With speedy service and a smile I received my slice of mac and cheese pizza.It was different and tasty with mushrooms, noodles, banana peppers and cheese.They offer tacos, subs, salads and a variety of pizzas.Plenty of on site parking. read more

Two Guys Pizza - Two Guys Pizza Mac & Cheese Slice - A slice of mac and cheese pizza with melted cheese and toppings on a white paper plate. - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Lots of choices on the menu like salads, subs , tacos and speciality pizzas.With speedy service and a smile I got my slice of deep dish pizza.It had cheese, Pepperoni and cut up mozzarella sticks.It was a unique and tasty combination. Plenty of parking in their lot. read more

Two Guys Pizza - Two Giys Pizza Deep Dish Slice - A rectangular slice of deep dish pizza with cheese, pepperoni, sausage, and other toppings on a white paper plate. - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

1 turkey sub! No extras but, we were charged for extra meat?? $5.00 delivery charge plus a 5% surcharge and tax!!! Not to mention a tip!! We did not use DoorDash. This was a regular phone order! read more

Two Guys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

The quick version of this: we received a pizza that had raw dough in the middle, even though the pizza was ordered well done. The long version: we moved to the area in 2020 and had to find our new pizza joint, we tried every pizza place in the area. The garlic parm wings impressed us, but the pizza was a bit undercooked - we moved onto the next place. Fast forward to today, we get the itch for some good wings and two guys is on the way home - we decide to give it a second chance. Keeping a detailed list of every pizza joint in the area, we are reminded of the undercooked pizza we had in 2020 and specifically asked for the pizza to be well done. One bite into the pizza and immediately realize I have a mouthful of raw dough. Plus one star for David's cookies. read more

Two Guys Pizza - The review I wrote in my phone in 2020 - A written review about food from Two Guys Pizza, mentioning pizza, wings, and pickup time. - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

A little out of my way but I kept hearing stories of the General Tso Pizza so when I was in that direction I decided to give it a shot. Called the order in at Lunchtime and food was ready on time when I arrived about 20 minutes later. Decent size seating area so you should be able to find a spot to sit down and enjoy your lunch. And good thing too because the General Tso Pizza definitely isn't a "Sit in your truck and eat a slice " kind of pie. Tasty enough, but with all the Sauce / Rice and just the general way it's made this is pretty much a Knife and Fork kind of Pizza as it's MESSY !! $15 with tax for a Personal specialty Pizza is pretty much in line nowadays. 4 Stars out of 5. I wouldn't make a special trip out here, but if I was close I'd eat here again ! read more

I'd like to try a whole pizza to do a full review, but the slices were great. We got a cheese and pepperoni slice and a Big Mac & Cheese slice. I liked the thicker dough on the specialty slice better than the regular one. The flavors were good and fresh, and the dough had a good crunch. read more

Two Guys Pizza - Slice of cheese and pepperoni pizza - A close-up of a pepperoni pizza slice showing melted cheese, crispy crust, and pepperoni slices, served in a pizza box. - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

What pizza place doesn't have slices on the weekend? Pizza is mediocre at best. I'll spend the money elsewhere.

Pizza better than most but could use less cheese, more sauce, thinner crust and more time in oven. Tasted better second day when we baked it on high heat for more time. All in all better than most in area. However long way to go to beat 99's pizza read more

Worth the drive from Kenmore! Extensive "pizzeria style" menu items along with some new twists on your old favorites always using only fresh ingredients. Hot and cold dishes are well seasoned and expertly prepared every single time. Dining area is always clean and staff is attentive and present. The owner is on site as well. read more

Traditional Buffalo pizza! Thick crust, Lots and lots of cheese, and curled greasy pepperoni. Delish! Their sauce isnt overly spiced and gives out more of a tomato paste type flavor and consistency. The subs are average. Nothing special about them but if you are looking for a decent cold cut or chicken finger sub, give them a shot! The customer service is where they really shined. They were so friendly, greeted us while walking in and really made sure we had everything we needed. read more

