If you're planning a party, I would highly recommend them for catering. We ordered pizza and wings for our opening pool party. All of the neighbors couldn't stop complimenting how good the food was. The price for the quality of food was super good. You'll have to meet Jay as well. He's a great guy and a fellow Pittsburgh guy. The pizza reminds me of home. So thankful I found this place! Would highly recommend. read more

I ordered the deep dish as it is the only place in town that does it. 90 minutes later I called to ask where it was. They had delivered to the wrong address. Apparently it was too late to make another deep dish so I was out of options. Refund or not, now I have to order from somewhere else and wait another 60 mins for delivery. Saying "it's out of my control, it was delivery driver error" is not acceptable. Fix it or have delivery drivers who can correctly read the street numbers. If you employ them, you are responsible for their performance and "it takes too long to make another one" is incredibly poor customer service. I wish there was a zero star option read more

Carry out only and quite unkempt (chairs unclean and back door propped open) but the cashier was friendly and the pizza was good. Unfortunately, the pizza slid off of its crust on the drive home and released a small lake of water. Will bring a plastic container to put under it next time. read more

Jay’s Incredible Pizza - Interior - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

See all

WARNING.....DO NOT SPEND A DIME OR A SECOND OF HOPE.... My family and I ordered for the first time Friday night. I was excited to.see they had 'the ONLY authentic Chicago deep dish pizza" in my entire area on offer. No one in my entire family could get past the first bite. It was rock hard, smelled 100% artificial and was so greasy it left 2 stains the size of playing cards on my seat cushion-THRU the cardboard pizza box!!!! After a lot of examination, my husband and I came to the conclusion that the 'recipe' consisted of unboxing a cheap, supreme frozen pizza, placing a plain cheese pizza on top.upside down and shoving it in the oven to become the disgusting monstrosity that is now rotting away in a landfill. Forget this place......your stomach and your working memory will be FOREVER grateful...... read more

Halloween night we neeeeeeded something yummy to feed a crowd! The pros know to call ahead to Jay's; I did not, so it was quite a wait because their food is so good that everyone had ordered from here. We order the large primavera pizza (so thick and full of veggies), the large pepperoni, and the large meatball parm (so amazing!!!). It was all fresh and so delicious! We can't wait to try more items from here (calling ahead next time). The staff was all super nice and busting their tails to get everyone's orders out the entire time I was there read more

I wish I could give this place so many more stars! It is amazing! The staff went above and beyond for us tonight. The food was delicious, not to mention the HUGE portion. My wife is Italian (from NY), and she gave the food a 10 out 10 (I agree!). DEFINITELY going back! read more

So we get into the Jays Incredible Pizza and we order a large half cheese half pepperoni, a Greek salad, and some spaghetti and meatballs. The place inside the store was quite dirty and looks like it hasn't been cleaned in quite a long time. When we got in there we diden't want to judge a book by its cover so we decided to order. We took our food to the hotel and the pizza was nice, it was pretty tasty however the bread was a little tasteless. We tasted the spaghetti and it was cold and tasteless, the salad was ok though. It's an ok spot it's just pretty average. The people seemed nice though! read more

The large pizza is HUGE and the portion of wings is also huge. Pizza was okay, not the best but it was good.

Tonight was the first time we ordered from Jay's and I wish we found this place sooner we ordered two calzones and they were the best we've had and will definitely be ordering here more often!!! If there was an option definitely would give them 10 stars!!!! read more

Lots of good places for pizza in Wilmington and Jays is in our top five and definitely our go to when we want untraditional flavors. Our favorite pies are the Dee's pickle, Viva Cuba, and Spicy BBQ Chicken. The pepperoni rolls are a great appetizer. The staff is friendly. There is sometimes a bit of a wait so place your order ahead of time. It's super easy to order and pay on their website. They normally have a pizza of the week and also specials for holidays and events. Go check them out! read more

We love ordering from Jay's Incredible Pizza, whether for a family night or for bigger parties. The menu is extensive and everyone has their favorite. Great variety! We highly recommend Jay's Incredible Pizza. read more

Jay's Pizza is the best in Wilmington ! Service is great, take out only. Also great Lasagna and sandwiches, very reasonable lunch special too! can't go wrong choosing Jay's Incredible Pizza! read more

Pizza wasn't "incredible" in the least and the own has attitude. Furthermore, it's like a jigsaw puzzle getting to the place if you're picking up a pizza. read more

Definitely disappointed that I broke my no carb diet for this place. As we all know with a good pizza, it is difficult to eat just one piece. Couldn't even make it through one piece and threw the rest in the trash. With all the awesome pizza in town, I'm surprised the owner isn't trying to compete. read more

I just ordered a house salad and added chicken to it but got no chicken. So now I paid 10.50 for a salad. And I also clicked extra ranch - y'all charge for that - and didn't get one. So overall very disappointed:( read more

