Our go to when it comes to ordering just pizza not really big in on the appetizers or pasta dishes and the sandwiches are OK but their pizzas are amazing a little bit pricey especially if you get their white pizza($34) But we don't mind because we don't usually order in, but when we are in the mood for a pizza, we definitely choose this spot read more

After several nights of eating down at sit down restaurants in Wilmington, we wanted something low key, so decided to grab some pizza from Brooklyn Pizza Company. They also have a location near UNC Wilmington, but visited this strip mall location on Market Street since it was closer to us and reviews seemed comparable. There are several tables inside for dining in, but it's mainly a take out/delivery type of place as the set up is very utilitarian and functional without much atmosphere. That being said, the service at the counter when ordering and also when receiving food at the table was kind and friendly. We went with an order of garlic cheese bread and a large 18 inch cheese pizza. I have no basis of comparison with regards to quality or price compared to other places in the Wilmington area, but $24 for a simple pizza without toppings seemed a bit expensive. Both items were decent, but wouldn't compete with the quality of pizza ingredients I'm used to in the NJ/NY/PA area. The pizza was cooked well with a great undercarriage, albeit a bit oily, but the cheese, sauce, and crust didn't compare to the great pizza I'm spoiled with back home. That said, nothing was particularly bad, so grading on a regional curve, I'd rate Brooklyn Pizza Company a 3.5/5, which I'm happy to round up since all the employees were friendly, and it was a decent dinner overall. read more

See all

Pros and cons! Con: You pay in advance. If you want additional items you have to pay again and again. Weird. Normally you pay at the end so you tally up everything. Tip in advance. All I did was order. I have had no service so how do I know if I am going to tip and how much? Tips are "earned". All they did was walk out two pies. No follow ups, hows it going, want anything else, etc... Glad I chose a low tip value. Pros: I have had pizza in 46 states. NY pizza is The Best. Being from NYC myself I know "Brooklyn" pizza. This pizza did the name justice. Rating method: Service I would give 3 star and food 5 star, so I averaged at 4 star. We have only had the pizza, but from my experience, all things considered, I would definitely come back again. Pizza was fantastic. And when it comes down to it, thats all that really matters! read more

Brooklyn Pizza Co. - Pepperoni slices - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

See all

The food is always awesome. We have tried several dishes and it always taste in the New York flavor, which is fantastic. Service always good in a New York kind of way. :) Everything has always been good. You have to try the Jack Danial's wings. Just saying. read more

i am from jersey and never had a better pizza here till having one of theirs. after that experience i ordered to go 3 other dishes to go had those at home and was great!! read more

I read the reviews and decided this would be a great place for lunch. Unfortunately, I personally did not think this pizza was good. I had it delivered, and when it got to me it wasn't even warm and truthfully I don't think the pepperoni was even cooked. The garlic knots were good, but again not even warm. Just room temperature. I paid $27 for two pieces of pizza, garlic knots and garlic bread. Which, I wouldn't have minded the price especially for delivery but again, wasn't even warm and I'm questioning even if the toppings were cooked with it. Super bummed because I thought I'd like this place. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Co. - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Pizza was excellent! Thin crust NY style pizza and the chicken franchise were very good. We get takeout and the service is always friendly and great. I highly recommend this place. read more

Making pizza is an art. Nothing beats NJ/NY pizza but if you want something close, this is the place in NC

Fan of OC's lasagna? Whelp, lemme tell you, i never thought id find a lasagna even CLOSE to OC's. Brooklyn's is now my #1 fave & has a significantly larger serving, and is half the price. Quality consistent as is the cust svc. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Co. - Lasagna, bread - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

The Alfredo/white pizza is always a go to for my family! We love the great customer service both location's provide when ordering & picking up. I will say I feel as if the quality of the pizzas have been inconsistent lately.. maybe they are having trouble with staffing or ordering ingredients. But I will still support this small business and really appreciate them! read more

