So, we love the Upper Crust, we frequently stopp in for lunch however not a good experience this time. The service was absolutely terrible, and I don't name drop with bad reviews. Walked in on the July 4th holiday Monday, not very busy and they did have at least 8 servers that I counted. We ordered 2 pizzas and my wife ordered the pulled pork sandwich. The pizzas came ahead of my wife's sandwich, I asked for crushed red peppers and parmeasian cheese. Well, minutes went by and still no peppers or cheese so I grabbed another server asking for it and it came in a timely fashion. 15 minutes after we got our pizza my wife's sandwich came and she ordered it with extra sauce on the side. Not only did it come with no sauce on the side it came dry without the sauce on the sandwich that's supposed to come on it. So she waited almost 8 minutes for someone to bring sauce so at this point my wife didn't want the sandwich and declined it. And note they did remove it from the check. The pizza is always good here and today was no different, nice lite Crust with good crunch and chew with the perfect amount of sauce and topping. We asked for a box for the pizza we couldn't eat and we were brought these tiny plastic containers that one slice of pizza couldn't ever fit in but we got that situation corrected easily. Listen, I get it, people do have bad days, I'm not unreasonable or a jerk customer, but when you pay to eat out you expect certain things and they fell way short today but we will be back hopefully with better service. Let me add that we are over tippers, usually 25% or better but remember what TIPS stand for- T- To I- Insure P- Proper S- Service read more

See all

staff extremely unprofessional missing food 40+ minutes for 3 12 inch pizzas poor attitude from cook as if he had nothing to do with why we only got 2 of our 3 pizza read more

We stopped in for dinner on a Wednesday night. Service was prompt and friendly. Our server Emma was very kind. The food was really subpar. My husband got the Korean wings, which he'd typically like but didn't even eat one full one. I ordered us a plain cheese pizza to split. It took a while because apparently the first one caught on fire in the oven and they needed to make another. Well, almost wish we got the charred one because the pizza we did get had the floppiest crust imaginable. I think if the crust was more well done, it would have been better since the flavor itself wasn't bad. I do wish we had more napkins though because either the grease or the EVOO they top the pizza with falls right off with our thin the crust is. Probably contributed to it being soggy. The other note is the bathrooms. Gettysburg in general always impresses me with how clean everything is outside and inside the businesses but this bathroom was rough. It reminded me of a college bar bathroom. Wet, dirty floor. I'm not a very large person, but I am a little pregnant and trying to comfortable fit in the first two stalls was claustrophobic. I had to use the large, handicapped stall which I avoid as I do not need the ADA accommodation. If they can figure out the pizza situation and tidy up the bathrooms, I'd probably go back and maybe just try another appetizer instead of the wings. read more

Came here with a group of people. Ordered. Food was wrong or never came. When food arrived it was cold. The manager was supposed to come over but never did. They're short staffed so they shouldn't have such a big seating area. Maybe scale back the seating so things will run smoother. read more

Pricier than most of the restaurants I've tried in the area but a solid choice for those that like wood-fired pizzas. Good selection of both red and white pies, as well as a sandwich list and a barbecue menu (on behalf of Borough BBQ). The service was quick and there was no wait on a Saturday night considering the building is massive. read more

The Upper Crust - The pepperoni with arugula, the pulled pork, old fashioned, and margarita - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

The pizza crust is remarkable with perfect texture and chew, but lacks originality. The service was fast and the servers kind. The ambience and sound in the restaurant lives up to expectations. I had mixed feelings about Fire Pit Pizza. The ambiance was cozy and the staff were friendly, but the food didn't quite live up to the hype. The pizza crust was nicely charred, but the toppings felt a bit underwhelming and lacked bold flavor. Service was decent, though our order took longer than expected for a not-so-busy night. It's a decent spot if you're nearby, but not something I'd go out of my way for. read more

Service was great and so was the pizza. Honestly the best crust and pizza I've had in a long time. Even got one to take home.

