Nice casual sushi place. Food was pretty good and the waitress was really friendly. Took off two stars because they mixed up our order on different plates. The manager or owner lady (I think it was) came and she literally took our chopsticks and tried to move the sushi roll from plate to another. They also forgot 2 of our orders and we had to wait longer for them to arrive while 3 of the people at our table of 4 already finished eating. We asked for a discount for the inconvenience and the manager said no. Overall decent place but lacking in some organization. read more

Very disappointing experience. Service was painfully slow, almost nonexistent. We waited over 90 minutes before our meal came to the table. Waitress did apologize and placed one small bowl of seaweed on the table for four people and said it was on the house. Thanks. Everything had to be asked for. Plates, water, wasabi, lemon. Nobody comes back to check if we needed anything else during the meal (e.g., water, napkins etc). What was ordered? One person ordered gyoza and a spider roll. Second person ordered sushi a la carte. Third person a soft shell crab roll and two sushi pieces a la carte. Fourth person ordered a tempura appetizer and an eel roll. 90 minutes plus waiting and almost everything came out at once; appetizers and main dish. Taste was fine. Nothing to rave about. Plates were presented without any traditional Japanese decor to look appetizing. Just rolls and fish on a white plate. Only 4 tables, including ours, being served in this restaurant at the time. Came in at 7pm left around 9 pm on a Saturday evening. Yes we're in a pandemic but 90 minutes is way too much time to sit at a table waiting for appetizers or food. read more

A nice cozy sushi place. We heard of it through friends and we decided to try it. The quality is there, the presentation and service are pleasing. The Tokyo fried rice was a bit oily but tasty. We like the prices and the fact that parking is available at the entrance. We will go back for sure. read more

Really enjoyed my meal here. Went on a weekday evening so it was nice and quiet and calm. The service was spectacular and the staff was so friendly! read more

I went to Toro for dinner on a Saturday night with one friend. We made a reservation but the restaurant never filled up so it wasn't necessary. Overall the experience was fine but nothing was particularly great other than the fact that the place is BYOB which is always a plus when you don't want to overpay for drinks. When we were seated our waitress immediately opened our wine bottle & brought over glasses which was nice. As an app I ordered the miso eggplant which was fine but slightly too salty & the portion was pretty small. To eat I had two rolls, eel with avocado (on the menu it's eel cucumber but they let me get avocado instead) & the garden state roll which is tempura salmon with asparagus. The garden state roll was good & unique, I've never had a similar roll before. The eel roll was pretty standard but the sauce was somewhat overpowering. Our server was friendly & I actually did not find the service to be slow like others have mentioned here. I did not like the interior of the restaurant, its not very attractive & is kind of dated. Also all the tables have thick foam glued underneath which was pretty weird. Prices are comparable to other sushi spots in the area. I think next time I want sushi around here I'll go back to my usual favorite (Aki in Bloomfield) or try somewhere new. read more

Toro Sushi - Sushi Bars Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Nice family-owned Japanese place good for fresh tasting sushi/sashimi as well as traditional hot food. I wholeheartedly recommend for both sit down and takeouts. read more

I have been to Toro a number of times, and sometimes it is 4 level. Last night--a 3, decent but not extra special. I do trust their freshness. The service is friendly. But they brought our starter sushi after they served our main dishes. We did try the sea urchin, $11 for two pieces. It was our choice to try it--and it was interesting. Also had eel, tuna which was very good, and a spicy yellowtail roll which was ok. The quantity of food seemed less than we recalled in the recent past. We did have a very good Groupon deal. We will go again, for we have had some very positive sushi dining here other times. Toro is convenient location for us, and I hope this small, clean establishment can up its game one notch again. read more

See all

Food is good but would not suggest going on any holidays. They are understaffed and the food will take too long to get. Went on Valentine's Day and ordered online, which stated it would take an hour. After waiting the hour, went to go pick up the food and the food wasn't ready. This would be understandable if they would give an honest answer as to an estimate on how long it would be. We saw a table full of tickets that needed to be fulfilled and then waited an hour and 45 minutes. While waiting, a customer came in and said they had called 15 times, but no one picked up. Like I said, food was good but not good enough to wait that long. read more

