I always love a Tosco pizza. It's got a local hometown vibe every time you go in, and they're always quick and efficient. I usually order over the phone, and I've never had any problems. My favorite pizza to get is the White Flag, but add pineapple and jalapeño. Delicious. Their slices are huge but you can ask them to double cut them to make them more manageable and easy to share. Just make sure that you pick up at the same location that you ordered over the phone with. 10/10 read more

I receive the text every week about the daily specials. Ordered a sandwich, which was on special, but I didn't indicate when I ordered that I'd prefer the special price. the young lady behind the counter then told me that I could not get the special price because I did not mention it. It didn't even cross my mind that I had to tell them I would prefer to pay less money and get fries with it. I'm so disappointed with their service. read more

I had a very good experience with this pizza shop. A host that I believe is named Kenny was extremely helpful and informed of the menu. Kenny provided excellent customer service and made sure that the pizza shop delivered to my address and that I received my delivery once I had placed the order. If you do visit this restaurant please request Kenny of you want the best service. To management, I truly feel that Kenny is an asset to your business. I would not have placed my order with your business if Kenny had not been as hospital and informative. Thanks to Kenny this pizza shop will always be my first go to when in town! Thanks Kenny! read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - The food was great! Thank Kenny! - Pizza Near Me - Wallkill, New York

They have great food and variety of this to pick from and different types of subs to choice

New to the area. Passed by and decided to stop in. Pizza is good. on the thin side of crust which i like. Not overloaded with cheese that it drips off and that's all you taste. House salad is nice and perfect for 2-3people. besides tomato , cucumber, and red onion, i like the black olives and roasted red peppers! My only slight complaint is that on subsequent phone orders, when told a time to pick up, seems its never ready on time and you may have to wait like 5-10 minutes. the positive is it is then hot out of the oven! read more

The pizza tastes good. I have been coming to Sals now known as Toscos for years and ever since Sal retired it's gone down hill. The pizza today didnt have enough cheese and not all the way melted. Hopefully they turn it around soon. Staff is always friendly and establishment is clean. read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - Large cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wallkill, New York

Food took 2 and a half hours to be made. 45 minutes to make and the rest to get someone to deliver. When I called they said well it's under warmers so it won't be cold. And that I had to take up any refund with door dash. I explained I ordered from there website online through there slice app not door dash. Again they told me it was through door dash and not there problem. Cold food, rude customer service, and a 2 and a half hour wait for food that is barely inedible. Not the first time I've had an issue with them but will be my last. Stay away from this place better food, prices, and service in many other areas. read more

Can I give 1000 stars?! We ordered "Jalapeno Poppers" as side and "crazy chicken" pizza. Who ever owns this place cares so much about the clients, the pizza was amazing and they deliveried in 30 minutes. I choose Tosco's pizza over any pizzeria. The just earned a new client. read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - Jalapeno Poppers - Pizza Near Me - Wallkill, New York

See all

Terrible terrible terrible I can not say it enough!!!! The food, the customer service..I have 3 separate issues at this place. OH and be careful if they give you a credit. Dec 27th we ordered food, which got delivered and was totally wrong. My children were starving after waiting extremely long to begin with after being told it would be 30-40mins.. so I was given the option to be brought the correct items or get a credit. I took the credit...and made my kids food that they liked. Because it was getting late. Well, little did I know I had LESS THEN A WEEK TO USE IT, Because calling today 2/5 I was told they expire at the end of the year...would have been nice to know when I was given the option..I mean really who orders pizza twice a week?!?! Not that many people. And the girl who answered the phone today to tell me that was very rude. I recommend going to ANY other pizza place in the area. Not worth the bad experience and frustration here. read more

I'm not a food snob nor am I difficult to please. However, as a former frequent customer, this place is absolutely horrible. My friends and I made fun of Tosco's every time we ordered (2 hour delivery times, food cold and tastes like cardboard, routine incorrect orders). This was the norm every time we ordered. We finally found another Italian restaurant that delivers at lunchtime and are delighted to be rid of Tosco's. I most recently ordered here last week at dinnertime (their main competitor was closed for vacation) - just a simple bacon cheeseburger (plain) and fries. As usual, the order was wrong. It took 90 minutes to arrive. The fries were like cardboard. The burger order was completely wrong. All the food was cold. My friends who ordered different food all complained that their orders were incorrect also. This is a routine occurrence. The only thing Tosco's can make right here is their Sicilian pizza, but it takes literally 1-2 hours to arrive. We've all made fun of this place so often that we're relieved to have found a good competitor to use. read more

Nice standard pizza, decent selection. The crust is a little bland (even by cheap pizza standards), but the people in there are generally chill and easy to chat with while you wait form your order. read more

