Tikal

Great food and service within a nostalgic atmosphere. Whenever I am in Greenport, I will make sure…read moreto stop in for a sumptuous breakfast or lunch.

After having visited and thoroughly enjoyed the Stony Brook location multiple times, this was a…read morehighly disappointing experience. Popped in for a quick weekend lunch since they had visibly open tables and we were seated right away. The person who showed us to our table led the way, and then dropped menus and utensils in a booth and kept walking. As soon as we made our way through the small restaurant, the absolute filth of the place was the only thing I could focus on. There were food scraps and garbage littering almost every surface of the floor. Our own table had dirty napkins, crumbs and half spilled sugar packets underneath, and the bench needed a wipe down before I could sit. Condiments on the table were dirty and if you moved them, the table was covered with crumbs underneath so no one is moving the condiments to clean. The bathroom was equally disgusting and unkempt. Despite all signs pointing to that we should've left immediately, we were hungry and had been driving for awhile. The food/drink was nothing like the other locations we've visited. In my 20 years of ordering Mimosas, I have never before been asked if I wanted a single or a double. It's prosecco, not shots. I went for the single because my expectations were low, and was presented with a weird little lowball glass of pineapple juice and a jigger of prosecco. That is completely ridiculous to cut a serving in half and call it a "single". For $12 you can buy an entire decent bottle of prosecco, and probably at least three bottles of whatever cheap they're serving. It feels like a cheat not to get a full serving. I ordered the Bootlegger for my meal which is fried chicken, melted cheese, bacon and Russian dressing on a roll. It arrived on a tiny hamburger bun with no dressing. Our server came once to ask how everything was the moment the plates were set down, and left when I told her I hadn't tried it yet. It then took about 10 minutes to obtain a side of dressing once I noticed my sandwich was dry. It was edible, but definitely not worth ever having again. My husband ordered corned beef hash and eggs, which was a plate filled with boxed potato sprinkled with pieces of corned beef. Eggs were fine. We did not use any of the condiments since it was clear they hadn't been swapped out or cleaned, and really tried to get out of this dirty environment as fast as possible. Servers were all concentrated in the bar area, some on phones clearly not busy...so it makes one wonder why no one thought to sweep the floor or wipe down a table. The state of the dining room was truly disgusting and honestly surprising. Our server barely attended to us so we opted not to bring this complaint to her directly and judging by the demeanor of the other staff, there wasn't a manger on duty. The bigger problem here is that if the public-facing front of house can look that way, I can only imagine how the kitchen is kept. We will never return to this location and sincerely hope it can be brought up to the same standards as the others.

Poached Egg on Multigrain

See all

Inside

Nookies

4.7(27 reviews)

1.0 mi

My husband and I were looking for breakfast while visiting the vineyards and Nookies did not…read moredisappoint!! The shakshuka was perfection and i had the bacon egg and cheese on a deliciously flaky biscuit. They also grow their own oysters and make delicious oyster chowder. This whole menu was delectable. We sat at the counter and watched as the skilled chef cooked each meal. It was cool to see. The restaurant is cute and small. The best breakfast spot in the area!

Off the beaten path, this elevated diner will transport you back to a time in history. Located at…read morethe Silver Sands Hotel, this clean, restored and small restaurant offers breakfast, lunch and dinner. The small menu offers meals inspired by classic diner items though elevated and modern. Impeccable service as well! Eat at the counter to watch the dishes being prepared!

Entrance

Shaved celeriac salad with hazelnut, pickled fennel, and goat gouda at Nookies at Silver Sands in Greenport

See all

Josh's rice pudding with grenadine plums and puffed wild rice at Nookies at Silver Sands in Greenport

Pip’s Cafe and Provisions

4.6(16 reviews)

Cozy little spot where my friends and I picked up some provisions before heading to the wineries…read more My sesame chicken salad was $17 but had more delicious chicken than one would expect. A friend's squash sandwich also got rave reviews. I'll be back.

We received this recommendation as a place to visit when coming to Greenport and I must say it's a…read moreMUST. We came twice during our trip. It's a cute upscale bakery/eatery. The vibes are immaculate. The staff are very friendly and welcoming. I got the chai tea latte, lemon poppyseed scone, and the avocado toast with bacon. OMG. Everything is a 10/10. The chai is perfect. Not too sweet but still very spiced forward. The scone was not too dry and all the right amount of sweetness. The avocado toast is to die for. The avocado is perfectly ripped, the jammy egg has me questioning my egg making skills, and the chili crisp adds a nice kick without it being overpowering. The bacon I added add an extra layer of protein, which was perfectly cooked. My friends got a ham and cheese croissant, which I tasted and wished I got one to go. Overall, this is an outstanding place for bites that are filling and delicious. I can't wait to try their lunch goodies!!

