Never had a bad experience at Brooklyn Pizza on Oleander Drive. Staff is always friendly, inside is always clean and inviting, and food is always good! Pretty awesome selection of pizzas and Italian dishes, as well as other munchies you don't see at many other pizza joints that I've seen, such as the various stuffed rolls. Love that they have Sicilian pizza, my favorite! And you can get pizza by the slice which is always good in a pinch! Affordable prices, good portions, and reasonable wait times... as in, not at all any longer than necessary for your food to be made fresh and ready for you to enjoy in a timely manner! With my order this evening, I did try to place it online but for some reason the final send through button wouldn't not let me push it to complete my order. Not at all a big deal to me, as I could call if I wanted but also I was only a couple of miles away so I just went in. I only mentioned this to the guy working the counter in case they needed to know if there was a problem with their website. I sat behind the window where you can watch them make pizza. All the staff looked happy like they enjoyed their jobs and each other which was sweet. My order was ready promptly (Eggplant Parm) and for whatever reason, they decided to throw me in some cannolis as a treat! My meal hit the spot, and the cannolis are delicious! I just want to say thank you for the extra treat, it wasn't necessary or expected but it was very kind and much enjoyed! Thank you BPC for always being a solid place to enjoy a meal. The owners should be proud of their staff for always holding it down in all of the ways of kind, enjoyable, and efficient. Much love! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Delicious cannolis! - Italian Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

There is no option, ordering online for "no cheese"...so I went in person to order. I like their 7 topping custom pizza option. Service was friendly ; took mine "to go". read more

This has got to be one of Wilmington's pizzas closest to a real Brooklyn pizza . Eat it while it's hot and crispy! read more

Stopped and got our pizza to go as we were arriving in town for vacation. It was easy pick up and pizza was good. Fried cheesecake was ok. We had one 12" with pineapple and one 12" with spinach and broccoli (not my choice lol). I'm not a thin crust fan but it's Brooklyn style and was still good. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pineapple pizza - Italian Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Brooklyn Pizza has been our go-to Pizza place for many years. They offer delicious pizza pies (round ones as well as square ones [Sicilian]) with lots of toppings to choose from, as well as a varied menu of Italian specialties. Enjoy!! read more

First time, but we will be back when we are in town. Food was fresh and excellent! Wished we had found it sooner.

Really good pizza. I will say, if you like a crunchier pie without flop I definitely recommend getting your pizza well done. Otherwise it's pretty close to pizza I've had in NY. read more

I'm originally from Brooklyn, NY so hard to give 5 stars, but the pizza was very solid - some of the best I've had in NC.

Best pizza in Wilmington. We prefer the Oleander Drive location. Love to watch the pizzas being made.

First time going to Brooklyn pizza and omg it was sooo good! I got the grandmas pizza? Or square idk? Either way it was HEAVENLY DELICIOUS! So good and saucy and refreshing! Still dreaming about it. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Grandmas slice - Italian Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Usually love Brooklyns as a born and raised borough NY girl myself, especially when I want a good hero or Sicilian slice. I was craving meatballs and was too lazy to make my own. I ordered 2 Sicilian slices with meatballs extra cheese all that and a meatball parm hero. All I can say is, the pizza was dead when I got it with the toppings thrown on it, the meatball parm hero was like chewing on peppercorns it was evident someone was more than heavy handed on the black pepper when making them. There was no relief and as much as I wanted to find an edible portion I could not. I will continue to order but I was not at all happy with the order I received tonight. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Deep search for an edible part of the meatball parm hero with no avail. - Italian Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Ordered food online, which had an option of "new credit card", it then the page it tried to open didn't work. So I had to go back and resubmit the order under "pay in person". I ordered the food about 31 minutes before pick up, but when I arrived, apparently they just received the order and just started making my order. Ended up waiting 30 minutes. While I waited, they gave me hot garlic knots with marinara sauce to munch on. I could smell the garlic emanating from the garlic knots before I even took a bite. They were indeed super garlicky. A bit too crunchy on the outside. I tried the Stuffed Chicken Parmigiana Pizza (18 inch only, $36), a Grandma Sicilian Slice ($5), and a customizable 12 inch Brooklyn Special Pie ($15). Everything had great flavor and the crust were crispy. Is reported that they make mozzarella cheese fresh from scratch and you can tell. It definitely does make a big difference in flavor. The Brooklyn pie comes with seven toppings so it's heavy, but it's meant to be a foldable pie. It was nice they asked me what part of the Sicilian pie I preferred, either corner or middle. They had a whole Sicilian pie in the display case-who knows how long it has been sitting there, but I'm sure they're following food safety protocol. A slice was taken from that pie and warmed up in the oven. The Stuffed Chicken Parmigiana Pizza took the longest to cook and it is very heavy, no surprise given the amount of food that's in it. Of course it was the most interesting food out of everything and definitely worth a try. It has "thinly sliced fried breaded chicken cutlets topped with mozzarella cheese baked between two thin pizza crusts topped with homemade marinara sauce and a dusting of Parmigiana cheese." This is a huge meal so it can feed a large family. A guy, I'm assuming the owner, wasn't super friendly, but his staff were polite and friendly. This is still a worthy pizza spot to get good pizza. read more

