I loved the food! Everything was delicious and very well prepared. I definitely recommend it." read more

See all

I've been coming here for years, but the quality is just going downhill. They hired young kids just out of high school or in high school but do not properly train them then when they make a mistake, the guy gets mad and yells at them when in two days ago whole order completely messed up twice and still charged me 100% should have given at least a 5 to 10% discount I will not be back read more

Loved the pizza we got the cheese and steak and cheese. Both were delicious and came out hot. Place is definitely dated but the food is great. read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

See all

I don't pop in here too often, but when it's lunchtime and I'm nearby, pulling into Tony's is an easy decision. The sub portions are generous and the wait times are always pretty reasonable, no matter how busy the place gets. I love a good roast beef sub, and this is a great spot to get one. There is plenty of room inside, even for large parties. Definitely stop in with your crew when you're hungry! read more

If you're super hungry like I was, it will be ok. Otherwise I would say it's a pass. Crust and sauce were fine, but the cheese was...different. I would almost describe it as chunky. People were friendly and maybe I caught them on an off-day but it really through off the balance of the pizza. read more

See all

Very nice place food is great I love their Italian sandwiches and chicken wings . The food is great but the restaurant's service is very good too. I recommend the restaurant. The prices are reasonable for great food and service. read more

Tony's is a Sutton classic - hasn't been renovated since my childhood and all the better for it! Places like this absorb the energy of a town coming together to enjoy pizza. The cheese isn't what it was 20 years ago, but Tony's makes a darn good pie. read more

It's been quite a while since we tried Tony's Pizza, as our last visit was memorable but not in a good way. When I checked my prior review, I see that it's been five years since we last crossed their threshold. Hopefully time has been kind. I recall hearing that there is new ownership at Tony's, and we were craving some takeout, so I ordered via mobile: Steak & Cheese (Large): $11.95 Chicken Wings (BBQ): $11.95 French Fries (Small): $4.50 These were ready very quickly, and after a quick drive home, we found that overall, we were pleased with the results. The steak and cheese was very good, a traditional, gooey, steak and cheese center, still hot inside a soft sub roll. The fries were great, hot and very crispy, and their "small" is quite large. These were better than I have been served at much fancier restaurants. The chicken wings were good albeit heavily breaded for our tastes. Overall, a much better experience than out prior visit, we'd be happy to order takeout from here again. read more

See all

Average at best. One & done for me. Heavy, floppy pizza dough. Even bad pizza is good though, hence the 3 stars.

Was on the way to the grocery store and stopped in for some pizza. Let me just say that, the crust was excellent, the toppings were superb and plentyfull, (nothing was skimpy). First bite was amazing. This is what pizza is supposed to taste like!!! I bookmarked this place so when we are in the mood for pizza again.... This is where we will be going. A great place and WORTH YOUR MONEY!!!!! read more

I rate this a 4.2. I got a grilled chicken calzone and it was money. The chicken in the calzone is perfect size and soft. Cheese is great and perfect amount of sauce. Inside has the classic look, food came out in regular time. Overall the calzone was gas and I would get again. #WhoIsTony read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

My brother and I went here for lunch. We asked to split the meal and this is what they did! Amazing! 2 separate bowls, his had cheese mine none, each got a warm delicious bread and a salad that had to be brought home! Eggplant Parm. Special is my personal favorite there but all meals I've ever tried are delicious! read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - Eggplant Parm. Special! Made for 2 different taste! Delicious!! - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

Been going to Tony's for several years and have had a consistently good experience. Prices are reasonable, orders have been correct, staff has been attentive and food is decent. 99% of the time I get take away, so I can't really comment on eat-in dining. Wings are battered sort-of like a chicken nugget. Steak sandwiches aren't greasy, the cheese is melty and the roll is tasty. Pizza is typical for style but it has always been cooked correctly; never over or underdone. It has the right amount of toppings and cheese and the sauce is fresh. Online ordering is super convenient. I place an order, immediately leave to go get it and have yet to have it not be ready 20 mins later. read more

The food and ambience was very good. The staff were very kind and helpful and I was served quickly.

Had American chop Suey today and it was delicious the chicken Parm is amazing. Any food that I get here is awesome.

