Absolute best custard I've ever had. They have so many options of sundaes, it's unreal. This is my second time here and I drove 30 min out of the way to come this time. First time I had the Cherry Lee Lewis which was delicious. This time, I had the White Chocolate Raspberry, which is one of their specials. It wasn't as good as the Cherry, but the custard was still delicious. The owners have always been super nice. Highly recommend. read more

Twisted Turtle Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

This was one of the first stops we made when we were in St Augustine. They have tons of options of sundaes here. I'm happy the even had a really small version bc I didn't want too much yet my husband wanted his own and he didn't want to share. We both enjoyed our sundaes and there's def a flavor for everyone. The service was ok. And the ambiance had a huge coastal mural on the wall and cute blue aqua light pendants. read more

Twisted Turtle Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Twisted Turtle Creamery is an absolute must-visit if you're craving something sweet. The ice cream is incredibly rich and creamy, with unique flavors that really stand out from your typical spots. You can tell everything is made with care and high-quality ingredients. The atmosphere is fun and welcoming, making it a great place to hang out and treat yourself. The staff is friendly, patient, and happy to help you find the perfect flavor. Whether you're a classic vanilla person or looking to try something new, Twisted Turtle Creamery won't disappoint. read more

In response to the business owners comment: The classic 'use a spoon' solution -- truly the gold standard in customer care. Apparently, $10 gets you a milkshake and passive aggressive lesson in utensil use. I was all for chocolate chips, just not an avalanche -- when a third of the cup is solid mix-ins, it stops being a drink. Also, just because the high price is listed doesn't make it reasonable. read more

See all

So we went to this little ice cream shop in world, golf village, and it is absolutely fantastic! Again, it looks so good and I ate it without taking pictures I had the Cherry Lee Lewis and it was sooooo good! It was a cute little shop where we feel very comfortable, and the service was filled with smiles. If you live in world golf Village or driving through, I would certainly suggest that you go there. My plan is to go back more often! read more

See all

Delicious! They offer a wide selection of unique sundaes. There should be something for everyone here. Sundaes are made with soft serve ice cream, but they are loaded with toppings. All in our group loved their choice. read more

See all

This place is outstanding! It was recommended to us and I am very happy that we had an opportunity to try it! Walking in, the place was immaculately clean. There were pictures all around the place that had examples of what their ice creams looked like! Furthermore the staff there was so nice. They were really informative and knowledgeable about their products. The love and pride that they had for their products really showed. I dont blame them since they make everything in house and everything I had was delicious! The ice cream itself was outstanding. I'm both glad (for my weight) and sad (for the taste) that I dont live closer. If I did, I'd be a regular there! I got the cheesecake (turtle style) Sunday and it was outstanding read more

Fun little find in a random strip mall. I love that you can turn any sundae into a milkshake. I got the butter pecan milkshake with bourbon whipped cream. The whipped cream had more of a kick than I was expecting. They are a custard shop and not an ice cream shop but it's very thick and creamy and has tons of flavor. read more

Twisted Turtle Creamery near Golf Village, St. Augustine. Omg!! I had to visit my favorite frozen custard shop on my first day back to St Augustine. So many choices--what to choose? Everything is so delicious sounding. It wasn't on the menu, but they made me the Lemon Meringue Sundae that I had there before. It was like being in 7th heaven! Definitely worth a visit!! My daughter loves their strawberry sundae where they use their own homemade sauce. read more

See all

Was delicious!! I don't normally finish an ice cream dish but I finished this one! I had the strawberry cheesecake, hubby had the Fiji banana split, kids had a strawberry milkshake and stair way to chocolate. Very polite and well kept place. Almost like a hidden gem! Loved the beach theme! read more

Twisted Turtle Creamery - The Fiji banana split - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Best ice cream of my life I would highly recommend coming here and get the cheesecake turtle style

Rock on the Turnovers, both Apple and cherry are tremendous. Yes the Twisted turtle Club, Strawberry Shortcake, and Stairway to Chocolate will rock the sweet tooth into a wonderful jams session LOL!!!!!! Their desserts are worth waiting for, so leave the restaurant and go get some that is much better!!!!!! read more

Overall great experience at this place. Came here after a meal from a restaurant next door. There were a good number of people at the place so we were intrigued and wanted to try and see what the fuzz about. Plenty of flavors to choose from but that day I just wanted a plain old soft serve ice cream. Very good and it hit the spot. Staff were very friendly. read more

See all

So amazing! We also got the "sweet Melissa" not pictured because it was gone too quick. The ice cream is so soft and creamy will be back read more

Twisted Turtle Creamery - S'mores sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Very confusing menu, staff was very unhelpful. There was no one else there and when I ordered a sundae, the owner hesitated asked her coworker if she could make it? Said they would have to stop what they were doing and clean a bowl. Decided not to bother with that, ordered a plain cone and milkshake. Neither were very good. We love ice cream and we're so disappointed. Surprised by all the good reviews, place was empty. read more

Amazing custard. The turtle club is my favorite but they have a lot of cool creations that make you want to come back and try something new.

