The food was good and actually early (delivery). Very nice…read moredelivery driver. Ordered 20 wings. My only knock.... I work in the restaurant industry. The wings that I received were some of the smallest count wings that you can buy... they were good, but when I compare the size vs any other restaurant in the area, they are less than 1/2 the size - zero exaggeration. The little things matter - I don't like to leave negative reviews so this isn't negative - it's constructive. If I pay $20 for $20 wings - they should be the same count or at least remotely close to every other competitor in the area. I support local but will Probably not order from here again unfortunately. I hope they can take this constructively, learn from it and succeed because I respect anyone that goes into business to support themselves/their family and like I said - the flavor was great! Just please do it the right way.

The pizza was great. The meatball Parm sub is good stumbled on this place because I visit this…read morelaundromat and nail salon about once a month, so this is where I treat myself. Services is great and great atmosphere..

One of the best Pizzas around. Never had a bad pie from Dom's. Dom is also a great guy. Good…read moreguy, great Pizza.

Honesty is the best policy.. after eating a Sicilian pizza Middletown,NY - Nice crispy crust,…read moreperfect cheese melt, crispy pepperoni, and a homemade sauce, simply fantastic. Later in the month I decide to order one from Dom's thinking it should be similar. Unfortunately it was not. The customer service was on point, I'll give them that. But sadly that taste wasn't there. I won't go again. Sorry guys.

I heard a lot of good things about their crispy crust pizza, and I finally had a chance to try it…read more It is definitely one of the best pizzas I've ever had. I haven't even had pizza even in Rome (actually any NY style pizza better than Rome's pizza) The dining area is small, 7-8 tables. it was very clean. When we were there, the restaurant was extremely busy, but the person at the front handled everything calmly and professionally. I saw about 25-30 large pizzas boxed up and ready for delivery. I learned they offer a 24-cut square pizza that's perfect for parties and large events. I'll definitely be back to try that next time. Very clean, friendly service, and delicious pizza. Highly recommended

Have to say I am a little disappointed. This used to be one of my favorite NY pizza places, but…read moresomething obviously changed. First tried it thirteen years ago when I moved here. Was just across the street from my apartment. I was sold. So fresh, abundant toppings and perfect crust. I used to order it weekly. Not so much when I moved down town. But would get it so often. Always ordered the supreme or meat lovers and was never disappointed. In fact ordered the night before I left about a year and half ago, and still great. Something changed. You can even tell from the photos. Veggies were wilted, old, or worse was a pie sitting under a heat lamp and since I ordered close to closing they might have just recirculated it. It was delivered in 30 minutes, no warmer box, and pie was less than warm and crust hard, like reheated. None of the toppings were like before. Don't get me wrong. Pizza was not bad. Not great, but not bad. Just not the NY style pizza I remember, and disappointed with my first NY pie since being away for a while. My only guess is the family that owned it and truly cared, sold it and the new owners are more about profits and cheap ingredients. Only my 2nd day back and a sad day.

Love this place! They have extremely fast delivery . The pizza and wings are great! The garlic…read moreParmesan wings are my favorite. They Also make a Greek salad that i love and the veggies are always crisp. I've ordered the eggplant dinner so many times and it's always consistent. It's good home cooking. They send garlic bread and a small garden salad with all the Meals too. It's a nice family owned business and they are always friendly and accommodating to my asks. Like changes or special requests for my disabled daughter. They've even made me things that weren't even on their menu. I wanted broccoli with some garlic and they made it for me. I happily will continue to support this business.

I wanted a couple of quick slices of pizza so I stopped in at this joint in ordered their chicken…read morebacon ranch. The flavor and toppings were pretty good although you can tell it was sitting around for a while, despite them heating it up in the oven. All in all it was pretty decent. The inside of the restaurant was clean and the cashier was nice.

