I walked into the Tinder Box with literally ZERO knowledge about cigars, but was looking for a wedding gift. The staff gathered the details of the gift intention and broke down all the considerations from mildness to country of origin and how to trim the cigar for use and how to enjoy. I ended up buying six individual El Rey Del Mundo cigars that they encased in a separate cigar box and loaded it with matchboxes and included the cap cutter. I had such a lovely experience and hope my family enjoys the tradition of celebrating the joining of families with a cigar! read more

Tinder Box Buffalo - Cigars and complimentary matchboxes and a cap cutter - Tobacco Shops Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I was greeted upon arrival walking in and was immediately helped with finding the cigars I wanted. Large selection of sticks. Beautiful lounge that is spacious with at least 4 large TVs. read more

Tinder Box Buffalo - My Father Cigar - Tobacco Shops Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

This is my home cigar lounge and supplier. I have been coming here most of my adult cigar smoking life. I truly enjoy the family atmosphere they have provided me. I've bought everything from humidors to tobacco pipes to your common cheap accessories here. They've always been beyond helpful in every way. Prices are very fair and the staff is extremely knowledgeable. They go out of their way to make sure you leave with what you want. They've also been beyond helpful with any issues that Ive experienced whether it was with a bad cigar or defective accessory. I can't say enough how much I appreciate the people here. Top notch. Thank you! read more

Good selection but the prices are pretty high. I will continue to visit a few other places in the area and see how they compare. Nice staff and very helpful. No problem parking at all. read more

"Life is too short to date ugly women and smoke cheap cigars." -My Uncle *********************************************** Find me here on a relaxed afternoon sitting with a friend in one of the many leather chairs or perusing their great selection of cigars, pipe tobacco, and specialty cigarettes. If you're an occasional smoker, the guys who work here are always happy to help you find something you'll like. In accessories, they sell a variety of humidors and lighters. I always like that there is a congregation of regulars in the back room talking or watching hockey on the television. The back part of the store has about eight nice leather chairs - you sit with cigars surrounding you on all four walls. The selection is vast, the customer-service nice (in a gentlemanly way, of course), and the atmosphere is as a cigar lounge should be. In addition to the aforementioned qualities, I give Tinder Box five stars because it fills a much-needed void in a culture traditionally lacking in places for men to get away and relax together. read more

Tinder Box Buffalo - A typical afternoon for me here. Catching up with a friend. - Tobacco Shops Near Me - Buffalo, New York

Spent $50 on their most expensive Padron. It smoked like a $3 cigar- absolutely terrible, when I told the person who helped me purchase it he shrugged his shoulders and blamed the high price on tax. Instead of refunding my purchase and helping me pick something that would smoke decently not like an ashtray of grey flavor. Padron has lowered the bar but continues to sell at premium prices. Total shit. I left it after 1/4 of the way smoked. read more

My husband loves to come in on occation to enjoy a cigar or a pipe. We have a small collection of pipes and have bought several of them here. They have a pretty good selection of pipe tabacco and a very large selection of cigars. There is a nice little lounge in the back with a TV and comfortable selection of chairs to sit, relax and enjoy a tabacco product with a drink. It is great, now that we live down the street, to come and have a cigar a few times a year and wonder the store. They have a very nice collection of humidors up front and even sell cigarettes and cloves. I really love the smell of the place, earthy and sweet. If you enjoy smoking and like a nice cozy atmosphere with a nice group of people this place is for you. read more

Tinder Box Buffalo - Aaron enjoying his favorite pipe. - Tobacco Shops Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I usually preface my reviews of cigar shops/ lounges with a exposé regarding heritage, calmness, and urbanity. The tinder box encompasses all of those aspects of the craft that is cigar making and smoking; yet they do so without being brazen. Their ancestry to cigars is not overt; their awards and family photos are tucked away in the back hallway, rather than showed-off in the front of the shop. The tinder box does not boast or brag, or attempt to impress. Their inventory, hospitality and knowledge speaks for itself. The selection is VERY plentiful and houses a variety across the spectrum of cost, flavor, and strength. Prices are competitive. But their location draws in a clientele that can afford paying $11-18 for moderate-end cigars. The lounge is innovative, considering the fact that they are in a busy plaza on transit that probably costs a lot of overhead. The space is narrow and deep. It's not cramped, but it's not spacious. If at full capacity, you're essentially sitting side by side a bunch of grown men, like waiting in an airport terminal. There's complimentary coffee and water. Yet seconds cost and additional $1 (which I honestly feel is unnecessary), other places in the area have snacks and unlimited drinks. Overall, I like it and would go if you're in the area. Buffalo cigars is opening a new location downtown on Main Street which I would check out in addition to their Orchard Park location. read more