Jay’s Incredible Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, North Carolina

On short notice I requested a half pan lasagne. Jay accommodated me and I was thrilled. Never having had his lasagne I did not know what to expect, it was huge and delicious. I would recommend his lasagne to everyone. read more

These pizzas are big! The That's Incredible pizza was a hit at our house. Doughy crust. The Hawaiian was okay, I didn't think it needed the feta cheese (how is feta Hawaiian??). read more

Pros + The Online Ordering system is easy and efficient. Love the customization for each item like salads +The Antipasto salad. The vegetables were crisp and fresh. The deli meat options were authentic. Delicious salad. *Note* Even though it has Italian dressing listed as an ingredient in the main part of the salad, I do recommend adding more on the side. + The staff was friendly and was ready with my order, early. Cons - I ordered a regular plain cheese pizza. Normally we fight who gets leftovers the next day. Not this time. You have to judge a pizzeria off its most basic pizza. - The Sauce was way too sweet. Like a marinara but sweeter? - The cheese was thick and didn't have much taste. - People love the crust but I didn't think it had any flavor. I can only rate based off what I experienced and tasted. I would go back for the Antipasto salad again, and to try the Chicago pie as that seems to be their specialty. read more

We ordered from Jay's through EZCater today. It was my first time trying their food and had saw the owner post multiple pictures on social media. I wanted to try the Dill pickle pizza very badly. I ordered Greek salads, Caesar salad, and Italian su,, dill pickle pizza, and a regular pizza with the works. The salads were huge and the Italian vinegaraitte was delicious. The Italian sub may be tied for first place in Wilmington with Taste of Italy. It tastes like a real Italian sub like I used to get in Pittsburgh. The dill pickle pizza has a little bit of an unexpected kick to it. It was good, but I don't think it was my thing. My dad loved it. Their regular pizza is One of the best in town. Absolutely delicious! read more

See all

Good pizza I like plain old pepperoni. Great deal two slices and a drink for $6 !!!!!!!!

Was here a month ago. Had pepperoni pizza with extra cheese. OMG!!!! Best pizza I ever had in a long time!!

This is currently my favorite pizza in Wilmington and I hope more people try it. So far I have ordered their white pizza and a cheese pizza. Both were perfect. The crust is delicious. It might be my favorite part. Usually when we have pizza I will give my dogs little pieces of crust. When we order from here I find myself sharing much less. On both pizzas the amount of cheese and toppings was perfect. Some places don't put enough, but I've also had it where they went crazy and put too many toppings and you can't enjoy it then either (biting into an entire slice of onion, or 1 bite has 8 black olives in it. Not ok) Anyway, the sauce was wonderful, again not too much, not to little and great flavor. I want to order pizza from here everyday. read more

Still looking for the best pizza in Wilmington (yes I'm picky -- grew up on NY and New Haven pizza) but this place at least deserves an honorable mention and prob in Top 5 for sure. Crust is great, sauce is meh, a tad watery and I felt like it was missing something. Delivery was super prompt and friendly. Will try them again! read more

I found Jay's last night when all of my regular pizza spots were closed or didn't answer when I called. This place used to be Midtown pizza but now it is under new ownership. Jay was so friendly and helpful over the phone and he even gave us 15% off. He sent us home with our pizza, a coupon for 20% off our next order and take home menus for the next time we came. I ordered a deep dish Chicago style and a 18 inch mushroom and pepperoni. The Chicago style was outstanding. It had sausage mixed into the sauce, a chunky tomato sauce, pepperoni, Parmesan and mozzarella. The mushroom pepperoni did not disappoint either! You could tell all of the ingredients were fresh as well. This is a great local business to support and my new go to pizza place! read more

Ordered a Chicago style pizza and was very excited. They called and said they burnt the bottom so they were going to be late...100% good with that. The pizza that showed up was doughy at best. Flavor was good but texture SUCKED and not close to a Chicago style pizza. I hope this was a one off but will never order with family in town because I wouldn't serve that to anyone read more

I got a Chicago Style Pizza for the first time on Super Bowl Sunday for a party. It was soooo good. I lived in Chicago for 5 years and this one was equal to or better than up there. I would order another one soon. Hint, huge deep slices so you need a few people to join you. the sausage was great! Everyone who works there is very friendly. Jay is the owner and he is wonderful. Debbie H from Wilmington, NC read more

We're big fans of the pickle pizza as well as the white. Crust has a nice crunch and isn't too thick or thin. The salads are always made to order and have always been crisp. Can't recommend this place enough read more

Ordered delivery this week and only took about 45 minutes. Got the Don with mushrooms, the pickle pizza add bacon and beef, teriyaki wings, and a house salad. Home made ranch and blue cheese were on point. Salad was fresh! Pizzas were hot and what we ordered, I just prefer a little longer bake...totally my preference, the hubs loved it. Kinda wish the wings were baked a little longer to be a little crispy on the outside and I feel like Incredible used to have a seasoning on them as well as the sauce. Would definitely order again as their specialty pies are legit. Thankful to have them right around our side of town! read more