This was my first time eating here - I met up with a friend and his fiance. We ordered 3 specialty rolls and lobster fried rice. I was a fan of all 3 rolls (we ordered yuki, upper montclair, and I forget the 3rd one we ordered) and the lobster fried rice was solid as well. The place is also BYOB which is a plus - I brought a bottle of wine and the server provided 3 wine glasses. I would come back here again. There is a parking lot outside with ample space - I believe most of it is metered parking ($.75 / hour) but if you park right outside the restaurant I believe that is free parking reserved for customers. read more

We came here after failing to get another reservation at a Thai place in the same area. The food was completely underwhelming, didn't taste super fresh, and was overall not worth the time or money. We wish we had stayed home and made something simple from the pantry. In particular the soft shelf crab roll was oily and the sauce overwhelming, and the salmon in the salmon avocado roll was clearly not fresh. The color and smell of the fish just wasn't right. After one bite I put the roll to the side and didn't eat it. Went with two stars because the service was attentive and polite. Doesn't make up for the very, very, lackluster food. Wouldn't go back, and wouldn't recommend. read more

We passed by this spot on a Friday night and decided to stop in and try it out. A client of mine had recommended this place to us so we figured the food would be really good. Upon entering, we were immediately seated by an older woman. The place had some good traffic, but there were also a few seats available. One thing I noticed right away was that the decor was outdated and could absolutely use some updating. We then waited a while and finally a girl came over and apologized on behalf of the server who was supposed to be helping us. She took our orders and we waited about 15 min for our food to arrive. The food arrived and out 5 rolls didn't fit on one plate, so we had to have the food served on two huge round plates which made it a little inconvenient when you're trying to share with someone. The sushi itself was okay; I've definitely had much better. For $70 I figured the sushi would be a little more memorable, but it wasn't. Just regular sushi that you could expect to eat at an AYCE spot. On the brighter side, there's public parking outside and we were lucky enough to snag a spot right out front (score!) All in all, I wouldn't come back here. There's way too many good spots in Montclair and this place really needs to make a few improvements to live up to expectations. read more

Great sushi spot + Sushi is fresh. Had the tuna and salmon dinner and was real fresh and delicious + Solid salad and miso soup + Great friendly service + Not a huge restaurant but it has a nice warm and casual atmosphere + The tempura ice cream is awesome - There is some wait but it's a sushi restaurant so you should be expecting that going in read more

See all

Loved it .. my husband and I were craving sushi .. checked some of our fav places but no availability and tried Toro for the first time. Ordered a complete meal; miso soup salad brussel sprout app sushi house tea. Everything was delicous fresh and tasty. Also loved the ambiance and everyone was friendly helpful and accommodating. Definitely going back. read more

Came again and tried their new dish: Sushi Pizza. I told them I didn't want anything raw and they gave me crab stick and avocado and the "pizza" which was really nice. Very great place read more

Toro Sushi - Sushi Pizza - Sushi Bars Near Me - Montclair, New Jersey

Best sushi in town. Hole-in-the-wall spot perfect for any weekday, or an advanced order on a weekend! Fairly busy/exclusive spot.

I was invited By my friend to join her at Toro sushi. I was famished and looking for nice portions. Well I was Pleasantly surprise to meet Andy and Vicky the owners of toro sushi, they were so kind. They recommend great dishes such as Tuna Kinuta, tuna tartare and soft shell crab roll. Such a Zen atmosphere and just what I need after a stressful couple days. I am very particular about what I put in my body, trust me when I say this was the freshest sushi I have ever eaten. Every bite just melted in my mouth. If you are a true sushi lover you must try this place you will not be disappointed. The restaurant was very clean. I would definitely return and bring all my friends and family. read more

Happy to see that Toro Sushi is still operating during this pandemic. Went the other day with a friend and the food is fresh and delicious as always! read more

