I really only go to Tony's for 2 things: their bacon pizza and their meatball sub. Both are amazing. Unfortunately they don't have great appetizer options and their salads are lacking. But pizza & subs are always consistent! read more

I really wanted to love this place. It is a order at the counter, find a seat and listen for your number to be called type of restaurant. It is Greek ownership, running with a strong Italian flair. Lots of folks at the counter to help you And All are more than willing to assist. Tonight, I ordered there chicken with lemon and garlic sauce on rigatoni. At 1495 it seemed like a good value. I received my order within 10 minutes and I had a substantial bowl of rigatoni with a slice chicken breast on top, the portion was large. However, unless I am grossly wrong, it was chicken, grilled with Italian dressing, and the pasta was tossed in that same Italian dressing. It wasn't horrible, but it was slightly south of good. And I'm not sure that the lack of sauce for the pasta Was not a good thing. The dish came with a warm roll with butter. The bread was fantastic. Last time I was here I had a simple pizza it is the Greek type of thicker pizza with a crispy crust. An awful lot of cheese made it quite heavy. But it was not outside of what my expectation was for this type of pizza. I still will come back to try some other things to see if I can get that star rating up a little bit but bottom line it is adequate not very expensive in large portions read more

Had a large order with 4 salads Got home no dressing Had no dressing at home none was offered never heard of salads that come with no dressing. read more

I've eaten here a few times. It's nothing really remarkable in my opinion. I frankly prefer Harry's much better, but this place was closer and on the way. We went there twice this week. First time I had the Ceasar salad, which was super plain and pretty boring. It was just lettuce, shredded cheese, and croutons. The second time I went, I had a toasted turkey sandwich. It was again just ok, but I didn't like the way it was made. They used like a hoagie roll, meat was laid in the bottom with all the lettuce, tomatoe, onion, etc on top, so when you would fold it and bite into it, you either got a mouthful of meat, or lettuce. I like my sandwiches to have equal amounts of everything in each bite, its just tastier that way! My mom had a chicken sandwich. Again, nothing remarkable...just your everyday, average, crispy chicken sandwich. I've never had pizza here and perhaps that is their forte but for me its just average and not a place I will be visiting much more. read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - Toasted turkey sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

Great food no matter what you get, pizza, calzones, subs, salads. It is all great food. Eat in or take out it does not matter your food will be fabulous read more

Absolutely love Tony's pizza. In my opinion it's one of the best pizza places in the area. I remember going into Tony's back in the early 80s when it was just a tiny little shack and Tony himself was working behind the counter. The profits that he and his business Erna help pay for the additional family from Greece. It's a very busy place, they always have their order correct. They're always friendly. Saying hello when you walk in the door and thank you come again as you walk out. I can't recommend this place enough. I wish I could give 10 stars. They definitely deserve them, AWESOME job Tony's staff!! read more

Old school, large scale pizza joint. Oh not just pizza, but everything Italian you can imagine. Order in. Eat in. Take out. Very clean facility. Very nice staff. Awesome selection. plenty of parking. This place is always busy. High volume and quality for at affordable prices. No negatives. DEC2019 read more

We had an impromptu family stop at Tonys after we went to the pumpkin patch. Kind of awkward when we first walked in. No one greeted us or told us where to sit etc... But they did have a person spraying and wiping tables which was great. Staff wore masks! We ordered at the counter and sat, then waited for our number to be called. My wife loved her steak and mushroom hoagie, my Chicken Parm was okay, the chicken was odd.. definitely from a package...My 4 and 2 year olds got chicken nuggets and mac and cheese. The amount of nuggets and fries for the price was awesome. The mac and cheese was a plastic container of Kraft for like $7...not the greatest value but we knew what we were ordering so...both kids meals came with ice cream cups as well. All and all, good food, great portions!! Will go back for Pizza, somehow we failed on trying the pie read more

Tony's Pizza is one of those local favorites and naturally has a fairly high rating. However, they aren't perfect. My recommendation is to be weary of overly high or low ratings as this is slightly better than your average pizza and sub joint. The details: * Decent prices for a sandwich or a pizza * Fairly large amount of food for a "medium" pizza or a sub * Ingredients seem fresh * Still your average greasy-American pizza read more

See all

The Italian Sub was huge and had bologna so I was a fan. I added banana peppers. The buffalo wings were good but just beware they're a dry rub, not saucy. Overall everyone was real friendly, the food was above average and I'd come back. read more

See all

Really good food, tons of options, and reasonable prices. We were in the area to try out a new play place for our toddler and were all starving after. This was super close so we gave it a try. Got a pizza, fries and mozzarella sticks. Fries were so crispy and delicious. Mozzarella sticks and pizza were awesome too! Sauce was good and tons of cheese on the pizza. Place has a lot of seating and an upstairs and downstairs. Low key place which is perfect for families with kiddos! read more

