The MVP pizza was perfect and the vibes here were incredible! The service was great and attentive. Dont order two slices unless you plan on bringing one home with you. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Springs, Florida

Ordered take out so I can't speak for the vibe. This is a proper New York-style slice. The crust had that classic foldable texture and just the right chew. Everyone in our group loved the cheese pizza, the pepperoni was also delicious, but the veggie slice ended up being my personal favorite. Everything tasted fresh and well-balanced without being overworked. Solid spot when you want a legit NY slice in Orlando. read more

The best pizza AROUND, Oviedo, Winter Springs or any local TOWN. Made fresh, the flavors UNREAL, A thin crust slice is an entire MEAL. Slice of the day, 1/27/25 was a WIN-WIN, It's called the Mango Habanero HAWAIIAN, Now the question is, where to BEGIN. Out of this world crust add the BASE, 'Nsane sauce allows it to ENCASE, So here is why I think they win the PIZZA RACE. Pineapple chunks, juicy and RICH, Italian pizza at its finest, not a thing I would SWITCH. Zesty ingredients set this slice APART, Zoom to 5229 Red Bug Lake & try it A LA CARTE.., And tell me which is better, the chicken, cheese or sauce so spicily SWEET? All you'll want to do is EAT and then REPEAT. My five stars are common but not my RANK, The Best Pizza in Orlando, take that to the YELP BANK. Jose and Trey were the ones who cooked this right on Monday. read more

See all

Pizzaooked good but soggy under cooked, cheesey knots were good. Waiters acted as if they didn't want to be there. Atmospheric was good. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Cheesey knots - Pizza Near Me - Winter Springs, Florida

See all

Great spot, I've been eating here for like 20 years.. back when they were lil Anthony's. Same good quality and service. I'll either eat in or order to go regularly - the food is good! read more

Hands down Best pizza around central Florida! Better than Dough Boyz Pizza! Sorry‍ I said it read more

See all

Yes Please! You can't help but smile when you pull up to this place because you know you're going to get the best pizza or the best calzone you've ever had. After we had our uneventful sushi we came over here to grab a calzone and we were not disappointed. Just look at this thing! It's massive. We shared it and even had enough to take home for a snack for the next day. We also had a antipasto salad That was delicious. Everything was served fresh and hot. Our server was spot on always checking in on us and getting whatever we needed. There is not much seating here so you will either have to wait or give them your name and they will call you when a table is ready. I think this is a very busy side of town. If you want good pizza that you can get by the slice or by the pie you must come here. Tonight was the first night I tried their calzone and it did not disappoint. Come get you some; read more

See all

Nancy and I stopped by Tomasino's on our recent date night in the Winter Springs area. We arrived around 7:30pm on a Thursday evening and this place was jamming with a 25-30-minute wait (actually not a bad wait for a full restaurant). We decided to go across the street to Hokkaido Sushi and get a small meal then return later once the wait died down; we returned an hour later and were greeted/seated promptly. Our server, Gabby, took great care of us, brought our drinks out quickly along with an ice cold Peroni draft ($4.99). We ordered the Greek House Salad ($10.99) and the Butcher Calzone ($12.99) with extra sauce ($0.69) to share. Our salad was ready in less than 10-minutes and the Calzone took about 25 minutes, sweet! The salad was filled with fresh ingredients and included salami, ham, feta cheese, kalamata olives, diced cucumbers & green peppers, and pepperoncini. Gabby brought out extra dressing at no charge. The dressing was a balsamic vinaigrette and was quite tasty. The Calzone was huge, basically a 12"-14" Butcher Pie folded over and baked, awesome! There was no way we could finish all of this food between us, but it was a lot of fun finally trying a Tomasino's Calzone for the first time. This is my first time visiting the Winter Springs Tomasino's location. I have to say this store seems smaller than the Lake Mary one. Also, this one seems to have a lot more employees. I counted 9 people working when we arrived. The one in Lake Mary might be lucky if they have 4; Kudos to Nick and his team at the Lake Mary location for always busting his butt and providing exceptional service. Tomasino's makes an awesome pizza, the Ricotta Be Kitting Me, the VIP, the Butcher's Pie are my favorites. My lunchtime favorites include the two slice & drink combo ($10), the Bossman's Meatball Sliders ($10), the Tomasino's Spinach salad ($13), and the Italian Combo sub ($11). If you love Italian food and are looking for a great place to dine-in or take out I highly recommend checking out Tomasino's! read more