Toro is a Fantastic sushi bar. Chef Andy really cares to bring you the very best quality! The Sushi offering changes from week to week depending on what is fresh, which is exciting. Always check white board for specials! My wife and I frequent often and we are never disappointed. We always order omakase which means "leave it to the chef" and tell whatever dollar amount we want to pay. The chef then crafts amazing sushi displays that are almost a shame to eat. I shared some samples on this post. I recommend sitting at the bar to really experience what toro has to offer! read more

See all

I almost never write yelp reviews however, after the dinner that I just had I feel obliged. I normally don't bother with a review because many places manage to meet your expectations. I was expecting just a run of the mill sushi restaurant but Toro sushi was such a surprise! I had a few pieces of sushi a la cart and a few standard rolls because I was a bit apprehensive but they did not disappoint. The salmon was melt in your mouth fresh the yellow tail was also some of the freshest I have had in NJ. I had never tried them before because to be honest there are too many sushi places in Montclair for them to be on my radar. If your a discerning sushi lover and appreciate quality fish I cant recommend Toro sushi enough. read more

It's was my first time at a restaurant with my brother and his wife. The service was excellent, the staff was friendly and professional.

This hidden gem is the definition of hospitality. Superb waitresses and staff make the experience even more pleasant. For the food- DELICIOUS. Great sushi that is slightly expensive, but they have 1/2 of deals on certain days. The specialty rolls are excellent. The quality of fish is excellent. Cannot wait to come back. read more

We were the only ones in there early for a weekday lunch with our little ones. The waitstaff was all young teenagers and, while nervous, they were exceedingly attentive. The sushi itself was solid and fresh. Would try them again. read more

I was in Montclair recently. Looking for a sushi restaurant to go to at 9:20P on my way back to NYC. Obviously a little late for the suburbs but there had to be one place open late. The other sushi place we called closed at 9:30p and they would only do take-out at 9:20p, fair enough, everyone wants to go home after work. Yelp led me to this fine establishment tucked away in a strip mall behind a main street. The people were friendly, the music was low and good and the food was delightful. I had a Yellowtail hand roll no rice and a salad. We were content. I'd stop by here again when in Montclair. MY CHECK-IN TIP: Open till 10p! We made it! Hand roll no rice is great! read more

Yum. Thanks to my friends, I got to dine here recently. It is somewhat hidden being that it's not out front on Valley Road. (It's sort of behind the Bellevue Theater, if that helps.) Pretty delicious, standard sushi. They also do bento boxes. Wait staff was really nice. Cool dark wood decor and feel. read more

Sushi is alright but I gotta say.. they do make really good chicken or pork Katsu. It's perfectly thin but still meaty. They give you a lot so.. Whenever I order take out, I still have some to save for the next day since I can't finish all of it in one sitting. read more

Amazing food and service, would absolutely recommend this restaurant! Friendly environment and staff, would recommend to anyone in the Montclair Nj area! read more

Favorite sushi in Montclair. Staff is always friendly and sushi is fresh and excellent. Prices are very fair for the quality. This is standard for a lot of restaurants, but there is a clear correlation between how crowded they are and how long your dinner will take. On a busy night, be prepared to not get your food for at least 45 minutes to hour. Everything is prepared fresh which isn't a negative, just keep that in mind if you're trying to make a movie afterwards. Also, don't forget to go next door beforehand and get some asian beers or sake. Prices are fair and your bill won't seem bad with the help of the BYOB policy. read more

Definitely in the same league as Dai Kichi and a step above Bamboo. They present your food cleanly and with aesthetics in mind but that does not mean they skip out on freshness or flavor. I also really like the woodsy Asian decor, which was surprising given the Upper Montclair plaza strip mall location. Don't let the location fool you. What you've got here is some quality eats. read more

