This is a cool place!! We had a short wait, which we didn't mind. We were lucky enough to get a booth up front next to the roll up doors, it was a beautiful evening to people watch in Gettysburg! We ordered the Margherita (red sauce) and the four cheese (white pizza), and they did not disappoint! The crust was delicious with perfect ratio of sauce and cheeses. You can see into the kitchen and their huge wood burning ovens. They have an awesome huge bar and a game area in the back! We will definitely come back to the upper crust! read more

See all

Very disappointed. Come here on a rainy Sunday night. 7:40pm. Kitchen closed for barbecue. You are open until midnight? Waiting to see how the food is.....calamari tasty but overpriced. White pizza salty and over-garlicked. $1 for two rings of caramelized onions. Another bad value. read more

We stayed an extra day to be away from the crowd and came downtown to this place based on yelp reviews. We were seated quickly and loved the fact that we were half way between the ovens and the roll up doors in the front giving us fresh air and a great view of the street. The beer selection is decent and has some local brews. My wife ordered a drink off the menu and they made it perfectly. As for the the pizza, we ordered the gumbo. It was fantastic. T was sweet and had the heat from the andouille. We will definitely be coming back soon as we have a camper near by. Also the service was fantastic. read more

See all

Stopped by for lunch. Friendly server and accommodated an order of pizza by eliminating one of the toppings. (chili oil) The pizza is cooked in large wood burning ovens. Games and pool tables in the back. read more

Starting off by saying we visited during the Gettysburg Christmas Festival so they were very busy. That being said, the food was just okay. We had the cauliflower appetizer which was different, interesting. We had the margarita pizza, sweet and spicy pizza and the brisket pizza. They were all okay. Just fine. The building itself is very cool. They had the doors open which was pretty but it got fairly cold inside. We waited over an hour for our food, but they were crazy busy so we expected that. We also had a sangria cocktail which was tasty but pricey. read more

The Upper Crust - Cauliflower appetizer - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Very disappointed in this restaurant, we had out of town guests and it was a disappointed. Service was slow and the food for a very simple menu was extremely disappointing. Some of the food was cold and had to be microwaved. The location is nice and huge inside but very disappointed in the food and service I would definitely recommend going to one of the other good restaurants in Gettysburg. Hopefully management will change in this restaurant and it will return to a good place to eat and bring family and friends. read more

Probably not return since nothing special (average pizza, service, warehouse space. .. ) Some may go there for free games in the rear, large bar, lots of seating, Summary: ... "if COSTCO had a sports bar " read more

The food specifically the pizza and cheese steak were great. Will be going back here again.

The only thing that wasn't amazing about the restaurant was the service.Don't get me wrong, our waiter was really nice, but they took like 15 minutes to send her over. That was my only problem. The pizza was delicious. I recommend the upper crust to anybody who wants a great meal in Gettysburg! read more

A barcade... upper crust is upper awesome! Amazing selection of libations and brews! Staring at the beer case, you may get overwhelmed... decisions, decisions! The employees are extremely knowledgeable to help you make the perfect choice! The pizza ovens are works of art and sadly were done for the night when we arrived! But we will definitely try again because the menu looked tempting. We loved the casual, fun vibe of this restaurant and enjoyed our hang! Great drinks! read more

See all

The Pizza is very good. A lot of selections. Service was right on point. They have outside seating and garage doors that open up so it's just like sitting outside. Right on Route 30 in downtown Gettysburg read more

The Upper Crust - Dark Ale - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Our local go to. Kids love the free games. Only issue is they frequently close the kitchen early- before posted kitchen closing hours. Why even have kitchen hours if you're not going to follow them, so tonight we're dining down the street at La Bella because upper crust closed the kitchen 30 mins early. read more

Visiting Gettysburg for afternoon and found this location jus down from traffic circle. This Monday afternoon was not too busy and was seated immediately. No worries though, the dining area is huge. Caution with sitting at side walk seating. Traffic noise can be a little loud with windows open. We were given food menus and a drink menu which includes specialty drinks and a good list of micro brews and other popular beers. We elected to go with a Light & Bright Salad and Four Cheese w/mushroom pizza to share. Our salad was served first and had nice presentation. It had all ingredients mentioned on menu and was ok. Could have been tossed with a little more dressing. If your trying to cut calories this is the salad. Our white pizza arrived soon after which is cooked in doomed pizza oven. The crust is thin and had minimal amount of ingredients. It was cooked well. Our server was nice and checked in with us several times. read more

For one thing, this place is massive and is kind of warehouse-y but also a restaurant. I've had the pizza and salad here and also came here just for drinks before a show at the Majestic. I think it's a cool option to have in downtown Gburg but I wouldn't say it's the best I've ever had. I wish they had a few more salads and also options for gluten free people. I am not but my mom is, and so that makes it less likely for us to come here. I do think the bar area is cool and well stocked. The service from the waiters have been good but you're kind of ignored when you first enter and are at the check in stand, so that can be frustrating. I would be back for drinks but not sure about the food. read more

