Vito's Midtown Pizza is a great takeout-only spot that delivers exactly what you want from a classic pizza place. No indoor seating, just no-frills pizza done right. The slices are large, New York-style, and come out piping hot (literally steaming when we opened the box). We ordered both the Hawaiian and their version of the Supreme, and both were really satisfying. Good balance of toppings, solid crust, and plenty of flavor without feeling overdone. Pricing felt very reasonable for the portion sizes, especially considering how filling the slices are. It's the kind of place you go when you want reliable, hot pizza without overthinking it. We'd absolutely order from here again next time we're in Wilmington. read more

Vito's Midtown Pizza - Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

See all

I ordered two mushroom pizzas and they give me two pepperoni pizza. I have an allergen to pepperoni and they can't even take an order right now. Now I have to wait for the manager to contact me. Because they are closing This place went down hill read more

My daughter wanted pizza Lastnight and we ordered a half white/half veggie 18 inch pizza. Both of them were delicious but I especially liked the white pizza. They really stepped it up since the last time I ordered from here. read more

Vito's Midtown Pizza - 1/2 veggie 1/2 white - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

I'm from NY, moved here last summer and was looking for Good NY style pizza. I tried Vito's and was not disappointed. This is my go to for a traditional NY pie! Service was good as well read more

Look what I found today and it's delicious. I noticed an anonymous post the other day asking where they could find fresh lasagna sheets. Well here they are. And try the pizza while you're there. Best in ILM Vito's midtown pizza College and Long Leaf read more

See all

Delicious pizzas and a really friendly staff! We always have a good experience here whether we pick up or have it delivered.

Arguably the best pizza in wilmington. The white pizza is so good. We ordered a large pizza and cinnamon sugar desert pizza. Order time was estimated for 20 minutes. Done in 19 ‍. The desert pizza was so incredibly good my boyfriend and I ate the whole thing that night. They forgot the basil on my white pizza but it was just that good it still gets a 5 star rating from me. read more

I've ordered the pierogi pizza a few times now & if you love the taste of a real Polish pierogi in the form of a pizza... Look No Further YUM YUM YUM This pizza lets my heart & Soul go back in time with memories when I was young & making homemade pierogies with my mom.. yes who is Polish from the old country.. And yes it was an all day event Ok here it comes another CHALLENGE If you can find another place or make this Pierogi pizza in our area - - -I'll buy you a free pizza read more

Vito's Midtown Pizza - Pierogi Pizza One Word YUM - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

See all

My go-to lunch spot whenever I want a good New York style slice of pizza. Perfect combination of sauce and cheese with a crispy crust. Rare to find these pizzerias make actual NY style pizza read more

Other than our terrible experience with door dash and our pizza having to be microwaved when we finally got it, it was amazing! I wish I would have had it straight out of the oven because I'm sure it would have been even better. I don't think the staff noticed that the pizza was there for over 45 minutes late for door dash to pick up but they did not make extra measures making it better even when I had to the store to pick it up. Anyway, this was our first time there and the pizza and salad were delish! I will give it another shot. read more

Vito's Midtown Pizza - Buffalo Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

See all

Absolutely exceptional service, if you want a good pizza this is the spot to go! The employees are awesome and the pizza is great! 10 out of 10! -Adam read more

Vito's Midtown Pizza - Me and A great slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Checked out this new pizza place that opened on college road next to Enterprise. They currently don't have any indoor or outdoor table service seating but may in the future. They do have some bar stools inside and one mini table if you do want to eat there. Currently it is to-go anyway because of the coronavirus crisis. The hours are 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. at the moment but that may change after the restaurant restrictions. Their menu includes Pizza and salad. Currently they do not have dessert but may have some in the future. They didn't have salads available during my visit. One Pizza on their menu that sounded interesting was the Pierogi, which is mashed potato instead of tomato sauce, and is topped with sauteed onions. Decided to try a medium sized cheese pizza ($12.50). I was the first customer of the day. Some of the pizza crust edges were burnt and the staff member actually offered to remake the pizza. The burnt edges were really not that bad so decided to keep the original. The pizza is thin crust style. The outer crust was crispy but not so much the rest. The dough flavor was okay. There was plenty of cheese but I wished there was a little more of tomato sauce on the pizza. Overall, thought it was a good solid thin crust style cheese pizza. read more

