I'm making my way through every pizzeria in the area I live in now. I finally made it here because I passed by another pizza place on my way to Walmart. This place is just a short distance past the Walmart on Route 88. Basically your typical pizzeria. A friendly enough older gentleman served me. I forgot to take a picture but the place in the Pizza was pretty standard. The slice was a little smaller than some competitors but for $2.67 it was excellent in flavor,, texture and cheese to crust ratio. I would definitely go back. read more

Partner got me pizza since i was craving i normally dont order from here..... he goes all the time with his boss and coworkers so thought ok should be good..... Well its a mess its super floppy slices just rip when you pick it up its too thin soggy and just no thanks gave me the icks I was hoping for better maybe just a bad day..... it was loaded thats a good thing but the pizza was just floppy super thin you can't eat it normal would need a fork and knife which isnt how you normally eat pizza...... Again he enjoyed it but for me ill stick with my normal places maybe eventually give this place another try.... read more

2/5 Let's start with the fact that I placed my order at 8:14 PM while I was at work and scheduled it for a 9:00 PM pickup. When I arrived, it still wasn't ready and I ended up waiting another 15 minutes. When I mentioned it to the owner, the response I got was simply, "Yeah, I know." As for the food, the cheese was ice cold, the bread was burnt, and the lettuce in the salad was brown. I've only been here twice, and honestly, that's enough for me. The one positive thing I can say is that the portion size is good for $16.75, and the side salad at least came with some vegetables. However, it's disappointing that there wasn't even any butter provided for the bread. Unfortunately, between the service and the quality of the food, this isn't a place I'll be returning to. read more

Bought 3 large pies (meatball & sausage, pepperoni, plain) for a luncheon and everyone wanted to know where I got the pizzas from...bc they all thought they were excellent. Owner was really nice, and as a local resident, we've gone to Serpicos for years. read more

Pizza Crust has gotten way too thin and it's floppy definitely changed something up, too bad

Just left there with 4 slices. Pure flop. The crust was wet and soft. Absolutely a waste of money.

Delicious pizza and great selection of dinners. Love the eggplant parm pizza!!! Definitely recommend.

Nicest people, honest traditional food with fair prices and prompt delivery. Cant say enough good things. So many pizza places sell rubbery crust pizza but theirs is good. Catering is also fair priced and they aren't grubby with money up front. Great people! read more

I love this place!! Dominic and Sergio always nice and friendly! Pizza is always perfect! These cards are not from me the other happy customer didn't k ow how to post them! read more

See all

Very flavorful pizza and subs! Love the Sicilian. So glad there is a place in town with tasty pizza!

Best pizza in Brick,by far. Great service and prices. Pizza is great every time. This is our new go- to pizza place. Clean well run family business. read more

Extremely disappointed with the order we received tonight. Normally serpico's is our go to for take out pizza but never again. We ordered the grandma pie, a plain pie and a chicken parm sub. All were mediocre, cold and sad. The grandma pizza is advertised with "fresh mozzarella" but what they put on tasted old and disgusting. I have no clue what they put on our pizza but it definitely was not edible at all. It was not good quality or tasty at all. The plain pie was extremely over done and so hard my toddler couldn't even enjoy dinner. As for my chicken parm sub I asked for extra sauce and actually paid $0.75 extra for sauce and there was no extra sauce. The sandwich came dry and flavorless. Normally serpico's is great but after tonight's order we will never waste our money again especially when the area is filled with tons of other options. read more

Serpico’s - This is what they are advertising on the website. You can clearly see the difference in cheese and quality. - Pizza Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

See all

Had pizza here several times and it can be hit or miss but the cheesesteak was actually pathetic. There was very little meat and the bread was very dry and over toasted. It actually tasted worse than it looked. read more

Serpico’s - Horrible cheesesteak. - Pizza Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

Delivery driver can't read house numbers. Delivered our food next door. You have one job my dude. My neighbors held on to the food for 20mins before they figured it out it wasn't there's. Which sucked for us. Can't say I'll be ordering anytime soon. Get better drivers who can read a receipt and house numbers. I literally have large house numbers on my mailbox that's visible from the road. Food is good otherwise. Recommend getting if you're picking it up from the restaurant. Forget delivery. That's the service you get when you tip the driver 20-25% lol. read more

Had Delivery a few times and Every Time was Fantastic,Food&Pizza Still Warm,&I don't live close. Nice Friendly Staff&right before closing they Still took my order,&DeliveredTook us a Year to find good pizza in Brick;) Serpico's ,a hidden gem on Rt88 read more

Great chicken Marsala with gluten free penne large portion too. Would give more stars if they offered gluten rolls

Sad. I. Ordered 3 pies. Asked for a delivery no ear than 130 to 145. They arrived 117. Cold

Great food! Amazing fries!! Pretty fast. Got the stuffed shells and penne vodka and both sauces are great. Highly recommend if you're in the area read more

Pizza is always amazing. I tried out the chicken parm sandwich and that was also outstanding. Great service and wonderful family business. Thank you! read more

Serpico’s - Pizza is always amazing. Tried out a chicken parm sandwich and its outstanding. Great people and family business. Thank you - Pizza Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