Pizza dough had no flavor. Not even salt. Looked better than it tasted. Brisket was full of fat and flavorless. Food was subpar. My expectations were high based on the ambience and how crowded it was but it was a flop, unfortunately. Sad because it's a cool place. read more

The foods great the service is excellent my wife and I really enjoy the vibe of the place. Will def be back. It's a little pricey but not bad compared to other places read more

The Upper Crust - Mac and cheese balls and beer . - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Weds night. Terrible horrible awful service. Long wait. One drink of 2 finally arrives. One entree of 3 comes out quickly. 10 minutes later - the appetizer. Then the second drink arrives (that was ordered when the first was ordered). 15 minutes later followed by a second entree. after an hour the third entree ( just a salad) arrived server took that off the check. But overall terrible experience. read more

Soggy, greasy pizza, rubbery cheese AFTER waiting 45 minutes....restaurant was less than 20% full. After chasing down our waitress she states that the computer system went down and never printed the ticket. But why did she not notice....no answer. Chef came out 5 minutes later with the second pizza, same excuse. Manager finally came over, took the pizzas off the bill. read more

I like this place. The service and food were very good. As a bonus you can also order BBQ from the adjacent restaurant. Very roomy and airy. read more

See all

This was the first time here while touring with a group. It was pizza. That's about it. It had good flavor but it was just pizza. The addition of some pool tables and games made it more exciting for our kids and I know they enjoyed the experience. read more

The Upper Crust - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

In a word: Pathetic. Feels like a tourist trap. Atmosphere is enjoyable. Music being played is good. Food is over-priced and disappointing. Games in the back need major TLC. The shuffleboard tables were unplayable. It's embarrassing to have a place of business, of this size, like this in downtown Gettysburg. read more

The food was tasty and the waitress was friendly. Service was slow as we waited about 15min before anyone came to our table to take our drink order. Food delivery took about 20-30 minutes to deliver after order. Giving three stars because waitress was very nice read more

We stopped by Uppercrust Pizza on a Saturday around 5 PM with a group of four and unfortunately had a very disappointing experience with the service. We went to the bar to order drinks and were acknowledged by one of the two bartenders, who told us, "I'll be right with you." After that, we waited for more than 20 minutes without being helped. What made it more frustrating was that the place wasn't particularly busy at the time. There were still seats available at the bar, and with two bartenders working we expected someone would circle back fairly quickly. Instead, we were left standing there the entire time without any follow-up or explanation. After waiting that long, we decided to leave. As we were walking out, a server finally said, "I can help you," but by that point it was simply too late. We ended up heading over to One Lincoln, where the experience was the complete opposite. The drinks were great and the service was prompt and attentive. It was disappointing because we were looking forward to starting our evening at Uppercrust, but the lack of attention at the bar made it hard to justify staying. read more

We had a very nice dinner here. We ordered the hummus for an appetizer and it was great. There were two kinds: one with chickpeas and the other yogurt based. Both excellent. We then had their mushroom white pizza. It was fantastic. We had ice cream for dessert that's made on site. Very good. It was quiet and comfortable. It is open to the outside and was very comfortable in late August. read more

Good service! Our waitress was very attentive. Other than that our experience was just meh. The food was alright but definitely not worth the price. Our $12 Motz sticks also came out burnt, and visibly black. It was pretty busy so we understood the wait time. I just think that for the price of the food and the quality we receive, it was not worth the wait or the money. read more

We were hungry after a trip to Hanover, and decided to stop here because it looked cool and we wanted pizza. The place is cool, kinda confusing to get to the bathroom, but cool. But the food, not cool. I had a pizza and the flavor was just kinda off. the dough was too doughy, and the cheese tasted weird. Sad because the place is cool. Service was good, just need to work on the food. read more

Not worth the money what so ever. Perogies were terrible, very small, and over priced for only coming with 4. Pizza was bare minimum as well with not much flavor. We got the sweet and spicy and did not taste either. Will not be returning. read more