See all

Best pizza I've found in Wilmington area!!! Great sauce (no heartburn)! Thin crispy crust. Sadly it's only takeout. No indoor dining. But worth the ride from Leland. read more

Ordered a Buffalo Chicken pie, a white pie with spinach and a regular pie with 1/2 pepperoni and half sausage. All three were solid and I enjoyed them all. Drive through pickup was a cool addition. Staff were super friendly. We will definitely be repeat customers. read more

See all

Vito's earned our business last night!! We have alternated between Vito's and another NY style pizza place. The other place was too busy to take our order last night, so we decided on Vito's. My son went to pick up our pizzas and as he was walking through the door, Vito's called to make sure we received the correct pizzas. Unfortunately, one was not correct. Without hesitation, they apologized profusely and asked for address. Within 15 minutes we were hand delivered another steaming hot pizza. Way to go Vito's!!! This is amazing customer service and you will always have our business!! Thank you!! read more

Ordered 3 pizza one cheese 2 pepperoni sausage today. Cost $67.47. Scant meat on both. Cheese looked like they took off pepperoni to make it all cheese. Tasteless pizza. First time I used them and won't again. Way overpriced. read more

(This review was personally written I never spoke to any staff) I moved down from NYC/NJ a little over a year ago and have been searching for the closest flavor and pie to meet my expectations which are extremely high. I like to try plain pies to base my experience as it's the test... and my gosh I'm SO upset I didn't find this place SOONER! IT IS SO GOOD! It's bursting with flavor the sauce has zest, the cheese is perfect and the crust is good enough that even if you pick it up late (as I did) it was DELICIOUS. I can't imagine had it been hot but that's on me plus I love cold pizza if it's good so it was oddly the best test. I HAPPILY give this 5 stars because I'm a NIGHTMARE and probably the pickiest human ever esp with pizza. Also ordering online and pickup was so easy via drive thru. This is going to be my new place!!! Thanks so much Vito's!!! read more

Vito's Midtown Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Pierogi pizza is unique and wonderful. The spinach and feta is awesome and you can't go wrong with a basic cheese pizza. Try a cookie too. read more

Crust tastes good, sauce is good but they cook it in a conveyor machine thingy, so the crust doesn't get that outer crispiness, even when you ask for it well done. I'd give this place 5 stars if they used an oven. read more

We have been going to Vito's for the past few years the Mid town location is very convenient to us. We love the drive thru pick up. We love that they expanded their menu to include take and bake items, pasta and wings. What prompted me to leave this review is that I've noticed the service and food quality is going up and getting better which isn't usually the case in the food industry. Our Vito's seems to be getting better and better. Try the Pierogi pizza I think it's their signature Pie. We love it and anyone we have turned on to it has never been disappointed. We have family that comes from out of town and request that pizza specifically every time! Our 5 yo Old son loves it as well! They definitely are doing things right at this local business. read more

Ordered delivery from here last night - got a cheese pizza, the BLT salad, and the cinnamon swirl pizza. Everything was pretty good; would order again. read more

Vito's Midtown Pizza - Cinnamon swirl pizza (couldn't get a pic before a slice was devoured) - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Our go to pizza place, they deliver ( order directly in their website to save some $$ and earn points). Best pizza in Wilmington ( former New Yorkers, so we know our pizza). read more

Excellent pizza and even better service! The staff is friendly and helpful! Cannot go wrong with Vito's!

