Some of the best pizza I've had in a while. The restaurant is spacious, with lots of indoor seating. There was so much to choose from. I ordered their fried zucchini, white slice, bbq chicken slice, and bacon ranch slice. They all were fresh and tasty. I enjoyed not to much oil dripping from the slices. The fried zucchini was crispy, fresh , and the marinara sauce gave it that extra wow factor. The customer service was awesome. They are very personable and friendly. It's a family owned business. I traveled all the way from Brooklyn to try them out, and I can't wait to return. If ever you're in the area please give them a try. read more

See all

I moved that in New York sometime ago I should've put this up last week when I was there and I have to say over and over again still the best pizza on Long Island overall and meatball Parmesan heroes are the best. All the food is the best whenever I come back to New York, it is the first place I come to, and if you've never tried to trust me, Bobby, the owner is a great guy read more

See all

My family has been getting great pizza and other Italian specialties since the 1970s. The quality has been consistently excellent. You can't go wrong here. If you eat in the restaurant the warmth of everyone is very apparent. read more

Have had both pizza and hero's. Always hot always fresh. Never ate in was to go. Top shelf!! read more

When you walk in it's very warming and welcoming. With a big display counter and a smiling person behind. They have a huge selection of speciality slices and pinwheels. Staying is not an issue, as they have tables, chairs, and booths. I got 2 regular slices. I give them 8/10. Good crunch Good chew Right amount of sauce and cheese. Was able to keep the fold the whole time. I will be back! read more

Have passed this pizzeria many times and never went in cause I just thought the parking was too difficult . Someone told me today that this was their favorite pizza in Plainview ( it at the border of Plainview and Hicksville on Woodbury road and south oyster bay road). I asked why and he said , it's the cheesiest! Anyway, I decided to try it and was very pleased. I had a cauliflower pizza which was excellent and I could present it was healthier. The regular slice was also good and really cheesy as promised. Inside the dining room is nicer than you can tell from the outside. The staff are efficient and accommodating. You can park on the street , but they DO have a parking lot in back, around the corner. Gotta say, although I haven't been here for 28 years, I plan to return. read more

See all

Always the best Italian dishes. By far the best pizzas in Nassau County. We have been enjoying their food for 49 years!! read more

Very good cheese pizza and veggie and chicken parm. Not the cheapest but quality is good. Service is not the friendliest, do not give you nice big paper cups, only small dentist cups... Does not take Apple Pay or Amex.. Will be back for the pizza since it's the best local slice I had so far read more

Vodka pie w/ pepperoni pinwheel crust - Absolute favorite pizza! I would get it every week if I could. (By the slice on Friday's only, pies by the order). Lovely owners, great staff, round/square slices are the best. Rolls galore! Hicksville and Plainview love Raimo's! #SecretMenu read more

Raimo's Pizza - Vodka pie, pepperoni pinwheel crust! - Pizza Near Me - Hicksville, New York

We hopped off our plane at LGA and came right to Raimo's, suitcases in hand. We live in florida, and we definitely don't get amazing pizza often, so Raimo's was the most delicious treat for us in a LONG time. This pizza was to die for!!! Everything about it was perfect - the crisp crust, high quality cheese with the perfect amount of oil, and the delicious and tangy sauce. Sooooo perfect it melted in our mouths. We couldn't stop eating slice after slice. In addition to the pizza, the restaurant itself was great! Service was so friendly and fast, and super affordable too. Will absolutely come back next time we're in this part of Long Island! read more

This place always made decent pizza; I used to visit the place when I was a school teacher in this area. But the thing that I always found uniquely excellent here, which I had to return for today, is their crispy, tasty pepperoni pinwheels. As always I love mine well baked and super crunchy. And the pizza is average at best, with nice sauce, but clumsy, chewy cheese and a fair crust. Mangia! read more

Raimo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hicksville, New York

Been coming here for 26 years - but my Raimo era sadly has to end now! The new owners (the company traded hands a few years ago) changed the recipe. (If it works, don't fix it!) The quality of the crust plummeted dramatically. The mozzarella & sauce is not the same. I can never come back here. This is so disappointing! If any of the former employees are monitoring these reviews (we are "I would like to pick up a grandma pie w/extra roasted garlic & fresh basil") ... we sure do miss you! On the only positive note: this current staff is professional & friendly. read more

Not since it sold to a nice Indian man who something tells me doesn't have the best inside scoop on how to make Italian pizza - so food took a major step backwards. Service just isn't the same - and ambiance I really couldn't say I didn't stay - they used to have the best Chicken Cordon Bleu in America. But now I'm kinda depressed about the new place. read more