Ordered pizza and wings last night. Was surprised on how fast they were able to complete our order, (20 minutes). C&P pizza was done perfectly with cup and char pepperoni. Garlic parm wings were done perfectly crispy but not dried out, seasoning was delicious. To top it all off, super friendly service! Can't wait to order again! read more

The variety of pizza is great! Lots of interesting topping combinations. I can only speak to the lunch time slice deal. The pizza is not super warm Coming out of the display. The flavors were good. The staff were friendly. The dining area has a bunch of tables, so it works well for a group to come in. They have a selection of pops available. The sub choices were plentiful! read more

I have tried this place so many times and always end with the same thoughts. The food is pretty good but the staff is NEVER friendly. Between the person on the phone when ordering who keeps words to a minimum and the delivery person (many times the same man) who has given us attitude I don't think I will order from them again. It doesn't take much to be a decent person! I don't appreciate the rude attitude and they clearly don't appreciate my business. Don't bother! read more

Wish I could give this place more stars. The food was really good, but everyone who works here seems to have a massive attitude problem. Called to place an order about 2 weeks ago, and the girl answered with hello. Didn't say anything about the business name so I thought I misdialed. Delivery guy got to my house and had some snarky comments about the delivery. Won't be giving them my business anymore. read more

I hadn't eaten from Two Guys in a couple of years. I was visiting a family member and we decided to go for lunch. I ordered a small steak salad and a 20 oz bottle of Pop. The salad was listed at $8.99 on the menu. I have no idea how much the bottle of Pop was. All I know is, I was absolutely floored when my bill came to $14.40 for those 2 items!!! Either the price of the salad wasn't correct on the menu, or that bottle of Pop was $4! The salad was good, but I'll never again spend $14.40 on a small salad and a pop. It's a shame, because the food IS good, but the cost of that two item meal was ridiculous. read more

I can't say enough about their fish frys, pizza and subs. The chicken wings are good but small. The owner is awesome! Highly recommend this place for anything. And if you are ever disappointed, tell them and they will take care of you. read more

I wanted to give this place a try as I just moved in to the neighborhood and it's close by. I ordered a large pizza and an order of mozzarella sticks. The place is very clean and the staff were friendly. There is a lot of seating area although I ordered take out. My pizza was average. I ordered cheese and pepperoni and it was like most other places. The mozzarella sticks were also average but it's hard to mess those up! Overall I may come back here if I'm in a crunch for time since it is close, but it was not my favorite place. read more

Two Guys Pizza - Large Cheese and Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

We are regulars to this pizza spot, half because we live on stony rd across the street and half because they have excellent products! Owners are friendly and accommodating, when the owners are present the food is 5 stars when they are not there food is 4 stars. A few visits ago I was recommended the General Tso pizza, so last night we gave it a try, will also be the last. I should of taken pictures but just didn't for some reason, anyways there was maybe 1-1.5 lil chopped up pieces of chicken per slice and there was more rice than anything, the taste wasn't good and the pizza wasn't good, stay far away from that pizza as it is extremely expensive and just terrible. Only reason for the two stars is cause mikes golden char wings always are ! read more

Husband ordered a deal, well thought he did. Said 34.00. When I called the next day to ask about it I was told he ordered 20 wings and 1 large pizza and that wasn't a deal. Total came to 59.00. Umm for pizza and wings? That's insane. Meanwhile we were told well I delivered your pizza that's what you got, whether it was a mistake or not no apologies. Bad business practice. read more

The pizza is great, me and my son Chris order there all the time. I love their chicken tacos but they have a Steak Supreme Hoagie that is out of this world!! And all the specialty pizzas...amazing! My favorite specialty pizza WAS the beef on weck pizza till I had the General Tsos pizza. We have no shortage of pizzerias in the area that's for sure, but there's a reason why we keep going back to Two Guys. Delivery is fast, and when I go in to pick up my food, even if they're busy, they're still super friendly to me. I won't go somewhere if I'm treated like a nuisance, but I NEVER get that at 2 Guys, SUPER FRIENDLY staff. Top notch pizza, wings, tacos, subs. I love it! I hope they never change! read more

