Now that I've had every single thing on the menu from Great Lakes pizza, I feel like I can give a fair review. That's right! I've had their pizza, subs, wings, chicken fingers, salads, tacos, burgers, quesadillas, sides, and so on. I've even had their lent fish fry. This is the BEST quality pizzeria that I've been to. Everything is fresh and delicious every single time. The staff is great, food is always ready within its quoted time range, and I've even had food delivered and it was on time and still nice and hot! The prices are very reasonable for the quality and quantity. A few highlights as far as the food for me, would be their pizza, specifically their dough and sauce (I always get extra sauce because it's that good), but if you're looking for a specialty pizza, I'd recommend the steak Huron. It's like a steak sub, in pizza form! Delicious. Their chicken finger subs are miles better than anywhere else in the area, and I recommend their death sauce if you love spice. Although I have to say, their cold cut subs are better than anywhere else too, the cold cuts are always sliced nice and thin, and they're always piled high. For a cold cut sub, I'd have to recommend the American assorted! Their tacos, don't even get me started. Go with beef, chicken, or chicken finger, you can't go wrong. All amazing, and they're a great size. Salads, again, they're all fantastic! The beef taco salad and the julienne salad are my 2 favorites. It's hard for me to choose what I want to order from here, it really is THAT good! Adding a photo of the beef taco salad I ordered for lunch today, with nacho cheese and death sauce, and I added sour cream at home. It was so good, I could cry. read more

Great Lakes Pizza - Beef taco salad with death sauce and nacho cheese. 10/10 for SURE - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

We order subs from here, and let me just say that while his pizza and wings are great, every single sub that I, my wife, and in-laws have had from here has been on point. I never give 10/10 because perfection doesn't exist but this place warrants it. Always fast, always steaming hot, and they take care of their place and property. Go here, he cares about making fantastic food. read more

Great Service, great food. Recommend them. Will not be disappointed. Been ordering from them for years and haven't been disappointed.

Back again, Once again I was quickly greeted by one of the staff at the desk, and within moments I had my chicken finger pizza (and chicken finger meal/salad//all not pictured). The chicken finger pizza was done perfectly, good size chunks and it was ordered the only way it should be made, with a bleu cheese base. Spot on pizza, also so good my 3 year old had to get in on it. Chicken fingers were of good size and came with a fair amount of fries. ( I don't want to give a crispy rating due to in box sweating). Salad... container was completely full and appears to be quite fresh. Well done GL team.. read more

Great Lakes Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

The sub being good saved this rating. The estimated wait time via the online ordering was wrong and I needed to wait another 10 minutes for the pizza slices. I ordered extra meat for steak hoagie. I don't think it had extra meat, but it tasted good. The manager offered to remake the sub, but I was too hungry and wanted to eat. I hope the staff can verify if orders are correct before the customer receives it read more

I'm right down the street, so this is a pity. Found not one, but TWO long hairs in my cheese fries. Food handling 101: tie your flipping hair back. Management, please supervise your staff, because something went seriously wrong. Order was steak sandwich and cheese fries 1/6/25 at about 4:20pm if you care to track who in your kitchen it was. I will not order from here again. read more

Shawn's Pizza Reviews REVIEW # 19 GREAT LAKES PIZZA COMPANY INDIAN CHURCH RD. BUFFALO, NY SCORE 6.7 Friendly staff and a very nice, clean dining room. Heard a lot of good things about this place but I wasn't too impressed with the pizza. Pretty thick slice with a ton of cheese, almost too much. Sauce was lacking flavor quite a bit. Wasn't the worst slice but there are many better options close by. read more

Great Lakes Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Had an amazing fish fry tonight! Huge piece of fish with all the traditional WNY sides! Fish fry at a pizza place?! YES! read more

Great Lakes Pizza - Fish fry. coleslaw, potato salad, fries, macaroni salad, rye bread ! - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

My go to for pizza, wings, subs and more. Reasonable prices and quality food & service!

