Came home from being out of town, and of course needed a buffalo pizza fix! So went to my neighborhood spot and tried one of there new pizzas, the Spicy meat lovers!!!! OMG... This was absolutely delicious!!! Nice and spicy. It is rich, which was fine because it controlled me eating only one slice vs three hahaha! They have a few more new items on the menu, ill be checking out soon! read more

See all

Food is very tasty. Ordered two larges, fries, and onion rings. $60 felt like a lot for two small larges and decent, if not generous shares of fries and rings. I was a bit surprised the place had no one in there on a Friday night, but I think it's only takeout? Service was decent. Person was super nice. When I said it was for a kids' slumber party, she gave me a bunch of paper plates. read more

La Pizza Club - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Ive always been a fan of their pizza, one of my kids is super picky and this is about the only pizza he'll eat. It's always cooked well, never sloppy looking and the sauce isn't so sweet like a lot of places are. I went in on a Wednesday this week and found out their Wednesday special is a large cheese & pep for $18. I have to put that in my calendar. read more

Don't go here. The front register person was extremely rude for no reason. I asked her for a blue cheese, she sighed, and then she slammed it on the counter. Then she was so short with me and I was so confused where this was all coming from. She did this all in front of my son. I gave her that negative energy right back and she tried apologizing, then she started mumbling under her breath about me, while walking away to the bathroom. All in all- the pizza was bad, but the customer service was worse. read more

A few weeks ago I tried to order a Roast Beef sub. I was rudely told on the phone that they have not sold Roast Beef for over a year. When I mentioned that it was on the online menu, I was told they have not updated the menu. This week I called and ordered 3 chicken finger dinners. The lady who answers was rude again! The online price said $12.99. Before my order was delivered, I received a call that I gave the wrong credit card number. She was friendly for this call. I had her read it to me. Nope I gave the correct number, they entered it wrong. My bills was $80. I called to question and the price is actually $18.99. Bait and Switch? Why are they not updating the online menu? Its been a year! Also, all 3 of us had stomach issues for 2 days after eating the chicken finger dinners. This was the last time, after many years as a customer, that we order from this business. read more

I've been to LA Pizza club many times back in the day, but this was thr first time I've had them in years and it was still pretty good. My fries were a bit cold, but nothing an air fryer couldn't fix. The fingers were good and there was a chicken soulvaki sub that was also pretty good. Prices are reasonable and portion size was great. I can't speak on the pizza because it's been years since I've had it, but I'll try that next time. read more

La Pizza Club - Honey mustard fingers & fries - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

My favorite place to get a chicken finger dinner. Their wings that are done on the pit are amazing too

I've tried LaPizza Club a few times lately and their specialty pizzas are very good and reasonably priced the service is friendly and quick. I'll be adding them to my "go to" list read more

We wanted a pizza and had a coupon for 1/2 off of a large one topping pizza. We ordered a cheese and onion pizza. We were told it would be ready for pick up in 25 minutes. It was ready right on time. While I could see the onions, I did not really get the taste of them. I did enjoy the pizza, but I was a little disappointed that I could not taste more of the onions. read more

Had a party at our Business on Thursday 2/29/2024, bought 4 party platters from La Pizza club, all 30 people could not say enough nice things about the food and how it was prepared . John Glennon Creative Storage Systems Buffalo NY. read more

I've been coming here for years and it has the best steak hoagies. Screaming hot till the last bite. I've been to Pat and Gino's in Philly and there is no comparison. read more

La Pizza Club - Steak Hoagie with peppers, onions and mushrooms. Fantastic! - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

A prototypical Buffalo Pizza. Not too thick, not too thin. Just right. Nestled in the heart of the Hertel Avenue strip, La Pizza Club is a wonderful, family owned joint that has been around for quite some time, yet seems to fly under the radar when people cite their favorite WNY pizza establishments. They offer a consistent product and it's hard to beat their Wednesday special of a large 1-topping pizza for $11.99. That's only $15.83 Candian for all of our friends to the north, in case you were wondering. Oh, you weren't? Oh well. It's a good deal. Classic Buffalo pies, solid wings, friendly staff, and no frills takeout service. What more can you ask for? read more

La Pizza Club - Large pie; half cheese, half green + red sweet peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

L.A. Pizza is actually pretty awful. But Buffalo Pizza is awesome. So ignore the name and try it, and compare to some of the best slices in town, such as Imperial, Bella, Franco's, Molinara's, and Good Guys. La Pizza is somewhere between 3 star and 4 star pizza. A little old and congealed on the slices sometimes, which I've heard other people complain about too. But it still tasted pretty good, and certainly hit the spot. And the guy serving me the slices is always super friendly and nice. There's nowhere to sit in here, so you'll be getting your slice to go. Try Zip's and Daddio's down the road too. I'll give it a 4 for being friendly and not bad. But a word to the wise: they need to warm up their slices for their customers. They taste way better that way, than out of a warmer and therefore lukewarm. Not that Luke is particularly warm. Unless he's like, sunning himself on a golf course in Scottsdale Arizona in August. read more

La Pizza Club - I can't hear you: LA LA LA LA - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Very plain, tasteless pizza. Unfriendly / almost rude service. Would not recommend. Lots of better options on Hertel to choose from.

