Just opened so they are figuring things out with timing and being organized. To-go only. Called to…read moreplace my order and I was told it would be ready in 30 minutes so that's when my partner arrived to pick up the pizza but it was not ready yet. He had to wait quite a while for the pizza and they ended up giving the wrong pizza. I wanted the Big Mamma pizza, but they ended up giving us the Dottie pizza (Vodka sauce with bacon and sweet onions). It was still a good pizza. I liked the flavor and the dough. The crust was thin and crispy, and still fairly crispy after sitting out for a while. The biggest size that they offer is 16 inches, which is enough for 2 to 3 people. Wouldn't mind trying this pizza place again, but hope they will become more organized.

Yum... the D.A.D. Pizza was killer. Added a cannoli for dessert... made for a perfect Friday…read moreevening! The staff are super friendly and the store is really clean and welcoming inside. Will definitely be ordering from them again!!

After several nights of eating down at sit down restaurants in Wilmington, we wanted something low…read morekey, so decided to grab some pizza from Brooklyn Pizza Company. They also have a location near UNC Wilmington, but visited this strip mall location on Market Street since it was closer to us and reviews seemed comparable. There are several tables inside for dining in, but it's mainly a take out/delivery type of place as the set up is very utilitarian and functional without much atmosphere. That being said, the service at the counter when ordering and also when receiving food at the table was kind and friendly. We went with an order of garlic cheese bread and a large 18 inch cheese pizza. I have no basis of comparison with regards to quality or price compared to other places in the Wilmington area, but $24 for a simple pizza without toppings seemed a bit expensive. Both items were decent, but wouldn't compete with the quality of pizza ingredients I'm used to in the NJ/NY/PA area. The pizza was cooked well with a great undercarriage, albeit a bit oily, but the cheese, sauce, and crust didn't compare to the great pizza I'm spoiled with back home. That said, nothing was particularly bad, so grading on a regional curve, I'd rate Brooklyn Pizza Company a 3.5/5, which I'm happy to round up since all the employees were friendly, and it was a decent dinner overall.

Our go to when it comes to ordering just pizza not really big in on the appetizers or pasta dishes…read moreand the sandwiches are OK but their pizzas are amazing a little bit pricey especially if you get their white pizza($34) But we don't mind because we don't usually order in, but when we are in the mood for a pizza, we definitely choose this spot

Literally the best pizza outside of ny hands down . I have never had a bad experience here .read more

The pepperoni pizza was awesome! Crunchy crust and great flavor. There was no way to go inside when…read moreI went so you have to order by the window but it's a great vibe in a beautiful area. Service was decent.

Never had a bad experience at Brooklyn Pizza on Oleander Drive. Staff is always friendly, inside is…read morealways clean and inviting, and food is always good! Pretty awesome selection of pizzas and Italian dishes, as well as other munchies you don't see at many other pizza joints that I've seen, such as the various stuffed rolls. Love that they have Sicilian pizza, my favorite! And you can get pizza by the slice which is always good in a pinch! Affordable prices, good portions, and reasonable wait times... as in, not at all any longer than necessary for your food to be made fresh and ready for you to enjoy in a timely manner! With my order this evening, I did try to place it online but for some reason the final send through button wouldn't not let me push it to complete my order. Not at all a big deal to me, as I could call if I wanted but also I was only a couple of miles away so I just went in. I only mentioned this to the guy working the counter in case they needed to know if there was a problem with their website. I sat behind the window where you can watch them make pizza. All the staff looked happy like they enjoyed their jobs and each other which was sweet. My order was ready promptly (Eggplant Parm) and for whatever reason, they decided to throw me in some cannolis as a treat! My meal hit the spot, and the cannolis are delicious! I just want to say thank you for the extra treat, it wasn't necessary or expected but it was very kind and much enjoyed! Thank you BPC for always being a solid place to enjoy a meal. The owners should be proud of their staff for always holding it down in all of the ways of kind, enjoyable, and efficient. Much love!

