Wow! All I've got to say is wow, great service, great frikin food. This pizza was amazing the ways the flavor melts on your young's and the cheesy bread was just phenomenal. Wings were crazy good even without the sauce, never tried dry rub wings but man this was a great start. read more

Needed a pizza when I got to town late and this was the answer. 7.5/10 pizza. Definitely worth a try.

Food is good, service was terrible. First the guy taking our order couldn't be bothered to separate our two couples tickets. Acted like it was going to be a huge pain in his rear. Then, 4 out of 4 salads we ordered were wrong. Not one was correct how we ordered them. The brought the pizza but never brought us any plates. Never brought us refills. Never came back to the table until we had finished eating. Horrible, horrible service. Will not return. read more

Unique pizza. Delicious. Had an issue with my order and they corrected right away. Great service

Pizza was good but kinda bland to me. I like a more flavorful sauce. The crust was good but looked pre-made. With the limited pizza options here, it will fill the need. read more

We ordered white pizza and it was literally no sauce but cheese on the top of the dough. Also it was overcooked. Taste little bit better than pizza from the store. read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

2stars because of poor service. Pizza and chicken parm were delicious. However i ordered it takeout, when i got back to my room no takeout utensils for the chicken parm meal. I called and they were so rude said I had to ask for it. Also when paying i left a custom tip the person chuckled like they were expecting a 20% tip on a takeout order. I'm sorry since when do these places expect a tip when I come pic up a meal?? Ridiculous they packaged it and handed it to me. We are from Texas where everyone is so friendly much different experience here in the Keys. read more

AMAZING food and great service! The garlic bread is to die for. They do a great job with all their foods. I've been there a few times and wanted to go again this trip, but they were closed due to the parents of the family passing away from COVID the same day. I am heartbroken and wish the family the best. Please support them! read more

The only way to get the best pizza, and all around best experience in Marathon. Family business, no other choice but Upper Crust!

Quite Expensive good pizza. Closes early on a Saturday night. Their large is 16" and they don't have a larger one. Still hungry. Won't go back. read more

Ordered and picked up in 20 minutes. Fast service. Pricey for the product: $38 for a large pizza, one order of cheese sticks and a single soft drink. Pizza is "OK": thin on sauce that wasn't flavorful, though with ok quality toppings. Crust is thin and seemed well prepared. Overall a bit bland. Seemed like nice folks, prompt and accurate service. Big negative for me: they do not accept American Express. read more

I think this is a great little pizza place. A bit over priced. 1 topping pizza cost me $24. Pizza is good for Key West. It was very busy when I came in. Lots of people drinking alcohol. A pie slice might cost you around $7. My husband truly loved the pizza. I thought it was good too. It's just a nice thin pizza that's enjoyable. read more

See all

amazing food, we tried a little bit of everything.... wings- crispy & spicy bbq chicken/veggie/ deluxe pizza- perfect amt of sauce and toppings! garlic cheesy bread was sooooo good stuffed shells came with 3 shells and it was the perfect amount of food for one person- also comes w a salad and 2 slices of garlic bread only complaint was that it was a little pricey:/ read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Stuffed Shells & Deluxe - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

The restaurant is exceptional. The service gives you a nice home feeling and the food is amazing, especially their carnivorous pizza. If you're here for pizza, I recommend either the white pizza or a classic deluxe pizza. read more

See all

pretty good! we got garlic bread, and it was pretty good. nothing super special, but it was still yummy. pepperoni pizza was also pretty good, but it was a little sweet. personally i consider myself more of a savory pizza person over sweet, but this was still enjoyable. i put parmesan cheese on it and it was really good. not super crowded, was a calm environment. staff was very kind as well! i would recommend stopping by if you're in the area. most of the bad reviews are irrelevant and not accurate. read more

Closed during operating hours, people parking and walking up to locked door. Maybe there was an issue but should put a sign up.

Very fresh , food was very good. Fast servicee. Clean nicee place. I was surprised how good I it was. Enjoyed my meal.

Wow. I ordered 2 large pies and all I can say is that was bad pizza. It is very similar to school cafeteria types. We were very hungry and ate it begrudgingly read more

Needed a quick pizza while on vacation. Quick ended up being a 55 minute pickup time. The pizza was ok and the staff was friendly. Not bad for the islands. read more

The food is delicious!! We got the garlic bread with cheese, super delicious!! The place is simple, but worth it.