Ordered Small pizza while I'm driving motorcycle in colder condition 15 min before they closing. I asked "can I still eat inside? Sure, was answer. After pizza was done (12 minutes In oven they told me restaurant already closed and I have to leave. My reaction" are you guys filming me on fun camera? So here is my dinner outside reality. Never go back to this place where promises comes different with reality. That's maybe this restaurant so close to the very busy route and they don't treat every customer as real guest. So sad for Albanian and Greek customers. read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

See all

Pizza is OK. But when you order tomato, feta, spinach, and garlic... you get no sauce, pounds of spinach, and no cheese. Olives were a bonus! Bring your floss, because the whole thing was spinach covered. Crust was so underdone. Not raw, but still. I had to put it in the oven. read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - Holy spinach. Not much feta or mozzarella. - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

See all

So fourth time our order was wrong in the details (not a busy time of day) and once an entire item missing. Not close enough to go back but now I wonder if they just don't check. Will go elsewhere a while. read more

Very good the food is fast and very cheap We be back And the steak and chess is one of my favorite on read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - The best pizza i haver had . - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

See all

Very long wait for a simple cold vegetable sub. Prepared incorrectly (left off things so ordered, left on things I asked to leave off.) The mushrooms were soggy and tasteless. Very small amount of peppers. Mostly white colored lettuce and a couple of slices of tomato. I was already late for an appointment so when I told the staff about the mistake I waved off the chance to fix it but they did offer. read more

Hadn't been back to Sutton pizza in almost 15 years and wow I can't believe it still looks,smells and tastes exactly like I remember as a kid!! The new entrance/exit makes it even easier in and out and really that was the only thing that was different to me. The cute fish tank is still there and now as an adult I know they serve beer and wine. Not a huge selection, a few bottled beers a few on draft and a handful of wines to chose from...but thats all ya need! We got a large pepperoni pizza and mozzarella sticks that were unbelievable. Their pizza is so light on your stomach but the flavor is like no other. Prices are so reasonable we were able to get the food plus 2 beers, wine and 2 pieces of carrot cake for around $40. Not only great food but great memories with family from long ago :) read more

See all

During storm duty during the 2011 pre-halloween freak storm, there were loads of angry people without power. I understand your frustration. Hate me, but I work to restore your power. Storm duty - Line patrol consists of noting locations where there are downed powerlines. Simple, but we do not want to close a circuit where there is a possibility of electrocuting kids/dogs/stupid people playing jumprope with zappy wires. End Tangent/Start of review... Tony's was our staging point for much of the most of the week. We would meet here in the morning (some people dead from guarding a downed line through the night) and get our grub. Darned good grub. We were all over Sutton/Northbridge/Auburn/MIllbury/Grafton. We could have chosen a better place, had there been one, to wind down after touring backroads a few hundred miles. Come here if.... You are not on a diet.... You want steak on your steak and cheese sandwich the size of a pug... You want to be 'healthy' and polish off a salad, also the size of a pug... You are a fan of fishtanks built into flooring... You need to grab a bite on the way up to Wachusett...(buy your season pass before 8/31 and get 2 Fall Festival Tickets and 2 SkyRide Tickets) You don't believe me... You believe me... Tony's is probably the most common pizzeria name, but this place is not your average bear. read more

