1. Two Old Forge Girls Catering

    0

    Old Forge, PA

    Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Two Old Forge Girls Catering

    3.0 (2 reviews)

    Two Old Forge Girls Catering Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Two Old Forge Girls Catering

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of AM W.
    0
    55
    11

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Caterers 338 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Constantino's Catering & Events - Antipasto Display

    Constantino's Catering & Events

    (10 reviews)

    UPDATE: Ten stars to Constantino's! They have perfected the art of Weddings. I cannot put into…read morewords the amount of care and detail every single staff member put into our Wedding last night. I can't imagine any other event venue in NEPA able to compete with this top notch crew. They set up all my decor and accessories, even figuring out how to hang a sign on the window that I had specially made, going above and beyond to cater to our needs. Every bartender, waitress, bus boy and cleaning staff had a smile on their face and genuinely enjoyed the evening as well. If you are a bride or groom, and want to have ZERO stress on your Wedding day, do yourself a favor and book Larry, Kelly, Alicia and their entire crew!!!! I haven't even had my Wedding at Constantino's yet and I already give them 5+ stars! I did however have the pleasure of having my bridal shower here a few weeks ago and it was a dream come true, I can't even wait until my Wedding day for them to surpass my expectations with their amazing food, amazing venue, friendly and professional staff, and impeccable service that you just cannot find anywhere else in this area. Larry and Alicia have specifically been outstanding to communicate and work with. I thank you all from the bottom of my heart for the time, attention and detail you put into each and every one of your customers.

    I can't say enough about how pleased I was for having chosen Constantino's to cater my family's New…read moreYear's Eve gathering. They were professional, prompt, and exceedingly courteous. The food was absolutely delicious and I will most definitely be calling them next year. Thank you. Thank you!!

    Anthony's of Old Forge - Half eaten chicken franchise and veal Calabrese with a side of pasta

    Anthony's of Old Forge

    (90 reviews)

    $$

    I did something stupid and I have zero regrets…read more I knew it was stupid. The waitress knew it was stupid. As did everyone at the bar. And you know what? I'd do it again in a heartbeat. Many years ago, I went on a little tour of Old Forge pizza. We tried the red. We tried the white. We went to the famous places. We went to the dives. But somehow we never made it to Anthony's? Maybe it was their hours? Maybe it was because the Old Forge white was not available by the cut? It's hard to say. But what I know for sure is that I came out of the tour with a deep abiding love for Old Forge white with broccoli. IMHO it needs the broccoli. Regrettably, my old favorites for white with broccoli have fallen from grace, which is a loss. But the silver lining is that I have found Anthony's and their white broccoli is amazing! An entire white broccoli pie is a staggering quantity of food. So when I walked up to the bar as a solo diner, and placed my order of a white broccoli pie for here, the waitress looked a little uneasy and paused for a moment. In the pause, I acknowledged that I knew I was ordering enough food for a crew, and that I expected to be taking much of it home. It also takes a staggeringly long time to bake something that large in an oven. And I knew that going in. So I nursed my Yuengling, and even took a few nibbles of bread and butter that were brought out while I waited. I have to say, that first bite just had me swooning, and I don't swoon easily. The top crust was beautifully seasoned with herbs, spices, and onions. The bottom crust was golden and crisp. The cheese was oozing and broccoli was bursting forth. Please, please, please eat this pizza in the restaurant. It's glorious when it first comes out of the oven. The longer it sits, the less crisp the bottom becomes. Trust me. It's worth it. With the beer, tip, and taxes, the whole thing set me back $33. Obviously there were leftovers too. My original plan had been to offer cuts of the pie to other folks at the bar, but by the time I got there, everyone had already eaten, so I wasn't able to give away a single cut. So it goes. And I did push myself to eat more than I should have. Slice one was a revelation. Slice two a delight. Slice three felt more like a dare. And slice four? That was pure hubris. I only got a couple of bites in and then I had to tap out. But I wanted to tackle at least half of the pie on premise. So it goes. I learned something about myself that night, but more importantly, I discovered a new Old Forge institution, to which I am looking forward to returning time and time again. P.S. I should note I saw lots of food come out, and really all the portions are huge. Just like I could have split this with a couple other folks, the same is true for every dish was brought to the bar.

    The best restaurant in town. The renovations are beautiful and the food exceptional. Love their…read more10oz filet always cooked perfect and matt at the bar is one of the best.

    Lucca Restaurant - Super Oily Chicken Marsala!

    Lucca Restaurant

    (54 reviews)

    $$

    I'm really disappointed with my recent order from The Restaurant named Luca, that came highly rated…read moreon DoorDash. I had such high hopes for the chicken marsala, especially given its stellar reviews. Let's start with the house salad, which was made exactly to my specifications. I asked for no onion and no tomato, and they happily accommodated me. The dressing, though served in a tiny dipping cup, was absolutely delicious. I wish there had been a bit more, but I didn't request extra, so I can't fault them there. Now, onto the main dish: the Chicken Marsala. It arrived piping hot and securely wrapped in shrink wrap, which was a nice touch to keep it warm. Unfortunately, that's where the positives end. When I opened it, I found only two and a half small chicken tenders that seemed barely dipped in any kind of flour or seasoning. It looked like they had been hastily cooked in a frying pan without any browning (Maillard Effect/Reaction) , and there was minimal breading/flouring at all and upon closer inspection, it seemed like the chicken was just coated with mashed potatoes that came with it rather than a proper egg and flour mixture. While I acknowledge it was freshly made, it felt rushed. The chicken and mushrooms were lacking any flavor from the marsala sauce, which clearly hadn't been cooked long enough to absorb any of the sauce's supposed rich taste. Speaking of the sauce, it was disappointing there was a noticeable amount of oil separating from the broth, forming clumps in a sea of oil & grease, reminiscent of survivors clinging to debris after The Titanic's sinking! The sauce lacked any seasoning, and I could barely detect the signature marsala wine flavor that should be present in this dish. I understand that many places may simplify their recipes nowadays, but this was just bland. There was no salt, pepper, or any other seasonings to enhance the dish. When I attempted to contact the restaurant for feedback, I found out they were closed for orders, which led me to believe my meal was one of the last they prepared for the evening. It seemed like the chef was in a hurry to finish up for the night, resulting in a haphazard meal that lacked care that Lucca was allegedly known for! Comparing my dish to the mouthwatering images on their website, it's clear there's a significant difference. My chicken marsala was not the dark brown, rich, well seasoned and flavorful thick Marsala Sauce/gravy I expected (from their menu pictures and other restaurants) but instead, it was oily and devoid of flavor. Even the mushrooms, though fresh, tasted like they had just been rinsed off and sliced without any seasoning or browned (Maillard Effect/Reaction) in its preparation. Ultimately, isn't the point of ordering Chicken Marsala to enjoy its savory, delicious sauce that enhances the chicken and mushrooms? Right now, I have to say that I've had better chicken marsala from a local grocery store's hot bar, and at a much lower price. It's a shame my experience didn't match the restaurant's reputation. Chicken Marsala not only can benefit from the Maillard Effect, but it is entirely DEPENDENT on it to build its signature flavor profile. The browning of the chicken cutlets and the mushrooms creates deep, savory compounds, which unfortunately my dish was severely lacking!

    Excellent food and service. The chicken, filet and cheese ravioli. The antipasti platter was also…read morevery good.

    Two Old Forge Girls Catering - catering - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...