Since moving to Florida twenty years ago from New Jersey, I miss the simple fact that the northeast has great pizza on almost every corner. Imagine my shock and dismay when I arrived in sunny Florida and quickly discovered that good pizza (or even decent pizza) is something that you have to seek out and once found, these little utopias of good pizzas in a sea of pizza waste should be treasured. So, when business brought me up here, I had to take advantage of my surroundings and enjoy some great pizza. Raimo's Pizza offers a great pizza pie. By the way, it is also refreshing that people understand that I mean pizza when I say that I want a pie. They offer a pizza that is a tantalizing blend of dough, sauce, cheese and spices. While many embrace toppings on their pizza, I am more of a pizza purist. A cheese pizza to me is the perfect pizza, though I will indulge here and there with a pizza with all of the toppings. I guess with me it is one or the other extreme when it comes to pizza. I would definitely recommend Raimo's Pizza. read more

I love the food from here and the people who work there. Whether pizza, main course or their specials, you won't be disappointed. Two of my favorites are the personal pizza pies and the Salmon Piccata special. Take out or eat in, it's always good. read more

Raimo's Pizza - Salmon Piccata with artichoke hearts, capers, over linguine. - Pizza Near Me - Hicksville, New York

ALWAYS a delicious pizza when we order here! Grew up in Hicksville, and our family would drive from the Bethpage border to Raimo's for their pies! As I grew up I was introduced to Sicilian pizza and it's close cousin, the Slab pizza (aka Rllio's). Ordering was easy, we are from Maine so we have some different toppings like hamburger aka chopped meat. When I asked she kept saying "This is Eaimo's in Hicksville, you know that right?" Lol! Super nice and patient as we navigated our meat selection. Mushroom and sausage pie, cheese pie, and a Sicilian pie were called in, 20 minutes on a Saturday evening. We were attending a function at another establishment so the timing was perfect for us. We arrived in time. There was no parking along Woodbury Rd so we made the right after the pizzeria where behind the building there was plenty of free parking. We walked in through the back door and were greeted immediately by the friendly woman on the phone. Our order was just about to come out of the oven! As we waited we walked along the counters seeing what other delicacies they offer. Decorated with Italian scenery and items that are used for cooking. Seating was a majority of booths with a few stand free tables. There were Calzones , pasta dishes, and Gelato in various flavors. Got the pies home and thoroughly enjoyed all the pies with my family and friends we entertained where we were staying in E. Northport NY. Yes a drive, absolutely worthwhile. No pictures as we dug right in :) read more

Their pizza is your classic pizza done right. Their garlic knots are perfectly crisp and soft with the perfect amount of garlic. Definitely recommend. Only thing that's horrible is that they don't deliver! read more

See all

This pizzeria is the king of Hicksville in my opinion. The dough had that freshness smell. The cheese and sauce was fresh and aromatic. Some pizza has a ton of oil, but this pie was not oily. It was just an overall great experience. Keep it up! read more

Raimo's Pizza - Regular pie, light on cheese and sauce... perfection. - Pizza Near Me - Hicksville, New York

Ordered meatball parm hero, Sicilian, and margaritas at this Italian mainstay for over 50 years. My favorite was the pillowy soft meatballs and Sicilian. Enjoy read more

Raimo's Pizza - Margarita - Pizza Near Me - Hicksville, New York

We ordered the large pan of lasagna for a party. Delicious.The manager made the order easy and everyone loved it.

I've been to Raimo's a couple of times, but never to this location. I was in the area and did a quick Yelp search and this was one of the top choices within the vicinity of where I was. I placed an order for a large pie and some garlic knots. The lady on the phone was pleasant enough and the transaction was a quick one. Once I got to the restaurant, I wasn't greeted right away, but everyone did just look at me come in. Felt a bit a strange, but I shook it off. I got to the counter and the lady sounded as if she was the same one that answered the phone, but I didn't ask, so I'm not entirely sure. But in any event, I didn't get the same vibe off the phone in person. She asked me what I wanted, I told her I here to pick up my order. She asked for the number that I was told to give over the phone and I gave that to her as well. I saw that they had Buffalo pizza and I ordered a slice. It's kinda my weak spot. The guy who gave me my order was nice and so was the other guy. I mean, to me, customer service is key. Now on to the food. The garlic knots were good, but really soft. I was looking for the soft chewy middle. The pizza was ok, but not like the other Raimo's pizzeria that I'm familiar with. All in all, it did it's job and provided us with something to eat, but left more to be desired. The slice of Buffalo also didn't do it for me. It was lacking some flavor. I saw a lot of good reviews on here for it, but it was a miss for me. read more

