Growing up in a huge Italian family, over the years I've come to appreciate good Italian food. Villa Monte surpasses "good" Italian food, and crosses over to "outstanding" Italian food. I've explored a good portion of Villa Monte's menu and still to this day haven't been disappointed. Delivery or My personal favorite dish is their Stuffed Rigatoni; there's just something about their sauce. My family and I have been coming to Villa Monte since they opened. The staff has become like family to us, and we have never had a negative experience. Everyone is so lovely there, and they really make the restaurant feel like home. Definitely check it out if you have the chance! read more

If you guys are shrimp scampi slice and baked clam only on Thursday and Friday. It should be advertised on your menu on your website or say something. The last time I ate here you guys didn't have IT. IT SHOULD BE MADE ALL THE TIME. . Please don't review this business if you received a freebie for writing this review, or if you're connected in any way to the owner or employees. read more

I ate the baked ziti pizza, it was DELICIOUS. The pizza is hard to pick up with all the pasta on it, but you can cut little pieces or you can eat some of the pasta off of it then eat it. The crust isn't too thick or too thin, it's just right. I would recommend the baked ziti slice to people who love pizza and pasta with sauce. I LOVED the baked ziti slice! read more

Nice place, was nice and quiet. My partner and I were the only customers in the restaurant half. We had just commented how nice and quiet it was when a staff member from the pizza side came and put on a big screen TV rather loud. He did not consult with us which would have been courteous since we were the only ones there at the time. I didn't go to watch sports - that's what sports bars are for. Went to enjoy a good meal in a pleasant surroundings but unfortunately that wasn't the case either. My partner ate chicken picata which he seemed happy enough with. I ordered vegetables with marinara which was way too greasy and nothing special. When the bill came, we were charged an extra $2 for fettucine which I was not informed was the case when I ordered. We were not told in advance that there would be a surcharge for paying by credit card nor were we given the opportunity to pay with cash. the card was processed before we could add a tip which forced us to leave a cash tip. All of these instances shows that the owners do not respect their guests. we will not be back. I do not recommend you choose this place. read more

Probably the most pizza selection of choices, without compromising the quality of any slice. Sweet and Spicy chicken is delicious and all meals are just as excellent. Always refer people to this place, never dissatisfied. read more

Villa Monte - Pizza Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

Pizza Parlor with over 15 different kinds of pizza to choose from. I go here when i am craving for pizza slices. $10 for 2 slices with soda or water. Best tasting pizza near Melville. read more

I did not eat the pizza...so I have no idea how that is. Service: AWFUL Food: While the portions were HUGE and tasted good going down, I am STILL sick from the insane amount of garlic they use and it is almost 24 hours later! I threw out the leftovers. Hidden charges: they charge extra if you change the sauce that is on a dish! $2 extra...and they don't tell you. Apparently it is on the menu (someone told me it was) but, really, I have NEVER been to a place that charges extra if you change a sauce so who would notice that little note on the menu? (what is the difference between a red sauce and fra diavolo? A few red pepper flakes? Certainly not worth an extra $2) They charge extra if you want vegetables instead of pasta (almost $7 extra!) I for one will NOT be going back again. read more

Yummy pizza! I had a bruschetta slice and a pesto slice. Great flavor and texture and above all... beyond delish! There's at least a dozen plus kinds of pizza to choose from so definitely make sure you have an appetite to try them all! Great back room to dine in on your lunch break. I would highly recommend this restaurant for a pizza lover! read more

Best Pizza place around. They have a huge selection of slices and everytime I go in there I try a new slice. Never been dissappointed. People that work there are not assholes which is very rare in a Long Island pizza place these days. I think they're actualy Italian too. Also very rare! Shrimp scampi slice is gangster. read more

Good pizza, especially if you like speciality slices. They have a whole bunch of different slices, if you can think of it, they probably have it. Just be prepared, this place gets packed at lunch. Seriously, we barely were able to get a table. read more

Seriously I have given this Pizza shop several times but it never works . The Pizza Pie That They Delivered was burnt on the bottom . I went another Time for Pickup and again it was burnt . The Next trip was my final . I ordered Chicken Parm slices , Cold To go . when I came home in the box was one Chicken Parm and one other that was a plain slice with chicken thrown on it . When I went in to order the man said he wanted to heat it up but that was not the case . all he did was take a regular slice and throw chicken on top Terrible . No matter what we order or How Many Tries . there always seems to be a issue . I would never have a catered affair There and I will not go back any more . I am tired of paying good money and terrible food in return read more