Totally worth the money we spent. It's nice to support a small business. Everything was fresh and home made. Can't stop bragging about it to my Jacksonville friends, worth the little drive to world golf village. read more

Twisted Turtle Creamery - Banana split - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

I had heard about this place from my parents who live nearby. I was in town for a long weekend that happened to coincide with national ice cream sandwich day. Twisted Turtle Creamery was offering a BOGO (buy one get one) ice cream sandwich deal. So we decided to pick some up for dessert. The shop is bright and the staff is friendly and welcoming. The cookies were homemade and the ice cream was creamy and delicious. We split each of the sandwiches into three so we could try some of each flavor. We had snickerdoodle cookies with vanilla ice cream and a chocolate cookie with chocolate ice cream. Both were outstanding. The cookies were soft and flavorful and the ice cream didn't melt too fast while we were indulging. I can see why my parents have raved about Twisted Turtle Creamery and will definitely consider returning the next time I'm visiting. read more

Delicious! They only have vanilla or chocolate custard but the options for how to have it served are limitless! I got Oreos and Reese's. My husband went with fruits. Both hit the spot! The lady's working were nice and quick even though they were busy. read more

The service was fantastic! We had a Sundae and a Banana Split and they were both delicious and the place is extremely clean!! Definitely a place to return again!! read more

They are so sweet and everything is delicious! I love this place. Will be back over and over again.

A love story: Oh so rarely do we stumble upon a hidden gem that we forget how soft the unicorns mane really is. In short; this place is absolutely fabulous! So many components needed to form such an experience. The husband behind the counter spinning a tale of how they all played a role in building their dream while putting together orders and explaining their menu options to customers . His wife working passionately to fill them, not cutting ANY corners in the process ( I literally watched her stop what she was doing to prepare fresh whipped cream) I had a quick flashback of sitting in my grandmother's kitchen watching her while she prepared us banana splits when we were kids.Their daughter; a Chef who clearly understands that quality and consistency are essential in producing a lasting brand. (they prepare nearly everything in house) clearly thought out flavor profiles and texture variations that work and complement each other really well. Their homemade custard was perfect in both consistency and flavor. Then executed perfectly to the menu description. Dang, someone pinch my cheek. During my tenor as an executive Chef and instructor at a culinary school this is literally what we taught and strived for, who we supported and who we were proud of. They hit it on every level. This place is an absolute MUST try. If they can maintain their consistency and keep pace it will be the best spot in town without really any competition. They have my business,and if you try them they will most likely have yours too. Thank you for strumming on some of my heart strings. You made my day read more

Twisted Turtle Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Ordered a birthday cake this past weekend . Not only was it the best tasting ice cream cake we have ever had, it was also beautifully decorated. Highly recommended... read more

Twisted Turtle Creamery - S'more's Birthday Cake! Amazing - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Delicious! Home made fudge, cheesecake ( for the Sunday topping) cookies, etc . We had the waffle bowl cheesecake sundae and the turtle sundae. read more

Love the coconut rum milkshake! We also had the butter pecan sundae and it was fantastic.

We heard great things about this shop and it exceeded our expectations. The owner was so wonderful and the custard was spectacular!! Such interesting choices as well!! We can't wait to go back!! read more

I had an amazing time today with the Wizard chef today. I asked her to make something special and she delivered her wizardry lol. We called it highway to heaven and weight watchers lmao!!! It had bourbon whip, homemade caramel salt with so much deliciousness I think it also had marshmallow. Like seriously it was great! So let's support these wonderful souls. And ask "Wizard" to do her thing!!! Ty so much see you in two months. I need to work off the calories read more

I have never experienced an ice cream shop that felt like a restaurant. Everything was handcrafted and made with a personal touch. This place was definitely different in the best possible way. Our daughters ordered the Smores Sunday and they actually toasted a huge marshmallow with a torch and put it on the graham cracker over the Sunday. It was incredible. read more

I ordered the Turtle Club Sundae and my husband ordered the strawberry cheesecake twister. They were both really good. You can taste that every ingredient is home made. The owners work behind the counter and are so sweet and patient. My only regret is that we got mediums instead of large! This place is a gem! read more

Twisted Turtle Creamery - Strawberry Cheesecake Twister - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

A great hidden gem! Clean space, kind service, and everything we have had here has been unique and delicious. All the toppings are fresh and the portions are huge! I hope that more people find this place - it is never busy so people are seriously missing out! read more

My husband and I stopped in after Dinner while on vacation. We had the Monkey Around banana split topped with a Turtle cookie, it was delicious. Will definitely visit again on our next vacation. It's a must visit. read more

Excellent place for an ice cream treat. Great selection and variety that will bring us back over and over again. Staff is awesome and friendly and background music is awesome. read more

Our family loves Twisted Turtle Creamery! Great little ice cream shop that makes yummy specialty sundaes with fresh, homemade ingredients and friendly customer service. Highly recommended! read more

First time and I love this place I'm. The Ice cream is really good and feels so home made it's crazy. The workers are so kind the cashier explained to us what they had and where everything on the menu was. The shops vibe was right on point with food they serve i could just chill there all day! read more