I had someone telling me to go to Serpico's and I love me some pizza joints so I had to check it out. The place is authentic. They had Italian music playing and the owner and his employees were Italian. They were even speaking Italian. I came in with a big appetite, so I went in and ordered a few things. For an appetizer, I got their eggplant rollatini. This was fantastic! It was a huge portion with so much ricotta and sauce, an enormous layer of melted mozzarella cheese over the delicious dish. The eggplant and ham were phenomenal and mouthwatering, and it was at a perfect temperature, not too hot, not too cold. I give it a 10/10. Now for the main event I got their specialty hot sub, the chicken Serpico, which was grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, and balsamic glaze. This was very remarkable! The bread had a great toasty crunch and it absorbed the balsamic glaze. Fresh mozzarella and the roasted red peppers were juicy, flavorful, and served as an amazing topping over the chicken! The grilled chicken was good, but cold. But it was a great sub, I'll give it a 7.5/10. Overall, good place, good people, good food. And a word of advice. When you go, be loud, clear, and repeat what your order is to the employee. That's all! read more

Serpico’s - Eggplant Rollatini! - Pizza Near Me - Brick Township, New Jersey

See all

This had to be the worst food we've ever had. The pizza was not cooked through, doughy, soggy and cold. The wings were like eating rubber and also ice cold. Flavor was bland and horrible. We had one slice each and one wing each and threw out the rest. We ate the box it tasted better !!! read more

It's very unusual for me to rate anything 5 stars. The pizza is amazing time and time again. Fresh cooked perfectly excellent ingredients and a great staff. Lived here for 50+ years and this is a gem read more

this is the second time I've came to this place. Both times, customer service sucks! The food wasn't anything to ever want again. It gave me heartburn and again, just very uninviting. read more

I figured I'd stop by this new pizzeria and give it a try for take out. Went on a Friday night ordered a large pepperoni pie, a large margarita pie and A dozen chicken wings. I told the young lady who was super friendly and nice over the phone that it was a 630 pick up (1 1/2 hrs). When I arrived the pizza was ready but not the chicken wings and I did not mind waiting a minute or two. However when I got home the pizza was cold. Obviously they made the pizza right away and waited to make the chicken wings available for 630. They seem busy, it's during Covid, I get it. But it was my first experience and I went in with an open mind.... read more

Coming from north jersey I have not found a great pizza in 25 years living here. Well.... I HAVE finally found it. Cheesesteak is amazing too. A must try! I am now a happy north jersey girl. read more

Serpico's is Awesome! From there Serpico Special Pie to the garlic knots and everything in between. We have tried there burgers , wraps , penne vodka sauce, antipasto everything has been delish !!!!! From the girls that answers the phone to the delivery service Can't say enough about this establishment. read more

Well-priced for the amount of delicious food you get from the catering menu. The penne vodka is incredible, but the Nutella Poppers are the greatest dessert found anywhere! They are a MUST TRY! read more

Went to get my large pie. When I went it they said 5-10 more minutes. Came back 10 minutes later, they gave my pie to someone else. Counter Said 5-10 minutes for a new. Waited 10 more minutes, staff was lost, so we left and went to Vesuvios! Won't go back. read more

I never do yelp reviews, however, our pizza delivery tonight was phenomenal! The delivery person was wearing a mask and left a receipt in the tip envelope. We ordered a plain, a white with tomato, and a Margherita pie. Prices are great -$46 for all three. The cheese was excellent quality, and crust was crispy yet tender. I have to say it was the best white pie I have ever had! Husband and son LOVED the Margherita and plain. We will definitely be ordering from here again! read more

This place is awesome. Never once got anything that wasn't delicious. Their vodka sauce is out of this world!

Hidden Gem!! Fresh great food at amazing prices all served with a smile!! Our faves include California chicken club, chicken parm sub (both packed with chicken served on great bread!) ... the pizza ... etc. We've been ordering our staples & then adding new menu items each time to try. read more

Good food. Fair prices. Try it. You'll be pleasantly surprised. Better than the rest in the area. Try a variety of their dishes. Pizza is fresh snd the crush is just right!!! read more

Just ordered Serpicos for the first time tonight. We moved to Brick 10 years ago and have struggled to find a good pizza place. I think the search is finally over! The pizza was amazing! The salads and greens were fresh and the cheese steak was awesome!! I'm looking forward to trying the rest of the items on their menu!! FINALLY!! read more

Living with a pizza place on every corner, youd think it would be easy to find a quality pie. Pizza is my favorite food , and this spot must be either new or a hidden gem, for the first time ever, I felt compelled to eat pizza two nights in a row. Stumbled upon it and ordered The plain pie last night (always judge by the plain pie first) then the grandma pie tonight. The flavor profiling in these pizzas are addicting. Each bite makes you eager for the next. Perfect amounts of cheese, the sauce & dough compliment each other perfectly . Everything is on point. They cook the pizza perfect not too much not to little.. transparently Attentive to detail and providing a superior product, you can tell they care . Thanks for caring . Will be back read more