I was on a road trip, stopped for the night at a nearby hotel & took a chance on Brooklyn Pizza Co. place an order to be delivered- - excellent decision! person who took my (phone) order was pleasant & very helpful. (I live out of state & knew nothing about this restaurant before tonight.) Our pizza arrived within the promised time. delivery driver was also pleasant & friendly. pizza was delicious! excellent crust & fresh toppings. If I lived anywhere nearby, I'd quickly become "a regular". read more

Brooklyn Pizza Co. - Large (18") pepperoni & green pepper pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

For the past 20 years I have always given this place great reviews, However, on March 1st I ordered the wings with hot sauce & a meatball Parmigiana sub - both were awful. The chicken was so dry (almost no hot sauce, but the chicken itselfwas exceptionallydry too) & tasteless I wondered how old it was. Half of the meatball sub had no meatballs at all. Both went into the garbage. I called before closing so I wouldn't be a bother during their busy time & was told I would receive a credit for my order. When I tried to use that credit - I was only credited for the chicken wings. Very disappointed & saddened that their food has gone down hill. I won't be ordering again. read more

Brooklyn Pizza is our Go-To Pizza spot when we want amazing, good quality pizza at home. By far the best pizza you can get in Wilmington, NC! We've been ordering from them for years and never had anything but the best quality food with the best service. Tonight, we ordered our usual and the incorrect salad was delivered, BUT, before we even realized it, they were at our door with the correct one. Brooklyn Pizza is the real deal and we don't bother ordering pizza from anywhere else! read more

We ate in. But I'd say it's more of a take out place. Food was good. We had the Sicilian thicker crust pizza which was excellent. read more

We have finally found the best pizza in the cape fear region right on Oleander in Wilmington,Brooklyn Pizza great restaurant great employees and great service clean restrooms pizza is amazing and always cooked to perfection give it a try you will be glad you did. read more

Very good pizza! I will definitely be back. It was exactly what I was looking for. I wish I would have known abt this place sooner

Update: It's been two years and I haven't found a better pizza in Wilmington. I've tried others but the quality and consistency of the pies at this shop really are unbeatable. Every time I've asked for a well-done pizza they have absolutely nailed it and their crust is the best. read more

Horrible service!!! In the past it was a well run restaurant. Used to really enjoy there food

This place is always great. If you're looking for a New York pie or slice, go here. Don't skip out on the salads. The service is very friendly and the restaurant and kitchen seem to be spotlessly clean. There is someone for every job there and when I was watching, they all did their jobs well and with pride. The staff members were clean and not grungy looking like I've seen in many other places where people just don't seem to care anymore. This is not that kind of place. You can tell they definitely care about cleanliness and service and quality of food. They have the coolest murals on the walls. The seating area is not really that big, but they have some tables and some seats at the counter, where you can watch the magic happen. I recommend eating it there for the absolute most optimal quality but take away is good too. You can sit outside when it's warm so I imagine having your dog with you wouldn't be a big deal. read more

Pizza really is the best I've had in Wilmington. If you call in the order they text you when it's done - nice feature. Price was reasonable Since we did take out, ambiance didn't come into the equation but nope, you're not coming here for the atmosphere. read more

This is one of the best pizza places in town but their mobile/ordering site is garbage!!! I have tried to order with so many problems that they have lost a loyal customer for life. It used to be simple but there are so many technical glitches, ordering is a nightmare. I tried to redeem my free garlic knots (just had to spend $15). My order was $20 but it would let me redeem the knots because "conditions not met" !? That's just one of many. Fix your ordering problems or you will continue to lose customers. read more