Such great pizza. Loved the grandma sicilian pizza slice! Would come again, recommending to friends! Service was fresh and quick. Loved the little area outside!! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Italian Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

in my humble opinion, wilmington is a bit of a pizza desert. if you are from new york, chicago, california, europe etc you know what I mean. brooklyn pizza is as good as it gets in this city, especially the location on oleander. service is always good, it's got a fun outside space, and the pizza is consistent. i will say that i prefer a slice straight from the counter, do not reheat, as when hot the toppings want to separate from the base - a pet peeve of mine. read more

Pizza was true NY Pizza. Crispy Crust, flavorful sauce, perfect ratio of sauce to cheese. Service is quick and friendly. Ambiance appreciate all the murals to Brooklyn and NYC. Best pizza in Wilmington. read more

See all

I really wanted to love this place, but unfortunately, it was a complete disappointment. Let's start with the pizza--it's not Brooklyn pizza. Not even close. On a scale of 1 to 10? I'd give it a 1. The crust, the sauce, the flavor--none of it matched the quality you'd expect from a place bearing the name Brooklyn. The lasagna? You couldn't even find it under the massive pool of tomato sauce. Same goes for the rice balls--completely drowning. If you're in the mood for a bowl of straight tomato sauce, then this is the place for you. Otherwise? Save your money. Now, I will say this: The staff was incredible. Super friendly and welcoming, and I have nothing but great things to say about them. But unfortunately, great service doesn't make up for bad food. And then, I happened to check the health inspection report. Nine violations. On February 26, 2025. Here are just a few: * Food not properly separated or protected * No proper date marking on food * Toxic substances not properly stored * Handwashing sinks not properly supplied * Issues with ventilation and lighting That's a huge red flag, and it definitely made me regret spending my money here. The only saving grace? My daughter had the vodka pasta and loved it. But for everything else? I wouldn't go back. If I could give this zero stars, I would. It should not bear the name Brooklyn--because this is nowhere near Brooklyn pizza.If I wanted 20 gallons of melted cheese and tomato sauce I would've ordered! Everything taste the same , cheese and sauce Very disappointing read more

This was the first pizza I ate when I moved to WILMINGTON back in 2004 they were in Wrightsboro at the time used to deliver to North Chase right near Laney high school. MJ -- Moved to Leland in 2005 and we didn't have much for a long time. I had to seek this bad boy out last week. Still enjoy it wish they would put a spot over in Leland. The service and location were awesome as well, nice shaded outdoor tables. read more

Best pizza in Wilmington!!!! The Grandmas Sicilian is life changing. The pastas and standard pizzas are great too.

It's about as close to a good NYC pizza as you can possibly get in the South. Definitely the place to order from when in the mood for pizza in Wilmington NC read more

The pizza was delicious, one of the best in town in my opinion! Service was a bit slow - we called in an order and arrived after the expected wait time and still had to wait an additional 15+ min. It was a Saturday though, so being busy is to be expected. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Margherita pizza, pineapple jalapeño and sausage pizza - Italian Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Pizza as good. They do a very busy business on Friday nights, which was when we were there.

I got my own 12" pizza with 7 toppings of my choice. It was amazing! I have ordered here 3-4 times already when family comes and we all love it! (We're from PA.) They give you a hearty amount of toppings; I'm talking chunks and chunks of meat and vegetables. I also got two different cheeses, (one being feta), and I will be ordering this again! I'm never disappointed! Great quality, great flavor, great pricing, and on time delivery! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - I chose 7 of my own toppings! Look at how much you get on your pizza! They don't skim you on food quality! - Italian Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

See all

This is our favorite pizza spot in Wilmington. It's soooo good everytime. Always quick and easy to pick up for takeout, reasonably priced as well. Love! read more

Pizza was cooked perfect and service was quick. Had the perfect New York style thin crust.