See all

Tomasino's has absolutely delicious, delectable, mouthwatering food; however, they have a number of problems. My husband and I have been ordering food from here on and off for many years. We have had a problem with the delivery drivers not getting their tips, and I would have to drive to this Winter Springs location with cash to make sure that our drivers got their tip! What in the world is up with this?! This has happened more than once. Today is Sunday, March 9th, 2025, and I placed an order online for food for my husband and myself. Online it stated would be an hour for our food to arrive. 75 minutes later, I called to find out when our food would be arriving, only to be told that they have no order under my phone number!! WHAT?? I'm sorry, but I'm done with this pizza place. There is much more to be told about this evenings experience that has been a fiasco, but I'll just let it be. Oh, one more important bit of information. After speaking to two different assistant managers, and telling them about the hassle I've had to endure, they had the audacity to call me back and ask if I still wanted to place my order...seriously?! read more

I first visited about a year ago and enjoyed one of their lunch specials, which was excellent. This time, we decided to opt for a takeout order. Although I initially planned to order online, I noticed a $0.99 service charge. While it wasn't a huge amount, I opted to place the order over the phone. Our food was ready for pickup in just 25 minutes. We went with a 14-inch The Butcher's Pizza and the Bossman's meatball sliders. The Butcher's Pizza was packed with pepperoni, sausage, sliced meatball, bacon, and ham. We're big fans of meat pizzas, and this one had the most meat of any we've had! The Bossman's meatball sliders were tasty too, consisting of three garlic knots filled with meatballs, marinara sauce, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese. However, we felt they could have used a bit more garlic butter on top as it didn't have much garlic flavor. From my previous visit, I recall the dining area being quite small with limited tables. On that occasion, I didn't have trouble finding a seat, and the service was both quick and efficient. Overall, I think Tomasino's is great but it's not out of this world. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - The Butchers Pie 14 Inch - Pizza Near Me - Winter Springs, Florida

See all

Our favorite pizza in the area, we love this place! The food is always good, the special pizzas are inventive and amazing, the crust is perfectly chewy, and it's consistent every single time. A must! read more

Arrived from vacation and of course I was craving pizza. New York style. I ordered from Tomasino's and as always it did not disappoint. I got the wings for my sister and she loved them too. Have ordered from here many times and will continue to do so. read more

Absolutely spectacular food. Service was direct and fast, along with the lighting and decor adding to the experience. 10/10

Don't order delivery from this place. They charge you a $7.99 delivery fee. Save yourself the money and pick it up.

I originally gave them a one-star review months ago for a horrible phone order experience but gave them second chance and I'm glad I did. I had the chicken arugula salad and a VIP slice and both were excellent. Gabby's service was exceptional. She was both genuinely personable and professional. I can't wait to come back and try more as I'm always in the plaza. Looking forward to my next visit. read more

So disappointed. Service at this location has been deteriorating over the past year, however my last experience sealed the deal. 736 in the evening i order two slices of peperoni... sorry we are out. OK I'll wait for you to make another... no we won't do that. Holy cow... I used to spend almost 120 a month here and recommend this place every chance i could. Congrats. I haven't been back in a month and have stopped recommending this restaurant. read more

every time i place an order it's a very long wait and poor. customer service every time i place an order it's a very long wait and poor. customer service read more

I don't normally write reviews for restaurants but I have had so many wonderful experiences here and tonight was no different. The food was AMAZING, the calzones are HUGE, the salad was AMAZING, and the knots.. omg. The staff is wonderful, they are attentive and nice. Our server, Dona, and the other lovely ladies made this dinner a 10/10 experience. Even the cooks are great, always smiling and taking pride in their food. We will always recommend this place to all!! read more

I'm new to this area but this place has great NY style pizza. The flatbread is crunchy and very tasty. I wanted to add this picture since I was afraid to order it since there was no picture. This is the perfect size for a lunch. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - The Bossladys Flatbread - Pizza Near Me - Winter Springs, Florida

The food was amazing, as usual. The service was pretty lackluster. We sat for about 10 minutes before being greeted. The drinks and appetizers we ordered came out when our food did, the food order was wrong... now in fairness they did provide us a side of meatballs to put on our pizza ourselves, but it was just really odd. I would stick to take out here. read more

I was pleasantly surprised by this hole in the wall. We ordered To-Go. Saw there was a vegan option and had to try! They said 30min and it took 40, not a big deal especially for a Saturday evening. There was a consistent flow of customers coming in to pick up so this must be a local favorite. Our pizza had vegan cheese (tasted like Follow Your Heart). We normally do no cheese to save on calories, but we're curious about their vegan. I appreciated the amount of cheese that was put on. Some pizza places will overload the vegan cheese, but not here! And they did no scrimp on our toppings. We added pepperoncinis, jalapeños, and tomatoes. It was tasty!! Will definitely try again! read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Vegan pizza with pepperoncinis, jalapeños and tomatoes - Pizza Near Me - Winter Springs, Florida

Excellent pizza! Fresh! Tasty! We order from Tomasino's every time we visit Casselberry.