Not sure what all the negative reviews are about. We sat in, party of 6. Nice service and some really good pizza. I recommend the spinach artichoke dip and the bbq chicken pizza. read more

Ordered a pizza for pick up and was told 30 min. Arrived 30 min later, paid for said pizza and waited another 10 min. (It will be ready soon). 5 min later they said it just went in the oven and it will be another 25 minutes. We were obviously upset and spoke up about the screw up, and the owner states "Your order is cancelled, we don't want your business". Customer service was atrocious and the pizza wasn't good enough to overlook it. The Keys has a million pizza joints, skip this one. read more

Stopped in here on a whim, and it didn't disappoint. They are generous with the toppings and the taste was delicious (got a double mozzarella with pepperoni and jalapeño). If you're in the mood for pizza at a no frills place then check it out! read more

I really loved this place. The appetizers are delicious, the pizza was amazing as well. We got the deluxe without mushrooms and our kids and us ate all of it. The service was on point, attentive, quick, and friendly. We enjoyed our time here! read more

Absolutely worst dinning experience I ever had. My wife and I used to frequent this restaurant over 16 years ago when we lived in Marathon. Though I read a number of negative reviews on Yelp about this place, now that we were back in the area, we were anxious to give our old spot a try. It was a Friday night and moderately busy. All it appeared to be on staff was two owners serving tables. After waiting at our table for 5 minutes, a lady comes by with two menus, drops them off and just walks away. Strange, but OK. About 10 minutes later, a guy comes back with an order pad and says, "What do you want?" We give him the order and he does scurry back with our drinks. 45 minutes later, the lady comes back with our appetizer, drops it off, says enjoy, and scurries off again. Yes, appetizer fairly good. About 10 minutes later, our meals come up. Very basic toasted sub sandwiches. Mine was fairly decent. My wife's had burnt spots on the bottom. I know this can be a problem in Italian restaurants which make pizza. Cheese from a previous pizza drips on oven floor, burns, new pizza or sandwich slides in, and old cheese spot gets burned into the bottom of the food. Just need to clean the oven a little more often to prevent this. Also, the meatballs in my wife's sandwich didn't taste right. Bottom line, she couldn't eat it. After about 20 minutes, the lady comes back, asks if there's anything else. My wife informs her what's wrong with the sandwich. The lady gets defensive, and states that all their food is homemade, and that they've never had a complaint about any of their food. My wife suggests she check her Yelp page, as there are several reviews complaining about the food and service on there. The lady just leaves and doesn't say anything. About 5 minutes later, the guy comes back, tells us he wants us to leave and never come back, or he'll call the police for threatening him and his wife. I say what threats? He says your wife is threatening to write a negative review about us and I'm not putting up with threats. I just want you to leave. By now a few people from other tables are looking our way. I explained to the guy, no one is threatening anyone, and that my wife is stating you should check your Yelp page to read the complaints, because as we've experienced, they are fairly accurate. He sill got in a huff, and said I still want you to leave and don't come back here again, then he stormed off. So we started to gather our things as it was getting a little uncomfortable in the restaurant with everyone looking at us, but before we got out of there, the wife of this guy came flying out with a bill for 40 bucks. Guess they did want us to leave quite that fast. So I paid the lady, and we got out of there. All this could have been avoided if when my wife told the lady there was something wrong with her food if the lady would have replied with: I'm sorry, don't know how that happened. Can I make you a new one or maybe something else? My suggestion : If you decide to go here you may or may not be disappointed with the food. You'll likely be disappointed with the service. The food is reasonably priced especially for the Keys, however, if you don't like your food or have a problem, I don't recommend complaining about it. You just might get asked to leave. read more

7.9 great spot. Dough needs to be a bit more crispy. Meatballs and wings are excellent

Two try's this week and the second was worse than the first. We ate in the first time. My chicken parm was tasteless and dry. The pizza was pretty good and the service was fine. The second time I came in a placed a carry out order for a single cheese pizza without sauce. The gentlemen wrote that down and I picked up the pizza 20 minutes later. When I got back to our house I opened a pizza with sauce. I called and the gentlemen insisted I was wrong and that he would not remake the pizza and I could bring it back and get a refund. Worst service I can remember. Avoid. read more

We ordered a medium and a small pizza as well as antipasti. Antipasti was written in the box but inside was a Greek salad which was probably half the price. Pizzas were burned on the bottoms, bland and in spite of it being burnt, were soggy. We didn't complain as we had invited friends to share it with us. Very disappointing and we won't go back. Oh yes, it came to $61! Extortionate read more

We love this little family owned and operated pizza joint that's a favorite with us locals. The food is delicious and made to order, the service is fast and friendly. They take great pride in their food and the cleanliness of their establishment. read more