See all

Original use of flavors used to create a unique balance of tastes. Not your run of the mill pizza. In house delivery. No third party delivery charges or mistakes. Not much to look at. It's a place where they make pizza, salads and sandwiches. Very clean. Great food. read more

Finally! Someone has taken over this place and is making Incredible Pizza again! Have waited to review to make sure they keep it up, and they certainly have. If you were disappointed with the previous incarnations of Incredible Pizza, do not hesitate to give them another chance. Jay obviously cares about the business and is putting serious effort into making this a great pizza place. read more

Got a large pepperoni and wings delivered. Service was great, they answered on the first ring. Was quoted 45 minutes for delivery and it got here 15 minutes early on a Friday night no less. Food was hot and delicious. Wings were tender and came with 3 sauces as requested. The pie was very generous with toppings and cheese. It was as good as you as you will find. I can't wait to try other items on the menu. DC read more

Incredible, exactly describes the pizza! Unique variety of options to choose from in pizza toppings. Look forward to trying the wings, lasagna and calzones I saw being hand made. Priced well, quick service! Met the owner Jay and it was obvious he truly cares about his customers. Definitely will go back again! read more

After living here for 5 years and trying just about every pizza place in town, i've finally found some good pizza! Jays hands down has the BEST pizza in NC. read more

We always want to try new pizza, as I'm new to Wilmington. Jay's got three strikes in my book. We ordered a Chicago with pepperoni and mushrooms for take out, and we're told 30 minutes. It was 45, with not a lit going on except "Oh, that's the pizza (some employee no longer present) started." Got home, the pizza looked delicious! Great toppings with a lot of them. The crust was a quarter inch of dirt-dry baked cardboard. Awful. The edges needed bitten to break. We paid $35 for a two-topping, 14 inch pizza. I really hope this was a one-off. I can't recommend Jay's. read more

Everything I've ever ordered has been awesome, Jay's has become our go to! Antipasta salad rocks!

Wow! Crispy thin crust with the most flavorful seasoning combinations! Made me remember Italy! Definitely a go-to place for a slice or a pie. read more

Ordered the Chicago style and it was terrible. The crust was burnt and stale. The service was quick and delivered promptly. So it wasn't all bad. read more

Hands down easily the best game out pizza in Wilmington. I always eat way too much because I can't help myself! If you've never tried it you owe it to yourself to give it a try. read more

JAY'S INCREDIBLE PIZZA I had the very good fortune of finding a great ,local pizza place yesterday. In a little strip center at the intersection of College and 17th Street, I saw a small sign for "Jay's Incredible Pizza". I wondered if it was the same Jay that I had meet on one of my many visits to another area pizza restaurant. Incredibly, it was! Jay, the new owner, of this once forlorn pizza place has been on the Wilmington, and New York, pizza scene for years. Jay knows pizza and is producing an impressive variety of excellent pizzas in his shop. He has only had his restaurant for three months and is working hard, and successfully, to breathe new life into a once dying restaurant. I ordered two pizzas from Jay and they were both excellent. The crust was uniquely flavored and very tasty and the topping were generous and high quality. Jay bakes his pizzas the old way, in a hot shelf, Blodgett Pizza Oven. Most of these ovens have been replaced by conveyor ovens. However, if you want to produce a great baked, tasty crust with gooey melted cheese and cooked toppings, the Blodgett Oven is the only way to go. Jay knows that and is producing his pizzas the old way, and the right way. Jay's Incredible Pizza menu is extensive and exciting. He has a nice assortment of appetizers, including wings, and a variety of specialty pizzas that are unique to his shop. Here's the real find. Jay's Incredible Pizza offers Deep Dish Pizzas! Jay brought a terrific recipe with him from New York and is the only pizza place I have found that offers a deep dish product. I will be back to try this hard to find pizza, Jay sources all his high-quality ingredients from a local distributor which is as it should be. We all should support our local businesses. Currently, Jay's Incredible Pizza offers pick-up and delivery. However, Jay is working on an outdoor seating area for the shop. Jay's is open 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM daily.: I walked into this shop and was immediately reminded of a pizza place I visited as a kid. Jay's Incredible Pizza has the nostalgic feel of a neighbor pizza place. This ambiance really adds to the excellence the entire menu has to offer. I recommend that you try this restaurant the next time you crave a truly excellent pizza. Dennis Mathews The Wilmington Food Critic read more

OMG! We LOVE Jay's Incredible Pizza! Appearantly there's new management and a new chef (Jay!) in an already established place. They have kept the best parts of the menu and improved the menu & service. We were drawn in by trying their Chicago style deep dish pizza but then saw so many other unique options that we've been back several more times. Can't believe no one else has come up with Pickle Pizza! Love it! :D read more