A place like Tony's is one that makes nostalgia erupt from your mind, whether you like it or not, been there a million times, first time ever or first time in a long time. This establishment has been around since 1981 and it feels like it as soon as you walk in. If you grew up in New England you probably had a major win on you T ball team or had a rough football practice and Tony's is where the coach ( or your dad, after a crushing loss, said "its ok champ' how about a slice?) would take you. My personal nostalgia is after ice skating with my aunt or pop I they would bring us here. Or after a movie in later years as a teen at the Rustic Drive in we would take over Tony's and stuff our little adolescent faces here. Now I bring my nephew here and as of late my bf to experience the amazing food here. They support local youth sports here and have since day 1. This is also another great thread in the web of our NE community, and this place has it down.Photos of teams from every sport you can imagine going back to the 80's. Everything is made with care - though you may not consider the food to come out that quick compared to other places, quality takes time!! so for the pizza, the crust is a classic perfected thick Greek crust. Not oily, perfectly crispy but not overdone. Holds up to the heaviest toppings, and the most delectable pizza sauce I've had outside the north end. They don't put too much or too little of anything in the dough or sauce.. its crazy how perfect it is with ANY kind of pizza you could conjure up. Sometimes when we have the munchies and head to Tony's we end up testing the limits of how much you can fit on a pizza without it bottoming out -but they manage to craft it all together EVERY time, Ingredients here are great, always fresh and never a soggy sandwich. I love pepperoni mushroom on my pizza and nothing is more of a turn off than canned mushrooms ( google it - you;ll never eat those again) but not here, they are always fresh and plentiful - if you love the fungus like me you should appreciate it too. I've had all kinds of subs here and I'll say now that the meatballs are humongous - so go hungry if you are opting for that classic - size doesn't change from pasts to sammich either! . After trying basically all of them over the years, I can say the pita pocket blt is probably the simplest but most delicious thing here!! So satisfying, slightly toasty pita bread stuffed with BLT and pickles and cheddar cheese.. UGH I want 7 of them right now. Salads are big and fresh and they actually MAKE their salad dressing which is always outstanding. My fasve is the greek salad but if you get a chance, get an italian sandwhich here and get greek dressing on the side. Its the most heavenly thing to dip your sammich into and it may even keep you awake at night....! I really can't say anything bad about the food. Staff is always attentive and usually friendly but always hard working- never seen people lazing about or chatting it up and ignoring the front like some places. Its a very kid friendly place, with some toy vending machines and gumballs etc.. The downstairs area they close off when its slow, but when its busy on a friday night or after a movie gets out this place can be quite bustling. Even so . the service and the food is always consistent and I will keep going back forever, because they will never close at the astounding rate they are going! read more

This is probably the worst pizza I have ever had They are in biz so long only because its the only place around They make DiGiorno look real real good read more

Always good food and the people are always polite and courteous. Online ordering is a plus.

Food was cold and pizza was greasy. And they got the order wrong, yet again. Used to be a good place when the previous owners ran it. Won't be back! read more

So much yes. What a great pizza (and everything else on the menu) place! We ordered the veggie pie, and expected it to be a bit weighed down and wet - as most veggie pies can get, but this one was perfect! Tons of veggies, like an inch high, the cheese is on top, the crust is actually a crust - not a soggy sad situation. It was very impressive. Their salads are great also, fresh and with variety. The restaurant is really big, and feels like a big pizzeria, italian family restaurant, greek joint - and it's just fun! The parking lot is huge, the prices are so reasonable, they're open pretty late, and even take card (except amex). I would definitely return. read more

I would always drive by this place on my way to and from Umass Amherst. I had always heard good things about it, but never had the time to stop by and try their food. However, my family was helping me move back home from school, so we decided to give at a go. The place has only sit down and take out there is no delivery. They have an extensive menu that mostly focused on their pizza, but has a large selection of sandwiches to choose from as well. I decided to go with the Reuben sandwich because it is one of my favorite sandwiches. The food did take a very long time, but the place was busy which made me confident the food must be good. The crowd was a mixture of old, young, and a bunch of teenagers. When the sandwich came it looked like it had been in the panini press for too long. The sandwich had a generous amount of corned beef on it, but way too much Russian sauce. There was a limited amount of sauerkraut, but I actually like when restaurants are light with the sauerkraut because it can over power the sandwich. The sandwich I would give a 6/10 I wouldn't go out of my way to get it again, but if I was in the area I would get it. If I ever go again I want to try their pizza because I saw a lot of people ordering it and it looked amazing. My parents both got salads and they looked pretty basic, nothing special. read more

The grilled chicken and pasta is one of my favorite things to order here. Plenty of fresh chicken and pasta. The sauce is also very good. The steak and cheese sub is also very good. The fries are ok, they seem to change the type of fries every now and then. There is plenty of room to eat inside, with tables on the main level and more tables downstairs. read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

See all

Ordered three large subs here; two Italian and one steak. The Italians were delicious. Loaded with meat and toasted just right. I'm not kidding when I use the term 'loaded', as it was tough to fit the sub in my mouth given all of the meat in it. The vegetables that accompanied the subs were fresh and tasty. The steak sub was cooked also cooked well and was very tasty. We got the subs to go and called ahead; so with that said, the wait was insignificant. Prices were fair. I used the restroom while I was waiting and to be honest, it wasn't as clean as I would expect given the place opened only 5 minutes before we arrived. Nothing too disgusting, just lots of paper towels around and a feeling of untidiness. It could have been the other party that was in the corner booth, who knows. read more

A decent little pizza place. Although the food was nothing spectacular when it came to flavor the local feel and friendly staff really made you feel at home. It was also pretty inexpensive and the bacon pizza had an obscene amount of bacon. read more