Far and away the best Pizza in Wilmington. The problem for us is the "far and away" part. A routine…read moreround-trip Pickup is just not practical. This is true NY style and very consistent. I have tried over 15 pizza places and they are easily the best in this category. I would say for Artesian: Cugino Forno and Don Luca. Eating in is not a pleasant experience as this is mainly a Carry-Out due to lack of adequate seating and even basic drinks other than a few soda can choices. Happy we found them nonetheless. Every time we meet new people they unanimously agree that Brooklyn Pizza is their top choice.

The food truck was at END OF DAYS Distillery and we ordered a pepperoni pizza and it was delicious…read more Only downside Igor sick as a dog, I am thinking they have Whey Protein in their dough, but it was worth it (almost lol) it really is good, you figure with up to 40% of the population not being able to process whey, you would just use plain flour, instead of losing 40% of your paying customers. Again it is delicious! Check it out

Pizza is good but... Staff is inept. Placed order at 8:07 and was on hold for 5 minutes and was…read moretold would be ready in 15 minutes. I showed up 20 minutes later and was told it would be 7-15 minutes. Very dismissive staff. I can get good pizza at multiple places but good service makes the experience better. A manager needs to get the staff in line. Maybe business is so good they don't care. ‍ A $25 pizza should come with better service. Service used to be better.

The customer service was unexpected. I ordered a plate of garlic knots while I awaited my order…read moreconsisting of one Sicilian Pie, 3 large cheese pies, and 3 Cannolis, my wife loves them! I've ordered from them in the past as the owner himself made a Christmas Eve order as is my family's tradition. I wholeheartedly recommend this restaurant.

Synopsis - Absolutely amazing food for great value!…read more Was staying at a nearby hotel with the missus and wanted to try some local Italian food when Agostino's popped up. Holy cow it did not disappoint. We ordered online, it was ready quickly, still hot and fresh when we got it, and boy did it taste good! The prices were reasonable and we tried a few different things--all were hits. Absolutely recommend Agostino's if you are ever in the area and you want some delicious Italian food! 5 Nummy Stars out of 5!

We came here on a Saturday evening and we were seated right away outside on the patio. There are…read moreTVs throughout the indoor part of the restaurant and there was also one at the patio. I ordered the gluten-free crust white pizza and there was plenty of cheese on it, but it could have definitely used more basil to give it more flavor. My husband ordered a build your own pizza and it had plenty of chicken and black olives on it. The server was friendly and attentive in the restaurant seemed pretty clean. There is plenty of parking in the parking lot at no cost.

Truly you'd be better off buying a pizza from one of those big pizza chains (dominos, papa johns,…read morePizza Hut, etc) because this place is trash pizza. * 2 guys with long hair in the open kitchen, standing around could learn how to make pizza. The thing was covered in THICK tomato sauce, making it so the cheese COULDNT even stay on the pizza, everytime you took a bite of a slice the whole cheese came off the pizza. Paid $22.50 for a pepperoni (MEDIUM) & it was so bad we couldn't finish it. [2.5/10] * My husband got a set of wings, we asked for them extra crispy & they didn't arrive thst way, but my husband said the wings were top tier even without the added "crispiness". [7/10] * Paid for 3 sides of blue cheese total, only received one. ‍[1/10] * We visit Wilmington once a year & this year we stayed in a condo in downtown- this is a place to skip next time you're in downtown Wilmington. Plenty of other places to spend your money, & if you're craving pizza, I'd try ANY of the other pizza joints in downtown compared to this. Hell, even PJ, Dominos, or Pizza Hut would haven been cheaper pizza & tasted / constructed better!

My husband and I ate there Saturday evening. I have Celiac and our server Zoe M was wonderful and…read moreso helpful with my needs. The food was great and she was an awesome waitress.

Great service and even better gluten free pizza. My sister and I have been wanting a crispy crust…read morepizza made from gluten and this place hit a home run. They make the crust from rice flour. When we ordered the lady said the pizza was small but it was enough for two people. We ordered a house salad which was full of olives (my fav) and creamy ranch parm dressing. There's nothing better. Ordered a pizza with veggies which were amazing and another with meatballs and olives (small bites). Both equally good. Our server at the bar was on it! She did not let us ask for anything. She kept our drinks filled and served our pizza. Great experience here and I know why it was so crowded.