Our steaks were delicious and the blue cheese dressing on our salad was excellant! BUT...we ordered 2 pieces of cake to go, one chocolate and one marscapone blueberry. The chocolate cake was two times bigger than the blurberry!! They were both very expensive and I can't believe the slices were so unequal. Don't order dessert to go, they will rip you off. I am posting a photo so you can see. read more

The Top Steakhouse - To -go Cake slices were very different sizes, but both were expensive. - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We celebrated our 19th wedding anniversary here on Saturday at 8:45 pm. My husband book over a week in advance and all the times were booked! This place is popular. We lived in Columbus all our lives and have never been. We always hear great things about it and it always wins best of Columbus Steakhouse. Upon entering, we were very excited. We got seated by the restroom and there was a few people in line. The place was also very very loud! The people who sat next to us were screaming at each other just to hear each other. We ordered our drinks. I got the $13 glass of Malbec and it was huge and delicious. My husband got the Old Fashioned. Drinks were delicious. We got our roll and butter and we ordered the calamari to start. Calamari was so good! It was crispy and hot but not greasy. It was also very tender and not chewy and dipped in the sweet Asian sauce...it was delicious. We chose right! I loved it so much. The waiter also brought out cocktail sauce that had a little kick to it. I ordered the Filet Mignon 8 oz. I had to ask for the price because it sad market price. It was embarrassing but I didn't want a big surprise. Our steak came with 2 sides! I ordered the side salad and the garlic spinach. My husband ordered the Porterhouse 20 oz. With the Ceasar salad and baked potato. We also ordered the Mac and cheese side. The salads were not the best. The Ceasar salad was super fishy. The side salad had way too much blue cheese. We were getting worried about our dinner. Our steaks came out and all our worries went away. Best steak and best sides ever!!! My steak was cooked to perfection. It was so tender and perfectly seasoned. It was the best steak I ever had. My spinach was so good too. I loved the Mac and cheese too! It was the best I've ever had! We were stuffed and left so happy. It was very expensive but worth it for special occasions. read more

See all

Our first stop here is always the bar for a cocktail. We love the vibe here and the cocktails are crafted perfectly! Highly recommend the top old fashioned or manhattan as both are made with Weller 12 yesr. On this visit we were seated on the outside patio which is enclosed with heaters. Our server was absolutely amazing but we always have wonderful service every time we visit. We started with a couple apps including the onion rings which are huge, the bacon and the shrimp cocktail. Nothing disappointed but my personal favorite was the shrimp cocktail. Next came the entrees and once again, everything was great and cooked perfectly. You really cannot go wrong with anything on the menu. We had to finish up with dessert and cocktails, especially when we saw a brandy Alexander on the menu. This is one of the best restaurants in Columbus on our opinion. read more

See all

This place is the perfect date night. The food was out of this world, the service was impeccable and the ambiance is sexy! I highly recommend you check it out! https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZThy2nxkc/ read more

See all

I came here for my birthday that's how good it is. The Top is genuinely unlike any steakhouse you've been to. It's been the same since 1955 and that's not a complaint. Dim lighting, live piano, leather booths, full Rat Pack energy. Food was good and portions are generous, sides included which you don't always get at this level. Fair warning though: this is not a get-in-get-out dinner. It's an experience, think less 'steakhouse' and more 'guided tour through 1955.' If you're on a time crunch or just want a quick steak, go somewhere else. But if you block out the evening and lean into the vibe, it's a Columbus institution worth doing at least once. read more

The Top Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I would give this more a 3.5 stars. The parking lot isn't large so we street parked which was free. The atmosphere is dark and cozy. We were seated by the fireplace which was nice. Service was great. Our waiter made sure to check in on us and food came out quick. We got free bread and the calamari to start. The calamari flavor was very good and I liked the chili dipping sauce, but it was very oily. We also got the sirloin steak and the half fried shrimp. Entrees come with 2 sides which is nice. My husband asked for the steak to be medium rare, but it came out pretty rare. I told him to say something, but he didn't. I'm sure they would've fixed it for us if we would've asked. With steak, he ordered the house salad and whipped potatoes. The dressing on the salad was delicious and it was pretty refreshing. He said overall the meal was alright, but doesn't think it's worth the money we paid. My french fried shrimp was cooked perfectly. Slightly crunchy and soft on the inside. It came with a sweet and sour chili dipping sauce. Drinks were good, but on the pricier side. They use higher quality liquor though. read more

