Giuseppe, who is the manager-owner I believe was super friendly and talkative guy like me. I liked the atmosphere: just like an old-fashioned pizzeria with a few tables, cranking out to-go orders. As I've said in other reviews, I am attempting to try every single pizzeria I can find, and there are quite a few in Ocean county. I am judging all of their plain Neapolitan pizza. Tony's was fairly priced; I actually had two slices. They had a higher than average cheese to sauce ratio. The crust was very good. He also gave me a couple of slices of some kind of upside down Sicilian pizza that I put in the toaster oven the next day. They had this Italian oregano on them, not overwhelming, and they were surprisingly much better than I thought they were gonna be. I didn't think I would like them, but I loved them. I will definitely return when I'm in the area and try other things on the menu. read more

Tony's Pizza - Upside down Sicilian with Italian oregano - Pizza Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

See all

Tried Tony's for the first time last night and was not impressed. Ordered two pizzas for my kids and their friends with the intention of giving them an early dinner. Unfortunately the pizza arrived VERY late, the delivery guy took it to the wrong house AND the order was wrong. All around disappointing. read more

Tony's is the best in Brick. My top 3 favorite food items to order, penne pasta garlic & oil with chicken, the chicken bacon ranch pizza slices and the cannolis. The owner provides great friendly service including producing fresh food with fresh ingredients. Clean location and small. Importantly great food from a regular customer from down the street. Thank you for the professional hospitality service, see you soon again. read more

Tony's Pizza - Penny pasta garlic and oil with grilled chicken. - Pizza Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

See all

The pizza was delicious and the cheese was so good Also if you don't like a thicker crust ask for it well done maybe cause it's a thicker crust And all the delivery is usually not as good in person But the pizza flavor is delicious ash they lit a lot of cheese! read more

Cheese steak was good. Fries were old & cold see picture. Delivery service was quick! read more

Tony's Pizza - Disappointed in the fries. - Pizza Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

We have been loyal and well paying customers of Tonys for a long time now. We pick up and order from them often, this was the rudest and most appalling ordering experience i have ever had with a restaurant, in my life. We placed an order for 2 orders of chicken fingers which at $14 dollars each(which is crazy as is)i expect it to come without cracked off pieces of plastic covering the food.We aren't people who call and complain..we have never given issue of any sort. Instead of just kindly accepting responsibility for food that came damaged upon delivery..the owner thought it would be more appropriate to call us liars, have an attitude, text us for proof of this slop, and offer to replace this plastic covered food as if it was charity. Find me one pizza place where the owner actually texts customers for pictures of the food for proof, and then the best part! sent out a driver tbag the food and give it back. I mean it's laughable. We put soggy cracked containers of chicken fingers and french fries in a shoprite bag to prove something to you. I'd be embarrassed. Will never order from here again! Also notice a pattern from other reviews that the owner is rude, horrible customer service, at what point do you accept that you're the problem maybe? That's not how you treat people. RESPONSE TO OWNER- You texted me asking me for pictures of the food, should I upload that here as well? And we have a ring recording of the driver saying "the owner asked me to take back the food, can you please just bag it" and then provided us your name. I'd prefer to save you that embarrassment. Funny how everyone else is always wrong huh? read more

Tony's Pizza - chicken fingers covered in broken plastic - Pizza Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

See all

Updated Jan 2020: While I appreciate a response from the owner (over 2 years later) he was present at the time we went in. He was actually the person who told us this.. We used to love Tony's but stopped ordering from there after an incident with a party we had catered. Since others have mentioned pricing discrepancies I felt the need to share. We ordered over 500 dollars worth of food and the price didn't seem right. When I returned the catering trays to the restaurant I inquired about the price difference. Apparently there was a new menu in the works with different pricing. I had hoped they would honor the pricing listed on the corresponding season/year but was instead told "it's only 5 dollars difference." Well, when you order 10 trays that adds up to an additional 50 dollars. This conversation was happening while my friend and I were being rung up for our lunch which only consisted of a few slices. No attempt to rectify the situation, meet halfway or even buy us a few slices. Poor customer service. There are far too many pizza places around with better customer service. read more