A group of friends and I were looking for a place that we could all eat together and were so glad we stumbled on Upper Crust. Everywhere else was swamped, and while Upper Crust was definitely busy, it is large enough that it can accommodate a lot of tables. Our server Brendan was fantastic and attentive, and even though we were a group of at least 10 he never let any of us fall through the cracks. He even helped us get dessert even though we just missed the ordering cutoff. A few of us split the roasted cauliflower which was really delicious. Not toothsome and really well spiced. It looks a little funky but just melts in your mouth. I also got the brisket pizza which was fantastic. Really thinly sliced meat on a white pizza with a crispy crust? Perfection. They also have a ton of beer options both on tap and individually and retail. I'm not a beer drinker but some folks in the group are and really enjoyed what was available for dinner and picked up some beers to take home. Highly recommend this place! read more

The Upper Crust - Roasted cauliflower - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

We went with a party of 5. The young host was borderline rude but maybe just shy. It felt like we were imposing on his time by asking for a table. The interior of the restaurant is hard concrete, cold and loud even with a modest number of people dining (under 50%). The walls were opened up so the sound of motorcycles and trucks passing sometimes made conversation difficult. It took a long time before we were welcomed by our waitress. She was reasonably responsive after arriving but not personable. It seemed that none of the staff were enjoying their jobs or making any effort to connect with customers. The food was just okay. The portions were relatively small with very little meat. The calamari was crispy and good. The Gyro was more like a small salad in a pita with too much sauce and so little meat that it was lost in the sauce, lettuce and onions. The pizza was okay but the crust was burnt mostly black. We would not go back and would NOT recommend the Upper Crust. read more

The food is amazing and the staff is always friendly! I love the games they offer in the back of the restaurant! Its large warehouse feel is very charming and I really enjoy it there! read more

Ate there twice while visiting Gettysburg. Such good pizza that we ordered another one the first night. Just ordered 2 the second. Wait staff lovely and attentive. Kids loved the free games in back. Skeeball especially. You can also order bbq from next door, and Lulus ices cream is two doors down. Can't enough of the quality of food, staff and games. You must go there if you're in Gettysburg! read more

PROS: Nice place to come and eat. Many tvs, games in the back, staff is nice, and it's huge inside so you won't have to wait to find seating. The atmosphere is also very nice and they have a BBQ restaurant attached to it. CONS: The spicy chicken sandwich was not spicy and the plain pizza cheese did not taste all that good. Service was a tad slow and the bathroom only had one stall (for a place of that size there should be more) OVERALL: Not my first selection to go to but for a sports bar, large party, or someone wanting to play games, this would be the place to come and visit read more

See all

Got cheese fries-cheez whiz, not very good The pizza was horrible. Tasted burnt. Best atmosphere but would never go back. read more

The atmosphere is great but the pizza not so much. We ordered drinks and got a pie to go but we waited for ever and realized it was the one we saw sitting for ever and no one bothered to bring it to us. The brisket was dried up hard and stringy and there was uneven distribution of cheese and onion and sauce. I'm disappointed it wasn't better. I so wanted it to be good. We felt bad returning it and left this 20$ pizza for a homeless person on a park bench after two slices. They are also sadly understaffed (only one bartender, working her butt off) and prep staff goofing off as we noticed when not being given our pizza at the to go drop station. They also need more fans for the bar and gaming area. read more

The Upper Crust - Brisket white pizza. Uneven sauce and toppings and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

The service was excellent. The ribs were terrible. The half-rack was more like a one-fourth rack and it was burnt. My wife's pulled pork sandwich was okay, but we will not return. The portions, for the prices, were shameful. We live in Gettysburg. This place probably remains open because tourists do not have many options. read more

We have always enjoyed the food here. The pizza is always hot and tasty. The service is usually fast, and the staff is courteous. It can get rather loud and hard to have a conversation at your own table. We have never played any of the games they have in the back (maybe someday). Unfortunately, the menu is rather pricey so we cannot eat here as often as we might normally. read more