Thanks to being located less then a mile from where I work, yesterday was the day I decided to give this place a try for lunch! After looking over the menu I decided to give the personal size chicken parmasagn pizza a chance and boy did I make the right decision. I placed my order over the phone for pickup and it was finished when I arrived. The place itself was a good size and provided a good amount of seating. The pizza was absolutely delicious, one of my favourites since moving to Buffalo. The cheese, the chicken, and the crust were all perfect. I'm excited to give more of this menu a shot in the future! read more

Two Guys Pizza - Pizza done right. - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Oh man, it's been ages since I did a review. Here's the scoop. I frequent here. Great people, great food, and realistic delivery times. I order more wings than the pizza. For a reason. Short story, their wings are really good, like really really good. They are huge, Crispy and juicy! Highly recommend it. The pizza, well, I have tried and tried to like it..... Something is off. Sorry guys. Their subs are great! I would have given 5 stars but the pizza....... Hey the Wings are AMAZING! read more

I love the pizza. However HORRID phone skills. If that person worked for me at my restaurant (which I am a restaurant owner) they'd be fired immediately. read more

Ordered a turkey sub and mozzarella sticks. Turkey seemed very low quality. Hard to mess up but was not good. Ate half threw rest out.

We have been ordering pizza and wings about once a week since the pandemic started. With a family of four, it's hard to find pizza and wings that we all like. Two Guys NEVER disappoints! Everything is consistently delicious! We are usually a pepperoni and cheese with medium wings kind of family but my son wanted to try Hawaiian. Everything we order is good! read more

Food is amazing. I love getting the Greek wraps and veggie tacos. This place is fast on demand. You can order and shoot right over and have the food waiting on you. read more

Ordered cheese and pepperoni pizza from here several times and we have never been disappointed. The pizza is evenly cooked and isn't too crispy. The amount of cheese is just right! Will visit again. read more

on point you can tell the food is fresh and they care about what they send out. just want to say thank you and great job to all the star staff. read more

We had ordered a pizza from Two Guys over the summer, shortly after they opened. and were disappointed with it. To be fair I figured, they had just opened and we would give them another try...so I held off with the review. So we recently ordered again from Two Guys and this time we had pizza and boneless wings because we had a coupon and it was a good opportunity to try them again. Unfortunately the pizza again was not very good. The crust is thinner than most typical pizza parlors around, but that's fine and in and of it self isn't bad, however the crust was really, really dry. This wasn't the worst problem though, the tomato sauce was so gloppy, bland, and dry also, that it was almost inedible. These were essentially the same comments we made to ourselves the first time we tried pizza from Two Guys. The boneless wings were fine, very tender and done really well, with a very tasty sauce. I think I prefer regular wings but these were Good and I would recommend these wholeheartedly. Overall I don't think we'll be back...I prefer the pizza from up the road from Riva's or would make the drive to Grasso's even though Two Guys is just around the corner from me. The wings upgraded the review to 2 stars...the Pizza alone would be 1 star. read more

Owned by " two guys", they wanted to bring an affordable product made with quality ingredients to the outskirts of Lancaster and they hit a home run. When I order a royal sub, I want real capicola. Not the fake crap that most shops use. They layer 6 or 7 slices of REAL capicola on top of three lengthy Italian sausage patties. If I were to guess, it is Mineo & Sapio sausage. I'll find out next time I go. We've eaten inside a few times. The place is clean and they have free WiFi. We mostly order to go because we live close by. Service is fast. Great selection of pizzas, subs, and other items. Their steak pizza is my favorite. All of the pizzas have a personal size too. So rather than put down $7 into the golden arches, or the king of burger coffers, give these guys a chance... er... give these Two Guys a chance. You'll be back again. read more