Cozy interior of Pip's Cafe & Provisions in Greenport on the North Fork of Long Island.

Pip’s Cafe and Provisions - The Ham Toastie--pressed sandwich with Black Forest ham, house-made apple jam, and cultured butter on house-baked demi ciabatta

The Ham Toastie--pressed sandwich with Black Forest ham, house-made apple jam, and cultured butter on house-baked demi ciabatta

See all

Blueberry Muffin

Goldberg's Famous Bagels

4.2(60 reviews)

Terrific bagels. Properly twisted. Good sandwiches, too. They even have flagels, which I love.read more

My first visit to Long Island! On a March morning, we landed off the ferry and immediately needed…read morebreakfast. Parking downtown was very easy. At 8am on off season, there wasn't anyone in sight. They had a huge menu inside. It was a tough choice but we decided for the Spicy Hobo and Bacon, Egg and Cheese both on salt bagels. I feel like I never get to see salt bagels anymore so it was an easy choice. I also saw the cucumber dill smear and I am OBSESSED with anything dill so I also ordered a pumpernickel with the cucumber dill as a later treat. So we ate the breakfast sandwiches fresh. Absolutely loved them. And the salt bagels were generously salted, boy was I thirsty haha Spicy Hobo has a hash brown inside and that was amazing. I ate the pumpernickel cucumber dill hours later and it held really well on the car ride. Overall, would go back!

Flat garlic bagel with Turkey bacon egg & cheese

See all

North Fork Roasting

4.5(146 reviews)

4.0 mi

Just the best place on the north fork. The food, the coffee, and the vibes never disappoint.read more

Amazing service. Very cute little shop in this town. I got a chai and my mom got a drip. The coffee…read moreis fresh and tasty.

Brunch breakfast sandwich

See all

Lavender latte

Sterlington Deli

4.7(131 reviews)

•$

Delicious sandwiches right by the North ferry. Service was friendly and fast and our sandwiches…read morewere made fresh at the counter. My hot pastrami sub sandwich (The Orient) was absolutely delicious and the perfect filling lunch for a day on the road. I'd definitely come back again to try another of their many sandwich options!

We had breakfast catered on shelter Island the morning of my sons wedding . Everything was…read moreperfect!! Easy to work with! ordered and set up beautifully and right on time! Delicious food and crunchy bacon. No one else I would ever call. would Highly recommend for delicious food and wonderful catering !!!!! Shout out to Owen!!

See all

Aldos Coffee

4.1(235 reviews)

0.0 mi

Locally owned & operated

Outdoor seating

bought my coffee beans and shared the best gelato and most chocolatey mocha with my husband…read more coffee heaven indeed

I work all over the east end of Long Island. I'll go through Greenport maybe half a dozen times a…read moreyear, but I haven't actually stopped in Greenport in years. So tonight I wrapped things up in Greenport and I really wanted to stop and try Aldos. I'm so glad I did. Espresso is my coffee of choice, especially as an Americano, and Aldos espresso is oh so good! Pair that with a nicely decorated store, super chill music and a killer view of the water and I was instantly in love. I didn't have any baked treats, definitely next time, as this will be a go to spot for now on. I am sure you'll like it too. I'm placing this in my top five spots with a solid tie for spot number two! Last but not least, I have to say the staff was super friendly and not pushy at all, I know I came in late maybe 45 minutes before closing, but they treated me as nice as if they just opened. Great job! Edit: Forgot to mention I grabbed a pound of espresso for home. Cant wait to grind some up!

