Grabbed a pizza and garlic knots for movie night. When we got it home we realized they'd given us a plain cheese pizza without the topping we'd ordered. I called and asked whether they'd be able to deliver the correct order-- or whether I'd be able to drive the food back up so they could fix it. All they were willing to do is offer a discount the next time I come in. Problem is we hadn't ordered from Jerry's in at least a year and after this I won't be back. The pizza wasn't great and the garlic knots smelled incredible but the pile of raw garlic on top killed it. To be fair, the woman I spoke with was apologetic and perfectly nice. But when you mess something up you have to do right by your customers, especially when they offer to go out of their way to get the food they paid for. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Longwood, Florida

I placed an order online for a few pastas when I bit into the chicken piccata I had not one hair .. not two hairs but an entire clump of hair in my mouth. after vomiting, I called the restaurant and they told me that I needed to contact Uber instead of apologizing for their mistake and offering a refund on their end, they said "oh well you need to call Uber. .. " it's sad that they would tarnish their reputation by hiring people who have lack of empathy and problem-solving skills. Highly don't recommend. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Hair in Chicken Piccata - Italian Near Me - Longwood, Florida

See all

I think we found our new Italian go-to. We've ordered take out twice and both times the food was excellent! We first tried the chicken parm and spaghetti bolognese. Both dishes had hearty portions and tasted really good. We tried their pizza recently and it was far superior to any chain pizza in town. I snuck a piece of chocolate cake into the order and man, it was so yummy! Not overpriced either. Their food was fresh and tasted great! We will be ordering from them again for sure! read more

1/5 - Came in for a pizza review. With the a regular cheese slice at $3 with toppings at an extra 50 cents, I had hoped for a better pizza since there is not a variety of different slices. I got one cheese slice and one mushroom ‍ slice. My coworker loves this spot but the pizza was not very good. The toppings came cold and the pizza was lackluster with no flavor, floppy and sad. Unfortunately, I won't be returning but perhaps items like entrees other than their pizza can be good! TikTok Reviewer: acaicaitlin read more

Jerry's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Longwood, Florida

See all

Food: I haven't tried anything but the pizza but let me tell you - the pizza is excellent NY style pizza AND you can order by the slice. Pizza is thin, but not too floppy. It always has this crispy crunch on the bottom that pairs so well with the cheesiness on top. All of the ingredients taste fresh and it is SUPER consistent on flavor and quality, which I really appreciate. Service: Great service! Family owned and you can feel the love here. Very nice people, always courteous, always make sure you're happy. Ambiance: I think I prefer take away at this location, however, you can definitely eat there and enjoy. It is comfortable, casual, hole-in-the-wall (but in a good way), clean, booths and tables available read more

Jerry's Pizza - Cheese pizza by the slice - Italian Near Me - Longwood, Florida

Food is okay. Lunch menu is decent. Atmosphere is like a diner...just tables and chairs, no decor. Mgr/owners have meetings right in the dining area which I don't care for. Place is clean. read more

Fast delicious local pizza! This is my neighborhood pizza joint so I'm probably biased, but their Bianca pizza is absolutely the best if you're a fan of white pizza. Perfectly thin crust and high quality ingredients. My husband is a fan of the meat lover's calzone. I just place my order online and pick up in a few minutes. What more can you ask for really. read more

This place was ok. I ordered the chicken parm and cheese ravioli. They both came with salads and garlic knots. The ravioli was pretty good and the red sauce was tasty. The garlic knots were pretty lame. Not much garlic to speak of and ultimately just tasted like dinner rolls. I did however like the chicken Parmesan. The chicken was nice and juicy and full of flavor. But, it certainly isn't the best I've had, especially not for $17! There are tons of Italian restaurants in the area that either charge less or provide larger portions. If I'm comparing them to a few others, I'd go elsewhere next time. Again, they were fine but we've had better for less. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Chicken Parmesan - Italian Near Me - Longwood, Florida

Decent spot. Tried it out for lunch, very quick service and they are friendly. Inside was a bit dark and dated. Classic pizza joint type vibes. Got the lunch special 2 slices and a soda for like $8? Great deal! Pizza came out fast but it could taste how burnt and hard it was. I may come back to give it another shot or order a pie to-go. read more

See all

Best Pizza in Longwood. Food is always fresh and made to order. Will do customizations upon request. Very kind and best of all it is a family business. read more

We discovered this family owned gem less than a week ago and I woke up craving Jerrys Pizza at 1030am...lol. Ordered tons of food because everyone loves it leftover too. So yummy! Thank you Jerry's! Highly recommend a slice! Pasta is amazing as well! read more

The best local Italian restaurant in the area! Great place for pizza too! The staff is friendly and welcoming. The food was delicious and even a good beer and wine offering. But you absolutely have to order the cannolis, they are made in house and they are heaven! Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5 Recommended dishes Pepperoni Pizza, House Salad, Cannoli, Chicken Wings, Jerry's Special Pizza, Flatbread, Garlic Knots, Chicken Marsala, Tiramisu Recommendation for vegetarians Highly recommend Vegetarian offerings Large vegetarian selection Dietary restrictions Gluten free options Vegetarian options Kid-friendliness Kid menu read more

Excellent pizza and a very quiet atmosphere. Just the way I like it. I enjoy coming to Jerry's for their fresh pizza and family friendly atmosphere. read more

See all

We love Jerry's. We don't venture from our favorite entrees of baked ziti and Greek salad. The vegetable sausage soup is great. I like the meatballs too. The service is sweet and timely. The atmosphere is like a diner - relaxed and friendly. We were starving and didn't think to take pics until we'd started eating! read more

See all

Ordered lots of pizza and wings for a party and everything was fantastic. Great communication with owner. Everything was hot and ready when needed and everything tasted great! Will definitely order from Jerry's again. Thank you so much! read more

This place has really Great pizza, great people behind the counter, really like this place a lot. The owner is back there making the pizzas.

Longwoods hidden gem!! I have been coming here for 20 years and it never disappoints. New York style pizza, huge pasta portions, and a perfect family atmosphere. read more

So this one is a sleeper. We wanted some pizza for lunch and decided to try this one out. The review were slightly misleading since they reflected service not food. Its a quiet simply place. We started with the Gio Rolls They were the perfect blend of crustiness and soft tender inner. They were topped with fresh garlic and cheese. The sauce was well paired and did not overwhelm. The slices were crisp on the bottom and perfectly cooked on top. read more

This has to be the worst pizza I have ever had. All the fast food pizzas are better. Don't waste your time or money. No flavor, it reminded me of when I was a kid and my Dad would make us Chef Bordiee pizza from a box. It was like cardboard, but we were kids, 50 years ago. Sorry Jerry, the trash pail ate your pizza. read more

We love their Meatball Parmesan subs my uncle picks them up for us they're huge with lots of cheese!! We like their pizzas too they are very good also. read more

They have great food, and went above and beyond to help out the community by being open in the aftermath of Hurricane Milton. Highly recommended. read more

Food and service are amazing! Can't beat this place for lunch or dinner. Authentic style pizza with the best ingredients. Hands down the best pizza in the area! read more

Just picked up a pizza. Taste good, but $11 for a 4 slice personal pizza? Used to be a lot bigger for $11. I'll do a degornos next time read more

Jerry's Pizza - Four bites - Italian Near Me - Longwood, Florida

I went to Jerry's for lunch with a group of 36 women, it was a little chaotic to say the least, but the young waitresses handled it well. It is awesome, that they have been around for 31 years. I had Stromboli for lunch with a coke. It was delicious. We definitely will go back. There is a separate room, for larger groups, which you can request. read more

Disappointing visit to Jerry's. Had always driven by but never ate there. Saw multiple 5 stars online and thought we would give it a try. Popped in on a Saturday night and we literally were the only folks in the restaurant. And in the hour of being there - only 1 customer came in for take out. Pizza just was not very good - tasteless crust and too much seasoning sprinkled on. Pasta dishes we had were ok. Think there are better alternatives for both pizza and pasta in Longwood. On a positive note- our waitress was very attentive, courteous and gets an A+. read more

Great food fantastic service . A must try check them out.Pizza awesome... pasta dishes on point... Try the Penne alla Vodka...

We've been in the area for a couple years now and have never tried this place until the other night! Hidden in a small strip mall by Winn Dixie... we decided to try it out. What a pleasant surprise. We went at night and it had a very casual, cozy pizzeria feel. My husband ordered the shrimp scampi. This was tasty but just needed a bit more salt. I ordered two meatballs and shared a large Greek salad with my kids. I'd definitely come back for a visit when I'm in the mood for some good Italian grub read more

Jerry's Pizza - Shrimp scampi - Italian Near Me - Longwood, Florida

See all

Super good quality food. The pizzas are excellent always consistent quality and. Very clean establishment great location super good parking. 100 percent value! read more

I had low expectations since it looks like a pizza parlor but the pasta was amazing! My favorite was the pene with vodka but the hand rolled manicotti and the baked ziti were great as well. You can tell the homemade quality from this place and I was very pleasantly surprised! The garlic rolls and a salad come with the entré and the rolls were homemade as well! read more

Jerry's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Longwood, Florida

See all

I was once a semi regular at lunch. I have made a real attempt to eat at family owned restaurants during these tough times. I had an experience a few weeks ago that has ended my relationship with this establishment permanently . Within a half hour visit, I not only witnessed an employee get humiliated, but also had the unique pleasure of listening to F Bombs being dropped while I attempted to enjoy my lunch. To top things off, I attempted to contact the owner about this incident though Facebook and he showed little, if any concern. I would suggest anyone with small children avoid this restaurant until the tall cook (Jeff?) learns a bit about how to conduct one's self while working in view of the public. read more

This place is not fancy, but it is clean and quiet. The flavors are natural and remind me of eating pizza as a kid. This is not a chain restaurant flavor. I give the flavor a 4.5 and the extra bump is for service. I observed the kitchen staff giving extra care to a woman who needed to keep her food dry and secure to take her dinner home home on the bus. He helped her wrap the entire order to ensure she would be able to eat when she gets home. Our waitress was quiet and polite. read more