The selection is great - TONS of options, but I have to be honest I'm never overly impressed with the quality or taste of the pizza. It's just OK to me. read more

I went to the pizzaria side and bought 2 slices and a salad to take away. When I got back to my hotel, I emptied the salad onto a plate and it had to be at least half a head of lettuce! As for the pizza, I tried the chicken parm and caprese. The latter was my fave; I wish I had gotten 2 slices of that stuff! read more

This is one of those Pizza/Restaurant establishments. I won't comment on the pizza as we ate in the dining area and ordered from the full menu. In the land of chic and contemporary Italian restaurants comes this sort of familiy oriented no-frills eatery. I can tell you the prices are un-beatlable and the place is lively and smells great!!!! We all ordered pasta and the portions were huge. The service matches the decor- basic- and without the suave groove that you get at the higher priced local competition. I'm a foodie and so for me it is all about the food. i would say my dish- and the others wer abover average-and at the prices- that makes a winner for me. it's noisey- smells great- and you will leave full- now that Italian!!!!! read more

Great neighborhood Italian. Half pizzeria, half sit-down restaurant. The restaurant has beer and wine. If something's not on the menu, they'll make it for you. You feel like you're family there. Very kid friendly. read more

The food is great! But the customer service is horrible. They over charge you then don't wanna help fix the problem. The owner messed up the order then yelled to shut the fuck up when asking to have the order be made the way it was ordered. Very unhelpful. Not a place that makes you feel welcomed. I've been going there for 11 years now and I will never be back after the experience I had today. I always over saw their rude customer service and hanging up too quickly when ordering take out or delivery because I enjoy the food but the head ache of the order never being right and the nastiness is just not worth it. Villa Montes just lost a long time and good paying customer because of their rudeness. read more

Sweet and spicy slice was delicious. The pizza is prob the best pizza I have ever had. Cappuccino to finish was perfect

I was really looking for a pizza shop that I can talk about. This is not it. It wasn't bad just average. The search continues.

One of my favorite spots for lunch. The pizza slices are big, they have an amazing variety to choose from and so far each slice I've tried has been delicious! Be ready for a long line during lunch hour, but it's worth it read more

Just moved to New York and am in temp digs nearby, so was curious to see what our options were in terms of pizza. (I love pizza - especially thin crust). So many different kinds of pie to be sure (it reminded me of the options back in Troy, NY at I Love NY Pizza). We started with the Shrimp Oreganata as an appetizer (with bread to sop up the sauce - yum!) and opted for an Old World (and asked for half with sausage). Really good. I'm sort of a pizza snob, so this is definitely not the best pizza I've ever had, but it definitely was delicious...and filling! One slice and a half and I had to tap out. The service was awesome, and atmosphere inviting. Totally worth checking out! read more

pulled up on Yelp. Penne with marinara and chicken was to die for. Service and atmosphere was great for a very good price.

Best pizza in Long Island! I love their whole wheat veggie pizza, healthy and delicious!

I watched this place grow from a pizzeria joint (with adjoining dining area) back in 2003 to the full-out restaurant experience of today. Food quality is way up there, as well as cleanliness. Their decor is modern Italian (of course!). I always get a slice of their buffalo chicken pizza and a corner sicilian, but they have a HUGE variety of toppings to please every customer. There's also a complete Italian menu for calzones and pasta dishes. The ambience is upbeat during lunch hours. The lady and staff (owners?) are consistently friendly upon every single visit. There's plenty of parking - no "circling around" and waiting for spots. There are also large screen TVs in the dining areas playing news and sporting events. read more

Betrayed by positive reviews. Maybe the worst penne bolognese I've had, ever. Disappointed by all elements - pasta, sauce, and meatballs. To top it off they got my delivery order wrong. read more

This is the only restaurant that has specialty slices with structural integrity! You can actually pick up any of their slices and eat it without a fork and knife. If you try that anywhere else, you'll end up with a plate full of toppings... They have the widest selection of specialty slices on the island, I think I counted 50 different pies once! They range from the ordinary Pepperoni to Calamari, to Hotdog and French Fry with Chipotle sauce. If it wasn't so far from home, I would definitely visit more often. read more

Fast, friendly, and always delicious! If you are looking for a great selection of pizza, salad, or Italian specialities look no further. I look forward to going there each week. read more