I used to hang out at this pizzeria when I was a teenager. They have amazing pizza & great pizza subs. You'll want to order take out or delivery,because the place is too small & claustrophobic.Its very busy,the food is great,a little pricey & not easy enough to sit down & eat there. The restrooms are way too small also. Very uncomfortable. But,if u want good Za or fingers & other things on the menu,have it delivered or order "take- out". You will be satisfied. Location- Hertel Ave & Wellington. Dennis,the owner has been there forever & at one time knew my name & what I was ordering. read more

Great local pizzeria on Hertel. They keep it simple, and I have never had a bad slice here. Worth a try!

One of the best pizza and sub places in the area

Their subs are amazing. Seriously, I wish I took a picture but I was hungry. Every single time they nail the order - extra tomatoes, light onions, ? No problem. My family gave La Pizza a shot after our former go-to started going downhill. Damn, what took us so long?! It's our third time ordering from them now and not a single disappointment. Made with care, good ingredients, and exactly what you order. Not to mention that my ham turkey salami sub looked like an ad when I unwrapped it. My family agrees. read more

They make a nice pizza with a soft yet crisp crust. Their pizza varieties are really great combinations of toppings, so get one of those if they appeal to you. I've also had their potato skins and pizza logs which are on par with any high quality pizza place in buffalo, definitely better than many in the city. I originally called for delivery, but they advised me pickup was SIGNIFICANTLY quicker so I decided to pick up this time. Good advice! Will order again! read more

So..tonight. Called La Pizza Club tonight for a pickup order. Always loved their pizza and service. Picked up the pizza, get home. Burnt on the bottom, pepperoni looks completely different than what they've had for 10 years..overall tasted horrible. Called them. Girl answers, very nice. I explain pizza was burned, no biggie. Just credit me. No biggie. She apologizes, takes my number and says she will just leave an in store credit. I say thank you, hang up. Three minutes later, manager calls and demands ( GET THIS!!!!) that he be able to deliver a new pizza, take back what we didn't eat, and refund only the amount of money for un- eaten pizza. So..I explain.."Listen, no biggie. The pizza is burned, its Sunday. We are going to bed soon, just credit us". Response??? Manager in an angry voice "Well I'm not just gonna give you a whole pizza for free!!! I can MAYBE give you ten bucks off but you still need to get the delivery tonight." My response? "CLICK". DONE. You will NEVER GET MY BUSINESS AGAIN. BTW..I have a sneaking suspicion owner/management has changed because this is NOT the pizza I always loved. Pepperoni tastes like cheap bologna, dough is tough and hard (and burned), and sauce is bland. Just supremely disappointing. " read more

La Pizza Club - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

This place never disappoints!! Steak pizza is diffrent from all the actually fry the onions. So it has that fried taste to it employees are always kind and patient when placing big orders. Very prompt delivery fair prices also read more

La Pizza Club - What's left of this carnival taste of fried onions and peppers on the steak pie delicious!! - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I've gotten pizza and wings here many times over the past few years. Pizza is always solid and their Chipotle BBQ wings are very good

Pizza is always consistent at La Pizza Club..... this IS Buffalo style pizza; not too thin & not too thick. Also added the garlic sesame crust - delicious!!! Also give the bbq wings off the pit a try - buffalos most underrated pizzeria!!! Never a bad experience, Pizza Club deserves a thumbs up! read more

La Pizza Club - Sorry, already started the demo..... - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Had a Mexican pizza, Yep it was very good. We lived in N.Buffalo some time ago and ordered here often, and the food was always good. We live in Grand Island now, but I wanted to try the pizza again, so I drove in to get one and it was worth the drive. They were nice enough to put the tomatoes and lettuce on the side, so we could warm it up when we got home. Easily worth the drive, will do it again ...Good to see Hertel looking good....good job guys. read more

I would give. 10 stars if I could! After no service at another "dog friendly" establishment on Hertel, I took my son and dog here, they welcomed the puppy with biscuits and water and couldn't be more accommodating! Well done La Pizza Club! read more

La Pizza Club - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

We ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza and 10 hot wings and 10 barbecue wings. It came to $35 when we picked up the order. We tipped them $4. Took it home and the verdict was unanimous: pizza is sub par (lacking a tomato base) and the wings (rubbery and soggy)are too. We tried this place because our usual place, Kenmore Francos, has been unreliable and inconsistent over the past year or two. We won't be going to either establishment any time soon. In fact, we're going to abstain from pizza and wings unless we cook them ourselves - More trouble, but good. read more

