Such yummy pizza I love the variation…read more Really good crust and you can customize it as Much as you want . Their cheese is always fresh

Dave Portnoy would be crazy disappointed in this establishments FLOP of the pizza. I love leaving…read moregood reviews, but god damn the pizza I ordered, when you pick up the slice the cheese & toppings slid down like a waterfall. Sad To owner not owning up, you reopened on 2/4 which is when I ordered & left review. Hoping next time there is more accountability & attention to detail.

Food was very good. Waitress very nice. Best broccoli I…read moreever had, really! An enjoyable lunch.

I had the most upsetting and disappointing experience at Pete & Elda's last night. I ordered a…read moredouble extra large pepperoni & onion pizza to be delivered on DoorDash. When I received the order, the pizza was a plain pizza with no toppings. However, the ticket inside the box had my name and what I ordered. So clearly, this was not the Doordasher's mistake, it was the restaurants. I called the restaurant and explained what happened & the manager on the phone Brandon said that in order for me to receive a refund, I'd have to contact DoorDash. I explained I didn't want a refund, I just wanted the pizza that I ordered. He then said I'd have to pick up the new pizza (which I was fine with doing) in 25-30 minutes. When I drove to the restaurant to pick up the new pizza, I'm then told by Brandon that I'd have to pay for the new pizza (which he never stated over the phone) & contact DoorDash for a refund. I explain ONCE AGAIN, that I'm not looking for a refund, I just want the pizza that I ordered. He then explains that it's just their policy & I'd have to pay for the new pie (even though it was their fault I got the wrong order.) Any decent manager or business would give the new pie for free because it was a mistake on their end. I obviously refused to pay for a second pizza & asked to speak to someone else. Then another manager named Joe comes out & basically says the same thing that Brandon says. At this point, I'm very upset because I'm being asked to pay for a mistake that I didn't make. I call my dad & let him know what's happening, & then he drives over with the pizza that was received and the ticket in the box. We then proceed to go back & forth with the managers for around 10 minutes. They completely avoided accountability for their mistake, & instead tried to blame the mistake on the dasher. The manager Joe was saying that "dashers pick up multiple orders at once & could've mixed the pizzas up." Clearly, that's not what happened in this situation, so it felt like they were trying to insult our intelligence. I ONCE AGAIN tell him that the dasher received the correct pizza from the restaurant because the ticket in the box was correct, one of their staff just gave the wrong pizza. I worked in the food industry for many years so I understand how DoorDash works. It's not the Dashers's responsibility to check the box and make sure the pizza is correct as that would be very unsanitary. The responsibility is on the restaurant to give the Dasher the correct order. After me having to drive to their restaurant when I wanted the order delivered initially, then my dad having to drive there to back me up, & us going back & forth with them, they finally decide to give me the pizza without me having to pay a second time (which they should've done in the first place.) Then the manager Joe tries to offer us a credit the next time we decide to go to the restaurant but I told him there was no need for that because we will never go to Pete & Elda's ever again! This whole situation has left such a bad taste in my mouth. I've had an issue before where I received the wrong pizza from Pete & Elda's & they simply remade my order and gave me a new pizza, so I don't understand why they expected me to pay again for food I already paid for through DoorDash! I have lived in Neptune all of my life and my parents have been living here for over 30+ years, & we were frequent customers at Pete & Elda's. We are so upset & disappointed that we can't even bring ourselves to set foot in that restaurant ever again. If they simply gave me the new remade pizza without demanding a second payment, this situation would've never happened. The managers were completely unprofessional and handled this situation HORRIBLY. You guys have lost loyal customers over a pizza that probably cost you $10 to make.

Mannn listen ... I like to think of myself as a pizza connoisseur, so I'm pretty hard to please …read more This was amazing ! Tasted so fresh

Excellent Pizza and BYOB, Outdoor Dining always nice. Service was spot on. Close to home and wasn't…read morerushed to leave.

Recently went down to Jersey shore to visit family and found this place on Yelp, I have to say they…read morehave one of the best ultra thin pizza ( bar Pizza)I've ever had anywhere. The crust and dough is outstanding great sauce and cheese and they offer many different toppings as well. The chopped antipasto salad is a must, enough for 4 people. Was in the mood for cheese ravioli and this dish was just way overcooked and very mushy... definite disappointment. Carafe and half carafes of red and White House wine, decent and goes great with the fantastic pizza. Fish, eggplant, chicken, and veal dishes. The veal dishes are cubed veal didn't order. Waitstaff is hit or miss. Some very friendly others not. Place is very busy and many locals love this place. Definitely recommend for the pizza. Truly one of the best.