See all

Recently went here for my Birthday! Great place to have a get together. The food is amazing and drinks are refreshing. Service was perfect. Ambiance was like none other. Highly recommend! read more

The Top Steakhouse - Lobster Tail Scallops - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

If you know you know. Solid steakhouse that's been around for eons. We've been here several times and some nights are flawless with the taste and quality while other nights are slightly off. For example their house made onion rings were crispy, hot and airy but were flavorless. We had to throw some salt on them to make them taste better. The prime rib is great but it appears much smaller than in the past. The drinks were fine. The mac and cheese was outstanding along with their steak. I recommend dining inside as opposed to outside on their patio as the inside has a Very nice ambiance. Overall if you take a date here they'd be very impressed. read more

See all

The Top is one of my absolute favorite steakhouses in all of Columbus. They have those classic steakhouse vibes with a dark lighting ambience; an amazing bar, and the service is spectacular! Everything is absolutely delicious here! The cuts of steak are fantastic, & they're cooked & seasoned perfectly You can't go wrong with any of their martinis and starting the meal with the shrimp cocktail is perfect to share with the whole table. Ending the meal with their chocolate cake tops off a wonderful experience! This is a must visit if you haven't yet been! read more

See all

If i could give this place 10 stars I would!! From the amazing and personable service, to the pano bar atmosphere, to the mouth watering food! Every time I'm in Columbus I have to go there and it's always an well crafted experience. This place could take all my money any day! Simply delicious! read more

See all

@Emily- yes we ate our food that I paid $400 for. As a beef cattle farmer - yes the steak was mediocre. Yes the drinks were mediocre compared to top restaurants that I have given 5 star reviews to for drinks. None of that was the cause of my review- as I stated. I am always fair in my reviews and never have I ever given such a disappointing review before. Yes the menu says in small print in the bottom right about a party of 5 but again it is well know that is not a standard practice for a party of 5. Also- as I explained, it was not the food that was my issue it is the disappointing business practices and your comments further illustrate that. See I chose your restaurant for a special occasion and you were the only disappoint part of the whole day. I leave fair and honest reviews based upon my personal experiences. read more

I've been coming to the top for about 5 years. We favor the bar (shout out to Amy) we come in about 3/4 times a year and Amy knows us enough to have a glass of wine and a beer ready. We alternate steak and app options but LOVE the ribeye. Wine is always top notch! Will be a loyal customer for many more years to come! Not one for taking food pics but did snap a pic of the bacon app! read more

The Top Steakhouse - Bacon app! - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The Top Steakhouse was absolutely amazing! The service was on point and the food was great. We absolutely loved Jerry at the piano bar. He played all of our song requests. We loved the drinks, the deviled eggs, the bread with butter, the Night Owl Special which we split, and the crème brûlée. Expect to pay for the premium service and food. I would absolutely love to come back! The best restaurant in Columbus! read more

See all

Very disappointed. We had high hopes for our anniversary dinner, but this experience was a letdown from start to finish. Despite having a reservation, we were seated in a cramped corner right next to the bathrooms and kitchen, with our table pushed against a wall. The noise level was overwhelming--so loud I could hardly hear myself think and actually made my head spin. They seated far too many tables at once, and it took our server nearly 10 minutes just to greet us. Drink refills were rare, and service overall felt rushed and inattentive. My steak, which I ordered medium-well, came out burnt. My husband's steak and baked potato arrived without the butter and sour cream we had to chase down after finally flagging someone. Even the calamari appetizer was overcooked. They did offer dessert for our anniversary, but by that point we just wanted to leave. The atmosphere was anything but relaxing, the food was subpar, and the service missed the mark entirely. We won't be returning. read more