Would not seat us because we have 2 non service dogs!! Very upset! Their loss! I have well behaved Weimaraners

The prices are too high for the quality of food. We went on a Saturday- early afternoon. The taste was not great. And the arcade games are broken. read more

Seriously the best pizza!!! Wood fired and the crust is just all kinds of yummy!!! Oh and the brownie with peanut butter frosting?!!!! Yes please!! read more

The Upper Crust - Brownie with peanut butter frosting and vanilla ice-cream. - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

My first time trying LuLu's Finest was a highly disappointing. $17 is way too much for three scoops of "ice cream". Mr G"s is 1000 times better. read more

Went here to watch the playoffs and have some food and drinks. We have been here before and had a great time. It was a good place to enjoy a beer, food and a game. Got sat at 6:09 and didn't have anyone even come to our table until we got up and asked almost 45 minutes later. Then it took another 30 minutes for our drinks to get here after half our party had finished their meal and the other was still waiting on food. When our food was served we didn't even have plates for sharing or silverware or napkins. While through out the meal we were served our appetizers. The place was horribly understaffed for a Saturday night during the first night of round 2 playoffs. Other tables were waiting half hour for anyone to take orders as well. The saving grace was our server Amanda who had 10 other tables and had to take on more tables because the bartenders wouldn't. And then next to us was a giant party of at least 20 and the reason it took an hour for us to get two pizzas. I don't know who the manager of this place is, but they clearly have no idea how to run a restaurant. Hats off to Amanda for keeping her cool and doing her best but shame on management for putting their staff members in these predicaments. Food was good but not good enough to wait almost an hour and half for. This place has bit off more then they can chew, learn how to close sections. read more

This pizza was sooooo good! There is zero historical ambience to this restaurant so it's a funny choice if you're there for historical Gettysburg sightseeing. The service was alright and could be improved. Their women's bathroom also needs some repairs on the locks, and none of the stalls had purse hanging hooks. But that's not reason to skip this place. The food was amazing. read more

Great variety of food! Reasonable prices! Plenty of space to spread out! Games for the kids! read more

Really nice appetizers and lots of pizza options! Cauliflower was SO good I could rave on & on about it

We stopped in on Labor Day 2021. It's a MASSIVE restaurant, but I think was short-staffed on our trip so we had to wait ~15 mins. When our time came, we were seated promptly and greeted with a friendly waitress. She took our order (2 pizzas and a salad) and took it to the kitchen. Our pizzas arrived fast, with a different waitress hastily putting them on our table and dashing off without getting us flatware. It took us a bit to flag someone else down to get flatware, not to mention that the salad was a little behind the pizzas. Also dressing was on the salad even though we asked for it on the side. Pizzas were good, not the best wood-fired pizza I've ever had, but def not the worst, and a great lunch after strolling Gettysburg. The place looks like it can accommodate large groups of kids (there's an arcade in the back), but even with reduced capacity, they still seemed rushed. read more

See all

Mia was a great server. Speedy, thorough and kind! Food was delicious. Brussel sprouts on pizza = 10/10! read more

The Upper Crust - Brussels and Bacon Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

If I could give it 0 stars, I would. Where do I begin; the manager was extremely rude to my party. They were condescending and unhelpful. The bartenders were also rude and disrespectful to my party. I can not imagine a business that treats their customers in this horrible and demeaning manner. To boot, their pizza is an insult to cuisine in this country. I will not be returning to this wretched and depraved place. To the manager who was unprofessional to my party, you should be embarrassed and ashamed of your behavior. read more

Decent pizza. It seemed freshly made, but salty. The Korean chicken wings were terrible. They could kill you with so much salt. The sauce was not Korean at all. Don't order it. Waitstaff were okay. The location is nice, right in downtown area, it's nice to watch people walk by. read more

The Upper Crust - Korean chicken wings - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Amazing experience. Some free games in the back! Service was great and the food tasted amazing. Definitely worth it for the skeeball in the back. read more

The pizza was amazing, the service was fast, and we loved the free games in the back. The only problem was that one of the cups was served a little dirty but overall it was a wonderful experience. read more

So we walked in and there was no line in front of us. We watched as people haphazardly and slowly moved about with no one picking their heads up to acknowledge us. About five minutes in, someone says someone will be right with you. About five minutes after that another bee hopping around person says someone will be right with you. The third person that said this to us several minutes later I responded with "that's what we're told." Finally a gentleman in white says right this way. He slowly meanders to a table only to find it not cleaned off. He gets seemingly annoyed and proceeds to clear it off one and two items at a time. Finally we are seated. No welcoming attitude. Seemed imposed upon. Someone comes right away to take our order. We order three drinks. All three in our party have time to go to the rest room one at a time before they drinks come. We ordered pierogis and French fries with some aioli sauce. The fires have some type of red spice on them. The aioli is flavorless. The fries are all little end pieces. The pierogis literally had a half teaspoon of potato in them. read more

