere must be affecting reviewers, because the food and service were both disappointing.
Everything started out ok with both of us ordering the local beer on tap. I had the red, and the Hoff had the brown ale. I started with clam chowder (their 82 year recipe or something like that) and the Hoff had the calamari and shrimp.
For dinner, the Hoff had ordered the "lazy lobster" and I went with the Maine crabcakes.
The chowder was very good, so I was encouraged. I tried the calamari and shrimp; I wasn't impressed. Both seemed flavorless. The Hoff didn't say much about them.
Then we waited...and waited...and waited... Finally, the food appeared. My crabcake was not really warm. I should have sent it back, but I was hungry. The crabcake didn't taste like it had much meat in it. Instead, it was like a combination of sawdust and seeds - seriously, there were these seeds in there like the kind you find in mustard. I guess those would be mustard seeds. Yes! But they didn't give the crabcake any flavor. I really think the sawdust description is apt. How sad.
The Hoff's lazy lobster was tough and chewy. It was either overcooked or old lobster. The asparagus was tiny, but they gave you more than two spears, so that was a plus.
We figured something must have happened with our meals to cause them to be so delayed. Maybe they were just sitting there waiting for the waiter to bring them to us. I don't know. We saw other people eating around us who came in after us.
To his credit, the waiter was nice and attentive - as attentive as he could be given we waited to long without food. But it was telling that when he removed our plates and saw that neither of us had even eaten half of our entree that he didn't ask if we enjoyed the meal. It must have been obvious.
Before he could hand me the dessert menu, I handed him my credit card and we were out of there.
Sorry, Waterfront Restaurant, you disappointed us. Maybe we caught you on a bad night, but we'll never know. read more