I heard so many great things about Vinnie's Pizza, so I decided to give them a try. We called to place an order over the phone and were quoted an hour and a half wait time, which I thought was absurd -- but we went for it anyway. We picked up the pizza at the time they gave us and brought it home, less than 15 minutes away. The pizza, to me, was just okay and extremely overhyped. The pepperoni was sliced very thin into strips and was almost flavorless. I know some people might enjoy this style, but it just didn't do it for me. For a large pie with pepperoni, the total came to a little over $20. Vinnie's is located in a very busy area, and parking can be a challenge. Customer service was okay. There are a few other items on the menu I might consider trying if I go back, but as far as the pizza goes, I just wasn't impressed. read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - Large pepperoni pie - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

If you are a fan of thin crust pizza look no further. Vinnie's is the best in town and the best at making thin pies. Every bite was filled with crisp flavorful goodness. Great service provided I'm looking forward to my next visit. read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Really enjoyed the quality of the pizza. We got one pie with fresh garlic. Price was decent pizza's a little bit lighter than expected but that just means I should probably order a second one, but we'll definitely come back read more

I promised my wife that we would find good pizza during a trip to New Jersey, and after a bit of searching, Vinnie's seemed like it would be able to deliver. It's a small spot - two tables inside, two tables outside - but the stacks of empty pizza boxes mark it as a popular one. They do sixteen-inch pies here (sorry, no slices) as well as sandwiches, pastas, and wings. After describing what we were looking for in a pizza, the young man at the counter suggested the Gramps (sweet Italian sausage, hot cherry pepper, and onions) with olives added, and we were sold. Fifteen minutes later, we were digging into a glorious pie. The crust was thin without being floppy or greasy. The sauce and cheese were both high quality. The peppers added a nice burst of heat. Cheap it was not (upper $20s after the additional topping), but there are some things you can't put a price on, and a sublimely delicious pizza is one of them. Truthfully, I'm not back up North often enough to say how well Vinnie's stacks up against other Union County pizza options (I grew up on Cioffi's), but compared to much of what I'm used to in the Tarheel State (where good pizza is good often by virtue of innovative toppings), it more than holds its own. read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Came here on a friday evening, there was a 45 minute wait for a pie which was fine because we weren't in a hurry. We placed our order at the counter and took a walk then came back in time for our pizza. We ordered one bella pie which was cooked to perfection. The crust had just the right amount of crispness and I like how they spread the cheese all the way to the edge so every bite has the same amount of flavor. The sweetness from the hot honey balanced out the saltiness of the soppressata and spiciness of the peppers. This was by far one of the best pizzas I've had in a while. I'd recommend ordering ahead of time (1 hour to 45 minutes) over the phone so that the pizza is ready by the time you arrive and eating it fresh at one of their tables. They only have 2 tables inside and a few outdoor seats but a majority of their orders were for pick up so we didnt have a problem finding seating. read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - The Bella - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

The sign says It's Vinnie's. You walk in. The smell hits you hot dough, sharp cheese, the faint bite of good tomato. A man behind the counter nods like he's been expecting you all day. The slice comes fast. No fuss. Crust thin but strong, the way it should be. Cheese stretches just enough to make you work for it. Sauce has that sweet bite that tells you someone back there cares. You take a bite. You don't talk for a while. This isn't fancy pizza. This is right pizza. The kind you eat standing up, grease folding into the paper plate. The kind that tastes better than you remembered when you were hungry. Vinnie's doesn't try to be anything else. And that's why it's perfect. read more

We just had lunch here today and it was excellent! Pete the owner is a genuine guy with great hospitality and great food! We tried the Artichoke Salad Side Meatballs Vinnie Plain Pizza and Chicken Cutlet, Mozzarella, Rabes Sandwich and we had no complaints. Fresh ingredients and everything came out hot and tasty. We enjoyed everything! Salad had a great dressing. Pizza was cooked perfectly. Chicken cutlet was delicious and the broccoli rabe was so good. Not bitter at all. Clean inside. They're very busy and I can see why! read more

See all

Awesome pizza! Thin crust, under carriage is perfect. Very tasty. The chicken parm was also very good. Highly recommend. read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - Chicken Parm - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