A nice place. Good selection. Got a great price on a very nice humidor. The seating is a little close but overall a very good experience. Have been there for some hand rolled events and always had a great time. read more

Have had a great experience at the tinderbox for 20 years. Always friendly and a great experience. Today I forgot my gift card (frustratingly the second time). Same guy at counter. Looked at me and said "How f"'ckn stupid are you?" I said I didnt appreciate that and he said it's like a bar environment in there. I left. (When I called after I spoke to a nice guy named James. He said the guy was the owner. D'oh! read more

Huh? Am I really the first person to review Tinder Box? People, life is too short to deny yourself the pleasure of a fine cigar. You can't take the money with you to Heaven, and if you're fortunate enough to live in the area off of Transit Road where Tinder Box is located, when you pass on the Federales are going to yank a good chunk of your millions anyway. Step it up!!! Tinder Box is located in a small storefront in the Lowe's Plaza close to Maple Road. It is a chain shop, yes, okay, I know that, but they are fully stocked with humidors, lighters, cutters and other accessories in addition to the cigars. Oh, and they possess a very good selection of sticks. Rocky Patel, Padron, Ashton, Arturo Fuente, CAO, Romeo y Julieta, so on and so forth. Of course, when I sought out my Rocky Patel 1961s they were all out!! Oh well. Life's tough - wear a helmet. The staff is very accommodating. It doesn't have to be an intimidating experience to roll in and see all of the choices. You will receive friendly advice and help when selecting your smoke. Inside you will also find a bunch of chairs and a television, so you can sit down and enjoy your cigar while pretending to be away looking for something at Lowe's. BONUS. I saw a handful of gentlemen in the shop doing exactly that. Yeah, definitely, if you are on Transit for some reason and feel like enjoying one of the best things life has to offer then stop at Tinder Box. It's one of the better shops around. read more

Great customer service. Staff was very helpful. They introduced me to a new cigar line. It was a great stick. They just need better ventilation. If its a packed house the lingering smoke does interfer with you cigar of choice. read more

Tinder Box Buffalo - excellent picks by staff. We loved the selection. - Tobacco Shops Near Me - Buffalo, New York

I'll join you in reviewing this place, happily, Jason! I'm surprised there aren't more reviews here, as I know many people who enjoy a good cigar from here. I came here for the first time, in late 90's for a celebratory party for RealAmherst.com, back when blogging was new and exciting. We sat in the back and I just thought it was cool people could come and enjoy a smoke here. The staff is extremely helpful, knowledgable and they really know their customers and what they like. My husband was frequenting this place for a while, and would quite often send me to fetch him a cigar to enjoy after a long stint at the restaurant he manages. (What is this 1950?!) I rather enjoyed doing that favor for him especially since I'd spend more time chatting with the fellas there than it took for them to grab his Gloria Cubana or Romeo and Juliet. I'd never remember what cigar Michael would want, but these guys always knew exactly which kind. I think their prices are reasonable and they have a selection of "factory throwaways" for those who are not too choosy, for only a couple bucks a piece. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, I always feel like I'm walking into someone's living room. As a regular, I've also enjoyed perks like an occasional free lighter or extra couple cigars, just because. I'm all about personal relationships with businesses, and I feel like I'm part of their family. They'll have special events with trays if food, and I've always been invited to grab a bite to eat! Anyways, Michael gave up cigars recently (yay lungs! Boo trips to tinder box!) but definitely recommend smokers to go here and will go back gladly, anytime. Jim, Jason, Vince, Gary....miss these guys!! They know their stuff. If you like stogies, or know someone who does, go to Tinder Box! read more

Awesome cigar place ! I walked in , having never bought a cigar in my life and needed to purchase some as a gift for a relative. I was greeted immediately, he asked for my budget and then showed me some wonderful options. He even offered to gift wrap it for free and let me use a coupon from yelp! Wonderful service and staff, would highly recommend. read more

This is one of those truly epic smoke shops, I love the atmosphere here. The employee's make you feel welcome and know their stuff when it comes to helping you choose the right tobacco product. Now I'm an occasional pipe smoker (again), and love a good cigar, and I love the fact that I can purchase a decent cigar in the range of 5 (for the discontinued stock) to 9 dollars or purchase an ounce of really good pipe tobacco for very little. They do have a large selection of pipe tobacco's to choose from all are moist and aromatic. The chairs here are comfortable and you can purchase drinks on site. This is my go to place for my aficionado fix. read more

