Capri has the best Italian subs in this area..we always get a #4 . It loaded either way delicious fresh cold cuts and hood bread. Enjoy!

It may sound funny, but one day I was in the area picking up food for dinner and I got a hankering for slice of pizza. Fortunately Capri Pizza was a block away so I decided to check it out for the first time. Capri is inside an interesting structure. Unlike traditional pizza shops with bench seating or tables laid out to one side, Capri has a counter where you order and a second level a bit higher up that I did not explore. I ordered a slice with mushrooms and it was put together and served up very quickly. I have to say I really enjoyed it! The crust was thin and crisp, allowing for a structurally sound "fold". The sauce was good, with a nice balance between savory and sweet (favoring the former). The cheese had good flavor and was melted beautifully. They also weren't stingy on the mushrooms! I look forward to going back to Capri to try other slices. Definitely worth a visit! read more

I ordered a half Pepperoni pizza. The 4 slices were huge. It looked and smelled great when I picked it up. It tasted a little bland as it needed something. The crust was not crispy, as I wished it was. Still a decent pie. Filling for sure. Again, it just needed something. read more

Capri Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

I like that the pizza is thin but that's the only thing I like. The crust was flavorless and soggy, the cheese had no salt, no flavors of garlic or anything. There was no crunch either. If it was thin, crispy, and had some salt in the dough, cheese or sauce it would really help. read more

I'm only commenting on the cheese pizza not the subs. For me there is a delicate balance of cheese to tomato sauce, that cannot be broken. This pizza is 90 percent cheese (thick cheese) and 10 percent sauce. If you like a very cheesy or extra cheese pizza, this might be for you. For me, it makes the pizza a little too oily and removes the taste. There is also just a lot of cheese which doesn't melt nicely so you are just chewing on cheese at times. Once again not my thing but I think some folks like that. read more

My Nonna and Mom (both FROM Italy not fake Italians who can only say mootzarell and gabagool) always loved the pizza here. Sauce was always fantastic and the subs are a full meal even if you get a half sub. Legit anything on their menu is great and affordable too read more

Best pizza hands down. We always order from Capri and they never disappoint! My 2 1/2 year is picky but never turns down her fav plain slice from Capri. read more

Capri Pizza - Plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

always loved your pizza since I was in my twenties amd worked down the street!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Trying this pizza place for the first time today I will give full review after we eat we ordered the thin grandma pie with fresh mozzarella. Hopefully it will taste good. read more

Tiny, hole in the wall place with damn good food. The hot sandwiches are heaven. Chicken parm is amazing. The pizza is amazing. You cannot go wrong with this place. The cold sandwiches are good too! read more

Capri Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

I have only lived in the neighborhood for a couple of months now and finally found a go to for pizza. Drove by it quite a few times before I decided to just stop for a slice. I love that the sauce is layered all the way to the crust and that they use whole milk cheese and not that part skim stuff that stiffens up when it cools. Yes its a little greasy but thats what you get when you eat really good pizza. As for the comments about the masks, I have yet to go in while they were not wearing it. I look forward to trying out some of their extensive subs menu in the near future. read more

I order delivery from here when I had to work late until 2nd shift. Got the sausage and mushroom pie for around $20. Average pizza not bad but not great. No I didn't eat the entire pie. I saved 2 slices for breakfast the next day. read more

Came here cuz I was in the mood to try a different pizza spot than my normal ... This place always seems busy. It's small inside . No place to dine in or eat. It's a take out kinda place . BUT the plain pizza slice was really good! Also tried the chicken parm sandwich and that was pretty good too. Would definitely come back again read more

One of my absolute go-to spots when I'm back home. Great pizza (for me, it's always the plain pie, no toppings). The subs are also great. I've been coming here since the mid-70s (by bicycle!) and the quality has never wavered. read more

See all

Hole in the wall on the Blvd but the best pizza in Kenilworth, hands down!!! The margarita is delicious. The pizza is always cooked well. I just wish there was a dining area. read more

See all

Best pizza in the area, the owner even had tried to whack me. I loved it. But I can't say enough about the place. I would eat there if I could place an order but my number is blocked. Love this place. Can't wait until I see them again. It will be an experience like no other. You can't beat this place, number one in NJ and the Tri-State area. You go Panzienza. Great job. read more

spider crawled out of my pizza box. Underside of the box was covered in dust and webs. Pizza was amazing though. People that work there are sort of cranky and not the most personable and the no gloves while making the pizza is a little gross but it is the old school way. Pizza is 10/10. I will continue to go back! Capri or die baby! read more

always great pizza. figured an update is due because it's not important to wear masks in public anymore. 5 stars. go get it

Just returned with a half pepperoni, half mushroom pie and as always, outstanding. It's unusual today for quality to be maintained, but Capri hasn't disappointed me over the last 12 years. Happy New Year to the people at Capri. read more

Today I changed it up from my usual 1 - 2 slices by getting a meatball sub. Everything is kept cold until you order. They build the sub, put it in tray and heat it up in their blistering hot pizza oven. It only took a couple of minutes to get hot. Good amount of sauce, not so much so it's leaking everywhere. The sauce was mild, probably the pizza sauce but good. The meatballs were a good size, about 2.5 inches. Three filled the half sub roll. The bread was nice, soft and chewy with a little crunch from being heated. Meatballs were pretty good and I'm a self proclaimed meatball snob because mine are killer. Slight garlic taste and seasoned well. Would have this again. read more