I got here at least once a week and it never disappoints. It's my favorite pizza in the area. The charred edges of the pizza are delicious. I usually get the cheese pie with hot honey and it's so yummy. I also burn my mouth on the pizza because it's too good to wait to cool. Vinnie's only has two tables inside so go at an off time if you want to eat there. Service is exceptional. John is my absolute favorite and always makes good conversation. I cannot recommend Vinnie's enough. I still think they should bring back the day dream. #bringitback read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - Pepperoni Roni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

really really like the pepperoni pizza we had from here. sometimes places with with good looking interior usually do not churn out great food where local people are coming in and out with large orders. saw a garbage man come in to get his large order while I was waiting for my pie. there's a couple tables inside and outside but with a toddler and large doggy we opted to enjoy our pizza at the park. we didn't want to disturb the peace in Millburn. the pizza was thin but with a lot of cheese and sauce to make be soggy. it's not doughy and was crispy hot out of the oven. read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - mushroom pie - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

As a recent transplant to the North Jersey area, I've been on the hunt for the best pizza here, and Vinnie's is up there on my list as one of the best I've found so far. We got the Sgt Peppers pie (Meatballs, Long Hot Peppers, & Onions). Perfectly crisp, thin crust pizza. They did not skimp with the toppings and it was evenly distributed across the pie. The peppers had a nice kick that was the ideal complement to the meatballs. Fantastic cheese and sauce (and in the right ratios, too). read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - SGT Peppers (Meatballs, Long Hot Peppers, Onions) - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Certainly could compete with most any good pies I've had in NYC. Split a pepperoni with two others and it was a perfect amount of food (3 slices each). I like the long thin alternative with this type of pepperoni and I like that the cheese sticks to the thin crust, fresh out of the oven, perfectly. I'm still thinking about this pizza hours later wondering when I might have it again next it was so tasty. Washed it down with a Stewart's root beer and enjoyed a beautiful day on the outdoor sidewalk chairs/table. Everything came out quickly and as expected. read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Stopped by late afternoon around 4 PM Two outdoor tables both occupied and two inside tables occupied. Small spot not much space inside but plenty of real estate for the number of boxes and items they need to churn out the orders, which in the short time we were there, at a fairly odd hour it was BUSY. The oven was nonstop about 6 pies at a time. We ordered: Wings (4/4) Husband said it was pretty much one of the best wings. Perfectly crispy outside, not overcooked inside, sauced but not drowning. Plain cheese pie (4/4) Recommend waiting 15 seconds before taking a bite if you're eating it fresh, piping hot! Stretchy cheese perfection, sauce to cheese ratio was good for the thin crust that still somehow withstood all it was holding. Crispy and doughy at the same time. Solid option without any bells and whistles required. ***One note I would definitely recommend eating it there, I imagine take out could ruin the consistency. The pizza gets cold quickly because it's so thin which would probably make the crust less enjoyable. Penne sausage and broccoli rabe (4/4) Not oily, crispy sausage and ample broccoli rabe cut up nicely for a bit with each bite. Always love some good fresh garlic browned and crispy! Garlic nots (10/4) A M A Z I N G Not sure I want to know, but HOW garlic knots made beforehand, sitting on a shelf can still be so fresh tasting with a glazed top and doughy inside smothered in garlic Parmesan herbal goodness. Essentially a gluttonous savory version of a Cinnabon type consistency but BETTER by 100. Hands down the best garlic knot I have eaten in my life. Will be back. Reasonable pricing, sticking to the basics of just delivering on execution of their food. What a treat of a discovery. read more

See all

This spot was great!! It was perfectly crisp, the service was good. You can tell us a good spot, phones kept ringing and pizza kept getting made. The place is very small. Looks like many people don't dine in, we ate inside and it was cold in the area where they have tables. Pizza was delicious I love that it's pizza all the way and no crust. This was a gramps pie - hot peppers. Sausage peppers and onions. I wish I had some ranch on the side but they didn't carry any. Everything tasted fresh! read more

See all

Saw this place was a top reviewed spot (and saw Portney's review) and had to check this place out. Right off the main downtown area of Milburn it has some outside seating when the weather is nice. Inside it's two small tables and a nice/newer vibe. The pizza takes me back to the classic bar pie with thin crust. Not greasy and does have a little crisp at the ends it's a really great pizza. 8.7 Go and get it, I will be back read more