The Brooklyn Pizza company was an amazing find in Wilmington. I only discovered it due to a social media story about a second location opening. My wife and I decided to try it and were not disappointed. The friendliness and helpfulness of the employees were surprising and welcomed. As my wife is temporarily on crutches. I dropped her off at the curb so I could go park. When she started towards the restaurant, one of the employees ran from behind the counter and got the door for her. I thought this was a very nice thing to do. The person attending the counter took the time to explain the menu and the already-made options that were in the case. After we ordered, we were told to sit down and that they would bring us our meal. They brought our meal and asked if we wanted any additional toppings such as oregano or grated Parmesan. After we had mentioned that we would like those toppings, he told us to remain seated and went and brought it to us and asked if there was anything else he could do for us. The service was amazing for this type of restaurant. As for the food, it was great! The pizza crust was thin and chewy. Just like a good slice of New York pizza should be. The star of the meal though was the dish they call "grandma Sicilian slice". This was full of flavor and the toppings were well-balanced. I look forward to becoming a regular customer and trying more of their offerings. read more

See all

Great place for authentic New York style pizza, made by people from New York :) Friendly staff, great food and fast delivery.

We order here often, the delivery is pretty quick if you live in ogden, (30mins on weeknights, 40-60mins friday-sunday nights) And not like most pizzeria here this place is actually open past 9pm ... not sure what. these other places are thinking closing @ 8-9pm on the weekend, they just dont get it. quality of the food: I'd like to compare them to my favorite Chinese take out place "the paper crane". They are reliable, fast, and always satisfy the craving. Pizzas: I like plain cheese pizza lightly well done, and they do it 9/10 perfectly.. As for topping they can kind of over do it, but thats easily fixable by pulling them off. Pastas: Have not been disappointed on a single one of their pasta dishes, comes with bread as well.. Apps: Id give the Apps a 3/5 stars, they can be inconstant when it comes to their apps but overall pretty good. Id give them a 5 star, but I only give 5 stars to places I'm 100% satisfied every time, we have had a few instances where they've forgotten a whole pizza, or salad, or app, and have had to wait for them to deliver it 30-60mins later... But overall a good New York style pizzeria to order delivery or take out from .. read more

Pretty solid choice for pizza, it arrived on time and was very hot! It was $19 for a large half cheese half pepperoni and I had leftover pizza for the next couple of days. Would order from here again and their menu is pretty large so there are a lot of things to try. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Co. - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

First and last for me. Coworker and myself visited for dinner and "ate in". Ordered calzone with pepperoni, mushrooms and sausage. When delivered to table I was pleasantly surprised at the size and golden color of the baked calzone. It really looked fantastic! When I cut into it, I was disappointed in the "toppings". The cheese was plentiful (if anything, maybe too much). The sausage was "sliced" as opposed to "crumbled" which I much prefer. The mushrooms had to come from a can as they were no bigger than 1/2 in max. (Reminded me of button/sliced mushrooms in a small can from grocery store. (Much prefer fresh larger mushrooms). I didn't see any pepperoni until I was about 75% through and found a clump of about 6-7 pieces lumped and stuck together and that was about all the pepperoni in the entire calzone. Yes, this is a critical review but 100% honest. I'm guessing what I had may not be what the place is known for because the delivery business out of this place was incredibly busy. As stated at the beginning, first and last visit. Bottom line.... Atmosphere... C- Staff Attitude and Friendliness...A Comfort of "dine-in"...C Food quantity.....A- Food quality....C- Overall...C read more

First things first.... I'm a pizza and Italian food snob ( Born and raised in NY ) so I don't steer people to places that don't cut the mustard.... The Pizza is as good as it gets not being in NY Proper. Also their other menu items from the Calzone's to the Stromboli are top-notch.... Take a ride by or get it delivered I sincerely doubt You'll be disappointed...... read more

This is the third time I've ordered from Brooklyn Pizza and I have never been disappointed. I tried something new, and I am very glad I did! They have delicious food, great pricing, and fast service, even on Mother's Day! Thanks guys! I can get a taste of the north here in NC! read more