Few five stars I give out but they deserve it. Pizza is outstanding especially their famous Sicilian. They make a great pasta with broccoli olive oil garlic dish with grilled chicken on top that's outrageous read more

I've passed by Raimo's a bunch of times and finally decided to try them out! The pizza is great! I like the soft chewy dough and the toppings were not greasy/oily like other pizzerias. The mozzarella sticks were not fresh and seemed to have just been sitting out. Other than that, my order was ready for pickup in 15 minutes and check out was seamless. I will try their pasta dishes next time! read more

Raimo's Pizza - Margarita 16" - Pizza Near Me - Hicksville, New York

What a disappointment from the previous owners who took care to have great pizza foods and help. The new ownership, and food is not the same. I had a bad experience last year when I took a friend to grab a late dinner. THought they were open til 10 weekdays and 11 w/ends. Well we got the food and within 2 minutes, someone starts washing the floor next to us and the surrounding booth with an ammonia based cleaners-- Ever try to eat italian pasta with the stench of ammonia? We asked could they wash the other side and were told know because they were closing early! WHen I referenced the the hours on the door - they said they changed it and were closing up. So I asked, why didnt you tell us you ere closing when we said we were staying and sat down-- Noanswer-- Left the food- the taste of ammonia was everywhere Several neighbors also noted the quality down. Well, tried lunch this week- just a slice of grandma's piece-- the worst-- its like eating a sicilian slice way to yeasty, think with a few teaspoons of sauce, a basil leave a small amount of cheese-- Never again . They may like scimping on cheese, and other ingredients but the place certainly isnt crowded - Don' waste your rime read more

This is the first time I have ordered from Raimo's. And I'm very disappointed w the food. The food arrived cold. If you love cold pizza, this is the place for you. The linguine Frutti di Mara consisted of overcooked chopped up spaghetti, see pics. And the Fettucine ala Penne, no need for teeth, you can gum your way through and swallow. The Chicken Parm and Chicken Marsala was flavorful, however it was cold. I was looking forward to trying Raimo's after reading all the reviews and I won't be ordering from them again. There are more negatives and it outweighs any positive. read more

See all

Raimo's is simply the best pizzeria in the area. We had a large group of guys to feed so we always order food from Raimos because it's more than just a pizzeria. All of their salads are very good, their pepperoni chips are outrageously good, we like their chicken cutlets pizza, their Sicilian pie is fantastic. Everything we have ever ordered from Raimos has always been great. Try a shot of Espresso when you're trying too. read more

Amazing and authentic pizza. This place is my CHILDHOOD. Just the right amount of CHEESY DELICIOUSNESS. It's good for sit in, very casual vibes to catch up with friends or fam. The other italian dishes are amazing too, and they also have a gelato bar, so if your eating in it makes for a great dessert :) read more

Raimo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hicksville, New York

See all

Hmm. I'm not sure what happened. I used to frequent Raimos. Pizza was always on point. Now, I'm not sure. Two times in a row my boyfriend and I ordered a pie well done with half sausage. When we brought it home it wasn't well done at all. Not even sure if it was "done" at all. The pizza was extremely doughy and the cheese would just slide off. It definitely needed at least 3 more minutes in the oven to be at least "done" in my opinion. The flavor was just okay. Due to the cheese and sausage sliding off because of the undercooking, I had to eat the pizza with a fork and knife. We also ordered garlic knots. When we got home they were cold. Not even room temperature. But ice cold. Maybe that's because when I went to pick up the pie they just took a bag of garlic knots from on top of the oven. Maybe they have them pre packaged? That's what it seems like. Also, it was JUST DOUGH! There was no garlic, no olive oil, nothing on the knots. (See picture!) it was just knotted dough. Not worth $3.50 at all. For a pie with half sausage, 6 balls of dough (can't call it garlic knots if there wasn't any garlic) and a 2 liter bottle of soda it cost $27.81! That is a little over priced. Especially for the quality. Go elsewhere. read more

Raimo's Pizza - Garlic knot...more like baked dough. Where is the garlic?! Not present. - Pizza Near Me - Hicksville, New York

Absolutely amazing I've passed by this place all the time on the way to work & heard so much good things about this place. I tried the bbq chicken slice & 2 garlic knots & they were cooked to perfection & tasted delicious. I wish I tried this place sooner & also the staff were very friendly as well. I highly recommend coming to this pizzeria it's worth it!!! read more