The Top Steakhouse - My medium well steak burnt and charred. First time I got one burnt to a crisp. Tried to eat as much as I could but was disgusted. - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Such an awesome place for a special celebration/fancy night on the town. The ambiance is unique and transports you back in time with the dark features, leather seats, and pianist. We ordered the shrimp cocktail, house salad, and ribeye which were all great. It was my boyfriend's birthday so they brought out a complementary sundae, as well. The service was awesome. It was overall such a nice experience - I will definitely be back. read more

The Top Steakhouse - Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

They are fantastic if you want mid-century dining experience. Think rat-pack...and piano bar, dim lights, great steak, and here, the price does include two sides and not ala cart!! Has lots of different seating indoors, outdoors, by the fireplace indoors, or main dining area or large bar seating area at tables or bar. Don't overlook the piano in a pinch. Don't forget to book ahead! read more

We went to the Top last week and I had the NY strip steak. Needless to say I was disappointed in my meal. In the week read more

Very great service here, the servers are all very knowledgeable. Ordered a 8 oz filet with mashed potatoes and house salad and it was very good. On the more expensive side with each entree $30-50 minimum but worth the money. The table ordered the Mac and cheese, the French fries, shrimp cocktail as an appetizer. Not too many gluten free options. read more

We've been coming here for over 30 years, and it has always been our go-to spot for special occasions, which makes this visit especially disappointing. My New York strip was on the thin-cut side, quite fatty, and almost seemed over-tenderized. My husband's prime rib, unfortunately, was tough. The side of spinach was overly salty and heavy on the garlic to the point where it overpowered the dish. On the positive side, the drinks all around were well made. Service was very good -- attentive, friendly, and professional throughout the evening. At this point, the Night Owl special is probably the better (and more affordable) option if you want steak. While the restaurant still has a nice old-school ambiance that we've always loved, it gets very loud when full, making conversation difficult. Sadly, despite decades of loyalty, we probably won't be returning anytime soon for dinner. It's disappointing to say, but the experience just didn't live up to the standards that once made this place so special to us. read more

For the past couple years my wife & I have wanted to try a different restaurant for our anniversary. We'll get as far as sitting down to order but each time we'll decide to go back to The Top Steakhouse. The food is delicious but is only second to the service we receive. I can't say enough about our positive experience there. I'm sure we'll be there again next year. read more

The Top Steakhouse - Ribs, whipped garlic potatoes, garlic parmesean mac & cheese - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We always loved the Top... been going there for 30 years. But 2 bad experiences in a row and I doubt we go back. Last night the service was great, but my medium rare filet came out medium well, To not make a scene i tried to eat it but just too overcooked. Our server immediately asked the kitchen to refire one, but it took over 20 minutes and everyone else was done eating and plates were cleared. Then the second steak was terrible as well. Not overcooked, but way over seasoned to the point of being inedible, and I don't know how you cook a steak where the top third and bottom third are well done and tough, and the middle is cold and rare, but they did it. Baked potato's always were salted and tasty, this one felt like it came out of the microwave. Just a bad meal. The time before we were guests of a family member, so I did not send the lamb back, but it was as tough as shoe leather, overcooked, over seasoned and just bad. I have actually watched the rating for this place going down, and have had several friends mention poor experiences. Sad but it looks like a long time Columbus staple is no longer on our list to go to. read more

We don't need USA Today to tell us just how good this restaurant The Top, is...From top notch service to consistent quality food, and throw back steakhouse atmosphere...we've loved this restaurant for years. Thank you for being here; Columbus is lucky to have you still!!! You continue to be at The Top of our list read more