Pizza was very good. It reminded me of NY NJ pizza!! I have lived in the area for a few years and tried quite a few different pizza places but this is the best so far! read more

Hands down, the best pizza in the area. I don't even consider anyone else anymore. The staff is super friendly and helpful, too.

They have all sorts of dietary pizzas! GF, vegan, vegetarian, keto, and "normal" people too! The GF pizza crust is ok. It could be a littlecrisper, but overall no combines. The only toppings you can't have are the ones with breading (eggplant and chicken), and meatballs.wverything else is good to go! Wings are not breaded, but they share a fryer with mozzarella sticks. So, not bad if just intolerant like me, not so good if celiac due to cross contamination. Great food, awesome staff! I've been coming here since 2008, when I moved across the street, and they are my neighborhood pizza joint. I love them and their food! read more

I liked the flavor of their pizza (tried pepperoni and cheese) a lot but amount of cheese on the pies are just too much for me. It ends up being a bit too oily and soggy for my taste. I wouldn't mind giving it another shot and maybe request for less cheese. read more

The food price to quantity and quality is off centered. The server was good. Was surprised to find a few pieces of sausage in a non-meat pizza. The server did not make the mistake and offered To change it out. Had some really odd customer in a wheel chair that did not leave me and my family alone and was not wearing Shoes and or socks which also grossed me out. I was of on The fence with the place being up next to a service station with food service being next to the automotive fumes and Chemicals. read more

Absolute RIP OFF. I Paid over $100 for two pizzas. Unbelievably expensive. They upcharge EVERYTHING and ANYTHING.

Our absolute favorite pizza place. We've been coming here since before they were Tomasinos. The food is amazing and the staff is even better. Kayla was our waitress tonight (and many other Friday nights) and she is just perfect. Warm and welcoming, they were crazy busy (Friday night) and our family was seated within 10 minutes and eating within 25. Everything was delicious, pizza, chicken parmigian, and a Stromboli. We have food for at least one more meal for our family. read more

The calzones here are amazing, just want to mention that off the bat. The pizza is very good but inconsistent. Many times, you will get a perfectly cooked, evenly sauced pie. Sometimes, you'll get underdone dough with excessive sauce and it's disappointing. The desserts are amazing, HOWEVER, the portions are bananas for the price. Just $5 less than an entire calzone gets you a tiny piece of cake about two teaspoons worth in size. The price of dessert is outrageously marked. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Teeny tiny $9.09 tiramisu. - Pizza Near Me - Winter Springs, Florida

Went in and bought some pepperoni slices off of their slice special. Pretty legit and I got it with a Pepsi. I forgot to take a pic because I ate it so fast had to mangia. I didn't notice until after but the cheese shakers are rusty and dusty. I am a cheese dumper so I saw the cap was looking all messed up. The nice taste in my mouth dissipated after I stopped in the men's room and the toilet needed work. The flush button is clearly old and boss needs to tighten the chain and probably get a new flapper. Some wise guy didn't have the patience to hold down the button for a 10 second flush and I bet it happens every day. It was hot and I was sweating because I don't think the AC reached the restroom. It didn't matter because the front door has a half inch gap all the way down! I was ready to get to Home Depot after seeing all these easy fixes a handyman could do. Food was good but the laziness or maybe even ignorance in the maintenance makes you wonder what else they don't keep up. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Open door. - Pizza Near Me - Winter Springs, Florida

Gosh, I hate giving such a great little place a low review. Let me start off by saying the staff is great. On a busy Friday night, all of the workers were still in high spirits, joking around with customers and trying their best to meet all the orders and still attend to those of us eating in the small restaurante. HUGE shoutout to our server who was great and fun and patient and attentive even with two kiddos under two. The pizza was... good. It was a little soggy on the bottom but at least the dough was edible and not burnt like most other pizza joints. The garlic knots were good, but.... Too cheesy (I know right???). The meatballs were also, just good. If you're lucky, like us, one of their regulars that picks up a pizza every Friday night also picked up our tab and surprised us! read more