This was one summer. I moved from the Bronx. I was trying to get ice cream next door. Parking sucked. I was with my girl she wanted ice cream. We found parking and it was in front of this place. I went in to ask the person the car is sticking out by like 2 inches in its driveway. Plenty of room for cars to get out I was just being courteous . It was an elderly guy and don't know if he was the owner but he was rude up front. He said " If I get out I'm hit the car". I was like I'm literally getting ice cream and leaving. He then said "Do you speak English?" I was shocked. I never faced discrimination like that before. I grew up in the Bronx but I guess we was all minorities there but it still bothers me till this day. It was not needed. I speak perfect english I was born here. Racists don't need to be in business. Screw that place. I stormed out cause I'm not a confrontational person. Never got the ice cream. Moved out the area. read more

Not quite a four star. The crust was uneven, Very thick on one side. Sauce was deceently seasoned. Not much of a crust. Very heavy. The pepperoni was spicy but great. Overall a 3.5 read more

La Pizza Club - Thick on closest piece. :/ not even - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Great owner. Cheese pizza is the bomb. Great and fast service. Clean place. Some seating inside and out. Great location.

My quest for good Buffalo pizza continued last night as I decided to order from La Pizza Club. Despite living off of Hertel for almost a year now, I have never tried any of the pizza around here. I had a really good parking spot on my street, so I didn't want to drive, and I didn't want to pay for delivery. So lo and behold, I picked La Pizza Club because I could walk there. I called the number to place an order. As I've mentioned in my Lovejoy Pizza review, I hate slices, and would much rather order a freshly made personal sized pizza. I saw that La Pizza Club had a Mini 7" pizza, so when I called, I decided to order a Cheese and Pepperoni mini pizza. The guy on the phone informed me that it was more worth my money to get three slices instead. I asked him how fresh they were and he said "they just came out". I was faced with a real dilemma, but I decided to go for it. I told them I'd be there to pick them up shortly. When I arrived, the guy informed me that he threw a 4th piece in there as well (maybe they wanted to get rid of it?) I'm not really complaining because for just over $6, I got 4 slices of pizza. Not bad! The pizza was just OK though. I took them home, which may not have helped, because they weren't that fresh tasting. They had a perfect amount of cheese (not over the top, but just enough) but I wanted more sauce and less dough. I ate two slices and have the next two saved for today, but I just wasn't wow'd. read more

Had a delicious stuffed banana pepper pizza amongst their delicious regular cheese and pep. Food and service never disappoints! Not to mention a great bang for your buck !!! read more

Just had another Chicken Finger sub for lunch and this really is one of the better ones I have had in town. Still nice and crispy fingers, actually providing a little crunch to the sub. Plus they are beefy fingers, which makes for a stacked sub. I would have said Jim's Steakout was THE place to get one for out of towners to try, but they are over $10 after tax, this is just over $8. At same price this sub wins; but being even cheaper its hands down better. Also upped it a star as I had their Pizza and Wings Monday night before trick or treating at Sister in Laws. The wings were excellent, done in proper Buffalo style. Pizza is perfectly Buffalo too, medium dough, heavy cheese and slighty browned edges on thick pepperoni. Delicious. This is what a Buffalo Pizza place is all about. No wonder they have been in business over 35 years. Good Job guys. read more

Really good pizza, you shouldn't be disappointed if you eat here. The only thing is that the pizzas are pretty oily/greasy/messy. Ask them to "drain" or "deck" the pizza while it's cooking so that the water/oil can leak off and the bottom can crispy up a little more. read more

After years of this being my local pizza joint (and a four-star rating on yelp), we had the worst experience tonight. Food was far from ready, which is one of the few requirements for a good pizza place. This led to a discussion, and then an argument (I have hungry toddlers at home), and ultimately the owner telling me to get lost and giving me the finger...which I have a hard time excusing under any circumstance. There is one guy who has been working the front counter/phone for years (but not tonight) that is great (and probably single-handedly keeps this place in business): he UNDERSTANDS the customer. I don't know his name, but I will follow him wherever he goes next. In the mean time, we'll be heading to Milano's on Englewood. It's a favorite of my friend who was actually born/raised in the outskirts of Milan, Italy. Adds time to my pickup, but definitely worth it. read more

Only tried the Hitman sub, and found it AMAZING. Received a gift certificate that paid for three premium subs with a little change left over. Very friendly staff, VERY good food. read more

Having used to have lived in N. Buffalo and moved out to Kenmore, I still travel here to get my pizza. Friendly folks and great pizza make this the best pizza on Hertel! read more

It's definitely comfort food but not gourmet. For what it's worth and the timeliness, if you don't care about calories or paying a bit more for food that isn't bad tasting, go for it. read more

La Pizza Club - Eggplant parm, half my sub- - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

This is my second review of La Pizza Club. I just cant say enough nice things about them. The food is delicious. They are nice and courteous and friendly. Everything is always fresh, hot and delivered quickly!! I love this place! On days where I have worked long hours and I'm tired out--this is my go to for food. read more

I live in NJ, every time I come to Buffalo, I have to have The Hertel! It is the BEST! Don't miss out on this amazing sandwich!

this place was amazing! they were so friendly and everything we ordered was perfect! even though our order was difficult they were very understanding and made everything excellent! i highly recommend ordering from here! read more