The pizza was excellent. The issue that needs to be addressed, delivery, which they use Grubb hub and they absolutely suck. I gave them specific instructions on where and what to do for the delivery. All they did is leave it at the door never knocked or notified us. read more

Terrible experience making a first attempt to order pizza from this restaurant. I went online, provided my credit card information, telephone number, and then submitted text code I was sent. Then I was told they needed more contact information from me, without explaining what they were needed. After numerous attempts I called the restaurant. There they told me they didn't know anything about the order and I should contact the company I ordered through (such as DoorDash). But I had ordered from their website and wanted reassurance that my credit card information was not going to be used and was safe. Person on phone seemed confused and said he would check. He then hung up on me. Way too many great pizza places in Wilmington to be treated like this. Highly encourage folks go to one of the many other places instead. read more

GAWDAWFUL. I'm pretty sure someone took a Piggly Wiggly brands frozen pizza, chucked a few toppings on a medium and said 20 $ please. Guys. It was complete garbage. The crust was cardboard + concrete + burned. The rest was barely passable. Hands down the WORST. And this is from someone who says there is no such thing as bad pizza. Go ANYWHERE but here. read more

Great texture, taste, portion and price! Staff is friendly and gripe is they are not open all the time. Favorite so far is the pierogi and the white pizza. read more

Pizza is just ok. The pricing per topping is pretty expensive for how many toppings they actually put on there. I asked the young lady if they made their own ranch there. She said yes, but when I picked up the pizza they are kens brand ranch. It was gross. read more

This is usually a go to pizza joint for us. The Margherita pizza is our fave, but we've tried almost all of them. Great pizza. Terrible service every time. read more

Ordered curbside pizza over the phone, when I got there the cashier came out to meet me as soon as pulled up, ran my card on a handheld and brought the pizza right out. Fast and friendly, Easy as pie. Pizzas were tasty, thin crust style. No complaints. Only thing is 45$ for two pizzas is a bit pricey in my book, so this probably will not be our regular thing. read more

We are from NY and worked and lived on Long Island and Manhattan, Bronx and Brooklyn and this pizza is one of the closest NY slice. So the reviews where people say this isn't a NY slice probably live upstate or just don't know good NY pizza. The other complaints were the slice is to thin... that's what a NY slice is so maybe you need to find a domino's that might be your jam. The only con is there is no dinning in and the staff hasn't been very friendly. However the pizza is very good. read more

Certainly better than Dominos or Ceaser but absolutely not close to NY pizza! Dough was soft and hung when folded, ewww, and pretty scant on sauce and cheese. No olive oil at all. Pretty bland. Even tho I only live about a mile I'd rather drive to Ogden or Front st for real pizza! Born and raised in NY so I do know pizza! read more

Spent weekend in Wilmington visiting my daughter and craving New York Style pizza! Vito's did not disappoint!!! Will be a must have next visit!!!! read more

My fiancé is from NY and does not think they should be able to call this pizza NY style. The crust is normal thickness, but the pizza itself has very little too it, paper thin. It's like paying full price for half the ingredients. He said it might've had decent flavor but there was so little to it that it was barely enjoyable. He ordered a medium cheese pizza and to give them the benefit of the doubt he says maybe their large would be better, but he has no interest in trying them again based on how little there was to the medium. He was very disappointed. It's too bad because the location is convenient, the service was decent, and the pizza was ready when I went to pick it up for him. I didn't try it because I don't do dairy but my fiancé loves pizza, "knows pizza" and does not recommend. read more

THE PIZZA IS AMAZING - it would be a 5 star if the service wasn't so ridiculously awful. No management present, a couple of kids running around yelling at each other. Yikes! read more

Best pizza in Wilmington! I'm gonna see if Portnoy will come down and review it!! One bite everyone knows the rules!

This pizza is just not great. The crust and marinara lack much flavor. The staff is awesome and very friendly. Have never really cared for the Vito's at WB (tourist trap) but decided to try this one out since all of our other favorite spots were closed. As I said before the staff was super friendly and welcoming, just was not impressed with the food. We got a Hawaiian pizza and Caprese Salad. The salad is pretty standard and was good. The pizza just did not have the flavor needed. It was very soggy and cold. Not sure if it was not enough marinara or if their marinara recipe lacks Italian seasoning but it just was not there. I doubt I will be back but would definitely consider it due to the friendliness of the staff. read more

A very good pizza! Not a generic crust or sauce, tasty. Delivery was fast and they sent texts to let you know that it was in its way. Recommended. read more

Great pizza. Love the dough they use as the crust is out of the world. It was a fluke ordering from them, but glad I did

best pizza ever... amazing costumer service! if you visit wrightsville you need to come here