Decent pizza, nothing really special. I probably wouldn't get it again just because it really didn't leave any kind of impression on me as being extremely tasty. read more

Great Lakes Pizza - a sign for great lakes pizza company - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Not to be confused with declaring that Miss Garbo loves this food (Greta Loves Pizza). The service was really nice at Great Lakes, but it just wasn't very good pizza in my picky little book. The slice was dry and not warm at all... it tasted like it had been sitting around all day and was $2.44, which granted is nothing at all, but if it had been heated up to be piping hot (like every place should) perhaps it would have been more pleasing. Still, people love these slices so give them a try. read more

Great Lakes Pizza - My gf makes great lakes - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Pizza is such a complicated food...some like it thick, some like it thin, some like sweet sauce, some like tangy sauce, some like triangles and some like squares....Reviewing a pizza place in Buffalo is like playing along with Jeopardy on the TV. Sometimes you nail it, but most times, you don't. The pizza was pretty good. I liked the crust and the topping to crust ratio was appropriate. As of today, I've eaten from there twice and ordered from there once. Had I not tried a friend's pizza that they ordered, I never would have known that this pizza joint that I pass all the time actually had good pizza. It's very unassuming in appearance. The time I ordered from them, I only got wings. I called them at about 10 minutes before they were closing and I asked whether it was too late. She told me "no". As long as I was ordering before close, they would get it done for me. That was impressive because many places will stop selling 30-15 minutes before close so they can get out of there. Great Lakes didn't do that. When I got there about 10 minutes after close, they were waiting patiently with a smile; and they had fried my wings lightly, just as I had specified. Oh yeah..the prices were reasonable too! read more

Good eats very friendly. Excellent location plenty parkin. ,quaitiy food location easy to get to. Home delivery is prompt and fresh A1

Employees are nice, GL subs are my go-to for subs and they are the only pizza place that doesn't make insanely sloppy subs. I decided to try their pizza again after not having it in years because I always see people raving about it and I don't think the pizza is anything special and taste just like any other average pizzeria around here. I also know the economy is crazy and prices are high everywhere but I was surprised at the $38 price tag for a large pizza with fries (there was an additional topping on half the pizza). read more

Pizza is the best in town wings are always cooked perfect and all the employees are super friendly

Great little place to grab a casual bite to eat for lunch! The steak hoagie pizza had a cheddar cheese base that was surprisingly good, I have only ever had a red sauce or garlic oil base under my toppings before. An order of fried mushrooms came out piping hot and with a generous side of ranch for dipping. With two drinks, the total came to about $27, which was a bit steep but at least all food was of high quality. I'll be back to try one of the weekly or lunch specials they have during the week to keep it more frugal. read more

Great Lakes Pizza - Fried mushrooms (cause I can't get enough of them !) - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Decided to try a new place out today and went with Great Lakes cuz why the hell not? Anyways, ordered a large cheese and pep with 10 wings for delivery. The woman who took my order was nice as well as the delivery driver and it came pretty quick so that was a plus. However, the pizza was pretty good but nothing special, regular sauce, good crust, decent under carriage but was definitely on the more greasy side compared to others which I didn't really enjoy. Wings were excellent and cooked nice and crisp and not soggy like some other places. If I could give 3.5 stars I would because of the service and the wings. Another thing to note though is their box which states "better pizza, better price" do not find that true considering a large and 10 wings was over $30 after taxes and the pizza wasn't that great. Overall not a bad place and would try again but could be better read more

First time ordering from here and everything was delicious! Ordered a cheeseburger pizza, pepperoni pizza and BBQ & medium wings. The wings were extra saucy and very tasty. My favorite was the cheeseburger pizza. Definitely plan to order from here again! read more

Great Lakes Pizza - Cheeseburger pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I just had the BBQ/HOT wings - finished with the char on the grill ... these are MONEY. great size, cooked to perfection, the sauce has just enough zip to get the nose running. Great wings. read more

On our way through while traveling. Stopped by another pizza place that got better reviews but it turned out to be sketchy. Great Lakes had friendly staff & delicious food. We had the Lake Superior pizza & bbq wings & they were wonderful! t was great being able to bring in our own beer too. Nice seating area. read more