The service was friendly, a tad slow but nice people. The restaurant is huge, so we sat near the windows to people watch as we had a few beers and an appetizer. The street was so loud with backfiring Harleys I'd recommend sitting further back. The downfall for us was the appetizer of fried green tomatoes. BBQ sauce on fried green tomatoes seemed weird, but you never know. The tomatoes were thin cut and slices halved, breaded in cornmeal and seriously fried. But they had no seasoning and no taste, the tomatoes were cooked right out of them. And BBQ sauce? Oh dear. No. I don't recommend this dish. read more

The Upper Crust - Fried Green Tomatoes with Smoked BBQ Sauce - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Truly have never had such a bad dining experience. When our waitress brought our waters, she accidentally spilled a whole glass onto my dad's lap. She apologized and brought a small stack of napkins and walked away - did not help clean up, there was ice and water all over the table, and also on the floor where they also didn't help mop or bring a wet floor sign. We had been sitting for an entire HOUR when my husband's food finally came - just his meal. Not our appetizer, not our bar drinks, just the one meal. The waitress apologized a few times and told us that the bar just wasn't making our drinks because they were prioritizing bar drinks. We finally got everything at once after sitting for about an hour and 10 minutes. This place has absolutely no structure - food runners were walking around with no idea which tables they were supposed to go to, management was no where to be seen, we had to ask two different people for silverware and napkins and condiments, my wine came in a snifter beer glass, wait staff had sections that included inside and outside that were far apart. I thought maybe we were just dealt a bad hand, but I saw tons of other customers looking around and seemingly unhappy as well. The pierogis were literally inedible, but the pizzas were actually great. I'm honestly the most disappointed no one offered to take something off our check for the extremely long wait times or inconvenience of the water spill. Just absolute chaos in there from the minute we arrived til the minute we RAN out the door. I'm sure at other times when it's not really busy, it's a tolerable experience, but do not subject yourself to this!!! read more

Charged $55 for a double of a $31 bottle of whiskey. Profit margins are important however, blatantly price gouging a reasonable drink at any other bar is disgraceful and I can not recommend this establishment as it is very disingenuous with pricing. Do not trust this be standard bar format of pricing at shelf level because this bar does not comply with this industry standard practice read more

First want to note that when eating here, you're also able to order food/drinks from Borough BBQ and ice cream from Lulu's Finest Ice Cream, both of which are next door. This was a great perk to eating here since it added some more diversity to the menu! We got 3 pizzas, which was enough to feed 5 of us. The pizzas are normal size. Definitely not huge, but not personal pan size either. The crust was a universal crust that was on the thinner side, which we liked. All 3 were great, and I'd order them all again. The brussels and bacon pizza was more brussels than bacon, but we got this one for the greens so we liked that. It had a sweeter taste to it, which I'm assuming was the bacon marmalade, but it wasn't too overpowering. The gumbo pizza had a nice Cajun flavor to it. It has a surprising amount of meat on it, so you get your bang for you buck when it comes to this one. We also did a custom pizza with pepperoni and pineapple (controversial, I know). The Smoky Cider Nor'Easter was an awesome drink and perfect for warming you up on a cold day. My wife got the Roasted Pineapple Mint Julep and loved it as it was a great balance of fruity and herbal-y. My sister got the strawberry pomegranate mimosa and loved it as well. The waitstaff was extremely nice and provided great service. Arguably the best part about this place is the FREE arcade located at the back of the restaurant. All you can play skee ball, basketball, air hockey, pool and shuffleboard. This provided some entertainment while we ordered a post-lunch round of drinks. We will definitely come back here! read more

The Upper Crust - The Brussels and Bacon Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Food was overpriced for mediocre pizza. As other reviews have stated, brisket pizza lacked the amount of brisket for the price. Service felt rushed, even though they weren't busy. Seems like they fill the outside/front seating to portray busyness when in reality those are the only seats filled. Biting off more than they can chew with the space. read more

The Upper Crust - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Service itself was great, we had a very nice waitress. The food was terrible. Chicken cheese fries the chicken was cold and barely any cheese. My pizza was brought put and practically slung on my lap, and it was full of grease. We had one pack of silverware that was dirty. The burgers were dry and blah. Waited for a second drink and was basically ready to leave before it even came out. I definitely do not recommend spending your time and money here and I never leaves reviews however this was probably the worst experience for a restaurant that I've had. read more