My absolute favorite pizzeria! I grew up around the street and have been coming back for over 20 years. They have a huge assortment of pizzas- the salad slice and barbecue chicken tying for my favorite. Their pasta dishes are great as well, although their salads are not my favorite. Very kind staff, would definitely recommend. read more

OKAY Long Islanders.... This is it... the best specialty pizza in the center Long Island area... I have tried alot... and their has been some good contenders... but this place just rises above. Dont go here to get a boring old plain slice ( there are better places for that) How about a white claim pizza? Deep dish marinara? Rigatoni alla vodka? or their special Old Fashion slice? How about some meatball parm slice? This place does specialty pies like nobody else. It is worth every dime. They renovated the place like five years ago ( maybe a little less). I used to go when it was just a little hole in the wall. Now it is all fancy looking with a nicer dinning room. I only ate their once and it was good, not amazing. However this is the place you go to for a good specialty pie. I can not believe the bad reviews this pizza place is getting. Every time we order a fresh specialty pie my family is in awe. We always order from there. there is just nothing like it! read more

Huge selection of specialty pizza, I would definitely recommend this place. Don't let the outside fool you, it always looks closed

Holy Cow! They have SOOO many types of Pizza, I wish I could live here! The Sicilian slices are insane! I had BBQ Chicken Pizza topped with Bacon! and a Sweet and Sour Chicken slice, $4 each but totally worth it. The BBQ was on the sweet side. What I love is the crispy bottoms. Sweet and sour was questionable in theory but my fav of the three I tried. I also had some of the Buffalo Chicken, Yum! read more

Excellent Pizza, Great selection of slices that have a quick turnover. Very generous with the toppings. Plenty of Parking.

My go-to lunch spot, not only does my office order 15-20 pies every first Friday from this place (and might I add they are always delivered ON TIME and Hot), every time I walk in the door the owners are always happy and inviting. My go-to slices are the sweet/spicy chicken and the old fashion (alla vodka) two banging slices. This is probably one of the best pizza places outside the city limits. I recommend this place. CINQUE STELLE! read more

Terrific, original, creative slices!!! Buffalo Calamari Pizza? Shrimp Pizza? Whole wheat vegetable?! YES PLEASE!!! Awesome selection you do not find in many places around Bethpage. read more

It's hard to find great pizza in Long Island, but here it is. Great pizza, Huge selection (it's hard to decide what to get!), and very friendly staff. The dining room is also excellent with ample seating if you go during your lunch break from the office (a big plus) read more

This has to be the most variety of pizza slices ever offered under one roof!!! I cruised up and down the counter looking at all the different offerings and came back to choose the Monte Special slice of heaven!!! This is how to do Pizza!!!! read more

I try not to review local pizza restaurants too often. There are just too many, but this place is terrific. The choices of specialty slices are endless, and really, really good. The real star, however, is the restaurant. Excellent food, always piping hot, and plentiful. The marinara sauce shines. Oddly, it's closed Sundays, but if you can get there you won't be disappointed. read more

Large selection of specialty slices. On this trip I had a pesto thin crust slice. At 4.25 for a small slice, I thought it was on the pricey side, but it was very good. So a good choice when you need a quick fix and you're in the area read more

Wow!! My mom warned us the portions were huge but I was not prepared. The staff is super adorable and friendly, the seating is spacious and not crammed on top of each other, the Caesar salad was out of the world and I cannot give enough stars for the calamari and penne entree. My dad's veal Parmesan could feed three people and my mom's linguini with red clam sauce was devine. Oh, and let's not forget how soft and warm the bread is- not hard and crunchy where you can't spread the butter. Absolutely love this place and look forward to coming back! read more

This place is a hidden gem. I play hockey every Thursday night at skate safe around the corner and my cousin and i go here right before they close for dinner each week. Food is always great (fresh not frozen) and the service is good. Even though we come in around 9:30 when they are going to close soon they never have a problem with us sitting down and getting waiter/waitress service. The owner is a nice guy. Highly recommend the Grilled chicken Parm dinner. Chicken is always fresh, soft and cooked to order. Very solid place read more

Pizza was only okay, IMO. They have a huge variety. I tried the Tony D, buffalo chicken, and BBQ chicken. I thought these were a little sauce heavy with the BBQ sauce which was a little too sweet for me too and the crust was slightly overcooked. Atmosphere is great as there was plenty of seating, both casual and restaurant style. read more