Wow, what can I say. This was a really amazing pizza. We got the Jalepeno poppers and an extra large Crazy Chicken. Yum yum yum. Now this was more of a NY pizza I was expecting. Th extra large was entirely too big for my wife and I but it was really something special. I am so glad my wife found this place and we will definitely be preserving her when we get the pizza cravings (or about once a week). I would absolutely say that if you haven't tried their cream cheese Jalapeno poppers and their Crazy Chicken Pizza, what are you even really doing with your life?! read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - X-large Crazy Chicken....it was every bit as good as it looks - Pizza Near Me - Wallkill, New York

Over charging for credit cards without notice. RIP OFF ALERT they are adding a hidden charge for credit cards. When I went to pick up my pies they added almost a dollar to the bill, when I asked why the charge was to high they informed me they add a charge for credit cards. I asked were is the notification off this charge, they said they don't know. No where is it stated! In store notice, coupons or online! I can understand the charge back but hate hidden charges and the lack of notification. Customer lost! read more

The sauce is good but I couldn't get past the vast amount of bugs flying around. It wasn't only flies... it was other winged critters... mosquitos (long legged ones), gnats.The place is a dirty mess. The garlic shakers are caked and nothing flows. The server took a plate off the table and instead of walking it to the back left it by the garbage can. The tables are a mess. It seems the Lucy rush was busy and no one has cleaned the tables. It's 2:27pm. They are not busy. We are the only customers here now. Lots of playing around amongst the staff and no care is given the place. It's sad because the food is probably really good based on the sauce I tasted on their pizza. read more

Disgusting food! And terrible costumer service, I asked for a manger and they gave me a fake name. Weird and unfortunate to a family business. read more

Terrible service!!!! Every time we call to place an order it take 20 minutes to repeat the order, your put on hold. The one gentleman ( I'm being sarcastic) is very rude doesn't know how to take orders and more than 50% of the time it take 60 to 90 minutes to deliver, the orders are wrong and cold! Have spoken to Manager and she was very rude too. Not going to be using them anytime soon! The only thing they have going for that place is Kaitlyn. When she's in Orders are correct and taken in a timely manner and she is professional and courteous! And no matter how terrible the service is, I tip the delivery guy quite handsomely. Not his fault! read more

Tosco's Pizzeria is an amazing Italian spot. I am a huge fan of pasta, and I loved their pasta here. It was delicious and a good price.

Poor food quality, rude staff, outdated pricing on online menu. Only reason for 1 star is pleasant prompt delivery boys.

This place is not good. The restaurant had a ton of flies and we did not enjoy our food. Paninis were soaked with dressing (who puts dressing in a panini??) and as a result the bread was extremely heavy and mushy. It tasted like raw dough. The meatballs in the meatball parm hero had no flavor. The servers were friendly but extremely busy with take out orders so service was slow despite there only being 2 tables for dinner. I wouldn't return. I hope they can take care of their insect problem. read more

Staff at front counter is very rude and unprofessional. Pizza occasionally too burn but not even worth calling to let them know. We've encountered two separate issues, and both times times were told "we're sorry." Definitely won't be using this place anytime soon. read more

We use to be frequent patrons of this establishment but lately we noticed that things aren't the same as it was! Tonight's pizza was very disappointing - The crust wasn't tender and tasty as it use to be and there's very very little cheese on it! I think we will start using Rob's in the Hamlet for a change! Not sure why they are skimping but I am hearing this from other folks as well! read more

Food looked good but tasted and smelled horribly. As I entered I was greeted kindly (it was awkward) they're definitely running a business with a health administration safety violation. Never again. 1 star read more

If u wanna wait 1 12-2 hours food food that sucks by then cuz it sat so long.have fun, food CAN BE great if it's not waiting almost two hours on a Wednesday afternoon to get to you read more

Bought wings today. Than realized I paid $20 for a dozen! Looked at menu and it says $13.95. I asked cashier and she says " oh is that the new menu?". On top of that, now they charge you for using a card! Thief! read more

Pizza was soooooo delicious. Great customer service ! I've ordered on 3 different occasions and all three I had a pleasant experience !