See all

Hands down the best dining experiences we've had. Every time. From the moment we walked in, everything felt intentional and welcoming. The service was exceptional without ever feeling stiff or rushed. Our server was knowledgeable, attentive, and genuinely wanted us to have a great night. The steak was outstanding. Perfectly cooked, beautifully seasoned, and easily one of the best cuts I've ever had. Every bite was rich, tender, and exactly what you hope for when you go to a top-tier steakhouse. The sides were just as impressive, and the drinks were crafted thoughtfully, not just poured. What really sets this place apart is the consistency. Food, service, atmosphere, all of it worked together seamlessly. It felt like a special occasion restaurant that still manages to be comfortable and approachable. Worth every dollar. We'll absolutely be back and will be recommending this place to anyone looking for an exceptional steakhouse experience read more

Lately, I've been ordering their burger. It's a steak burger, and hands down the BEST burger in town. Paired with their perfect crispy fries, it's always perfect!!! read more

The food here is amazing! The restaurant has been around for quite some time and that's not a bad thing as I think that is one of the main reasons the food does taste so good. I think the ovens have a very strong influence on the taste. Don't forget the chefs are some of the best in the city and deliver consistently. The consistency is key, and the ambience is elegant, even in the midst of the service of their professional waitstaff. If you want a perfect meal for a very important occasion, this place would be hard to beat. read more

Amazing food very elegant very high class vibe but it's still casual tire people food is a1 more high-end prices if you wanna show up and show out on a date, bring a game definitely recommended. It would be a night. They won't forget! read more

See all

Listen this review is going to be short and to the point. This place is hands down AMAZING great service a small cozy little establishment the kicks out food the will have you coming back again and again for more live music the servers are incredible they know the menu do a great job in explaining in full detail each and every item which helps you make a decision you won't regret. Some may say it's pricey but guess what when it's this GOOD you won't have a problem with paying it's definitely worth every penny you spend! Now you can ignore what I'm saying or you can get over to THE TOP for an experience you won't forget! read more

The Top normally gets a 5 star +++++ rating from me. My friend and I stopped in for a cocktail after an outing with our friends last night. We both live near The Top. We settled in at the bar prepared to enjoy Jerry Wolfe's piano playing. We were very disappointed that this group of rude and disorderly people kept grabbing a microphone and singing along to the music. I was there to hear piano bar music, not a bunch of clowns who liked to hear themselves sing. It was God awful and I hope you hide that microphone SO THAT WE CAN ENJOY THE PIANO BAR AND JERRY'S PLAYING. PS: Our bartender did not like or enjoy it either. We were encouraged to complain. You just have to take charge here even if these folks are regulars. Deep down, I have to believe all of the staff hate it as much as we did. read more

Laurie was our server and she is 5*. Helped out four-top in so many ways. Great gimlet and Sazerac. Impressive. Our Rez was in the patio but there were heating issues. We were lucky we arrived early and were able to switch to the dining room. I'm not sure others would be able to do that, when we left at 745 the restaurant was super crowded. Hamburgers, ribs, fish were all excellent. See you next time Top, always a favorite of ours. read more

See all

While I was in Columbus for a nursery convention I was invited to dinner at this establishment. It was a bit off the beaten path but obviously it has been here for some time. So it must be good right? When you walk in it is quite dark and it is a bit of a labyrinth. I needed a guide to get me to the outside patio area and our table. As we wove through the smaller rooms and dark halls it felt like something out of a spy movie... I kept expecting nefarious deeds to be being performed around he next corner or someone to say "Bond... James Bond" or "shaken not stirred". Once outside at my table it was much more normal. they had these just planters that were outstanding in various places. The patio area was filled with plants and planters... it created a nice scene. Once we were ready the table ordered various apps and drinks. Crab cakes, calamari, etc. it was all good... nothing exceptional but good. For our mains, well it is a steakhouse, so I ordered the 14oz ribeye. With sautéed mushrooms. I asked fir medium rare but it came out medium to medium well. It wasn't shoe leather but it was on its way. The steak was seasoned nice but there was little to no juiciness. The potatoes I got as my side were good, yep that's right not mushrooms... turns out they were out of those. In the end I ate what I could of the steak and it was ok. I usually pass on desert but they were boasting a bread pudding on the desert menu and that is my favorite desert. I ordered one against my better judgement and what my stomach was telling me. I should have listened. The bread pudding was dry and really only marginally good. It certainly was not worth getting. The flavor was minimal and a dry bread pudding is not something worth eating. Our service was fantastic. Having a table of 10 was a chore for the staff and getting everything out relatively at the same time is no easy task but this crew did it. My meal was not terrible... but if I had been paying these prices for just mediocre food I would have been much more upset. By the way I tried to get out of this place after dinner and had to send up smoke signals to be rescued. They sent out a search party and they rescued me. This is a confusing building! read more