I don't know much about cigars, so when I've been here I'm usually pretty lost. I have a few family members that love cigars so I've been to Tinder Box a few times to look for gifts. Whenever I go the staff has always been very helpful. Whether I need cigars or some sort of accessories, they are always happy to assist me in finding what I need and answering my questions. This is my go-to place for cigar gifts. Plus, they have a check-in offer on Yelp for 10% off your purchase! read more

Full disclosure: I am not a cigar smoker nor a fan of any kind of smoking. BUT a loved one is so in I went. It was evening and in the lounge area at the back of the store were several men in comfy chairs, smoking cigars and visiting, chatting about whatever manly men do in a cigar shop. I stopped in for a humidor (which I know nothing about) and one of the associates came up to assist. After a bit I selected a humidor, but noticed it had a blemish, and it was the last one. I then chose my second choice, still a nice humidor (I'm told) and in cashing out, I was given 10% off as a goodwill gesture. I'm so glad I shopped local, it would have been so easy to go online for the purchase, but I did want to see it and learn a little about the product. The gentlemen continued to enjoy their cigars and it reminded me of the yarn shop social circle with ladies congregating in a knitting circle, or Steel Magnolias at the beauty parlor. Only difference is the knitters don't have to go home and do a double hair wash because they smell like smoke! read more

I'm a big fan of this place. Great selection. Very nice lounge with water and coffee. Friendly staff.

Walked in and immediately felt out of place. The guy behind the counter did acknowledge us or ask if he could help us. Back room full of old grumpy mean. However, lots of cigar selections! Just a weird environment read more

Vince was fantastic in helping us find something special. This place is nice, clean, extremely affordable, and has a great selection. Definitely a place we will frequent! read more

This is my favorite cigar shop in Buffalo. Amazing selection of well-kept cigars along with an extremely knowledgeable staff. There is a great crew of guys that hang out here at night that welcomed me to the shop like I was a 10-year friend. While I try and sample some of the newer shops in the area, the Tinder Box is always my go to for premium cigars. Do yourself a favor and stop in! read more

I have always enjoyed shopping here for many years. It is on my list to stop at when I'm in Buffalo. Great cigars and great prices. Jim is a real gentleman! I wish I lived in Buffalo, I would be a regular. read more

The last two times I've been to Tinderbox, two different employees who were cashing me out repeatedly touched the head of my cigars as they were scanning them and placing them in the bag. I thought this reflected a lack of cigar etiquette. The top of the cigar is what goes in the mouth, and I don't appreciate another person's hands/fingers to be all over that part. I left the shop rather yucked out. read more

I was having some work done on my vehicle and walked down the street to go here because it's somewhere I've always wanted to check out. Not my first time in a Tinder Box, but my first time in this one. They have a very very good selection of cigars, pipe tobacco and pipes and of course cigarettes like Dunhill and Sherman's. I had gone in there to buy a pack of Dunhill's, but after looking around I decided since I had some time I would pick out a cigar. After looking at offers from Punch, Upmann, Montecristo, Cohiba & other manufacturers, I chose a Macanudo Court. The cigar was very fresh and aromatic. I sat down in one of the leather chairs and listened to and talked with the few others in the seating area. Unfortunately my vehicle was ready sooner than I expected, and I had to get to a meeting so my visit was cut short. The price selection was very good, no matter what you want to spend, you won't be disappointed in the selection offered. There were no cigar snobs here either, which is a huge plus, and the staff is very helpful and doesn't talk down to you, like they do at other cigar lounges. By all means, give them a try, if you've got a question, ask them. They'll be very helpful. Two thumbs up Tinder Box, you really have created a great place. read more

This place rocks a good group of guys to smoke cigars with. The owner was great he had lot of stories to tell about cigars. The night crew well let's just say those guys no how to live and smoke a good cigar. The one guy who offered me a drink from his homemade stash who by the way carries a gun he had me cracking up. The book that one patron wrote about the place I had a chance to read online while I was there it's worth the money. If you are in town even for a short time check them out you won't be disappointed. read more

I am from Toronto canada... Coming down to buffalo I had no clue where to find cigars or a nice cigar store around. (Other then what they offer at duty free.)I checked up on yelp and found this diamond in the ruff!! I had an excellent experience here and will definitely return on my next venture to buffalo. Hopefully on my next visit I will be able to take advantage of the lounge they offer. I recommended this place to any fellow Canadians who are visiting. Great selection and a large selection to choose from. I kind of wish we had a place like this back at home. read more

Love this place. The guys here we very helpful and eager to answer all questions. Need to come here to relax

Great spot! Very knowledgable and friendly staff. The best selection of cigars in WNY.