Good pizza. Ordered a half plain half chicken parm pie and a Hawaiian pie last night, as well as a large order of fries and Pepsi. Everything was good , but the only thing I thought was odd was that the delivery driver dropped my food on the porch but didn't contact me. Of course I understand the Covid-19 precautions, but if I hadn't looked outside I wouldn't have even noticed the food was delivered. I'll definitely order again and try some of their other menu items. read more

50 bucks for a margarita pizza and a cheese pizza with two toppings. High way robbery. When I called instead of listening they were defensive. The specials if we ordered would of saved 20.00 dollars. Never will go back. Unbelievable read more

My family and i have been a customers since 1994. The pizza is awesome, always hot and ready when picking up! Constantly busy these folks still provide helpful and professional service. Beverages are always cold. Well known in the community this is one of the local businesses that makes good food with hard work and great ingredents. Strongly recommend calling for a few pies or stopping by for a slice between errands! It is the best place to hide from Rt 88 traffic :) read more

Terrible Pizza It's a Greasy wet floppy mess. All a can taste was the greasy cheese. Dough was almost wet underneath not crispy. 30min after eating a slice I can still smell the greasy cheese. Give this spot one star read more

Tony's Pizza - Greasy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

When we called in a delivery to Beachwood, the person took the address and order. They did NOT say they don't deliver to my town. Thirty minutes later, they called back. At that time, they said they don't deliver to my town. I sincerely apologized for the mistake. Then I was told I had to pick it up. Either way they were going to charge my credit card. After the employee got extremely rude, I asked for the manager to call me back. The manager said I had to pay for the order, which I refused. He then said I was stupid for calling the wrong pizzeria. He admitted this was the 5th time it happened today. That right there tells me, the person taking the order is the problem. I will be contacting my credit card company. read more

My uncle said it was the best pizza in NJ. I'm not arguing as I've yet to find something outstanding while traveling here, but it was just okay... We ordered 3 pies: regular, Sicilian and a half mushroom half sausage. The regular slice was ok. The crust was cooked well but was unremarkable in terms of flavor and nuance. The sauce was meh, and the cheese was extremely oily. The Sicilian looked good, but was poorly cooked. The outcome was soggy and doughy in a not good way. I stayed away fro the toppings pie as they looked like they weren't well cooked into the cheese. Compared to other places in NJ so far it's not that bad. Not that good either... read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

See all

This place has high prices so I had HIGH expectations. The food was just okay. I got a small cheesesteak which in my opinion was the price of a large. It was dry, practically no cheese. I got the fried mushroom appetizer which was good but not great and came with dipping sauce. Here's the kicker.... I like to get a handful of items even though I'm feeding just me for two reasons, one, I love leftovers and two, I like to really get a good idea of how the food is at a place when I first eat there. They offer a $14 appetizer sampler that comes with chicken fingers, wings, mozzarella sticks and fries - "that's perfect" I thought! On DD I was given the option to add several sauces at about $1.50 EACH so I ASSUMED this was going to be extra sauces since I'm not planning to spend another $5 for a dish I'm sure comes with side sauces.... Not a single sauce was included! No marinara for the mozzarella sticks, not hot sauce or blue cheese for the wings, no honey mustard or bbq for the chicken fingers. Are you kidding?! What am I supposed to do with a dry platter of fried foods?? Extremely disappointed, will definitely be trying to find a less expensive and more flavorful option in the future. And I had my Dasher pick up Coke at 7-11 since they only carry Pepsi products. read more

Tony's Pizza - Breaded Mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

See all

I accidentally called this location and ordered 2 pizzas. The delivery driver hung up on me when I told him it wasn't my house. Very polite young female responded when I called with "I'm sorry the person that answered the call Should have asked what town you were in; unfortunately he also delivered the order" an hour later the owner called me and said "sorry you cost me money call your bank" then proceeded with a harassing text message in which he took my phone number from his business and texted me from his personal phone. Attached are the text screenshots. Even my bank responded to my dispute with "its a shame a merchant would treat you that way when they can easily refund the costs" This Guys a loser. Or, perhaps her perfect and has never accidentally called the wrong number. I understand I made a mistake with the phone number but as a business owner (as I also am) I would NEVER steal money from someone for making a mistake. read more

WARNING OF PRICE GAUGING , check your menu prices! specifically when the owner operator rings you up! He's the little guy normally making the pizzas. I didn't realize multiple times that he adds an extra $2 it seems for no reason. When I called to inquire, he seemed pleased to have done it intentionally. After telling him I hope it was worth the $2, he responded with profanity. Geez, some people just go out there way to try to take advantage of repeat local customers. read more

Needed comfort food - delicious classic pizza!

My family and I love Tony's! Great Pizza, Great Pasta, best chicken wings in town! Amazing service! Someone accidentally took our order wrong, and when I called back to let them know we were missing some stuff; they send whatever we were missing at no charge! They really do take care of their customers. Support local Businesses Support Tony's!!!! Great Job Guys!!! read more

Awesome pizzeria! Really good Philly cheesesteaks as well. They do a great delivery service we use them all the time for my brother who's confined to a nursing home. I'd say hands-down it's the best pizza Italian in the area without a doubt!! read more

Pizza was very good, we asked for it to be cooked on the lighter side. Cheesesteak special was good also. We will order again because the pizza was just how we like it but hopefully next time it won't be such a mess read more

Tony's Pizza - Cheese slid all over during delivery but it was a tasty pie - Pizza Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

I enjoyed the pizza here a few weeks ago, then I went back for a Eggplant Parmesan sub. It was a disappointment. Soupy and bland, except for the cheese. I would go here for pizza, but skip the subs. Pat's Pizza up the road has much better subs, and, I'm extrapolating here since I've never had Tony's, probably better cheese steaks. read more

Their pizza is delicious we get both regular and Sicilian they are so good !!! They also make a great Caesar salad and eggplant parm wrap !

Pizza was good. Mozzarella sticks were different but good. Meatball pizza was good. Delivery was on time and friendly. I would get again. Happy it was open on the holiday. Thank you! read more

One of my fav pizza places and it happens to be down the road from me! Delivery is always super fast. The pizza is a little doughy which I can see people may not like. I love it! If you do like crispy pizza make sure you ask for crispy. read more

Tony's is a great pizza shack nestled on route 88, in an area that has about 10 pizzerias per square mile. In my ~11 years or so in this town, I've driven past Tony's a ton of times, but never ventured inside. On a week where I was feeling fairly adventurous and eager to try new places, I popped in here for a calzone for dinner, having pretty much given up on any sense of eating healthy that day. When I entered, the first thing I noticed was that they had a pretty damn good selection of pizza by the slice to choose from, ranging from the fairly typical plain / pepperoni / sausage / sicilian, to more oddball stuff like baked ziti pizza and "chicken bacon ranch". When my calzone came out, I did what I always do when ordering a calzone - I asked for extra sauce, since most places never give me enough. The guy behind the counter a Tony's gave me a kind of worried / confused glare when I asked this, and he showed me why. They don't just give you a cup of sauce, they give you a freaking cauldron. There's enough sauce in that metal tin to bathe a small child in, and still have some left over for your meal. When I got home and opened the box, I found out the calzone was gigantic, just like the sauce. On top of that, it was fairly well filled with a pretty good amount of cheese and ham, and nearly impossible for me to finish in one sitting. The pizza is pretty great as well, and the slices I've had were a pretty great size (I think they cut the pizza into 6ths). I'm definitely coming back here for more - great food at a pretty fair price, with generous portions. Everything a Jersey pizzeria should be. read more

This was ok pizza. The sauce and topping were tasty but the pie could have been baked another 2 or 3 minutes. Nobody like a soggy pie.

I've had Pizza all over Ocean County, Tony's has the BEST FOOD around! Pizza, Cheese Steaks, ETC... read more

Trying several local pizza places throughout this Lent on Fridays with the age-old test of the large cheese pie. My wife gets the garlic bread. This was the first place up. Ordered online through their website. A tiny but active kitchen. A good sign. Service was prompt. Food was super solid. read more

The pizza is probably the best in the area since all the other pizzerias in brick and point taste the same. I wish they would make it a little crispier but it's still a good pie. the food and sandwiches are really good too but I don't like that they charge for delivery. Don't expect me to tip your driver when you charge me to deliver but force your driver to use their own car and their own gas. read more

Ordered 3 large pies on Hallloween - one plain, one with onions and mushrooms, one with pepperoni and peppers - all were cooked perfectly and delicious - decent crust - delivery was fast to considering it was Halloween at 5:30pm - only downfall was that we all got a stomach bug the day after - boooo! read more

Came in on Thursday October 31st, 2013 for the $5.99 lunch special --- after driving down Route 88 and was not disappointed. We ordered the Penne Vodka Special with Bread along with the Chicken Parm Pasta Special for $5.99 each ( $12.73 for two people with tax)-- and it hit the spot. The portions were generous and the food was tasty. I would have eaten it in the place --- however, all three of the booths inside were taken along with the picnic table out front. I will definitely visit again when in the area. read more

I have never dealt with such unprofessional and rude people. I had accidentally called the wrong Tony's Pizza placing an order for DELIVERY where I provided my address. Nothing was mentioned that they were in Brick or that they do not deliver to my address in Beachwood. A half hour later I get a call saying they are in Brick and I must've called the wrong location, I sincerely apologized and then the phone was handed off to some guy who proceeded to tell me I MUST come pick up my order, they will not refund me, and continued to be rude and nasty while calling me stupid. I then get a call back from the Manager who at first seemed to be polite, then switched to just as nasty as his employee after I kindly asked for a refund. I recognize that I called the wrong location but this was an order for delivery where I gave my address to the restaurant, it should have been acknowledged from the beginning that they would not be able to deliver. And the way they handled this is absolutely disgusting! By the end of it all the manager refused to refund me, leaving me no choice but to file through my credit card company. read more

I drove to brick today to show some houses, and was hungry after. Tony's pizza was pretty close so I decided to stop by. I'm glad I did!! Their chicken parm pizza and buffalo chx pizza slices were sooooo good. I could taste the freshness of the ingredients. 10/10 recommend. read more

This is my favorite pizza place around! Salads are excellent, pizza is great, sandwiches are always great etc. but the staff tops it off! Always sweet and friendly. And the prices are fair. If you are hungry, just pick up the phone and call them, you won't be disappointed. Thanks Tony's! read more

I'm pretty sure this is my second review on yelp, ever. I really don't understand how this place is rated 4 stars. First, the large pizza was the size of a medium. They cut a large pie in 6's instead of 8's (I've never heard of large pies being cut in 6's, only mediums) to make up for the skimpy size. Aside from that, the pizza was absolutely inedible. The garlic knots were so old that we couldn't bite though the dough. I'm saving the best for last, the chicken fingers and fries. The chicken fingers were burnt and clearly the scraps from the bottom of the frozen bag. They were little burnt nuggets with no chicken in them. I wouldn't even let our kids eat it. We called back and I will say that whoever answered was trying to make it right, but we were so disgusted we decided to pass. I hope they make some changes. read more

Tony's Pizza - What are those? - Pizza Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

Great pizza! Reasonable prices. We always order ours "well done" and it is perfect! Our favorite - pepperoni, mushrooms & onions -yummmmm. read more

Tried this place tonight. Ordered the stuffed shells- the ricotta was dry and grainy, and the fries were undercooked. They called me and I missed the call. When I called back 15 minutes later, I told them I missed their call and the answer was 'okay?'. The tiramisu was good, but other than that I wasn't super impressed. read more

We stopped by here on the way to a Lakewood Blue Claws game. It was a bit out of the way but we went for it because of the 4 stars on yelp. Pizza was ok not great. A little greasy for my liking. Price for 2 slices one Sicilian and a 16 oz soda was $10 bucks. The place was very small so not good for eating in. The phone didn't stop ringing while we where there. Lots of people ordering cheese steak sandwiches. Tony's is worth a try. Don't think I will be back. read more

See all

Never disappointed with their food. Grandma pie is the best around. The eggplant is a must!!! Meatballs are better than my own. Staff is always friendly including the drivers. You order and normally get within 30 minutes. read more

My fiancé and I just received a menu in the mail and decided to order something. My chicken sandwich, although simple because it's grilled and there is nothing much to it, was fantastic. The chicken is excellent -- usually, a chicken sandwich is good but not high quality chicken-- tonys though-- was great. I am very impressed. The Mozz sticks are delicious, too. Excellent excellent excellent. read more