Capri Pizza - Meatball sub. 3 good sized meatballs, just enough sauce, pretty good. - Pizza Near Me - Kenilworth, New Jersey

i work nearby and decided to give this place a try. When i was charged 10 dollars for a grilled chicken salad i thought, this is the last time i'll order from this place. It will certainly not be the last time ! This is the most insanely delicious grilled chicken salad I have ever been served! the chicken strips were cooked to perfection and distributed in abundance, the lettuce was fresh and crispy and the chunks of olives and cheese made the salad appetizing and so satisfying. i also loved the light oil and vinegar container sprinkled with oregano to accompany the salad such a nice touch ! i know it sounds silly to rave about a salad but i've been trying to eat lighter and healthier and if the salad is prepared this good then the rest of the food must be great! read more

Fast service. Delicious pizza. Great staff! This pizzeria is where we go for real pizza when we are visiting Kenilworth. Wouldn't go anywhere else! read more

Great old school slice and even better pie. Delicious sauce and crust is chewy, yet not too crispy. Plain pie is the best, no need for toppings. Takeout only...no frills place and one of the better pizzas that I have had lately in the Garden State. We live in Summit and drove to Kenilworth, because it's that good. read more

This pizza is hella good. No bells and whistles. Just an authentic amazing slice. The delivery was fast and got here fresh out of the oven hot. Normally i have to tell places i like to have my crust well done, which isn't really the case i just don't like doughy pizza...who does? Well Capri crust comes just just crispy enough the way it is. Highly recommend. read more

Sweet sauce, too greasy, not a good pizza..was the shit back in the day,but no more..

There is absolutely nothing better than a hot slice of pepperoni pizza right out of the oven from Capri, eating it on a paper plate out front on the sidewalk. This is one of my all time favorite places to grab a slice, their pizza is perfection. read more

Good pizza but no one that works there wears a mask. With Covid, they should all be wearing masks for the safety of-their customers. I'll find another pizza place where they wear masks. I won't be back. read more

So I was on a site on Facebook for the best pizza restaurant around a certain area. One day Capri Pizza pops up so those who know me know I have to try it and boy I wasn't disappointed. The thin crust was good with a tasty sauce. From talking to the workers that day they explained to me that everything at the restaurant is good. I asked about the cheesesteaks and they said it's the best. Fast forward to two weeks later which is tonight I order two cheesesteaks one with extra meat and the other regular and I tell you the truth they didn't lie. It's in the top 2 best cheesesteaks I have ever had in the area. People trust me give the cheesesteak a try you will thank me later read more

Stopped in the area to go to another food establishment only for it to be closed..luckily Capri was open and decided to order cheese pie. Yum! The sauce has a slight sweetness and right amount of sauce in each slice The crust is not too thin or thick but just enough crunch to it. By far one of the best pizza places I've had in NJ..too bad I don't live close by to make me a regular customer but will definitely be my go to spots when I'm in the area. read more

I love their veggie pizza and the pepperoni pizza. The only complaint I have is that the pizza isn't crispy enough and it could use some more seasoning. Otherwise it's a great local pizza place!! read more

In town from San Diego for an old school good time with my brother. Tried this place on a whim. Got the chicken parm sandwich, oh so good. Looks like they have touched the place since 1968 and I would not have it any other way. Thanks for the great sandwich. Only thing missing was a little bull shit conversation. As a former east coast Italian this place gets two thumbs up. read more

Always amazing. 40 years we order from Capri! Never disappoints. Thank you so much for all the delicious pizza.

I work nearby and pass this place plenty of times, boy what a mistake that was. This place offers great service and the quality of the pizza is even better. Made to order, just give them a shot and you won't regret it. read more

Great pizza and sandwiches. Always ready in 20 minutes for pickup, and the delivery was on time on the occasions when I needed it

Pizza wasn't cooked enough and needed seasoning badly. Unfortunately only one of few choices open on a Monday. Otherwise there are several better choices in the area. read more

Great pizza! You won't be disappointed. Give it a try. One of the best local pizza you'll get around for sure and the prices aren't bad at all. read more

Geasy pizza that was falling apart before I was able to take a bite. First bite had a garlic powder taste that I could still taste 2 hours later. 3 employees there and only 1 was wearing a mask, guy behind the register taking orders and the one making pizza weren't wearing masks. Similar comments about no masks on other reviews. First and last time there. read more

Lived in area for 35 years now and easily the best pizza in area. Just perfect combination of tangy sauce, cheese and thin but foldable crust. Not your normal restaurant depot grease pie. read more

Been going here for years- never disappointed. No frills pizza and sub shop. Subs are quality and always a go to for my family.

Just great pizza. Nothing fancy, just a perfect pizza. The plain slices were delicious with a perfect crust. The place itself has no seating or tables. You walk into a fairly narrow entrance, and order. Walking towards the back you go up a couple steps to grab a drink or order a parm sandwich. I have been going back almost weekly for lunch. read more