I live next door and go in often after shear exhaustion just wanting something quick and fulfilling. The slices for individual sale have always been cold, after they heat it up it's greasy and falls apart. I've had the grandma that is thick and so crusty you can't cut into it. I finally just ordered a customs calzone. Peppers, onions and it tasted like someone knocked over a salt shaker into each bite. I kept slicing it into individual slices but each strip/bite was worse. Filled with salt. I love them being so close and convenient but I can't keep supporting a business that is not appetizing or cooked/served well. I want to give them 5 stars but after 8-10 times I just can't. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Italian Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

We are from NY and know great pizza. So far we have only tried the grandma Sicilian slice and it is the real deal. We wish they served wine and beer because that usually stops us from going there on date night. My wife and will get pizza there for takeout only unless they get their beer and wine license. Service is good nothing over the top. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Mama's Sicilian - Italian Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

Excellent! There was a miscommunication issue with my order (making it essentially inedible for me) probably somehow my fault because I placed the order online. I wasn't even going to say anything, but my husband forced me to call/go back and address it. I'm so glad I did. I felt so embarrassed/awkward sending the food back (not something I ever want to do) but the staff handled the ordeal so gracefully and with such kindness. Also best Stromboli I've had since leaving the northeast. I am thrilled with the quality of their food, friendliness of staff, cleanliness of the restaurant and overall vibe in there. They have my loyalty for all future pizza-type orders as long as I'm in Wilmington. If you haven't already, please give them a try. You won't regret it! read more

Amazing! This authentic New York style pizza gets a 10/10. Their grandma's sicilian pizza is so delicious that I had it three times in one week. Convenient location with great staff. We live within walking distance so we haven't sat to eat there but you certainly could if you wanted to eat the pizza right out of the oven. Their wings and pasta are also fantastic. I tried their jack Daniel's wings and unfortunately they were a little too sweet for my preference but their buffalo wings are awesome. We'll definitely be regulars here. read more

First time here at Brooklyn Pizza. I had very high hopes and so glad that I wasn't disappointed! My go to slice to see how "authentic" it is is a plain cheese slice. It was pretty perfect. Sauce was seasoned, mozzarella was fresh and "real", not that fake stuff most places use. I honestly felt like I was eating pizza from my favorite pizzeria in Brooklyn. Def will be our go to place now. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Italian Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

It's hard to find good pizza in the area but Brooklyn Pizza is awesome! The crust is pretty perfect, not too thin and not too thick with a nice texture. The cheese and sauce are are fresh, flavorful and seasoned well. The staff is very friendly and the place is spotless. The only negative I have is with the chicken Parm hero, the chicken was good but the bread was lacking. Maybe it's because I brought it home and the time it took caused the bread to get soggy but it also tasted a little stale. Maybe next time I'll ask for the bread to be toasted. Bottom line- great food and great staff, I hope they keep it that way! read more

Delicious pizza! Def coming back!!!! Service was good and it's so quiet and nice. I like that it's hidden! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Italian Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

We had a large cheese pie today and we absolutely loved it! If you are looking for thin crust NY style pizza with a nice crust... this is your place!! They have a nice outdoor space to sit and eat too! read more

Very good food and will eat here every time In town. We did delivery they were friendly on phone

Being a New Yorker in the South, I am always on the lookout for good authentic NY style pizza and related sandwiches. Brooklyn Pizza by far out passes the other pizza places in Wilmington. The food is consistently great, their homemade marinara is as authentic and delicious as you might expect, and the veal cutlet heroes are jut too good to describe! The indoor and outdoor dining experience is also welcoming. The outdoor dining is also pet friendly! Thank you for providing such a great experience! read more

Great food and service staff was very polite and service was fast. Prices are very reasonable for the quality of food you receive

Best pizza in wilmington easily! The creamy pasta pasta and vodka sauce pizza are always a go to

Friendly and helpful staff. Delicious and fresh Pizza. Will for sure be back!! Highly recommended.

Solid 3. Don't believe the hyped up, juiced up reviews. Plus the service sucks -- ignored my requests and left on a topping I didn't want and didn't add the one I did want. Just another mediocre pizza place in Wilmy. read more

Yes yes yes. We get always get the pepperoni pizza. Get this pizza once a week. Always great!! read more

I order Brooklyn Pizza (Market St.) for lunch. I call in, get a few slices, well done.. and by the time I roll up, it's in a box on the counter. The guys behind the counter and cooking the pizza know my name, are professional, friendly, and on time. As far as the slice... probably the best in town! Get it! read more