See all

Still the Best Steak House in Columbus. I Love the Newer Outdoor Patio area for a early dinner . We ate here Friday Night at 5:30 and a storm rolled in and we could watch the lightning and listen to rain while enjoying our dinner. The Food was fabulous as always. Salad crisp and wet, Shrimp was D-Licious , and the Steak cooked to perfection. JJ was a Wonderful server and always close bye. Can't wait to go again.. read more

See all

I hate to go against the grain, especially for a household Columbus establishment, but it's mid. I've been twice, and both times it was unremarkable. The first time was a date night that wasn't great but we tried again for restaurant week this year. We went to celebrate a birthday and enjoy the pixe fixe menu. The meal timing was awful. On the plus side, we were served our bottle of wine quickly. The 1st course was fine, served 45 min after we ordered. The 2nd course was served over an 40 mins later. When we finally received the main course, which the whole table ordered filet, the potato and cream spinach sides on the plate were all cold. The filets were room temp. My husband's was cold (he ordered rare). To their credit, the manager did stop by to offer condolences for lack of delivery and offered to refire the steak. At that point we had been there for over 2 hour due to timing so we were not interested in waiting a minute longer. They comped us $12 on our bill, which was less than the $20 2oz upgrade on the steak that was inedible. Our bill was over $400 with tip and if anything, disappointing. Ambience is nice, but we have many other great options in town. Truly not worth the nostalgia for the price read more

Three of us visited The Top for a birthday celebration on Feb 23rd. It was awesome. Our server was top notch didn't rush us at all and was very knowledgeable about the menu and specials. He was great. The food was awesome as well. Two of us got the prime bone in ribeye not the regular one on the menu and the other got the fillet mignon. All cooked to perfection and were delicious. Sides and salads did not disappoint. Love this place. I've been several times and will return. read more

The Top Steakhouse - Bone in Ribeye Prime Cut. - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The Top is our "go to" spot for a romantic date night! The drinks are amazing, the food is perfection, and the servers always care about our experience! Cher was our server, and she went above and beyond! read more

Best steak in town. Awesome retro ambiance. Great service. High quality bar. My favorite. read more

The Top Steakhouse - Bar area - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

If you want high quality; giant portions, and impeccable service... come here. Come here yesterday. Get the f#%€ over here immediately.

Came here for restaurant week. Everything went well. The service was excellent with a live pianist on the background. Food was outstanding and the ambiance is really romantic. The men's restroom is a little bit small and the parking was a struggle on our 8pm reservation. Good Top steakhouse experience read more

See all

I've always loved The Top for its consistent good food and service. Now, I will hesitate before going back. I took a friend for her birthday dinner-service started great until we ordered and were 'ghosted'. Had to beg to get our check to leave. The food, consistently good, strongly missed the mark. Both steaks were gristle filled and under cooked..we might have asked for a redo if the server would have appeared. They were not edible. The complimentary hot fudge sundae arrived melted with only a tiny amount of chocolate coating the inside of the parfait glass to appear that there was chocolate. It was a truly disappointing meal from food to service. I hope this is not a trend, yet I've heard from others that it may be. read more

Best steak in town. One of the best steaks I've had worldwide. Great service. This place is a Gem in Columbus. Old School restaurant. Very cool and comforting. read more

Great food and pianist and atmosphere t he e service was timely even though the waitress at the piano bar didn't communicate well with the doing in . read more