Man oh man... see, when it comes time to order food from somewhere I always try to stick with local businesses. I've used Brooklyn for years as our go-to pizza caterer at the office, but also tonight when my spouse hit me with "pizza would be good for dinner". The audacity of even thinking of big pizza chains over Brooklyn should be a sin. Ordering on their own platform was a breeze. Delivery was for about an hour despite us being right down the road, but that was okay. It was delivered in about 50 mins! The guys that run this shop are always incredible, super polite and thankful for your support of their business. It's great. Okay okay, now onto the food: I created my own stromboli which was packed full of the toppings I chose including some meats and veggies. Great cheese ratio and not too greasy. The marinara is *chefs kiss* as always. Then, I wanted something else so I clicked on chicken wings. To my surprise, "Jack Daniels" was an option for sauce. If you've never had JD wings, you're missing out. Talk about nostalgia for me as my dad and I always used to get these when I was growing up. Massive wings came, so so crunchy, and cooked perfectly. And the ranch? C'mon! My fiancé got a chicken parm hero, obviously delicious and a pepperoni roll that she had no room for! From past experience, though, it'll be even better for lunch tomorrow. Thanks Brooklyn! Until next time. read more

We are from NY and this pizza is as close to NY pizza you can get. Crust is perfect and the toppings delicious will be getting this pizza again for sure!!!! Everyone should try this pizza!!! read more

Amazing pizza! glad they opened right when my previous favorite pizza place closed down

Best pizza I have found in Wilmington. Can't say much more than that, it's NY style pizza that is Head and shoulders above the competition. I was born and raised in NY and I'm happy I found this place. read more

Spinach Lasagna!! Ordered extra sauce, which it didn't need, but some places don't give enough. Of course...extra cheese!! read more

Brooklyn Pizza Co. - Spinach Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Been ordering meals and pizza from here for years. We always tip 20%. Received the wrong order, called to let them know- they said the sauce on our pizza changed colors since we requested it well done- and that s why it doesn't look or taste like vodka sauce! What?!?! This is an easy fix guys...... sean's the right pie to the people that treat you right. You just lost us and anyone we can tell- read more

Their pizza is very good, chicken Mozzarella calzone is 3 meals for me, staff of young kids are great!

This is very good pizza! The pie was hot fresh and absolutely delicious! The crew was swamped with orders and delivery apps going out but took the time to ask if the pie looked good and thank me for the tip. All other pizza joints better step up their game! read more

Yes!! Wanted something quick and just realized that Brooklyn Pizza was very close by. Now I had been meaning to try it as I'd heard good things. I ordered 2 slices with onions and sausage. I was not disappointed the crust was perfect and reminded me of NY. Generous toppings and 2 slices was more than enough. Only takeout is available but definitely go!! read more

I've only had the pizza here, and have never been to the establishment physically, so I'll solely be reviewing the quality of the pizza. First, the positives: The cheese is melty and rich. It doesn't turn gel-like similar to some pizzas that use low-quality cheese. The sauce isn't overly sweet and pairs well with the overall taste. It's a lighter, more thin pie, so it doesn't leave you feeling sluggish when you're done. They're big slices. The negatives: This may just be personal preference, but the crust is too airy. It's crisp on the outside, but seems like it lacks a bit of density or doughiness on the inside. If the crust was a little more dense, it would definitely be one of my favorite pizzas in Wilmington. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Co. - Large cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

What a wonderful surprise . If you're looking to order an outstanding pizza, you've chosen well. However, you should give your tastebuds a treat. Explore Brooklyn Pizza's menu and you'll find a lovely range of Italian dishes which will delight the most discriminating diners. My steady is a lovely antipasto salad with a light vinaigrette dressing. YUMMO. My workmate recently chose a calzone with spinach and pepperoni which had me drooling. We had these delivered, and while it took a minute to be delivered (we ordered before they opened) it was in the time promised...for which we were eternally grateful. You must give Brooklyn Pizza a try...your tastebuds will thank me. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Co. - Antipasto Salad w/ vinaigrette dressing - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Best pizza in town! The owner Brad is so nice too!! Highly recommend Brooklyn Pizza.Co! Been ordering from here for years ! The pies are delicious and big! Your lunch and dinner all in one order. You won't be disappointed ! read more