See all

Bruce & Son

3.7(347 reviews)

In honor of what would have been my mom's 71st birthday, I went to one of her beloved landmarks in…read moreGreenport, or at least, it's current iteration- Bruce and Son. Twenty five years ago it was still Bruce's Café, aka Cheese Emporium, and I remember many a happy visit there with my mom and brother, for muffins, for scones, for cheeses, for brunches, and for the wonderful people who worked there. The bakery-style counter of muffins and scones is gone, and it's quite a different look these days, but the meals served by a new xrew of wonderful people lives up to the legacy granted in my memories. Ok, after that extended intro, let me tell you what we all ordered. I got the carrot "lox" sandwich, and I was truly surprised by how convincing the vegan lox was - before becoming a vegetarian I loved lox, and though the texture was a bit different (more tender than chewy) the taste was startling close. The fried egg was perfectly done and all the fixings - the whipped cream cheese, capers, dill - were excellent. DEVOURED. My dad is very old school and kind of didn't know what to do when he saw the menu, so knowing his tastes, I recommended the Savory Oats, and he was astonished with the dish he received. He all but licked the plate clean. My dad's girlfriend ordered the cheeseburger with the addition of bacon, and not only did they perfectly cook the burger to her preferences, the whole thing was as beautiful as it looked (if I wasn't a vegetarian). I think she may have left a lonely pickle slice or two on her plate. The girlfriend and I also both ordered the iced version of the "pep talk" beverage. It was a LITTLE sweeter than I would prefer and I would have liked a stronger fennel presence, but she adored it just as it was, so I was glad to have given her the idea. The service, from the host at the register, to the server who took our order and the additional staff who bussed the table, was excellent. It was a busy summer Friday and I was a bit worried because I was time-restricted thanks to needing to catch a train, but they were efficient and cordial while keeping the vibe laid-back in a way that seemed effortless (which I'm very sure it wasn't). The current prices might make it so that I couldn't patronize this establishmrnt as often as I did with Bruce's Café, but everything is so good and it has such a classy, elevated feel, it is worth every penny. Thank you to Bruce and Son and its wonderful staff for letting me experience both a lovely meal wrapped in bittersweet bittersweetly cozy memories.

Convenient stop for breakfast or lunch, or even just a cup of coffee while in Greenport…read more Indoor and outdoor tables. Friendly, polite service. Great choice for a light and casual meal.

Squash and labneh with sunny egg

See all

Ramp grilled cheese with tomato dipping sauce. incredible.

Kyle's

4.4(34 reviews)

2.7 mi

Kyle has a variety of breakfast options and other culinary options such as wings and quesadillas…read more She cooks like you're in her own home,...made with love

This is a much needed GEM on Shelter Island. From the moment we walked through the main dining…read morearea; to sit on the outdoor porch we were happy. The atmosphere both inside and out are genuine in soulfulness and charm. It is a wonderful place to spend time in and have a delicious meal. We went for brunch and were knocked out by the French Toast with Peaches and Blueberries ;and the "everything but the Bagel" offerings. Crazy deliciousness. We are headed back. Thank you Kyle.

Pecan shortbread chocolate drizzled barquettes

Front porch and back deck dining

See all

Pecan shortbread chocolate drizzled barquettes

Country Corner Cafe

4.2(93 reviews)

4.0 mi

Country Corner Cafe is a neighborhood spot filled with all the locals. We dined there for an early…read moreSunday dinner before leaving town, and it was nice to see their staff so acquainted with the patrons. Pancakes, omelettes, eggs bennie, burgers, soups and other cafe (or diner) classics round out their menu. And ice cream! Ice cream seems to be a big deal there; my beau even ordered a malt shake at 9am.

Ambiance (4/5): The restaurant is located *behind* North Fork Roasting Co. which had live music…read moreperforming on a Saturday. Due to our party size and our dog, we sat outside near the back parking, which had abandoned-looking seating (broken, dirty, etc.). However, it was shaded and you could hear the music next door. There's also 3 two-person tables near the entrance outside around the corner. The inside is retro and feels like you're dining inside a cozy house and an ice cream bar (Hershey's brand). It felt bustling as a standard diner on a weekend. Service (5/5): When we were walking toward the exterior back, the people outside near side entrance, had warned us that the service was abysmal. We loitered near the corner to let the waitress know we were wanting to get seated in the back (basically away from sight). Once seated, she came back and wiped down the dirty tables (which I'm sure no one usually opts to sit at due to their state). We immediately placed our orders before she went away. I think by doing so, our food came out lightning fast. She also came to check in on us twice throughout our dining. Sausage & Cheddar Flatbread Scramble (3/5): Expect an omelet on a piece of flatbread. The bread did not taste very good (perhaps store bought?) The home fries were deliciously crunchy. Breakfast Burrito (3/5): Nothing really stood out about the burrito. Croissant French toast (3/5): I liked how it wasn't too sweet with the filled cream but it felt like it was missing something. The addition of the table maple syrup definitely helped. I think next time, I would opt for the regular French toast.