My fiancé and I used to order from this place at least 3 times a month. I don't know what happened in the last month, but service has been absolutely terrible. The last 2 times we've ordered it to go we had to wait in the restaurant for at least 20 minutes. It's like they start making it when you get there after giving them a 30 minute head start. Our last and final time ordering from this place we waited 50 minutes before coming to pick it up only to find out that they ignored the order. The hostess said "sorry, it's not in the system". She didn't offer an apology or anything. I thought I had made a mistake by calling the wrong restaurant. I didn't and went back in to speak to the manger or owner. They cared so little that the waitress wasn't able to get anyone more senior than her to talk to me. To make matters worse this all happened at 9pm, so where else could we have ordered from at that time of night?? We ended up ordering from Veggie Heaven and they had our order ready in 10 minutes. Try the other two sushi places that are within walking distance before trying this sorry excuse for a restaurant. read more

This place has complete disregard for its customers, it is so money focused that it does not care if it has to rob its clients to get a little more money in. The delivery service is abysmal, and the customer service is criminal. I had to wait two whole hours to receive my warm, car encountered sushi. When I called the first time to check on my order I was blatantly lied to. The second time, I was told to figure it out as if it were my problems because they clearly only care about the 90 dollars I dropped on the food. This place laughs in the face of its own clientele and denigrates the people who simply wanted to help out local businesses. This place would rob you blind if it had the chance. read more

Good food for the price, nice atmosphere. Nothing outstanding about the sushi, but very well prepared. Minus 1 star for having to pay for parking; restaurant should "comp" you for 60 mins for dinner and 30 mins (or so) for lunch. read more

We have been going to Toro for 2 years. Tonight we had delicious fresh uni and otoro. The food is even better under the new management. Hibachi and sushi menus are both great. Highly recommend the Brussels sprouts special with vinegar soy sauce. read more

Fresh sushi, delicious food. Small restaurant with high quality sushi. Fried ice cream was delicious too!

Delicious. Everything was very fresh. Highly recommend. Staff very friendly. My number one sushi place in the area

After watching "Jiro Dreams of Sushi" and wandering into this place, I was deeply disappointed as there will be no joy in Jiroville here tonight. The sushi was not really fresh. The tuna was quite bland and the sushi rice was under-cooked. Presentation was ok and the place is pretty comfortable but that was it. Oh, when will Tomo reopen? Please come back. NJ needs u!!! read more

Really good food. It was really busy tonight and they gsve me something on the house to eat first. Will definitely come back

This place is ok. I think the quality of the fish is poor. The color is not fresh and the fish isn't tender. I usually order blue fin toro or salmon toro and they just taste off to me. It's always empty here regardless what day of the week. Waiting service takes a while to fill your glass of water. Waitress is more reactive with filling glass not proactive. So expect them to walk by without looking at your table. Sushi should always be using grade A fish in my book. Grade B isn't worth the risk. read more

After reading/hearing many stellar reviews on this place, I had really had high hopes. Aside from the friendly staff and easy parking, Toro really underwhelmed me. The tablespoon of seaweed salad that I ordered was just blah. Nothing special to it. No kick. No nothing. I then ordered the lobster roll which I thought would really impress me. Eh, not so much. It was very small, the lobster was very chewy, and the "caviar" it's supposed to be topped with? Well, I'm still waiting for it. Overall, the two star rating summary says it all, "Meh, I've experienced better." read more

This place is great! Totally hidden in upper montclair but worth the search lol. When I walked in my friend and I were the only ones in the restaurant last night. I usually take that as a bad sign but decided to give it a chance since all the previous reviews were great. The service was excellent, super attentive (although now thinking about it we were the only people in the place!). I have a sesame allergy and they were very careful to make sure nothing touched my food. For appetizers we ordered edamame (classic) and the pork gyoza, pretty standard and both were good. For dinner I got a plain tuna roll and the SoHo roll. The SoHo roll is usually a deep fried california roll with spicy mayo/eel sauce, I asked them to substitute the avocado for mango. They gave me no problems with the substitution and let me tell you...that roll was fantastic!!! I'm practically drooling over it just thinking about it haha. For desert we got the fired ice cream, always a win. This place is also BYOB - can't ask for anything more!! Only down side is the sushi can be pricey, like 12-15 per roll. I didn't see any specials on certain days. Overall great quality and can't wait to go back! read more

I love Toro! It's my favorite Sushi in Montclair. I always get Yuki roll and it's always really good whether I am dining in, picking up or getting delivery. read more