Our experience was not great! W waited almost one hour for our food. It was cold, obviously had sitting for sometime before someone brought it to our table. Our waitress was very nice and apologized. Told us they were 7 servers short that evening. We will not be back, Instead will go back to La Bella Italia for our Pizza. read more

BEWARE: Owner pushes all credit card surcharges (3%) onto the customer. Extremely stingy move. Poor quality food. Ordered appetizer, pizza, and drinks. Appetizer tasted like it came out of the freezer and into the microwave. Pizza was an extreme disappointment....like, how do you mess up a pizza?!? The cheese was runny, and the meat was dry and stale. Would not recommend. read more

Visited The Upper Crust yesterday for a pre-planned meetup with a large group of gaming friends. It was my first time here, and wow! I was shocked how big the place was inside. When I walked in, I was immediately greeted and asked if I was with the group, and they directed me to the back of the restaurant. The back of the restaurant has large, long picnic style tables that were perfect for our large group of over 20 people. I noticed another maybe birthday party at the table next to us. This place is great for large groups, very busy and bustling! The back of the restaurant has a large gaming area, which was awesome for the kids in our group to stay entertained. There are 4 skee ball machines, basketball, and various other games like pool. The machines are free to play which is an awesome touch! The food and beer choices are excellent. It was hard to decide what to order. BF and I are huge foodies and craft beer lovers. We tried 4 different beers. I absolutely loved the Cherry Blossom beer, and Pretzel beer. There is a wide variety of draft beer, canned beer, and cocktails. When I visit a new place or state (I live in Maryland) I like to try local beers only, draft. I was very happy that there were lots of PA beers to try that I was not familiar with. For food, there are 2 different menus, one for the Upper Crust, and one for the Borough BBQ next door. We chose the Pulled Pork Pizza from Upper Crust, and Corn Fritters from Borough BBQ to share. You place your order at the counter, where you can open a tab. It was nice because we stayed around 3 hours with our group. We went up several times to order more drinks - and it was very accommodating due to the fact that we had at least 15 different "parties" within our group - eliminating the need to split or pool checks. The pizza was awesome - I love the brick oven style. It was hard to choose, we will definitely be back to try more. The corn fritters were amazing, and a total surprise! I have never had "sweet" forward corn fritters (with the powdered sugar) - the hot spicy honey was an unexpected twist I didn't know I needed! I loved that the honey was actually spicy. The portion was huge, and there was plenty for me and my BF as well as sharing with 3 other people. The staff brings your food to your table when it is ready, which is a nice touch. Our gaming group does a lot of LARGE meetups with sometimes hundreds of attendees, and we have done events across several states. I'd say it can be challenging to accommodate large groups in a relaxed atmosphere. The Upper Crust was perfect, with lots of space for everyone to spread out, and the kids to run around and enjoy themselves as well. I was truly amazed at the massive size of the space, great food, staff, and relaxed atmosphere with lots of great food choices. I know that we will definitely be revisiting the Upper Crust again very soon. read more

See all

AVOID. Went for lunch, not busy. There was no host tending to customers. I was waiting with another couple who had not been tended to either. I ask bartender if anyone hosting. She said they were extremely busy and one of them will be with us shortly (only4 tables taken). I Waited while all the waitresses walked by ignoring. I left. I'm not surprised considering the several bad reviews this place has. I do not recommend. read more

I dropped in for a pint while exploring the town center. What a great spot and completely unexpected! I tried the pierogies and a an IPA. The tap selection was well curated although my top two choices were sold out. Service was fast and efficient without personality. The atmosphere is open, concrete floors with a dining room up front near the windows, bar on the side and games in the back. The games are all free! Skeeball for the win! This would be a great date venue if you want fun and casual, not romantic. It's walkable to everything downtown. I recommend it! read more

The Upper Crust - Tasty pint - Pizza Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania