Still trying to understand the hype about this place? The mustard spaghetti? A solid 6/10 The famous meatballs? 5/10? It literally tasted like it was frozen and reheated. Overly salty and on a bed of Parmesan cheese to make it look fancy? The diabolo pizza? Floppy mess. The rigatoni was probably the best dish we tried. 7/10 The service was also awful. How did we get served warm water on one of the hottest days of the season so far? We had a reservation and waited 20 minutes to get seated. Took forever to bring us a high chair for our baby. It was an awful first experience and will not be returning :/ read more

A client from St Pete met me midway. I turned to yelp for a nice lunch venue. I had never experienced Winter Park and I found it lovely, Prato was a perfect place to meet. Joey was our server and he was great. My guest was not as adventurous as me, so he got the meatball app which I tried and was excellent. I had the carpaccio and crudo, both excellent. I had the local lager on tap. We each had a personal pizza, I got the spicy selection and it was spicy enough. I loved the petite red peppers on the pizza. Overall it was perfect for our meeting and I would go again while in the neighborhood. read more

What a great spot for a date night. My boyfriend and I made a weekend reservation and were seated right away when we arrived. The inside is decorated so cute with plants and gentle lighting. We got a booth near the bar area. I started off the evening with an espresso martini - and boy was it good! I would definitely recommend. For an appetizer we started with the Prato Meatballs. This order comes with 3 large meatballs that were juicy and flavorful. Let's get to the entrees. We ordered the Rigatoni Bolognese and the Beef Short Rib. The bolognese was hearty and so yummy. There was alot and plenty to also take home for the next day. The beef short rib was extremely tender and the potatos were fluffy. I think this was a solid dish. To finish off the evening, we had to get a dessert. We ordered the cheesecake to split. It had a different texture an maybe a traditional cheesecake but still delicious. We had great service. The bar seemed to keep filling up the whole time we were there and a busy spot. Everything here made for a perfect date night spot. read more

See all

Prato is an absolute standout. From the moment we arrived, the service was warm, attentive, and effortlessly professional--friendly without ever feeling rushed or intrusive. The ambience is perfect: stylish yet relaxed, with a cozy, inviting energy that makes you want to linger. The pizza was exceptional--beautifully cooked with a perfect crust, high-quality ingredients, and incredible flavor in every bite. Pair that with their excellent wine selection, which complements the food perfectly, and you've got a truly memorable dining experience. Prato gets everything right: service, atmosphere, food, and wine. A place I'd happily return to again and again. Emma our server was such an amazing person, fast, professional and friendly. We will definitely come back again! Thank you Emma! read more

Prato - Absolutely delicious for a date night! - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

We came in for dinner and had a great experience. Service was welcoming and the atmosphere was so relaxing. I enjoyed a glass of prosecco. For our appetizer, we got the pretzel breaded calamari. It came with two sauces and both were delicious. The calamari was tender and crisp. For my entree, I got the truffle gnocchi. They were so pillowy and the sauce was to die for. The portions were solid. It was a good meal. read more

See all

Went here on a first date. The meatballs were stellar and I'm still dreaming about them! I had the mustard spaghettini and he had the rigatoni. I see why people love this place. To finish dinner, we shared the tiramisu. It was a bit light of the coffee flavor, but it was really fluffy! Nicely done overall. Our server was great too and gave use great recommendations. Can't wait to go back! read more

Prato - Mustard Spaghettini Cacio E Pepe - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Prato in Winter Park was such a fantastic stop! The vibe is fun and lively as soon as you walk through the doors. It was pretty busy for a Thursday--thanks to the gorgeous weather--but we were seated right away, even with the crowds. They offer both outdoor seating and bar seating, which adds to the relaxed, welcoming atmosphere. Our server was wonderful, taking the time to explain the menu and share some great recommendations. We started with the Burrata appetizer and holy cow... it was incredible. A huge, beautifully presented plate with super fresh lettuce, sliced pears, almonds, and the burrata split open and drizzled with prosecco. Hands down the best burrata I've ever had. For my lunch entrée, I ordered the Panino Caprese sandwich, and it was everything you love about a fresh caprese salad tucked inside warm focaccia. So yummy. I chose the house-made chips on the side, and they were amazing--crispy, flavorful, and clearly fresh. This was an excellent dining experience all around. Highly recommend stopping by Prato if you're in the Winter Park area! read more

See all

I was driving home from Orlando and decided to stop here for some pizza. It is conveniently located on Park Avenue in Winter Park. They have indoor, outdoor and bar seating. It was a beautiful sunny day so I decided to sit outside at one of their sidewalk tables. The menu offers appetizers, salads, pizzas, pastas and entrees. I opted for the Diavolo Pizza. It came with pepperoni, pancetta, and Italian long peppers. It was just a little spicy but tasted great. Service was quick from my server, Lily. read more

See all

Leo our server was extremely nice and walked us through the menu, and included his favorites. The espresso martini was really good and their in-house pasta is to die for. The setting is super nice too at night and very lively. Would recommend this spot for a good date night read more

See all

Outside seating and a birthday lunch. Food was 4.5 stars, service was 4 stars as it was good and pleasant but slow. 1.5hrs for lunch was a little more than we planned on. Bathrooms are shared gender and that can be not ideal. Would come back to try the pizza, it looked amazing. read more

Prato - Chicken sandwich and side salad - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

I have always wanted to come here and I finally came with my friends. The restaurant has a nice low lit ambience to it. The service here was good. To start we got the beef carpaccio and we really enjoyed it. I got the Cacio e pepe, this was amazing. The noodles here are so good and the sauce was delicious. We also really enjoyed the potato gnocchi so creamy and perfectly chewy. Last thing we got was the Margarita Pizza, it tasted fresh but it was a bit too floppy/soggy for me. I prefer a crispier pizza crust. I would definitely come back here again for their pasta. I want to come back and try their other pasta dishes. read more

See all

A little overpriced for what we got, but I would definitely go again and try a few other things. Portions felt a little small, given the price. Mocktails were nice and creative (I really enjoyed their espresso martini)! Dog-friendly is always a bonus in my book. read more

Prato - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

This place is beautifully decorated. I love the dim lighting and neighborhood feel inside. I heard good things about this place and looked forward to trying it. Upon seating, I was given water and greeted with a menu. After asking the bartender what the most popular drink was, he suggested the Cetriolo, "for sure" which is a martini made of cucumber organic vodka, agave, lime, white cranberry, and topped with a basil garnish. It tastes absolutely delicious. Its also one of the cheaper drinks on the menu. For dinner, I did a little research and saw some appetizing pictures on Yelp. I ordered the Mustard Spaghettini "Cacio E Pepe" half portion. It was delicious. Would definitely return. Even if for the martini alone! read more

Prato - Cetriolo - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Tried this while in Winter Park, noted the Michelin recommendation... Didn't not disappoint!! Got the Seasonal Pizza with Duck! Then also the Tagliatelle! Was great Out waiter Dekota was great, awesome recommendations, We sat by the front window, Beautiful park view!! Lovely Want to return and try more things!! read more

See all

After an amazing experience at the Scenic Boat tour in Winter Park, we were ready for lunch. My wife and I stop at Prato for a pizza bite. The place has a great atmosphere, service was great, and the best part, the pizza was amazing. I literally recommend this restaurant to any one visiting or staying in Winter Park. read more

Prato never disappoints. Accidentally made reservations for a week ahead but alas, they had tables for a party of 3 for lunch today. The ambiance is always on par and the service compliments it. They do change the menu, which is nice and today we normally get the escarole salad, but they have Caesar salad "the little gem". Both are perfect, I prefer the escarole to the gem as it has more of a vinaigrette flavored dressing compared to a creamier one. My husband is basic and ordered half cheese and half pepperoni pizza. I ordered the Funghi. Both delicious. I normally get a lunch sized pasta but was more in a pizza mood. My favorite is walking to the back and passing the kitchen where you see them making the pasta by hand. Prato is always a good option, but always remember to reserve a table! read more

See all

The best Italian restaurant! We went during lunch since we weren't able to get a dinner rez for weeks. We got the chopped chicken salad and the Diavolo pizza to share, and I got the rigatoni to myself. The salad was amazing. I usually order salads when I just want to get some greens in me but this was an enjoyable salad with lots of greens, chicken and bits of bacon that pairs well with the slightly sweet raisins. My rigatoni was perfectly seasoned and the noodles were cooked al dente. I could tell they were made from scratch. The diavolo pizza was the reason why we came and unfortunately it just wasn't the best diavolo pizza I've had. It wasn't that flavorful and the bite was tough and lacked cheese pull. The service was amazing and we had our waters refilled constantly. They were attentive and quite funny. The ambiance is wonderfully decorated with a tavern-feel. This place is definitely worth coming to try, especially their salads and pasta. I'll definitely come back to try their other pizzas! read more

Prato - Diavolo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Last night we visited Prato and my expectations were unfortunately not met. I want to start off with the atmosphere was very good and the staff were very friendly. It was a last-minute dinner reservation. We wanted something in the Winter Park area and Prato was the closest thing to a last minute table we can find. We had the meatballs to start and the octopus. The meatballs had a really good flavor and we're very filling. The octopus unfortunately came in a spicy sauce, one small potato, little chewy for my taste and the bacon, you can really taste the bacon grease. Wasn't my favorite octopus. Let's start with one of the most disappointing plates. They're Cacio e pepe. We were told that it's one of their most popular dishes. I posted two photos. One is of a real Cacio e Pepe from Italy and the other one is a made up version Pratos invented. Cacio e Pepe doesn't have sun-dried tomatoes or ham. It's a simple and most delicious plate with only two ingredients. That unfortunately was not served. It was honestly disappointing. That can pass more for carbonara. I'm not saying that they're trying to re-create the real dish. It was just quite disappointing, considering I was really looking forward to having Cacio E Pepe. We also had the spicy pizza. Could use a little more cheese on the pizza. Besides that the dough was perfect. Also a house Cab $31 dollar is ridiculous. You should have a house red or blend at a lot more reasonable price. It's house wine. The real star of the night was their homemade tiramisu. It was light and creamy in all the right ways. Will we return? Probably not. But the price was very fair considering it's in winter park. I would just order something else. I'm sure they have a lot of better plates. read more

See all

I am visiting from Houston and kept hearing people talk about Prato. We tried to eat there on Thursday night and the wait was about an hour to an hour and a half. That told me the spot was popular. We decided to come back the next night and I am glad we did. We found seats inside. The place looked great. The vibe felt warm and lively. We ordered two non alcohol Sangue di Drago drinks and they tasted fresh and balanced. I ordered a salad with cheese in the middle. I wish I remembered the name because it was delicious. Service was friendly and the food came out fast. I am glad we made the trip back. Five stars. read more

Prato - Sangue di Drago - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Enjoyed lunch at the newly remodeled restaurant. Smartly decorated and designed. We enjoyed the pretzel coated calamari very good but, didn't taste any pretzel crust. We also enjoyed the octopus. Very good. For our entree's we enjoyed the steak panini, Gorgonzola burger with a side salad. Both very good. Also enjoyed the Cacio e Pepe entree. The new culinary team is spot on with the flavors and presentations of the dishes. Service was very good. Very attentive. Friendly and offered recommendations. Great food, service and atmosphere for meals with $$ signs. Definitely must try. Enjoy the photos below. read more

See all

Our order: Margherita pizza with gluten-free crust, honeycrisp salad, Caesar salad, spring carrot soup, broccolini The Review: The star of the show was the GF pizza. Important to note that it's made in the same oven as the others and is open to cross-contamination. The salads were also nice, crispy, and flavorful. Why -2 stars? We came here for my mom's birthday, and I was really hoping for a seamless experience. The food was extremely slow to arrive and was served in a random order. For example, the broccolini, soup, and wine came at the very end (not to mention almost an hour later). The server did not come to check on us. The wines were bottom shelf, just really unfortunate quality. We got a Barbera and a Montepulciano. The burn in our throats was enough to know, and a quick Google search confirmed our suspicions. This could be a really great place for fine dining, if a few things are corrected! read more

See all

Prato is incredible, every time we go we have the best experience. Everything from the food to the service to the ambiance. Prato is also super consistent, it's delicious every single time. Moving out of Florida and leaving Prato behind is one of my biggest heart breaks! If you haven't been here yet you must go and experience it for yourself! Lastly, MAKE A RESERVATION you'll definitely need it they are so so busy! read more

See all

Truly delish! 3rd time here and it was been consistently great in taste and service! Make a reservation or you'll be waiting a while but still worth it. Have tried multiple menu items and love their calamari! This time around the husband enjoyed the chicken milanese panini which comes with a side salad. I had the mustard spaghettini yet again! It's said to be their "Cacío E Pepe" but it tastes more like a carbonara to me, either way it's delicious and you should give it a try! Got the $17 "regular" portion but didn't finish it. Great idea to get the tasting portion ($10) along with something else. No kids menu but they do offer a kid-friendly butter style pasta if you ask your server or a cheese or pepperoni pizza which is always our choice. Dark atmosphere inside with tables and bar seating, or lovely outside seating! Pretty tightly spaced so if you're with a stroller - beware. Highchairs and booster seats are available for children. Family friendly but ideal for business casual meets or date nights. read more

See all

When I think of Italian, I think of Prato. The menu is so well crafted and delicious. This is my absolute favorite restaurant in Orlando. I am extremely picky about Meatballs and somehow Prato does it right every single time. The Mustard Cacio e Pepe is my favorite pasta on the menu. The service here is great as well. Very romantic atmosphere. Love it here so much! read more

Prato - Prato Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

I had dinner at Prato at its peak-time on a Saturday night. I made the reservation 2 months in advance since it books up quickly and has a steady stream of customers throughout the night. The restaurant is beautiful but not pretentious and we were promptly seated. Our server, Julia was very knowledgeable and personable. The food was mostly really good and for the price, there was a good portion served. Highlights include the meatballs, pasta dishes, diavola pizza and both the desserts were phenomenal. The food did take a long time to come out and a couple of the appetizers were a miss but I still highly recommend checking out Prato. read more

See all

Upscale, rustic feel, with traditional Italian flair. Located in downtown Winter Park. We walked in on a weekday evening and were seated immediately. The atmosphere is slinky, intimate, and refined, fashioned with stylish accents all throughout. Our server, Manny, was fantastic. So knowledgeable and accommodating. HAMACHI CRUDO: So fresh & flavorful. Loved the pomegranate. One of the best hamachi crudo dishes I've had :D OAK ROASTED BUTTERNUT SQUASH SOUP: Perfect for a winter evening! Their spices really bring out a depth of flavor from the squash. SPINACH & SORANA BEAN AGNOLOTTI "DEL PLIN": Savory and sweet balanced well. Loved the bursts of freshness in each bite from the pole bean. FUNGHI PIZZA: Very... Salty... Any mushroom flavor was indiscernible from the sheer amount of salt. Not for me. After searching for a decent meal after a long flight, we were grateful Prato was open late and had no dress code lol. read more

See all

Since Prato is one of my favorite restaurants I feel like I only talk about the good. So let me talk about the bad for one second. However, just know the bad does not outweigh the good. It's just a couple of thoughts as a person who comes often. I hate where the host stand is. I'm busy nights. There's always a logjam there, which makes it uncomfortable when you're standing and trying to check in, but also uncomfortable when you're trying to leave. If you sit in that first table to the right, it's a horrible experience because people are trying to squeeze through the line and your table and the door is always open because there's not enough room for people to get inside and wait. I digress. Let's talk about the good. I don't think I've ever been to Prato and the service has been poor. Everyone who's ever helped me has done so with a smile and done so with maximum effort. This latest trip I ordered the olives, a couple of drinks and the mustard noodles Everything was fantastic read more

See all

This is my top place to take out of towners when I want to impress them with Orlando's food scene. Well, top 3 for sure, it's im-pasta-ble to choose just one ;) The whole place is a vibe, dark wood and mood lighting, floor to ceiling windows, no wonder this place is never empty. For the food, my go to are the meatballs, the arancini and the Widowmaker. I also like the squid ink mafaldine pasta, but tend to lean on the pizzas more often. Ive been on a no alcohol kick lately and tried the Apple of my Eye, and it was amazing. I thought it was a gin fizz and it tasted delicious, who knew. Life is full of pasta-bilities :) read more

See all

i enjoyed the meatballs and cocktails. need to go back to try the pasta but was underwhelmed by the menu overall. read more

Prato - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

Incredible food, the pasta was beyond my expectation. The sauce, the texture of the pasta, and the pizza was great. Service is average The look and feel of the place was rustic and great looking read more

Prato - Two bowls of pasta dishes are placed on a wooden table. The top bowl contains pasta with a tomato-based sauce and grated cheese, while the bottom bowl has pasta with a creamy sauce, possibly with mushrooms and meat, also topped with grated cheese. The setting appears to be in a restaurant or casual dining environment. - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

A Prato review. Let me start with the "Best" List: *Best Date Restaurant *Best Italian Restaurant *Best Restaurant Overall Source: Orlando Weekly 2024 I've enjoyed Prato a number of times over the years. In increasingly measure, it's become my choice for a special date night or occasion. As another Yelp Elite reviewer wrote, "If I could give a 10 out of 5 (rating), I would." I agree. After years of frequenting, I've found that reservations are the best way to ensure a day and time when I can enjoy the splendid service and fabulous food with friends and family. The restaurant is regularly packed even though ample seating is located both inside and outside. The bar "island" is the place to go between lunch and dinner. Drinks and a truncated food menu are available while table service is not. One of my food favorites is the pizza, baked in an oven visible from almost anywhere in the place and worth the wait. Diavolo and Funghi (vegetarian) regularly arrive at our table (or the bar in the tween time) and are always enjoyed. Should one not meet the restaurant's standards, we have found they will remake it and the server or manager will apologize for the delay. I've enjoyed fish ceviche, gnocchi, seasonal soups, paninis, and the Angus Beef Burger (yum), to name a few starters and main entrees. The adult beverages range from aperitif, to beers on tap and in bottles, to cocktails. Non-alcoholic drinks are also available. My wife and I have experienced top-notch service that balances between hovering and ignoring. We have always enjoyed our servers' recommendations and engagement. The playlists usually keep the mood lively. I remember a fantastic time on a Saturday afternoon with a fun 70's and 80's dance music when even the servers were singing. Recommendation: Make reservations if you want to ensure a full-service experience. The bar is good if you just want to pop in for a drink or quick bite, but be aware that you still might need to wait. read more

See all

I'm genuinely surprised I haven't written a review yet for Prato - or has it just been that long since I wrote it?! Either if this is an update or new, I must share that I love coming here. I genuinely enjoy anything I order, whether it's a go-to meatballs and diavolo pizza order or a night that calls for the seasonal ravioli and the seasonal pizza. I feel like it's actually a good value even if the prices seem like their "winter park prices". The pizzas are large enough to split and a whole pizza and an appetizer goes far with my husband and me. An honorable mention to everyone's favorite pasta, the mustard spaghettini. I crave this sometimes. It's sooo yummy. I have also enjoyed some of their lunch sandwiches. I just haven't met a dish here that I didn't enjoy! The drinks are tasty - the citriolo and the espresso martini are my FAVES. Absolutely delicious, as are the "mocktails"! I will say this is a difficult place to get a seat on a whim as it's bustling any night it's open. Which is a bummer because getting a seat at the bar is even more difficult. Reservations not required but definitely strongly recommended! read more

See all

Ambiance: The environment was super nice, Dim Lighting, more intimate space, comfortable chairs! Really appreciated how much effort they put into creating a space that was comfortable; didn't feel out of place at all. A little close to other tables but all good! Price: Valid for the portions and quality food! We got the Beef Short Rib and the Margarita Pizza, and can say that the $$$ matched the plate! Food: - The pizza-- SO good! The sauce is excellent, not too sweet not to bitter, the crust and dough tasted perfect as well. - The Beef Short Rib was tender, cooked perfectly and came with a generous amount of potato puree-- the ratio of veggies were spot on. Overall, would come again! Service was quick, we were walk ins on a Tuesday and they were able to sit us within 25 min during dinner service. Consider street parking when arriving to the restaurant. read more

Prato - Margherita Pizza - A Margherita pizza with a slightly charred crust, topped with fresh basil leaves, mozzarella cheese, and tomato sauce, is placed on a white plate on a wooden table. The table has a glass of water, an empty plate, and a small booklet or menu nearby. The background shows part of a person wearing a black and white patterned shirt and a dimly lit restaurant setting. - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

Came here for a mini celebration on a Friday night and expected it to be busy... it was. About an hour and a half wait but such is life. I will say the hostess stand tend to kind of write off any questions you may have or didn't really want to answer anything so that turned me off a bit... If I hadn't had in my mind the pasta I wanted to eat, I honestly would have left. By the time we were seated, the service turned around. Our server was sweet and super quick! Granted, it was a busy night and they want to turn tables but I did not feel rushed. As always, the food was delicious and that's what keeps me coming back! read more

Prato - A bowl of pasta topped with grated cheese and pieces of meat is placed on a wooden table. In the background, there is a plate of creamy pasta, along with glasses and utensils. The setting appears to be a restaurant dining environment. - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

If I could rate Prato a ten out of five I would do it. This place kills it every time. We come here often and have tried plenty of things on the menu. Nothing is a 'miss' although I do have faves! Their pasta is ALWAYS on point and made fresh. The service is impeccable, and we have never had a server that wasn't great. My personal fave is Spaghettini if you need a recommendation. Solid drink / bar offerings as well - try a specialty cocktail or ask for a wine pairing with your meal. They have a rustic feel to the inside and a patio for when the weather is nice. Dogs are allowed on outside patio as well! Overall: A++ Make a reservation. Hit them up for pasta. Get a drink. Enjoy! read more

See all

My husband and I decided to spend our anniversary having lunch at Prato. We both had been there before and love it so much that decided to come back for our special day. We started with some meatballs, which are the best I've ever had! For our entrees, we shared a chicken Milanessa and Cacio e Pepe. Everything was really good! We shared all three plates and were full and even had some leftovers to go. Customer service was a little slow since we had to wait 30 minutes after we got the appetizer (meatballs) to get our plates. It was on a Sunday at lunch time and very busy and loud so I guess that just how it is on Sundays. Other than that everything was great and we will definitely be back on another occasion. read more

See all

I love Prato. We didn't eat this time around but absolutely love their pizzas. Bartenders are always friendly and quick even when super busy! It's loud but not overbearing on a rainy Sunday. read more

Prato - Latte. - A latte with foam art is presented in a red ceramic cup featuring a white swan logo. The cup is placed on a matching saucer on a wooden table, with menus and a glass of water visible in the background, indicating a dining setting. - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

Love this place! I have been eating at Prato for a few years now and it always hits the spot. I love going to a place where I am guaranteed the same good and tasty quality of food, every time. I popped in again recently because they finally have their fall Butternut squash soup that I have been obsessed with forever. If you get a chance to try it, you'll know why. The service is always top tier and the servers go above and beyond making recommendations and making sure you have a smooth experience. I love coming here for birthdays or solo date nights out. read more

Prato is one of my favorite authentic Italian restaurant to visit in Winter Park. I had a taste for pizza, so I decided to do a walk in and enjoy. My wait time was about 10 minutes so not too bad on a Friday evening. My server came over within minutes, greeted me and took my order. My pizza came out within 20 minutes. As busy as it was, it wasn't too bad of a wait time which was nice. The restaurant lights are very dim, but is a nice atmosphere for date night, ladies night out or an overall good time. My pizza was a 10/10!! Definitely recommend. read more

See all

I will never stop screaming the praises of Prato. Every visit is consistently delicious and service is always fast and friendly. The ambiance is perfect for a date night or a night out with the girls. The best part? The prices are insanely reasonable for such a nice spot with such amazing and well presented dishes. My must visit for anyone who asks! read more

See all