We were excited to try Two Guys since the signs went up! My step son and I each ordered a calzone. One just cheese, and one cheese and pepperoni. My order was ready in 20 minutes. When I went in, I met one of the owners, the delivery guy, and the girl working the counter (sorry I am horrible with names). Everyone was really nice and they genuinely appreciated our business. There was plenty of parking and it was easy to get in and out of the lot onto Walden Ave. The seating area was clean and organized as was the counter area. I only live 4 miles away, and it smelled so good it was torture to have to wait to eat!!! The calzones were awesome! Just the right amount of ricotta cheese, garlic and spices. However, I was ecstatic that the sauce was not a watery marinara, it was thick and stuck to each piece dipped. Neither of us could finish our meal, it was so much food. You have gained a loyal customer! Great job and good luck. read more

Went there for lunch today and had the lunch special, 2 slices and a drink for $6.00. These were the specialty slices too, which made it even more appealing for the price. Readily available upon walking in were 4 different pizza types. I had the Buffalo Wing slice and a Steak Pizza slice. Absolutely delicious. Where else in Lancaster can you get specialty pizza by the slice for lunch? The atmosphere was clean and inviting. Very friendly people working there. The menu has many more items that I cannot wait to try. I highly recommend this place. read more

We ordered steak subs and ham subs and it was awful! The steak was steakums, and super greasy, not much flavor. The ham was disappointing as well. This place used to be the absolute best , loves them and is no longer !!! Soo disappointed read more

Holy smokes. So good. Wings were perfect. Pizza was delicious. All I can say is it's worth every penny. Wow.

After seeing the Chicken Finger Dinner a friend ordered from Two Guys a few days ago I decided to bring a Family Size (15 fingers) order home to my glutenous sons. I was a bit worried about having enough when I saw a few extra vehicles in the driveway indicating that there were friends over that their own families never seem to feed. It turns out that I didn't need to fret as the fingers were monstrous and fed four starving Call Of Duty gamers easily and surprisingly there a couple left for me to sample. Its not only the quantity but quality as well as the one I was allowed to taste was crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. The fries included with the meal were just about perfect as well. read more

I love fish fries and am always looking to try new ones. I not only enjoy the fish, but the sides must be homemade too. I have eaten a few at Two Guys now and they have all been fresh and give a very generous portion. The fish was battered and very fresh, the noodle salad was delicious, cole slaw creamy and fries very good. The price is great, under $11.00. Last week I tried somewhere else and paid $14+ and did not enjoy the sides one bit, to me, the sides are just as important as the fish. Someone told me about the Bacon Blue Steak sub (not sure of correct name) but it was juicy tender and I love the taste of the blue cheese in it. I tried that last week. When I find a good place, I like to go back and try different things. read more

I have ordered here quite a few times and it's my local favorite so far! Still not used to the buffalo style pizza as I'm a Virginia Beach native but everything I get is always good. The salads are huge and filling and the portions are huge! The delivery is always super fast and everyone is always so nice read more

Ordered from here 50 minutes before they closed and at the start the guy didn't understand what I was trying to order, when I finished ordering it was the wrong order, and when I got there to pick up my food... the DOOR was LOCKED. The place was supposed to be open for another 20 minutes. When I knocked on the door no one answered and when I tried to get his attention he told me to leave. I waited outside to ask him where my food is and he said I never ordered, I confirmed the phone number with him and he said I never called.All the while holding a box of the same food I ordered. I come to this place all the time but maybe not anymore. read more

Subs and wings are really good . Plain pizza is not that great but they have speciality ones that are really good

We really enjoyed our Two Guys pizza. I called in and wasn't put on hold! That was nice! When I arrived it was ready perfect and hot. I liked that the pepperoni was spicy and the sauce was so good. I feel it was a great value and very tasty. I thought the crust was a little thick but it was good. read more

Two Guys Pizza - a slice of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all