I had a sit-down dinner and enjoyed the pizza, a salad and a half-carafe of chianti. While not cheap, I was satisfied with the quality. The next meal was take out and I ordered the pizza, a chicken parmesan and a chicken parm sub. While the pizza was again satisfactory and I'm told the sub was good, the chicken parmesan is perhaps the worst I've ever had. Not only was it a small portion(1 tiny piece of chicken) for the $18.50, but it only came with a salad of lettuce and cheese and there were no other vegetables. The sauce was OK however only about 2 ounces with a big mound of spaghetti. Stick with the expensive pizza if you dare come here. read more

Lasagna, eggplant parm and pizza were all very good. It was very busy at the time so the service wasn't extremely fast or attentive, but the food was worth it. Their house tomato sauce is excellent. Second visit: chicken parm, meatballs, cheese sticks, pizza. Meatballs were excellent. Pizza still good. Chicken parm was decent, but the eggplant parm is a better choice. read more

Was in the mood for pizza, and boy did these guys scratch that itch! The pizza was top-notch, I don't think I've had one half as good in a long time. Generous toppings, and an amazing crust. We also ordered a small garlic bread... it was very tasty, but more like Texas toast than the traditional Italian style we're used to. read more

Large portions. The pizza was thin to medium thickness crust, very tasty. Decent spaghetti bolognese with garlic bread. Nice staff. Patient. read more

I would bet that they use frozen premade dough, and add toppings. Atleast that's how it looked and tasted. Not fresh, not original, very greasy, not as good as Dominos. I would say it's not the worst I've ever had, hence the two stars instead of one, I defintely regret spending the $7 that I did on an 8" personal pizza, which frankly, is a rip off. The service left a lot to be desired. For a family run, local place, this shop was very unfriendly, cold, and unwelcoming. Not what I expaected at all. For comparison of standards, I prefer NJ crisp thin crust tomato pies and pizzas that take 7 minutes to cook in a real pizza oven, not this 20 minute toaster oven bs that they call pizza in Marathon. Beware, and try to avoid unless desperate. read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Greasy, premade, boring pizza. too much cheese. Not enough sauce. Not as good as Dominos. Expensive, over-priced. Avoid. - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Delicious pizza! Nice thin crust but not soggy and not too crisp. Cheese bread had tons of cheese and was nice and crisp on the bottom. Mediterranean salad was fresh and homemade dressing was so good! Staff was all very friendly and attentive. Restaurant is very clean and they seem to take the sanitizing seriously. Will definitely be back! read more

Terrible service. For our last night in Florida, we decided to order pizza to enjoy at our resort. When picking up our pizza and salad, we asked for silverware. The lady working very rudely said they don't have silverware. We asked how could that be if they were serving us salad. She was so rude. We then gave her our credit card so we could check out-despite no silverware and she quite literally threw it back at us and said she doesn't take American Express. We then decided to walk out without food. She then yelled at us and said we were rude...not us ma'am it is you! read more

Amazing! They are so nice and the food is amazing. First time costumer just wanting some spaghetti lol traveling from Key West to Miami , late dinner. We googled places and this one showed up with three and half stars so we went for it. It was almost closing time and they still were so nice to cook us our food and stay open. Turned out it's a Family Owned, which is awesome. Locals helping locals, we own a Family Sign Shop in Key West. The place is SUPER clean and welcoming, the owners were nice and the prices are great. Food time came and WOW!! We got the pepperoni, mushroom small pizza, wine and the spaghetti dinner, sausage, includes garlic bread and a salad with ranch. Holy gees!!! Everything was super delish. I highly recommend going there... 5 stars for sure. I'm picky, so is the significant other since he's Italian lol. Hope this helped! read more

Great pizza! We stopped after visiting the Turtle Hospital on the recommendation of locals and were very happy we did. It was a little pricey but again, very good pizza. read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Upper Crust - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Go for the Pizza, save room for the Tres Leches! The pizza is perfect...fresh dough, fine ingredients and all put together with love. My family LOVES pizza and they gave it a huge THUMBS UP! I have to admit, I was pleasantly surprised just how darn good it really was. I'd recommend it to anyone even the most seasoned and traveled pizza connoisseur. But when asked if we want dessert who knew The Keys would have the best Tres Leches we've had in YEARS! Moist but not to wet, sweet but not overly so, fresh, homemade and one you'll tell all your friends about. Make it a pint to make it to Upper Crust. read more

It's a family owned small restaurant all of them really nice... everything has a home made taste pizza sizes are big we order a medium and a large pizza and we took more than 2 slides of each ... 2 pizzas are more than enough for 3 people, prices are a little big higher!!! But the taste of the food is Really good read more

Upper Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all