I've been a frequent customer of Great Lakes Pizza for years now starting back when they were still on Harlem Road. The pizza is really great. The crust is fluffy and results in the most satisfying crunch when you get to the end of your slice, the cheese is thick and luscious, and the pepperoni is perfectly crisp. Also I am a huge fan of their chicken finger pizza with the white sauce. There's a ton of chicken finger bits on it and the white sauce (blue cheese) really hits the spot. I know not many people think to get a quesadilla at a pizza place, but GLP has beyond awesome chicken quesadillas. The tortilla is perfectly crisp in a way that I could never replicate at home. Inside the quesadilla is chicken, cheese, and some sort of red sauce. It comes with lettuce, sour cream, and salsa on the side. I like to spread the sour cream on the quesadilla and put lettuce on top. It's the best! None of the other pizzerias I've been to have had quesadillas on the menu. Often I go to GLP just to get a quesadilla. Other quesadillas , whether they be from home or a restaurant, pale in comparison to the quesadillas from Great Lakes. Every time I go to Great Lakes the same guy cashes me out (I'm 99% sure he is the owner) and he is always very nice and cordial. One time I told him that I loved the quesadillas and he said "Yeah, they're pretty good". Humble guy! Lol read more

Great Lakes Pizza - Chicken quesadillas - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

This is my go to pizza and wings. Every single time is has been perfect. Their other products are great too. Great selection of subs and love the fried tacos. My father looks forward to the sausage subs. The staff is always friendly. The website is easy to order from too. I love this place. read more

The pizza here is a little on the greasy side. Of course, this is the perfect recipe for a "Pros & Cons" discussion: PRO Greasier pizza is usually indicative of a thicker cheese ratio (score!). Also, the lipid levels in this pie force you to stop shoveling slice after slice down your esophagus, and making it easier to enjoy one or two and not feel like a total fatty. CON You leave the dinner table after eating this pizza feeling like you ingested a toilet flushing or two from a Donald Trump rally. Truth be told, it was a little bit on the uncomfortable end of the greasiness spectrum. I hate to say it, but the cheese pizza was more appetizing than the cheese & pep, and more palatable. Sweeter sauce and chewy dough to round it all out, but a little to inconsistent on the quality to fully recommend this pizza to the Yelp Nation. read more

Great Lakes Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Great, tasty, hot, consistently delicious food. We order frequently as we work at a nearby business. The food from subs to pizza to quesadillas are all very good. The tiny details to presentation, even though it's delivery haven't gone unnoticed. I'd take a picture of my quesadilla now but I've already inhaled 3/4 of it! read more

The only place we go. We tried GL's for the first time about a year and a half ago and have been going ever since. The food is always good and consistent. We have never had a bad order and when we did have a small problem 1 time it was immediately rectified. Glad we are able to support this small business. read more

This is my absolute favorite pizza in Buffalo. But all of their food is good. The service is always phenomenal and staff is incredibly kind. I love giving this place my business AND the food is amazing. What's not to love ?! read more

Saddest sub I can say I've ever seen. This is there stinger sub like $13 dollars. There is like no steak on the sub clearly half of the sub all you see is the roll. read more

Great Lakes Pizza - Half of a stinger sub or what they think is a stinger sub can't find much steak at all and it's half bate with nothing at all on it. - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

So lately I have been ordering exclusively from Great Lakes, specifically for chicken finger subs. Haven't tried the pizza or really anything else, or any other sub.. but, the chicken finger subs are just outstanding. They are text book Buffalo small pizzeria style subs, with the toasted Costanza's sub rolls and oversize fingers, which you get 4 on a whole sub, so alot. Piccaso's might be the ultimate chicken finger sub experience around here (I think), but they're also $15. What you get for like $10 is I'd say about a perfect sub. Pics to come! read more

Pizza was good. Had cheese pepperoni on half and mushroom on half. I liked the mushroom because they weren't freeze dried like everywhere else. Had a coupon also. read more