I had High hopes due to the yelp reviews . What a let down, Ordered a Pie Half Pepperoni Half Plain. The pie was such a disappointment, it was undercooked & just straight trash. There pizza are extra doughy w/ barely any sauce & there cheese blend, was definitely nothing to brag about. Located on a corner w/ plenty of indoor seating. read more

Raimo's is the real deal when it comes to a pizzeria! A nicely done interior that's been well kept and clean! About a dozen different pizza options, chicken rolls, calzones, pasta dishes, and one of my favorites....rice balls!! The Cheese Sicilian is fantastic, but perhaps my favorite was the Chicken Roll! Basically a huge chicken Parmesan that's rolled into a fluffy dough and baked! Served with marinara sauce for dipping, it's like chicken Parmesan pizza! The rice balls didn't disappoint as they're about the size of a baseball and jam packed into a crispy deep fried exterior! Raimo's is a true delight in the pizzeria world of NY! They are super friendly and put out a worthy product! read more

See all

Excellent pizza, good sauce, great ingredients. A++ Will definitely return when visiting the area again. read more

I used to visit Raimo's back when I lived on Long Island rather frequently. I had heard about it years ago through friends and absolutely loved their pizza. Nothing has changed. Since moving upstate, there aren't very many places that I can say have exceptional pizza. Raimo's never disappoints and recent consumption of a take-out pie was no exception. This pie had extra cheese, pepperoni and mushroom. The crust is perfectly thick and there isn't a burnt spot anywhere to be found. The flavor of the sauce is just right and it reminds me of how I would be 9000 pounds if I lived in that vicinity. Great pizza. Look forward to getting back again soon. Too bad there's so much traffic down there! read more

I really wanted to love this place. However with so many other great pizza shops in the area, it's fails to hit the mark.

Best pizza on Long Island is an understatement. I go here on my lunch break atleast twice a week. I am a huge fan of this pizzeria. They are all so friendly and even their most basic slices are out of this world delicious. This is not your ordinary pizza place guys!!! Run there! read more

See all

The home of thick cheesy slice; the slice that never disappoints, if I'm in the mood for thick cheesy slice. The gruff counter service, the calzones, the gelato, the pasta. The food is always on point. The staff is attentive if eat in but I mostly take away. read more

Simply great pizza, owners are there working and the prices are reasonable Sicilian pizza pie is awesome. Cauliflower pizza is unique and a must have. Broccoli and chicken pinwheels are delicious too with the sauce on side, amazing read more

There food is great! I'm not crazy about there pizza. It's ok it's not bad but theres definitely a lot better. There meals are good and there hero's too. read more

Hmm coming up with a rating for this place was a little tough because I've frequented Rainbows a bunch of times over the past few years for lunch on the weekends. I've had good slices and not so good slices here. They say familiarity breeds contempt... ? Rainbows is a pretty typical pizza joint, but there are a few things to point out. They have a lot of seating and the place is very clean, so that is a plus. The best thing to get might be their plain slice. Their plain slice is very solid and is much cheesier than a typical plain slice. I prefer that actually. So if I was rating this place just on the cheese slice alone, I'm sure I'd give it a 4. I've also tried a few other slices here, and the experience with those slices brings the rating down a star. Now, don't get me wrong; Rainbows is a solid pizza joint. Can't say it is bad. Their specialty slices have been a bit lacking in taste. I had a chicken and broccoli slice recently, and have also had an eggplant parm slice. Maybe it's because they don't heat up the slices evenly, but the slices have never been crazy good. Always solid, but never banging. Also, the crust on the specialty slices tends to be a bit hard so I'm not sure how fresh they are. It's such a conundrum, because all of their slices look amazing. It's like being beautiful on the outside but average on the inside. Prices here are pretty typical of a Long Island pizza joint. My eggplant and mozzarella slice was $4.35. So that is my conflicted view on Rainbows! I'll definitely be back in the future. read more

Raimo's Pizza - Eggplant and Mozzarella Slice - Pizza Near Me - Hicksville, New York

See all

In my opinion, this is definitely one of the better pizza joints in the area. Their regular and Sicilian slices are on point, chock full of gooey cheesiness and just the right amount of sauce, which is a little on the sweet side. They have a nice selection of specialty slices and make a capellini alfredo roll which is my favorite. I feel that they use better ingredients, which obviously produces a better product. Keep up the good work Raimos! read more