[[HIGHLIGHT]]We loved the vibe, the service and our sandwiches![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Fun and friendly place.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The bartender was very helpful and enjoyable to chat with. read more

"We should try a new place," I announced to Old Gramps as we were driving through Nebraska on the way to see a couple of good-lookin' grandkids. He gave me the side-eye, as if he'd forgotten my title of (Self-Proclaimed) Queen of Yelp. But little did he know...my powers were in full force! I had the Smoke 2 Joints on gluten-free bread. He had the Good Vibrations on a gluten-y bun. Boy, oh, boy, were they tasty! We demolished both sandwiches off before our EV even finished charging (and our EV likes to slurp electrons quickly). I'm struggling to figure out why there were some negative reviews, and I'm mystified. Who knows? But in my official capacity as the One and Only Yelp Savant, I'm here to tell you to disregard those people and get yer butt to the Goat! Sincerely, Your Queen [[HIGHLIGHT]]PS: They have a nice patio area upstairs, and they don't do tap to pay.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] (Nice Goat owner, get a Square device and you'll be all set for tap to pay!) read more

The Otherside and Toasted Goat are co-located. We had the Iron Man and Mad House. Both were absolutely delicious. Sooooo good. Friendly service. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Cool vibe.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

Cool vibes, bartender was helpful, food was good and it came out fast. Seems like a cool place to hang with friends.

What a nice little spot. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Very friendly staff and surprisingly quiet.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I ordered the no sleep till Brooklyn sandwich with the tomato/goat cheese soup. Both tasted amazing, the bread tasted and felt like fresh bread. The soup though, that was fantastic. I am regretting not getting some to take home. I couldnt finish my sandwich and even today its still amazing. I dont know when but we will be back. read more

It had great service, great sandwiches and relatively cheap. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It also had a good atmosphere with lots of music labels, billiards and foosball and pinball machines[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. read more

Had the smoke 2 joints sandwich and it was excellent! Fresh toasted bread with flavor full tender meat. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Great vibe to this place but its just hard to find.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Terrible sandwiches and even worse hospitality. It took an hour to get us two sandwiches, which came out extremely bland and tasteless. We could've gotten better sandwiches at the grocery store. read more

The Toasted Goat - Sandwiches Near Me - Kearney, Nebraska

See all

We recently went on a trip driving from California to Michigan for Christmas. On our way back, we stopped in Kearney, Nebraska and after a long day driving, we DoorDashed toasted goat sandwiches. I have to say that the sandwiches we got were easily the best food we had in 12 days, from any state we went through, or any place we stayed!! Good size portions and Crazy delicious!! You gotta try this place! read more

Great spot - food is excellent and [[HIGHLIGHT]]loved the whole vibe[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It seemed like a great place to hang out[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. read more

We almost drove by because we didn't see The Toasted Goat but I'm glad we spotted the destination below the sign for Otherside. I ordered the " Good Vibrations" which was scrumptious. The owner Matt was at the bar letting us sample the local brews. Matt was as friendly as they come& I wish we were traveling back through. If you're in Kearney, NE stop. read more

The Toasted Goat - When driving by you might only see the Orherside but under is The Toasted Goat. - Sandwiches Near Me - Kearney, Nebraska

Glad we stopped in this place. Sandwiches were top notch and decent alcohol specials. Not from the area, so was happy with an $8 bloody only to find out it was $8 for a bloody and a tall boy. Went upstairs to the loft area and played a game of pool and some pinball as well. Lots of space to enjoy up there and an outside deck with a bit of shade and some fans. Would definitely come back! read more

The Toasted Goat - Fun signs everywhere - Sandwiches Near Me - Kearney, Nebraska

[[HIGHLIGHT]]The ambiance was grungy, dark, dirty and unwelcoming.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The menu doesn't offer variety and is too basic and simple. The woman bartender was rude, sarcastic and condescending. Wont ever return and wouldn't recommend. read more

We were driving from Chicago to Denver and got a little hungry. Decided to find someplace in Kearney as that was our last shot before the next stop in a few hours. We picked the Toasted Goat because they had 5 stars. Matt the owner served us and we loved this spot! Ryan ordered the Madhouse sandwich and said it was delicious. We had the roasted pepper and Gouda soup and it was really good! Place is super clean and has excellent Music! This was a convenient spot for us and we highly recommend choosing this place for a quick bite or some beverages! read more