Tony's is just ok. Perhaps it's Sutton good but certainly not anywhere near the best I've had. The pepperoni and peppers pizza was excessively greasy and only mildly seasoned. The Buffalo wings were a little better, albeit I wasn't overly partial to the batter around the wings. The Italian cold sun was probably the best but it too was not close to a fan favorite for me. Even the Pepsi in the drink cooler were lukewarm, and that sums up the experience...lukewarm at best. read more

Not sure how a small pizza and a small grinder is $30.00? Especially for below average food. Definitely disappointed with product and pricing. read more

We went here kind of spur of the moment when our usual place was crowded. We got here on a Saturday evening and it was crowded here too, but Tony's is set up to handle a lot of people. Our order was quickly taken at the 'order' counter and we were given a number. They have a LOT of dining space and we quickly found a booth to sit at. Our number was called very fast! My partner wanted to try the sausage and meatball grinder and I wanted the turkey and bacon and we agreed to share them. We couldn't believe the size of the grinders!!! They were so full that the ingredients were falling out as we were eating them!!! It ended up the sausage and meatballs was our favorite! We saw lots of yummy salads and panini's going by our table and looking forward to trying them too! Our bill for 2 grinders and a bottle of water was about $20.00. We'll be back for sure!!!! read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - Amazing grinders!!! - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

Lived in Douglas for a long time. Tony's Deluxe Steak and cheese is on of the best in the region. The onion rings are solid as well. The pizza is delicious too read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - Steak Bomb with Onion Rings - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

See all

Place is always great. Can't go wrong with anything on the menu. First time having the chicken cordon bleu and it was delicious. Onion rings always big and crispy. Greta atmosphere and quick and friendly service. read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - a view of the dining area - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

See all

Update review! 2023 style! My son was playing in a soccer tournament near Tony's so I decided to take the whole family for an early lunch! This place for me is a can't miss! The Quality of the food, the taste tells you everything is fresh! The friendliness of the staff makes you feel like you are at home! The salad was amazing, the pizza's were perfect, atmosphere was great! Nice wall of fame to distract kids! If you are in central Massachusetts or just passing through, trust me stop in and enjoy some great food! read more

See all

Always love to stop at Tony's, great location for an easy stop by. Call ahead and you're back on the road with a snack. Thicker pan style, good flavor but suggest extra cheese. read more

Great pizza, great service, cute restaurant! I love this place! It's great I would recommend

Always have fast service. The food is always hot and tasty. The portions are very generous. One of my favorites is the baked stuffed shells.

My boyfriend introduced me to Tony's a few months ago, they have the best steak and cheese according to him lol. I did try it but imo it could've been better if they added more cheese.. anyways, i usually get the Turkey Bacon Cold Sub, which is SO good, i get the small but it's still a LOT for me! I haven't tried anything else on the menu, so i'm not sure if they excel as much as they do on my favorite sub. The service is nice, there's a lot of workers there and seems like they're always busy, people come and go but it's not a bother if you sit far from the entrance. read more

I lived in the area about 15 years ago and everyone around there swore by this place and I remember the food was amazing. I particularly remember the Buffalo wings as being crispy, not the usual type that gets soggy because they merely put buffalo sauce on top of fried chicken wings. So when I was in the area I had to stop by. The place still has a nice atmosphere and you get your food quicker than you'd expect in a busy place. Unfortunately the food has gone downhill. The buffalo wings were the soggy mess you can get anywhere and the pizza was a closer to something you'd get at a chain rather than anything special. I was just left feeling disappointed. read more

Nope never again. The girl who answered the phone was super nasty to me. She kept interrupting me with "is that it?" I couldn't get two words out of I finally asked if I could please talk. She went silent. Then I said ok, that's it. And she got nasty and said "number 90 goodbye". Slammed the phone in my ear. I called the "manager" and he said he was "surprised because she's the good one". No apology. DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY AT THIS DUMP. NEVER GOING BACK. GOING TO GET IN TOUCH WITH THE OWNER. read more

Stop going downhill, Tony's. Chicken cutlet with rigatoni is now chicken tenders on top of rigatoni. They forget dressing for salads on the regular (I should know better by now and should check). The pizza is NOT what it was. I hate knocking local establishments but it seems the complaints fall on deaf ears and it's SO disappointing. SO very disappointing. read more