Tosco's has consistently been very disappointing. The food is pretty good, but every time delivery takes close to 2 hours. I have eaten at the location and found the food good and service fine; however, I have officially given up on ordering delivery. I end up calling to check on my meal every time and am told the generic "driver just left" yet still don't receive my food for 30 minutes. read more

Best pizza around ! Wings are big & juicy never dry & the fried Calamari is crispy & fresh served on a bed of lettuce & lots of lemon read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - All the knots ya can eat !!! Pizza is always slammin - Pizza Near Me - Wallkill, New York

What else to say right ? I decided to give them another try to sit in dining room wanted to pay some bills while waiting for food. No cell service fine it's pizzeria right WiFi ... I ask the girl and they don't give our password because WiFi if we use makes there computer crash.... we'll I got news for you I own a business you can pay for whatever you want in life update your WiFi to faster speed so your customers can use it ?? Wouldn't that be a good idea. In my opinion not a way to run business at all !!! read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - I really love my bread toasted, especially when you get oil and vinegar. I am so upset sandwich soggy - Pizza Near Me - Wallkill, New York

Excellent pizza! I'm hooked! I have never been disappointed there. Good pies and good prices what's not to like.

I placed a phone order for pickup and first hen my daughter got there to pick up they said that I just called it in and it was half hour before that. She had to wait at least another half hour for the order. We received the order when she got home and was missing two slices of pizza. I called to ask them for a credit for the missing food and this is where it gets crazy, I literally had to call them back 17 times to speak to someone. They either hung up or just left the phone on the counter, where I could hear everything that was going on. On the 18 try, they told me that they would return my call when they closed and never received a phone call back. I will try again today and I am hoping that I can actually resolve this issue. The customer service is horrible and if you are that busy,maybe they need to hire more help. read more

Not consistent. To be safe, order from Robs if you're around here. Their pizza came burnt and their chicken wings were dry. They do have okay pasta, I'll give you that they can cook a basic penne pasta. The people are kids, so you have to be VERY clear and ask every little detail because your charge of 20 may end up being 30. I usually order from this place but so disappointed with the service and the quality lately and make no mistake, the delivery kids are at no fault. However, the people who open the phone and take your delivery orders, PLEASE DO update your customer for any additional extra charges. Also, we are not ordering a lavish pizza so when there's extra charges, terrible communication and burnt food, that should be a sign to regroup your team managers/owners. As for us customers, be mindful they are young kids taking and adding up charges so when the food is delivered you may get hit with out of nowhere extra bucks.. it's a shame to say, this place has seen better days. Anytime you order with the coupons (they mail it to your house for deals but it's not really adeal) you get charged extra 7-10 bucks, so beware. S U C K S is my final thought, probably will play safe and order from Robs Pizza. At least they charge for what they say and never deliver a burnt pizza. read more

Good to go! Pizza is delicious, definitely better than the Pine Bush store and the drinks are actually COLD!!

They are lucky I HAD to give them one star, The said it would be delivered in one hour and it took Over TWO!! And the delivery driver did NOT have a face mask on! State mandate states Everyone Has to have a mask on much less young people delivering food the middle aged and elderly spreading this crap! And the pizza was over cooked and cold. NEVER AGAIN...... read more

Put in an order with no problem. Waited on food for an hour. Come to find out it was left on the porch: no knock at the door or phone call. Food sat outside the whole time and was cold! (NY winter mind you) terrible service! read more

The blonde cashier needs to pay attention to whatever order a customer asks for and change her tone of voice. It's called CUSTOMER SERVICE.

I ordered a bunch of food tonight and it was all horrible. The cheese calzone was watery. My chicken parmigiana was so tough I could not even cut through the chicken. All of the tomato sauce was very sweet, and was thin like water, it also tasted horrible. The garlic knots looked great but had no garlic flavor or any flavor at all! The pizza was the only thing sort of edible. We also ordered fried ravioli which were greasy, burnt and had no flavor. Everything was Terrible! I spent a lot of money for nothing! read more

I don't know how you mess up something as simple as rice balls. But they really managed. Sent me one rice ball, cut in half, and it had pees in it. Ruined my lunch, my day, and I will never order from here ever, ever again. read more

Who ever owns this place cares about the food they put out. I had the chicken parm dinner. It comes with a full salad. Romaine lettuce, roasted peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes and and olive. They are all great quality, not your usual pizza place salad. They give you a full side of pasta and a tasty chicken parm dinner. Perfectly done, delicious. read more

DON'T DO IT! The pizza slices are usually tasteless & they lie about whats on them. No fountain drinks only bottles. I wont go there again it totally suks big time! read more

We used to love this restaurant. So convenient to the high school and they delivered. Over the last year the quality has SERIOUSLY declined and they just seem too busy to keep up customer service. Quantity over quality. Final straw: Ordered a pizza at 5 pm, still not delivered at 6:15. When I called to inquire they said when they had a driver they would send it out. At 7 I called to cancel. They seemed unconcerned. And this isn't the first time. I'm sorry to lose the convenience but the food and service just disappoint over and over. read more