See all

It took an hour to get to sandwiches. I don't care how good the sandwiches are, no sandwich is worth waiting an hour for. By the time we got our sandwiches lunchtime was over. And the sandwiches were horrible. Cheap dry bread with no flavor. Two pieces of meat for a roast beef sandwich. The roast beef was not fresh or high-quality. Tons of shredded lettuce. No flavor to the sandwich at all. I could get a better sandwich premade at any grocery store for less money and much faster. read more

See all

Had high hopes for this visit but sandwich was average at best and pretty sure it was "in-house" made. Meh and meh gets

Jumped off the freeway for lunch and this place was amazing, we had some killer Reuben's that really hit the spot!

Joined a friend here for lunch the other day. Neither of us had been here before. My friend arrived before me and perused the place both up stairs and the main floor. While waiting, the gentleman sitting the bar shared some food suggestions with my friend. When I arrived we poured over the menu. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It was early lunchtime and the place was quiet enough to have conversation and enjoy the blues music playing in the background.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We placed our order with the cordial bartender and learned that a cup of soup could be ordered with a half sandwich..perfect for a light bite. We each had a cup of soup: red pepper with gouda..OMG delish and bacon potato...good, as well. Each of the sandwiches were fresh made and oh-so good! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Thoroughly enjoyed the atmosphere, clean bathrooms and good service.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Will be back with friends...not during the rush, however. Yummy good! read more

My friend and I had lunch at The Toasted Goat for the first time today and it was amazing! I had the Brooklyn (Italian sandwich) and she got The Oath--both were so good. I also grabbed a chocolate chip cookie and it was warm, gooey, and delicious. We'll definitely be back! read more

We enjoying excellent sandwich split, soup, chips. Quick service. All very good as we remember from previous stop here. Will absolutely return. read more

The Toasted Goat - Sandwiches Near Me - Kearney, Nebraska

The food was sooo good! I would highly recommend. The oath was suggested as the number one but decided to switch it up. So good, melt in your mouth! read more

The Toasted Goat - Good vibrations - Sandwiches Near Me - Kearney, Nebraska

Honestly one of the top three best veggie sandwiches I have ever had! Loved it! Can't wait to try more from these guys

The Toasted Goat is actually located inside The Other Side bar. I ordered a sandwich called The Pot. It was delicious and the bread must have been fresh out of the oven since it was warm and soft. I will definitely be returning to try other sandwiches. read more

See all

The sandwiches are enormous. On fresh baked bread, focaccia I think. We got The Pot and the Madhouse. We also got an order of the nachos and were not prepared for the size! Everything was delicious & we have lunch for tomorrow too. Prices are more than fair for the amount you get! read more

See all

Went on a whim for supper one night. Sandwiches are incredible! We were pleasantly surprised! [[HIGHLIGHT]]We ate while we listened to a live band![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

The sandwich was good but the girl behind the bar was one of the rudest customer service people I've dealt with. She knew she was being rude too because when I asked her for her name she wouldn't give it to me. She must not understand her attitude reacts on the business. I won't return. read more

Amazing sandwich and service is awesome Great atmosphere with great music. Tuesday all sandwiches only 10 bucks read more

The Toasted Goat - Amazing sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Kearney, Nebraska

Hits the spot. Don't overthink it, just go. Ask to make your sandwich "Omaha style"...forgot to take a photo but you won't regret it!

Had lunch there for the first time, will definitely be back! Great sandwiches with vegetarian options. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Cool vibe too![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Size of sandwich not as pictured on FB, small with no chips or drink, yet charged $14. Not worth it.

Expected an amazing sandwich based on the positive rating. There were no ingredients on the sandwich. It was bread with a piece of turkey, small amount of guac for $15. Ordered to go, didn't see until back on I80. Super disappointed...and hungry! read more

Drop the mic! BEST sandwich I have ever had! Place is awesome and the owner is so genuine and welcoming. A must place to visit in Kearney!

We are on a road-trip from Missouri to Colorado. Stopped at Classic Car Collection, then checked with Yelp for a lunch recommendation. The Toasted Goat was the number 1 recommendation with only 1 review. We decided to give it a try and it did not disappoint. The Oath sandwich was recommended, and they had 2 of our favorite beers on tap. Loved the vibe too. read more