This place is consistently good. The sandwiches and salads are amazing. I love their tuna and chicken salads and the Mediterranean Gorgonzola salad. Prices are very reasonable. Definitely worth going. read more

This place was really good! Ordered a small pizza and steak and cheese with mushrooms. The food was excellent and not too long of a wait. The restaurant was clean and spacious. Great find on a visit to central MA! read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - Small pizza with a meatball - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

What I've figured out is that the bad reviews for this place are mostly written about people having buyer's remorse after they ordered something random on the menu-- one girl complained that her spinach pizza didn't have sauce (yeah, that's because spinach and sauce don't go well together, the spinach gets all mushy). So really, this place is awesome. It's always busy, but the quality of service doesn't waver, it's always fast and courteous. Ignore the bad reviews and don't let them scar you off...or make a point to read them to see what the complaints were about. read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

I ordered take out from here a couple nights ago. I haven't been to Tony's in at least 10 years and my husband and I decided to try it again. I am now GF and they have a GF pizza so that made me super excited! My husband got a meat lovers (not GF) and he said it was amazing! I gotta say, this is the absolute best GF pizza I have EVER gotten from ANY pizza place yet!! The crust was crispy and tasty....not soggy or bland....it was a delicious pizza!! Thank you Tony's pizza for understanding and knowing how GF is important and making a delicious and quality GF pizza!! So happy I came back!! read more

Wish I could tell you about the food but we arrived at 8:40pm (according to Yelp they close at 10pm), and the owner told us (with no apology or remorse whatsoever) that they were closing early, and he refused to serve us. This is pretty much the only food around, so we wound up eating junk food at a gas station. The food we saw others eating looked totally devoid of love or quality so I suppose he did us a favor. My advice... don't bother. read more

Great pizza and pasta. Not fancy, but just good food and very reasonable prices for eat in or take out. If you like salads, the veggies are very fresh. Take out orders are always on time. Easy to get to location. Owners are always so friendly. read more

Always consistent. Menu never changed from previous owner, except for price increases.

This place kept getting recommended to my husband and I when we moved here and every time we have tried them the food has been mediocre at best, the orders have been messed up and the service has not only been bad but the people blatantly rude. I will not try them again. read more

Nothing special about anything at Tony's. The business has been there forever and will be the next fifty years. It fills the need. Noticed a few things recently: The small pizza is noticeably smaller in diameter. Simple math says make it ten percent smaller in diameter thus the surface area (and thus ingredients) are one third less. I sense a rip off at the same price. Raise the price, go larger and better. Quality not cheap price is more important. THANK YOU TONY'S for being open through the uncertain times. read more

Ok first time here and it was great! I got a small pepperoni half cheese pizza. The crust cheese sauce everything was delicious. I've always driven by here but had never stopped in. I will be back. I wish I lived closer but when I'm in the area Tony's is my new go to pizza place. The inside sitting area is very nice as well. read more

Tony's Sutton Pizza Restaurant - Cheese half pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sutton, Massachusetts

I really wanted to love this place. It is a order at the counter, find a seat and listen for your number to be called type of restaurant. It is Greek ownership, running with a strong Italian flair. Lots of folks at the counter to help you And All are more than willing to assist. Tonight, I ordered there chicken with lemon and garlic sauce on rigatoni. At 1495 it seemed like a good value. I received my order within 10 minutes and I had a substantial bowl of rigatoni with a slice chicken breast on top, the portion was large. However, unless I am grossly wrong, it was chicken, grilled with Italian dressing, and the pasta was tossed in that same Italian dressing. It wasn't horrible, but it was slightly south of good. And I'm not sure that the lack of sauce for the pasta Was not a good thing. The dish came with a warm roll with butter. The bread was fantastic. Last time I was here I had a simple pizza it is the Greek type of thicker pizza with a crispy crust. An awful lot of cheese made it quite heavy. But it was not outside of what my expectation was for this type of pizza. I still will come back to try some other things to see if I can get that star rating up a little bit but bottom line it is adequate not very expensive in large portions read more

I really only go to Tony's for 2 things: their bacon pizza and their meatball sub. Both are amazing. Unfortunately they don't have great appetizer options and their salads are lacking. But pizza & subs are always consistent! read more