I recently moved to Winter Springs from Lake Mary and would frequent that location a lot. Probably too much and I was excited to see there was one right down the street from my new house. The location is a little smaller than Lake Mary, but they still deliver the same quality food. I also prefer the service better at the Lake Mary location. Not that they aren't friendly here, but Lake Mary really made us feel like family. We've ordered delivery from this location which is always quoted an hour, but it's noted it may be busier on peak nights. Even on the weekend we always get our pizza within the hour. Everything I have here is amazing and we'll keep coming back for the delicious food! read more

Tomasino's has a few strikes in my book: terrible parking, teeny shop and long waits. Kinda pricy. But do they have the most important plus and maybe the only one that matters, TOP NOTCH PIZZA? Yes, yes they do. We got a vegan cheese and pepperoni/sausage pizza. The sausage was piled on. Always a plus. Our extra cheese pepperoni 18 inch had more cheese than you can shake a stick at. If you can put up with the non-pizza related drawbacks, Tomasino's delivers a world class pie. read more

Food is horrible. Ask me more for details. Never eating there again. Horrible staff and management. I had to give it one star but deserves -1 star read more

Crust is the make it or break it factor for pizza for me and thankfully Tomasino's nails it! Their service is always fast and kind, and sitting inside feels like I'm chilling at home. A great casual lunch spot! read more

Good food and good service. We enjoy every order and love the flavor of each thing we've tried. Extensive menu

I know nothing about making homemade sauce. Hell, I can barely get al dente right. But for lunch today, I treated myself to the delicious and sweet marinara sauce coupled with mozzarella cheese and penne pasta, a/k/a Baked Ziti. Fantastic! I did not even get to the garlic knots - a healthy portion of four. My niece appeared to enjoy the meatball sliders as appetizer - never seen those at a restaurant before but they looked delectable. And during today's pick-up (curbside) I was literally flabbergasted by the fact that they import and serve Junior's Cheesecake. My God! I'm from New England and Junior's is legendary. I am so excited to return to try the pizza. Fourteen or eighteen inches (size matters). And they serve by the slice (2) - lunch specials for as little as eight dollars. I cannot believe I have just found Tommasino's. So happy to be part of the family. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Meatball sliders appetizer - Pizza Near Me - Winter Springs, Florida

See all

So I heard through the grapevine that this place had some of the best pizza in town, so I had to come check it out. I love pizza. It's a cozy little hole in the wall joint, which I love. A little over a half-dozen booths in the whole place, slices ready to serve in the glass box, and one of the aforementioned booths full of pizza boxes that were in the process of being put together. I got sat and my super friendly server, Lauren, came over and introduced herself. She answered all of my questions and made the useful recommendation of going half-and-half on a whole pie. So I did it. I ordered a 14" pie, half The Butcher's Pizza (Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, bacon & ham) and half Hawaiian (Ham and pineapple). The Butcher's Pizza was much better than most meat-based pizzas I've had. Each meat added something to the mix. Even the usually blah topping of meatballs had a nice Italian kick to it. Big fan. The Hawaiian was solid as always. Even though there were only two toppings, the slice was slathered in those two toppings. Very generous portions. The crust of the pizza was the best part. Crust makes or breaks the pizza. We all know this. This crust was thin, the good stuff, but it was also sturdy enough to hold in all the toppings when folded in half. The crust of the crust was crunchy and chewy, but not too chewy. You now when the crust crust is basically a loaf of bread? Not here. Overall, this place was really really good. I usually give really really good places four stars, but this place really caught me off guard and thinking back, I can't think of a single critique about the place. The pizza was A+, my server Lauren was A+, and the whole scene was A+. I don't usually go with good pizza places like this when satisfying my football pizza needs, I usually just go with Pizza Hut, but I think I've finally found a place where the bang is worth my buck. Top notch. read more

From afar all pizza places blend in and look the same but what you really gotta look out for are the true mom and pop style pizza joints. This is the spot. I've lived by this place for 12 years and it's been all good for 12 years. We ordered during the Covid pandemic and they charged us over the phone and did curbside delivery! This was a relief during the time. When we got home and saw the beauty of these items we had to stop and snap pictures and let me tell you the pizza was amazing and delicious just how it looks in the pic! The wings were absolutely my favorite ever which was surprisingly good. The garlic knots with Alfredo were to die for as well!!!I highly recommend this place if you live or are new in the Casselberry area!! read more

See all