See all

Awesome pizza spot in Millburn. Couple tables inside and outside but generally this is a take-out spot. I did try dining inside once but the A/C wasn't on so it wasn't particularly pleasant on a hot day. It's right in downtown so parking is not the easiest. If you're lucky you might be able to snag a spot on the street by the restaurant, otherwise just keep going until you find something on the street or just go into one of the lots and pay for it. Those that know me know that I'm a bit of a pizza snob and so my standards tend to be high. I'm thrilled to report that Vinnie's does not disappoint in that regard. It's thin/pan crust so it's not too heavy - I could eat the entire pizza myself and not feel as guilty as I probably should. But it gives that perfect crisp taste without the burnt feeling. They have several specialties but you can also just build your own from their list of toppings, though pay attention to the cost. My personal go-to is always onions and green peppers. They only have one size of pizza unfortunately, it'd be nice if they had a medium size that was a little smaller and cheaper. I think they do sell a personal size during lunchtime but it's a little too small for my liking. If you're getting take-out and live further away, I recommend just eating it outside or somewhere nearby instead since it gets cold pretty quickly considering how thin the pie is. I will admit that the price is rather high for what you're getting, but really what isn't overpriced these days? Despite that, I look forward to the next time I'm in the area and can get this pizza again. read more

I'm the owners son and even I know and no glaze but some of the best pizza I have ever has in my 12 years of life

Always happy with Vinnie's. Reminds be of chicago deep dish, only its thin. Cooked in pans cheese all the way to the edge. Re-heats well. The wait can be annoying but it is what it is read more

Get ready to transport your taste buds straight to italy, with the owners grandfather's recipe their pizzas do not miss! Perfect amount of sauce and cheese & the most amazing unique pepperoni slices you'll ever see! But they have a lot of other amazing items as well, including meatballs, salads, and a very delightful steak sandwich meat with the freshest bread from Sorrento bakery! [ because if any true jersey person knows the key to any good sandwich is the bread] I even got a plain pie to go, if you haven't been yet run don't walk! read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - Meatball Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Pretty good pizza spot in Millburn. If you like thin crust then you will really enjoy this spot. There's a crispness/ softness that I really enjoyed about the pepperoni pizza. The service was great, pretty quick and easy to order. It takes about 20 min for a pie. The only down fall is that there is limited seating. When we went there was a group that took up all the seating so we had to take out to go. It was still really good after the 40 min drive back home. Def coming back! read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - Pepperoni Roni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

I went to the new location in Brielle which is not on Yelp yet. It was delicious. Crunchy thin and the sauce is perfect. I also had a white pie which was really good. The cheese gets crunchy on the crust. I didn't get toppings which is abnormal for me and it was so tasty without any. Will go again for sure !! read more

Amazing bar style pie. Great meatballs too. Solid people running an outstanding establishment. read more

See all

I have been on a quest to find the best pizza in north/central NJ and my search brought me here. I'm so glad it did. I barely have adequate command of the English language to do it justice. Just incredible pizza. I mean incredible. I have had some amazing pizza recently and this just blew me away. Take a look at the pictures. The ring of caramelized cheese around the rim is pure magic. Every pizza I saw coming out had it. Perfect every time. A super slightly burnt cheese taste and amazing crispness. The bottom was perfectly baked and crispy. Just the right thickness and texture. The sauce was a perfect balance of tangy and sweet and the cheese was good as well. I'm sure some toppings would be good but I don't think I will ever stray from just cheese. It is that good. I have given a few other pizza places five stars and now I feel self conscious about it. They just aren't in this league. Wish there was a way to give a bonus star. Like the amps that went up to eleven in Spinal Tap. Just be warned, they only have two tables. Yes, two. Luckily everyone knows this and everything was takeout but you might get unlucky. This pizza is beyond great. I would easily drive 3 hours to get some. Luckily I only live 45 minutes away. Top 2 or 3 pizzas in my life and I'm old and have eaten a ton of pizza. Just upset it took me this long to find it. Please go. You will thank me for it. read more

See all

This is our favorite puzza in Millburn! It is an aquired taste, since the crust is very, very thin and it is very well done. But you must try it!! Be warned that even on weeknights there is a bit of a wait so plan ahead read more

Second time in 6 months where the order is clearly marked on the receipt we receive but missing a full pizza each time. It could be DoorDash but they are letting it out the door and we never have this issue at other establishments. Done with this place which is a bummer bc the pizza is great. Also they don't care when you call them. So on to the next place. read more

This place has been on my list for a while, but what gave me the push to finally go was the recent "battle" I saw between Vinnie's and the beloved Star Tavern for best bar pie in NJ. Anything being compared to Star has gotta' be good! Boyfriend and I both really enjoyed the plain cheese pie (The Vinnie). I understand why some thin crust places don't do this, but I could have used more sauce (just my preference). Still really great flavor, the crust wasn't paper thin but was probably a step above that (which I really like), and the slices could stand on their own. The crust was chewy -- way chewier than any other thin crust pie I've ever had. I actually like that better than crisp, but I know many don't prefer that. Is it better than Star? No. That + it's also expensive as hell for a thin crust are the reasons for the four stars. But it's a great pie and I will totally be back! Friendly staff, order was ready exactly when they said it would be (45 minutes on a Friday night). Whole pies only! read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - One table inside and two outside. View inside from an outdoor table - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