It was soo good and fresh my picky nonna really liked it and it was so quick and the service was so…read morenice

Still this is my favorite pizza place in the area... it really is. I know up here they like crispy…read morepizza crust and that drives me up the wall because I prefer to fold it and not have to worry about broken crust caught between my teeth, etc.... so this one was really that good to make me look past that. But it's the quality assurance of this place.... half the time you order on a Saturday and their system accepts the order, the DoorDash driver comes by and "whoops!" they're closed. Then you ask when they open and they'll say 10am... and someone says "we had a family emergency"... and while I get that, how about you turn off the ordering system to accept the orders so I'm not out the money and the driver doesn't waste time driving to pick up the food? Then sometimes you'll get a great saucy pizza (which I love).... but other times, someone just decides to be lazy and take a pizza they've had sitting around under the counter for slices and just use that. So you paid $15+ for a pizza to be cooked fresh and you get a pizza that's dry and tastes like someone reheated the whole pizza. That was the last straw for me because they do it so many times... both of those things. Great pizza sauce, great pizza, but OMG, I can tell why I never see anyone inside your pizza place whenever I go... And they haven't changed... they used to sometimes just burn the crap out of the pizza too... you'd get a pizza that crumbles in your hand under it, or sometimes you'll get a crust with a huge bubble in the middle because they just didn't care. And that's why I stopped ordering from them... just laziness and no one is really around to make sure they don't do these things...... shame, really.

I should have ordered this instead of Sarah Bella. I tried this pizza couple months before I left…read moreto TX and it was spot on. See my precious review. The pizza is perfect. Dough cooked just right NY style. Chewy with light browned bottom crust. The sauce is fresh and honestly the tastiest I have had around here, and they don't skimp on it. Plenty of cheese and pepperoni. Perfect. The other plus is the greek and middle eastern dishes. All fresh and tasty. Love the Shawarmas. Full of moist spiced meet so filling. Service amazing. Ordered online. Drive there 10 minutes later for pick up and already done. If you are ever in the area, it is a must try.

I think I may need to just stick to pizza with this place. I ordered a chicken Gyro. The chicken…read morethat they put on it were little thin tiny strips if you could even call them that. The thing just fell apart all over the place so I had to eat it with a knife and a fork. Just not that good. Some of the chicken was really hard. Honestly I don't even know if it was chicken. My dinner mate kept saying it was tofu but I don't know if it was that either. We also ordered mozzarella sticks which were fine, nice size, typical mozzarella sticks. We also ordered quesadillas that we put in the fridge for the next day. My mate took it for lunch the next day and he said he threw it in the garbage. Three stars for the mozzarella sticks.

This is my 9th or 10th order from Dom's over the past year or 2. The food is always good, fresh…read moremeat and veggies on the subs, plenty of toppings on the pizza, home runs in both categories. This particular review is about the consistently friendly courteous service from the phone order takers and the delivery people. It is no secret that ever since covid customer service, especially in fast and informal food places, has gone down the tubes. Good help is hard to find, excellent help almost unavailable, yet in all my orders, I have yet to find anything to be even mildly annoyed about, much less about which to complain. The consistency month after month, year after year, speaks very highly of the owners and managers at Dom's. Their insistence that their staff treat customers right is in my mind not only the key to outstanding business results, but a testimony to the integrity of the owner/manager team.

Great spot to stop in for a quick bite…read more I don't live in the area, so I can't comment on delivery or how Dom's compares to the other pizzerias in the area. But I do drive down Route 4 through Stillwater on occasion and when I'm in the mood for something quick to eat, I usually stop at Dom's. I think the main reason I stop there is that it has a nice parking lot in front and I don't have to worry about on street parking. So when I see Dom's right off the highway it's easy to pull into the lot. Inside, you order at the counter. It's really set up for takeout as there are only two small tables if you want to eat inside. They have a clean bathroom and a trashcan by the front door. The people at the counter have always been friendly and helpful. They serve pizza, subs, wings, and a few entrees. Cheese pizza is available by the slice, but they will throw ingredients on it and heat it up if you want it that way. Subs are decent. One time I got spaghetti to go and it was acceptable, not great. Prices are reasonable. All in all, it's a great place to stop by for a quick and easy snack or takeout meal. Not fancy, but it hits the spot.

Came here on a saucy night last weekend and I must say, it still lives up to the hype from my…read morechildhood. Being from Albany, this was my favorite place to grab a slice when I was in Troy. Nothing compared. Imagine being next door to another pizza spot and not having to worry about competing lol. Next door is certainly not it. The prices have gone up to match the times I guess. $8 for two slices and a can of Sprite lol I don't want to age myself but I remember when this was $3 haha. Definitely worth it still. Service still amazing, greeted upon entry. Typical NY hometown pizza joint ambiance. Soooo many specialty slices to choose from. Hot slices coming right up! I wish they would do a vegan pie/slice option. I've been waiting years for that lol...

THE. ABSOLUTE. BEST. PIZZA. EVER. I'm from Texas and I'm so glad I tried this pizza. I honestly…read moredon't think I can have dinner tonight!! Thank you!!