This is my absolute favorite pizza place in the world, I've been a customer for years, since its beginning when they first opened on Harlem Rd. Everything from the food, to the menu selection, to the service is on point. First, the food. Everything is great quality, always fresh and delicious. My favorite thing to get from here is a sub, and I can't even choose a favorite kind of sub. Chicken finger, stinger, turkey bacon, and tuna are all tied because they're just that incredible. The pizza is great, they have so many different specialty pizzas but my personal favorite is the Steak Huron, and I highly recommend it! I have also ordered wings, chicken fingers, tacos, and snacks and sides from here and they are all just phenomenal. You really can't go wrong with anything you choose from the menu. The menu by the way, is huge and there is something for everyone. Tons of specialty subs and pizzas, if you can imagine it, it's probably already on the menu. The Greek sub is unique and wonderful! I ordered it one year for my birthday and was not disappointed. There are also tons of sides, from fries to nachos to fried pepper jack Mac and cheese bites. I have tried them all and they're all awesome. They have all tacos, quesadillas, burgers, chicken sandwiches, and salads too. And of course, the usual Buffalo pizzeria faire, pizza, wings and the like. Again, all tasty. If you eat in, they also offer beer and wine, and they have bottled, canned, or fountain Pepsi products. The service is just another plus. Everyone is friendly and they are wonderful to their customers. The few RARE times (out of hundreds of visits) that I have had an issue, it was resolved without a problem, and they have even delivered it for free when the problem was their fault. Mistakes happen, we're all human, but they are willing to make it right every time and go the extra mile to make sure you are happy. Any time I've ordered delivery, the food arrived within the quoted time, hot and fresh. I've yet to have a bad experience with the service. Another great thing about Great Lakes Pizza, is that they have really good specials. At the time of writing this review, Monday is any large specialty pizza for $14.99, Tuesday is sub day (buy 2 get 1 free), Wednesday they have a special on large cheese and one topping pizzas, and Thursday is taco day. They also have daily deals and lunch specials. I love a place that saves me money. They also do punch cards for subs and pizza, so after you buy 10 you get a free one. I HIGHLY recommend trying this place if you haven't already, and you'll see why it's a local favorite. They will always have me as a customer!! read more

This is my and my family's favorite pizzeria in the West Seneca area. The sauce is what makes the pizza. BBQ are nice size, saucy, and crispy. Prices are very reasonable as well. Definitely recommend. read more

Deep fried tacos! I reviewed this place before with three stars. I'm giving it four now because the pizza is much better than it was before and I found out they sell deep fried tacos. Tacos were great, almost as good as the fair. Pizza has room for improvement but it's better. read more

One of our go to South Buffalo/West Seneca pizzerias (we only have a few). Great Lakes cooks up a solid pie, has prices on par with the area, preps/delivers in a timely manner, and offers a good dine in experience. What more could you ask for. Wings and subs are solid as well, but we're a pizza focused bunch. On that note, they offer a good variety of specialty pizzas for those special occasions and hard to please eaters. Living in the area we go back often and you likely will too. They make pizza well. read more

Have had their food quite a few times now as they're very close to me. They have delicious wings, garlic bread, and smothered fries!

Absolutely love this place. They are friendly, prompt with delivery and their food is GREAT!!

This is now my go to place. The pizza is always good, the bbq wings are charred perfect, and you can actually taste the ingredients are fresh. Got a spinach pizza one time (minus olives, add meatballs) and it was great with fresh spinach, not nasty frozen like most other places. read more

Everything I've had here is great. Delivery is fast and the food is always hot. Even with the recent pandemic, they are still keeping on. No doubt it is stressful but staff is pleasant. Thank you for continuing to serve the community during these difficult times. read more

My husband and I were excited to try this place reading all the reviews and brosing their menu. Although they did taste good, we both got food poisoning from the chicken. I know things happen etc etc but as a restaurant, food safety is the utmost importance. Unfortunately, it turned our stomaches so we won't be trying this joint again which is such a shame. Ive lived in the SB WS area all my life and always try to patron our local businesses. I hope the owners take this review as constructive criticism and maybe will double check their food prep habits. read more

This place is a great little shop off the beaten path. I stumbled upon it one time and had to come back to check it out again. They have a good local style pizza that I got the first time and was surprised how cheesy their pizza was. Needless to say, it hit the spot. I came back today to try some other things on the menu, and it turns out their other items are just as good. They make a killer chicken finger sub, and their fries are the perfect golden crispness you dream of when you order french fries. I would definitely recommend stopping down here sometimes and trying them out. read more

My go to pizza place! Subs, pizza, everything is delish! Punch cards are definitely a plus! Everyone is nice and prices are reasonable.