Recently ordered takeout from here and have mixed reviews. We live in the area (less than a mile away) and were told our order would be ready in 20 mins. We picked it up on time and got it right home but nothing was hot so we had to do some microwaving. Mozz sticks: very tasty. Caprese panini: not what we were expecting (it wasn't pressed and the contents weren't warm although the bread may have been - much better after we heated it all up). Cheesecake: solid. Tiramisu: a standout - absolutely delicious! I wish the seating was a little more inviting here - we'd be more inclined to dine in if it was. read more

My wife and I have ordered pizza here many times and usually we pick it up. This is the second or third time we've gotten a delivery. The pizza was late over an hour and 20 minutes late. Pizza was cold. We will never order another pizza from this place again. read more

Food and service was very good, definitely going back, we went to Belmar board walk on our way home stop for a bite at Santinos, everything was outstanding. read more

Santino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Neptune, New Jersey

The food was pretty good - a great variety of pizzas with a slightly thicker crust. The service was super friendly and accommodating. And the atmosphere was family friendly. There was indoor and outdoor seating which was perfect. read more

We get takeout from them. Their pizza are excellent and their subs are really good. The bread is so good, nice and fresh . The staff is always pleasant and friendly. Definitely will continue to use them read more

Great food! Meatballs, pizza, and bolognese were exceptional!! Easy order and pickup or delivery and prices are fair.

We catered from Santino's for our family reunion. It was delivered on time and it was piping hot . Everyone was raving about the food . Several cousins went out of their way to say it's the best eggplant Parmesan that they ever had ( and their 100% Italian from Italy living in Brooklyn) You can tell the quality and pride that goes into the food . We highly recommend for parties. The pizza is delicious and always is hot when we get it delivered. The meat lovers and sqaure grandma is our favorite. read more

Great selection of fresh slices, daily specials and friendly service. Their plain slice is very good but I love the grandma and square slices. Nice clean dining area indoor and out. read more

I have been searching for a stuffed pizza. After a two-day search, I found Santino's Pizza just out of my Google search range. I ordered a stuffed Meat Lover's pizza, and it came with extra sauce. Let me tell you, it was amazing. The staff was also super friendly. Thank you, Santino's in Neptune, N.J. read more

OMG one of the best meals I've ever had!!!! What a hidden gem!!! The mussels marinara and chicken portofino were delivered piping hot with the perfect pasta, salad and bread. read more

Absolutely horrible!! The owner is NASTY!!! cares about the the almighty BUCK, serving sub standard food! Ordered a pizza and calamari!! Pizza was ok, calamari was HORRIBLE ! Overpriced!! Cold! They took it out of the freezer and threw it in oil!! Buyer BEWARE! New Owner!! New Attitude!! Beware!!!!!!! read more

Santino's Pizza - Under cooked fried Calamari beware!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Neptune, New Jersey

I wish I could say the customer service is excellent and the owner cares about his customers but tonight it wasn't the case. We ordered a $50+ meal to wait 2 hrs and to have the owner yelling at us on the other end. I liked the food and as locals wanted to like this place but in the end the way you treat people is how good your business is going to be. I was a returning customer and now will not be coming back. read more

So, I'm all about giving a place a second chance to redeem themselves. Plus, my poor memory is not absolutely certain that my first experience was totally bad. It was only last year but I do remember going to get my takeout and the order not being complete. I had to wait a really ridiculously long time. Takeout again and only 3 sandwiches. Not complicated. Wish me luck so I can change my two stars to more. Upon my return, a fresh review definitely results in 4 stars! Great friendly takeout service, by I believe the owner, and the sandwiches were very good. read more

Came in here order 2 slices and a lemonade drink it all came out $7.20 Very expensive for the quality pizza I received. There was barely any crust, that's how thin that slices where. The cheese quality was good. That was the only thing good about it. There's nothing worst than eating a thin slice with grease coming out of it on every bite. Seems like the deeper u go in jersey the worst the slices get. read more

See all

My wife and I are from Northern NJ and were visiting Bradley Beach for a long weekend. Not being familiar with the area, I searched the web for Pizza restaurants and found several positive Yelp reviews about Santino's and decided to give them a try. I called a pick up order for a Veggie Saute Pizza and was told that it would be ready in about 30 minutes; however, it wasn't ready until about 50 minutes from the phone in time. This was our first order from Santino's, and despite the delayed pick up time, the Pizza was superior to our regular Pizza Shop in Northern NJ. Compliments to the chef and staff., The pick up delay was well worth the wait. We will definitely be back for more. read more

While waiting for the afternoon fishing trip, several members of party were getting hungry. Not waiting to travel very far from the dock, we happen to find Santinos Pizza! What a great find, the pizza and Strombolis were large and very well seasoned. Clean restaurant, clean bathrooms, friendly staff...what more could one ask for? read more

Love this place, food is delicious and staff goes above and beyond! We order from here multiple times a week and cater with them often!

I love the food here. We order at least once a week. Delivery guy even gives my dog treats.

Excellent food (the best Caesar Salad) and excellent service (always friendly & accommodating)!!!

They make a damn good pizza. If I'm going to order takeout from any place on the New Jersey shore, it's Santino's Pizza etc. Last night I got a large plain pie and a large vegetable everything pizza, and it was delicious. I also often get their calzones, and appetizers and such. All very good. Their meatballs leave a little something to be desired, but that's a matter of personal taste I guess. Anyhow, like I said you can't beat this place for takeout pizza, it always hits the spot! read more

New to the area, and this has rapidly become our go to Pizza Joint. Delivery is always super fast, and the pizza is great!

Very disappointed, I saw a vegan sign, I decided to give it a try asked for a Vegan pizza and they gave me a regular chicken pizza, it was a long wait until they fixed it read more

Food is pretty good here. We love ordering in, the other night we had a surprise from one of the old drivers, he was so sweet! (I forgot his name but his dad was a fireman I think) He threw my trash away for me and got my mail ( he used to do that for me when the old owner had it) but it was so exciting to see him again! We always hope it's either him or the guy with the long hair with the cowboy hat & Trench coat! ! You guys have unique drivers! Exceptionally cool that you kept one of the old school drivers, that keeps us in the Santinos perspective! Miss Fred too hope he's doing good, our service is mainly delivery but it's always on time and exceptionally hot when those 2 drivers bring it (it's usually one of those two that coincidentally show up LOL ) ! Sometimes you can tell a place by its drivers! The only 2 that ever handle my food %!!!! The other driver, I love what he does he keeps the salad separate from the hot stuff he always tells me at the door (the firemans son) my dessert is never melted and my food is always hot! And salads always cold! We've had some orders get messy but never with those two! Thank you guys!!!!! read more

Best pizza wow. Reminded me of Brooklyn NY pizza. Very friendly staff and they even have drive trough. Our kids loved it as well as we did. read more

Santino's Pizza - Delicious grilled chicken pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Neptune, New Jersey

Grew up eating Jersey pizza and this did not disappoint. Restaurant was busy for pickup and my order which I had called in was ready in 10 minutes. Delicious real cheese (if you knwo you know), thin yummy crust and delicate, flavorful sauce. Great balance. I'm very picky with pizza and this was fantastic. Wednesday special can't be beat. Just made this a destination visit when I'm back in NJ. read more

Always love the pizza here. Service is always great. Pizza is on time when delivered. They re did the inside and it looks great! Love our local pizza spot! read more

Santinos is soo good! It's been in business for awhile but recently switched owners and has improved so much. I am a pizza snob and I think theirs is one of the best around- the white spinach pie is amazing. I've also got their pasta dishes, salads, soups and they never fail to impress me. you get a lot of food for your money. I currently am eating chicken soup I just ordered and it might be the best chicken soup I've ever had! Great place. Great people. Great food! Won't disappoint. read more

Santino's Pizza - THE BEST CHICKEN SOUP - Pizza Near Me - Neptune, New Jersey

They have a ton of options, we ordered a classic large cheese pizza. The pizza was hot, flavorful and delicious. My only critique is that the crust was thicker than we care for but overall it was good pizza. Will visit here again. read more

THe large garlic knot with chicken parm sandwich is amazing! Everything you want It to be! The chicken is thin and tender, yummy sauce and crispy garlicky bread knot. We are also big fans of the pizza and look forward to trying everything on the menu! read more

Such nice girls who work there and the pizza was great too! After a long and tiring day at Avon a group of 11 of us headed over, place was quiet on a Tuesday at 8 pm. We ordered 3 large pies with a variety of plain, veggie and my personal fave a French fry and jalapeño pie. Perfect t crust, crispy and thin. Must try, thank you Santinos! read more

Great, medium/thin crust pizza. Generous with the toppings and decent prices. Chicken wings are meaty, served hot, and with an excellent hot sauce and ranch dipping sauce. Clean, fairly basic, decor. Friendly staff. Plenty of parking. What's not to like? read more

Was excited to try this place based on the number of four and five star ratings, but everyone in our party left somewhat disappointed. The place isn't much to look at and the food was just OK. They do offer a gluten-free personal size pizza, which is primarily why we came here as my wife is gluten-free. Again, she felt her pizza was just OK. read more

I worked by the shore and at least 2-3 times a week we order from Pizza Etc. The portions are big and the price is pretty cheap for the amount of food you are getting. And the food is really good too. They have daily lunch specials as well as their regular menu, board specials and bowtie pasta specials. And if you order pickup, you don't even have to leave your car to get your food. You can go through their takeout window and pickup your food from the convenience of your front seat =) read more

Great pizza!! Tasty and quick , polite service 5 stars from a New Yorker and Italian !!

There's a lot of pizza dumps around here, however, this place always seems to be on the money. If you can go to any road side pizza place in the area stop here. They got their stuff together and the food is good. The delivery service is among the best in the area. Your food will arrive on time and hot; every single time. If you order a to go pizza from Crap & Eldas up the street your pizza is ice cold and nasty by the time you get home. I never had a problem with them. I do get crap that I'm insensitive towards businesses on here; but I'm praising this one! read more

I've ordered entrees from here 3 times in the past and i assumed I caught them on off nights. I've never left a yelp review before but went out of my way to leave this to warn future customs. As I found in the past, I paid 18 dollars tonight for a thumb size piece of chicken that is under cooked and half a handful of noodles. Don't spend your money here, don't waste you time with Santino's, they clearly do not care about preparing good meals for their customers. I will never order from here again and I'll make sure it everyone in my neighborhood doesn't waste their money here either. I can't wait until you go under and a real restaurant takes your place. read more

As regulars we love coming to this local establishment every Sunday for pizza night. Although we enjoy the food, the past several times we've been here the cooks have brought their children and allow them to sit in the dinning room while watching children cartoon shows at a high volume. Being in the restraunt business I feel it's completely unprofessional to one, make your restraunt into a day care, and two, allow the children to take control of the dinning area every weekend. We are paying customers and feel disrespected by the staff who could care less about their guests. Needless to say, we probably won't be coming back, which is disappointing. We considered asking the staff if we could change the channel or turn it down, but as an established buisness, it shouldn't even have to come to that point. read more

Nothing like it used to be. Ordered a pizza last night 1/2 bbq chicken 1/2 LIGHT peppers and onions. The pizza came it was drenched in peppers and onions and there was no sauce on it. It had ricotta, which I didn't ask for and there was soo much cheese. I've been ordering from this place since I was little with my family and boy has it taken a turn for the worst. Wish they'd go back to quality pizza and food. Probably won't be ordering from here again. Definitely a waste of $24 read more

Awesome spot for the league its in. While you may dismiss it for just another pizza joint like I did for the first 10 years Ive lived in the area, I was quickly convinced when I was brought here by my girlfriend's uncle one day I was working with him. They have really imaginative sandwich specials and their salads are bomb. They never skimp on the toppings on anything and its all just fresh stuff. Plus they have a drive up menu so if you get take out you dont even need to leave the car. Real smart on their part. Oh and their prices and portions are real good for the money. Peep this place out its a cut above many of the pizza joints around here. read more

Their Gluten-free thin crust personal pizza was aaaawesome, and am very impressed!!! I am happy to have found this place offers gluten-free pizza and any toppings, even eggplants are not breaded which has relieved my concerns.. But, this place doesn't offer non-dairy cheese, which is too bad.. However, I am happy with my GF personal pizza with great and well cooked eggplant slices and thick hearty bacon pieces, without cheese, at $9 and $2 extra for 2 toppings... Not bad, and I didn't even able to eat whole 10" inch personal pie... I had eaten half and save the other half for next day. Please consider to offer Daiya non-dairy cheese, as this will last long shelve life as refrigerated .. read more