See all

Stopped here after a hike around Purgatory Chasm in Sutton. Ordered a large cheese pizza and two diet cokes, $16 I believe. The dining area is large, open, and very nice. Not your typical pizza place on the inside. Lots of parking and despite being at an intersection on 146, very easy to get in and get out of. read more

Good: Italian sub, burger, fries, pizza Bad: chicken parm sub (seriously, WHY use frozen chicken patties?!?) Decent: salads Prices: good. Only $1 more for large sub vs small Decor: on point for the area. The place is always busy. Service: very nice. I always want to tip but they don't accept tips at the counter. Please, Tony's, opt for real chicken...it's embarrassing read more

Tonys is awesome. We go every single Friday night and I have zero complaints. Cindy L needs to RELAX about the bathroom situation....I mean, she really got into women being equals?? Haha....have a drink, crazy. Tonys is a 10 out of 10 in my book. read more

It's GREEK STYLE PIZZA! My experience at Tony's yesterday rejuvenated my interest in updating my yelp reviews. We were on a trip back to western mass and found ourselves hungry in the "middle of no where." I opened my yelp app just to see what popped up. Tony's was one of the few places easy to pull on/off the main road though it was only rated 3 stars and looked to have a lot of mixed reviews, we didn't expect much going in. The place was bumpn'!! This is not your fancy wood fired thin crust gourmet pizza, nor is it New York style big gooey slice of pizza nor is it chicago style for your deep dish/lot-o-crust folks. You have to know what KIND of pizza you are getting and judge it based off of that type of pizza. This honestly reminds me of a classic yummy, 80's style pizza oven pizza at the local bar/restaurant that I often experienced in the midwest (wisconsin). I understand this to be what many call "greek style." The crust was a mix of chewy/flaky but between a thin and medium crust. The toppings and cheese, I thought were pretty yummy and a classic fountain cola hit the spot. Now, I can't speak to all the other food there but if you know the TYPE of pizza you are getting, this ranks up there in that category. It's unfair to compare this to New York style, Chicago style or gourmet - this is just another style of pizza. Again, I am brought back to my childhood in the 80's eating this pizza and gone are the days of the classic pizza oven. This would be a great place for a take out pizza for the drive in down the road! read more

Unremarkable. I eat here alot and the only reason this gets high ratings is because it's the only pizza place within miles of most suttonites. Steak bomb is mediocre esp. When compared to places like Carls in Waltham or Vickies in Hingham. read more

So far so good! Finaly a pizza you can taste everything put on. Overall a better quality ingredients! No greasy and no heavy stomack after 4 slices! Feel full but not heavy!! The last star left behind will fill up after a couple more trial for consistency. Thanks Tony's pizza read more

I've been going here since I was little, and I've never once not liked the food. The service is great and really friendly. Best pizza joint in the Sutton/Millbury/Grafton area! My personal favorite is the chef salad. read more

Holy bacon pizza, batman! The bacon pizza here is ridiculous. Big huge chunks of crispy bacon. Small is enough to feed a very hungry person for dinner. Crust and sauce are fine, nothing remarkable. Highly recommended. read more

Stopped in with a friend for lunch, was waited on quickly, and food came out fast, hot and delicious! I had the Ruben panini with fries and it was perfect! We order pizza from here occasionally but wanted to try something different. Large seating area, nice and clean plenty of are to space out. A must go to restaurant! read more

The best pizza place in the world. Period. It's always been a great local hangout and is constantly busy for very good reason. It's the best cheese pizza on the planet. Other food is excellent as well. Affordable. Fast. Friendly. Tough to beat anywhere. To top it all off, from its start, Tony's has been a huge supporter of the local community. read more

It seems that if a small town in the Northeast or the mid Atlantic has a restaurant at all it will be a pizza place. Sutton is no exception and Tony's is the place. Actually Sutton fared well in this as Tony's isn't a bad place. It's big, clean and airy. Staff is friendly. I had the steak deluxe. Not bad, but as I have spent the last 4 years looking for the best cheese steak in the Philly area, the standard is quite high. The best thing about the sandwich was the roll. The light toasting crisped up the crust perfectly. The fries were good but I'm kind of negative on dusting them with flour , if that's what it is, to make them more crispy. MK had an order of meatballs that she loved. Then again she's never met a meatball she didn't like. One small gripe, soda refills at the machine were $0.50. Somehow I can't see that as a profit center. If you're in the area its not a bad place to stop.... read more

I haven't tried too many things on their menu because after having the seafood salad sub for the first time, it's always the only thing I ever want when we (rarely because we live so far from them) go there. Their food and service are BOTH amazing. I always look forward to visits there (it's a TREAT for me)! read more

I find the food here to be good, not great. I've had pizza and a few of the dinners here. The place is always busy, partially because there's nothing else in the area. read more