The Upper Crust - Pierogi with almost no filling. - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Fantastic concept from start to finish! Amazingly flavorful and satisfying pizza and appetizers. Love the entire atmosphere. The food is fresh. The menu is not overwhelming. Nice, clean flavors. Simple but well-paired apps with pizzas. Service was professional. Spot on. We are foodies. Always on the lookout for up and coming good places. Trying during covid. Can't wait to see the amazing play space with pool tables and games. We want to come back and really spend some time here with friends and family! The cocktails are fantastic. Well priced (we are used to paying much much more in NYC and #BucksCounty ) NOTE:: Please keep up on the craft beers. You were out of the seasonals. Left little to the imagination. Overall - a wonderfully fun concept to recreate in other towns hopefully- .modern simplistic clean. Please bring it to Philly metro area!!! Maybe King of Prussia! ?? KOP. Newtown !? Doylestown? So many overrated sports bars. This is a breath of fresh air in the pizza bar scene. Absolutely LOVE. You guys need to expand. You're needed! read more

The Upper Crust - Margherita pizza. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

We had the arugula pizza and cheeseburger pizza, both were yummy with arugula the best. Also Korean wings for our appetizer. Service was very good. read more

The Upper Crust - Cheeseburger pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Pizza is decent, light on taste byt crust was good. Service is way below average. On a slow night, will not split checks (lazy staff), didn't bring basics (silver, napkins, parm/peppers), never came back to refill drinks...charged us 20% tip. (20% is fine when server is not lazy) read more

I finally visited this location. Living in Gettysburg for 30 plus years and watching the evolution of this location from a Moose Club to a pizza restaurant. I was very please with my recent visit. I was able to be seated up front with the "garage door windows " up seating. My waiter was very professional and was attentive to my ordering. When I visited as I planned was their off hours (3pm) which also made my visit even more enjoyable. I ordered their Gumbo pizza and it was great .... A little lacking on the amount of shrimp. But it was a great pizza and I would order again. I would like to congratulate the owner on such a fine establishment and how professionaly the restaurant was created. If you are looking for gourmet pizza.... this is the location. read more

First time in Gettysburg and first time at Upper Crust Service was great and the personal pizza very good.. Place is huge so seating is not an issue... and it has an arcade! read more

The pineapple pizza is worth the burn! What a fun place. Large garage doors mean that even on a warm October evening you feel like you are dining al fresco! Service was fast and friendly. The space is gorgeous-hand tiled pizza ovens and all done in calming shades of green. Lots of craft beer selections and the pizzas are swoon worthy! Think crispy crust and inventive toppings. They will take the meat off of any pizza if you are a vegetarian like me! Highly recommend if you are in the area. read more

As one of the only "late-night" bars in the area, the Upper Crust has the potential to be great--operative word being 'potential'. Being a native New Yorker visiting the New Oxford/Gettysburg area, I was excited by the prospect of visiting a cool, local bar to watch the World Series. Sadly, the terrible customer service left me disappointed and dismayed. While I understand the stresses bartenders face when slammed, it doesn't justify nasty attitudes towards polite patrons. Of the 4 or so employees I interacted with, only one of them treated me with any semblance of kindness; sadly, her shift ended shortly after my arrival. I suppose locals will put up with this since they don't have the luxury of other options, but they'll never get my business again. Food is ~3/5 with an honorable mention to the pierogis (although I wish there were an option to order them boiled). Do what you will with this information read more

I called the owner/ manager twice today but no response. My son got food poisoning from dinner last night and was violenting throwing up Post dinner. I made 2 attempts to call the resturant to report the issue and food type so nobody else would get I'll.....no response 1/3 Update: Thr site manager contacted me today and was very attentive. He assured me he was going to perform a through investigation to ensure he is operating a safe kitchen. No other instances were reported but was genuinely concerned and very professional. read more

A friend and I were needing lunch, so we popped in here. Plenty of seating, lots of pizza ovens with PILES of wood stacked neatly throughout. Once inside, you smell the pizza ovens cooking... and you leave with that smell stuck to your clothes. The employees seemed overwhelmed (even though it wasn't a busy time). Our waitress neglected us, and wasn't friendly at all. The happiest any employee looked was when we were leaving. The menu is simple: pizza. There are 2 sandwiches available, 1 salad, and a few appetizers. My friend ordered a pizza, and it looked yummy. Unfortunately, I can't eat gluten, so that limited me to... a salad and fries. The salad was so-so; not really tasty, and also not filling. The fries were fine. If you have food allergies or sensitivities, then you'd be better off going elsewhere. Before I left, I used their restroom which is in the back of the restaurant... and I passed by an area with skee-ball and some other games. FUN! While I was in the restroom, all I could hear was the THUMP, THUMP, THUMP of the skee-balls... which made me realize how glad I was that that part of the restaurant was so far from the front of the restaurant where I couldn't hear any of that! read more

Food was average. Service was not the greatest. Slow. Felt like we overpaid for food and ambience!

Kris the server. She was amazing and very helpful. Just top notch food and service 200% recommend.