Old School traditional Tavern setting established 1947. Friendly Service and a straightforward…read moremenu. Formica tables, Carpeted Floor, Wood Paneling. It's 1965 in here and it's fine with me! Vic's is unapologetically traditional! They do what they do and do it right. If you're searching for a traditional Bar/Tavern style Pizza. Look no further. Its good reputation is well earned. Thin Crispy Crust, Sweet Sauce and gooey cheese. Can be a little greasy but actually in a GOOD way! Flavor bomb! Pepperoni, Sausage and Onions is the way to go! Fried Calamari appetizer is just the right size and if you order the Antipasto Salad; it can be shared by 4 people. It's BIG! Seating can be a little trying on busier nights (weekends/Summer) etc but moves well enough, and worth waiting.

Was catering my wife's 70th birthday party. Ordered Chicken Franchise, chicken tenders and Caesar…read moresalad and at the last minute realized I didn't order any pasta. The staff was more than understanding and helpful and was able to include a tray of pasta at the last minute. Everyone raved on how delicious the food tasted! I would highly recommend them to anyone!!

A staple in town - very popular. Quite warm inside from the…read moreovens and body heat. Pizza is standard NY style and classic Italian entrees that are nice in portion size and flavored well. Great white pizza, garlicky flavor. The cheesesteak however (although stuffed) was a little flavorless and very messy--the oil seeping through the bread, bag, and onto my clothes. No bueno. I will say the half size was more than enough though for the average person. Have not found service to be overly friendly here. Would still return for some classic, old school fare.

I've been here a few times and the food and value is exceptional! I'm from NY and like to think I…read morehave an appreciation of Italian food, plus I use to have a small pizza/Italian food restaurant. I had a fantastic sautéed spinach and mozzarella roll; the spinach was sautéed with garlic and baked in a light pizza dough, almost like a puff pastry. Tons of mozzarella and a tasty side marinara sauce. We also had a wonderful marinated eggplant hero with fresh mozzarella roasted peppers, arugula, and balsamic dressing. The bread was very light and the sandwich was enormous. I've had their entrees before and they are excellent as well. My girlfriend swears by their pizza!

Need a variety of pieces need a variety of desserts one a great atmosphere. I would look none other…read morethan here with the food the service the ambience checks off just about everything fullness deliciousness. This is the place to be. I would definitely recommend Maurizios . Worth the drive . Two specialty slices $11.

This place is delectable. Addictive garlic knots, Grandma's pizza, thick crust that melts in your…read moremouth. Not doughy at all, amazing. Their olive oil is is remarkable. Tonight we had veal marsala that melted in my mouth. Our go to place.

We order from here quite regularly. Today I ordered 3 small subs and a large salad. When serving…read morethe subs to my visitors, we found that at most there was one thin slice of meat and cheese on each sub. In fact, on one end of a sub there was only lettuce. We also ordered a white tuna sub and it certainly did not taste or look like white tuna more like chunk light. We ended up embarrassed to feed this to our guest and tossing most of the order. Definitely very disappointment to pay for food we had to throw away. Will rethink ordering from here again.

The staff is so kind and love to chat and socialize with customers. The man at the counter loves to…read moretalk about sports. The food is even better. Whenever I go there I always have a smile on my face. The food is so good especially the buffalo chicken pizza and their chicken wings so good!!! Easily the best pizza ever. The restaurant deserves a award.

I highly recommend this place!! The pizza is amazing! The subs are also out of this world... get…read morethe Italian!

Food and service was very good, definitely going back, we went to Belmar board walk on our way home…read morestop for a bite at Santinos, everything was outstanding.

The food was pretty good - a great variety of pizzas with a slightly thicker crust. The service was…read moresuper friendly and accommodating. And the atmosphere was family friendly. There was indoor and outdoor seating which was perfect.

Great pizza & steak sandwiches. Weekday specials are a really good deal. My go to for a quick bite…read moreto eat. Everyone is pleasant and attentive.

Been going here since 1971. The place has changed, gotten much bigger, but subs and pizza are still…read moregreat