The Thin crust Pizza 1. Very good sauce and cheese. 2. Pepperoni was difficult to find on the pizza and I was unable to taste it as there was so little. 3. While I could see the sausage, and it was very tasty, there wasn't enough. Only every 1 out of 3 bites had a piece of sausage on it. 4. The cringe part for me was the crust. While thin, it was heavy, dense and chewy; not crispy at all. 5. Pizza was somewhat over cooked for my preference, and didn't lend itself to being eaten cool or just warm. When re-heated in a 400 degree oven for 5 to 7 minutes, it was juicy and excelled. read more

This isn't the first time we've ordered and been disappointed with the service. It took almost three hours for the food and the price isn't cheap. The food is good but with so many other places around, it's just not worth it. Ferraro's in Westfield or Star Tavern are much better options. read more

I was on my way to AC and saw this place reviewed by Dave Portnoy I think he gave it an 8.1. It was quite a drive out of my way as this place took me north as I needed to head south . When I got about 20 mins away I called in my order and it was a quick easy order . I ordered a pie with pepperoni. When I finally got there I parked at a meter (first 15 mins free) . It's in a really nice area with a nice stream of water over an old bridge which was nice to see . As I entered they didn't seem busy and I was helped right away . The pie came to 21.00 which these days is more than fair . I couldn't wait to get to my car and chow down on some pepperoni pizza! As i opened the box I liked what I saw a nice well done thin pie with cheese all the way to the end of the crust . It had a nice char but I felt a little light with the pepperoni. So as I said it looked well done and thin and I thought it would be crispy . However it's softer and kind of chewy . It reminded me of a frozen pizza consistency . I'm glad I tried it and enjoyed the experience but it's not for me as I prefer a crispy pizza . My advice give it a try and perhaps have it to stay as the box came make it less crispy or in this case soft and chewy . read more

See all

Location cannot handle food allergies, if you have food restrictions avoid. "Manager" got mad at me for asking for something specific. Coworkers said pizza was great! read more

I drove 90 miles to get two pies. Next time I need to get more pies to the gallon. Totally worth the trip. The sauce compliments the spicy Sgt. Peppers pie. What I love the most about the pie is the cheese is carmelized, sauce & toppings right to the edge of the pan pizza. Driving down the turnpike all I could smell was the meatballs from Sgt. Peppers and sweet sausage from Gramps Pizza pie. This Philly girl is hooked. read more

See all

I saw a review of this place on social media and I was sold when he said the side of the pizza has burnt cheese. Mmmm heaven. I like their sauce too. It's not sweet like some other places. I don't eat pork so I've never tried any of this toppings. I always get plain. But I'm sure with toppings the pizza would be incredible. read more

Arguably my favorite pizza in the state!! I wish I lived closed but it's probably better I don't because I'd eat it for every meal every day. The shoestring pepperoni is unreal - there's nothing like it. I've also had the massive meatballs and size does matter! Heard great about their wings but haven't tried yet. read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - The Gramps Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

This is one of the best pizza places in the state. Cooked to perfection every time. We have tried roni, plain, hulk and critic. All tremendous. We think critic might be our favorite. Only like 4 tables. Two inside two outside. They get super busy for call ins. But it's worth it. My only negative is that I live 45 mins away. read more

My family and I tried this place via Uber Eats! The pizza was good but I've had better. Would definitely order here again.

The thin crust pizza is very good and it has the best of both worlds - a thin slice with a slightly doughy undercarriage. I had meatball & onion and the combo was delicious. If you plan to order, it might be takeout only because seating is very limited. read more

Vinnie’s Brick Oven Pan Pizza - Meatball and onion pizza - Pizza Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

Went for lunch early in the week. Fantastic pizza. Great crisp and flavor. Staff were very friendly and polite. Definitely going back often.

Solid pizza! Crust is nicely done, good flavor, nice crunch. Rigatoni with vodka sauce is excellent, meatballs are good and nicely prepared , flavorful and nice soft texture. Definitely worth a trip. read more

i had a great experience. everything is so good, i go here every week the pizza is incredible. the staff is so nice and just the vibes are amazing. I love it here read more

Excellent flavor on all 3 pizzas! First time here so we decided to try the Roni, Sgt Peppers, and the Gramps! All were very tasty! I'm usually a plain pizza guy so I will definitely be going back to try the regular Vinnie pizza! Good job! Highly recommended. read more