This is my favorite pizza in Florida. I've been going here over 30 years. The pasta dishes are not what they once were, but I still enjoy the salad, calamari, and the warm Italian sub. The wings are pretty decent for a pizza place. read more

Very disappointed in the quality of the pizza at Jerry's. Ordered four slices; two cheese, two pepperoni to go. Biting into the first slice I can only compare the texture to chewing on a tough piece of steak. The flavor was non-existent even with the pepperoni. Points for the pizza coming out in just a few minutes and piping hot after a quick 10 minute drive home. Disclaimer: I am originally from NY and a pizza snob but it also means I know good pizza from bad. Sorry Jerry, this just doesn't cut it. read more

Came in for a to-go order right when they opened at 11 in the middle of the week. Even with only one table and multiple staff, the girls working were too concerned with gossiping rather than getting my order right. Charged me correctly but put the order in wrong so we had to wait for them to remake it. Food is average and service leaves a lot to be desired. read more

Walked in to have dinner at 8:04PM and they informed me that they were closing. It was clearly posted on the sign that they didn't close until 9PM and online even said 10PM. Disappointing. Especially since we drove 20 minutes just to have dinner here with (2) children in tow. Not impressed. read more

Ordered online for a to-go pizza with several toppings and was told 30 minutes. I walked into the restaurant 30 minutes later and still had to wait another 10 minutes. When placing my online order I selected 4 toppings that I believed I paid extra for, but when I got home and opened the box I had a plain cheese pizza that was mediocre at best. I called the restaurant and spoke to the "manager" and was told the online service didn't list the toppings. I expressed my disappointment and asked if they would make it right and was told no. In fact, I was told that next time I wanted to order to go I should call in instead of ordering online. It is 2019, we can all place an online order with a dozen other restaurants that will get it right (and care if it is wrong), so why would anyone bother with Jerry's considering they care so little about customer satisfaction that they can't even remake a simple pizza correctly; or offer a free appetizer or Cannoli on another visit to encourage me to come back and give them another try? At this point I've given Jerry's enough chances to impress me and they always fall short. Go to Luna's across the street or Anthony's on 436 where the food AND service are better at both. read more

Still as great as it was when I was first here 20+ years ago! My father and I stopped in for lunch today. It's been maybe a few years since I was last here, so I was long overdue for a visit. My father suggested that we go to Luna's for lunch, but since he, my mother and some of their friends had just been there this past weekend, I suggested that we try Jerry's instead. I'm glad we did. He had the eggplant Parmesan sub/sandwich (it is available in 2 sizes, 6" or 10"; he went with the smaller, which was I think $4.25), and I had 2 slices of cheese pizza ($2/each). He said his sandwich was very good, as was my pizza. It's the best pizza I've had recently & I'm looking forward to coming back in here again soon to get some more. The pizza was hot, fresh and delicious. It had the perfect amount of grease on it, the crust was great and the cheese/sauce just as wonderful. I forget exactly what the menu said, but I think lunch specials are offered from 11 a.m.-3 p.m. Mon.-Fri., and maybe even a little bit on weekends (?). Not sure, but this place is definitely worth coming to, regardless. Our server was very friendly and the restaurant was a little more crowded than I was expecting. We had to park close to the very end of the shopping center as every other space, up to the one we took, was taken, and likely all parked vehicles were owned by Jerry's patrons. I knew this place was popular with the lunch crowd, though not this much. No problem, though - you're not going to have any trouble getting a table here as the restaurant is comprised of two dining rooms. There's ample space for many customers. Hmm ... what else? Oh, I think that Jerry's maybe only accepts credit cards/cash. No debit cards, maybe? I thought I saw a sign indicating as much near the cash register while paying. Stop in if you can and have some great food. You won't be disappointed! Price range is one $ for lunch/a few slices/etc., though the range goes to $$ after the lunch specials end and/or if you want a more extensive meal. read more

We decided to try this place yesterday so we ordered garlic knots, they were ok. We ordered a large cheese pizza and a special Calzone, I think they put the 2 in wrong ovens, pizza under cooked and chewy and the calzone over cooked dough and undercooked inside, way over staffed and loud staff. Not again read more

This is my new favorite Italian place! I have been driving by for years and on a whim my wife and I stopped and and had the best meal EVER...okay maybe not EVER but it was amazing! We got the garlic knots and they were amazing. Side note: they use large chunks of fresh garlic. So if you don't like garlic get them anyways... they still rock. both times I have been I have gotten the Chicken Parm. It is HUGE! Also, the best chicken parm I have had. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Garlic Knots! Best thing EVER!!! - Italian Near Me - Longwood, Florida

DO NOT waste your money on this terrible food! I ordered food to go and the calamari was rubbery, the wings tasted freezer burnt and the calzone had barely any toppings on it that I paid $2 a piece for. This place is TRASH. Your better off going to the Olive Garden to get your money's worth. For the prices of this food it should taste fresh, this food did not meet up to its high prices. Not to mention the manager and owner would not even refund me for this terrible food. read more