My family met for drinks at The Smith before and after a memorial service at a nearby hall for a family member. I didn't get the name of our first bartender, but on our return visit Dave was great. Welcoming, took care of us, and was genuinely sympathetic when I told him why we were there. Great guy, good spot. read more

Had weekday lunch here with coworkers. Nice ambience, a little bit loud. I came during the Knicks vs Spurs playoffs and they had a Knicks themed menu which was very cool. The food was great! Everything I had tasted good and I didn't have any huge complaints about. I recommend the truffle parmesan fries, burrata with bread, and the shrimp scampi (which wasn't spicy as advertised but was very fresh and lemony) read more

The Smith - Spicy Shrimp Scampi - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The place has indoor and outdoor seating--a room at the back is a bit easier to hear each other. We had a great waitress named Tiffany. We had all delicious food and drinks--we recommend the fried calamari, French dip, and strawberry pie! read more

Came on a Sunday night around 5, but grabbed a seat at the bar first and ordered a few drinks because we were still waiting for one more person in our party. Bartenders were cool and drinks were good. Because it was a Sunday and it was pretty busy, we decided to get a table before the restaurant filled up. The waiter was super cool and did not rush us while we waited at our table. I got the braised short rib mafaldine and I gotta say it was one of the better pasta dishes I have eaten in a while. Very thick and flavorful sauce along with the nice texture of the mafaldine pasta and nice and tender meat made this such a great dish. Very generous portion size, too. Even when we were finished and we stayed and talked a bit, we weren't rushed by the waiter and he let us continue to stay and talk. That was pretty cool of him. Also came by several times to drop off water and check if we needed anything else. Some negatives are that the place is pretty dark and kind of cramped. It is also pretty loud, so you will need to speak pretty loudly to be heard at your table. Overall, I loved the braised shot rib mafaldine. My friends also liked their dishes, which included the steak, late night spaghetti, and Mediterranean salad. If I'm back in the area, I will be sure to come back here. read more

Love to see the smith is the same across the board and various locations in the city. The food is amazing, the set up is great, and can't complain about the service. I love the chips and blue cheese app and the Mac and cheese is always to die for. We tried a salad with shrimp in it and it was absolutely delicious! read more

See all

Dinner at The Smith is the perfect preamble to an evening show at the Lincoln Center. It has become tradition for my husband and I to come here. We begin our meals as usual: drinks with shrimp cocktail to split. We then segue to our main courses of the usual: a burger for him and the shrimp scampi for me, although the formula for the latter dish has changed during my last two visits, so for tonight I opted for the pasta in vodka sauce instead. It was delicious, and I decided to make it my usual going forward. Then, we end with the sticky toffee pudding, my favorite of its kind in the city. I haven't tried anything at The Smith that I didn't like. The burger is delicious and the accompanying fries are wonderfully crisp while still retaining that soft, potato-ey interior. Their shrimp cocktail is delectably plump and sweet. The pasta a la vodka is creamy and imbued with so much garlic flavor. The pudding is so decadently sweet, yet you can't help but feel like you can indulge yourself to another helping. The Smith, once a convenient pre-show place to dine, quickly became one of our favorites. read more

See all

Met with a friend in the city for a late lunch/early dinner. She grabbed a burger and fries, I settled for the avocado toast and 3 French 75s. The service was excellent, the food and drink were good and the day was beautiful. read more

See all

When you go out to eat with friends and enjoy the summer weather. You look for ambiance, friendly service attention to detail. This place has none of that. Worse customer experience Stay away. read more

I'm salivating thinking about that sugar snap salad. If you're contemplating it - I promise you won't be disappointed. I also had the salmon tartare and it didn't blow me away but it was a solid meal. The restaurant is busy (came on a Friday night for dinner after a show at the Lincoln Center) but waiters are attentive and the restaurant has a great ambiance. read more

We came to The Smith for dinner on April 1st before attending a play at the Lincoln Center. This restaurant ambiance was just what I expected for a New York experience - full of life and hustle, bustle. The location is perfect for a meal before attending an event at the Lincoln Center. We were seated quickly because I had made a reservation. (It was busy so I definitely recommend making a reservation.) We ordered drinks and food, which arrived quickly. Both the drinks and food were absolutely delicious!! Especially loved the Manhattan drink!! My first Manhattan in Manhattan!! The only downside was we never saw our waiter Denny P after we order our food until he brought our bill (someone else delivered the food). We definitely would have ordered more drinks if he had come around again to check on us. All-in-all it was really nice but I had to knock off a star for the service. read more

See all

This location was PACKED! However we didn't feel it as customers. When we didn't see our server another server was attentive. This was my first time doing brunch. I had steak and eggs the steak was a decent size and the eggs were good fries were BOMB. As a starter I had mac n cheese if you love a nice cheese layer like me order it ! So good. For drinks i had a cucumber drink which tasted more pickle than cucumber so i prob wouldn't get it again but overall we had a good experience. I do wish the tables were more spread out but I understand trying to get as much customers in as you can. Not a deal breaker for me read more

See all

I hadn't been to The Smith in years and was excited to return before a show at Lincoln Center. I was very confused upon entry as there was a large amount of people waiting at the Host desk. Lots of people were waiting on their reservations to be met and some had been waiting up to 20 mins past their reservation time. The staff told us that their turnover was slow tonight, meaning tables were hanging out a bit after they had completed meals and paid the check. My party sat just 5 mins after our schedule reservation. I think they handled it well and that didn't go in to my rating. I think restaurants will have those nights. We got to our table and our server was very sweet and working so hard. I must admit, I was a bit underwhelmed by my pasta dish. It was good but was expecting a bit more rich flavor from a braised short rib pasta. It was a tad bland. My mom ordered a burger which she very much enjoyed. Finally, I will say this...that restaurant is so very loud. Because it's so crowded, conversations feel like they are on top of you and it's hard to hear. Would I go back? Sure. But I'm not rushing. read more

See all

First time dining at this location of The Smith. The location is bigger on the inside than what you see when you enter from the street. There is another dining area in the back for customers to dine. We were there on a weekend, so it was busy. We had a little bit of a wait, so we got drinks at the bar. The ambiance for dinner is a little darker than the Nomad location we usually frequent when in Manhattan. So those who have trouble seeing in low light may have problems reading the menus. We sat in the back area and sat at a table where it was half chairs and half bench seating. We had plenty of space at our table. The Smith has daily specials that rotate thru the week. Since it was Saturday I got the baby back ribs special which had a sweet glaze, kale and a potato salad slaw. I liked the potato salad slaw which was a refreshing bite that worked well with the tender baby back ribs. The bathrooms were located downstairs where like in other The Smith there are communal sinks where men and women share then separate areas for the women and men toilet rooms. We had a good time and will return in the future. read more

See all

Popped in to the Smith after a night at Lincoln Center around 9:30 on a Friday and was very happy to snag seats at the bar. The place was buzzing, and I hadn't made a reservation. The bar was perfect though considering that I was craving snacks and a cocktail. I ordered a dirty blue cheese olive martini along with the black truffle arancini and a side of fries. Exactly the kind of warm, cozy food you want to cap off an evening out. The staff were friendly and efficient, and our food came out quickly despite the crowd. It was the perfect low-effort, high-satisfaction stop before heading home. A solid post-show move. read more

The Smith - New American Near Me - New York, New York

This place was so crowded so make reservations. My dining mates liked their food. Mine was the grilled chicken sandwich. For me it was overly doused with the pesto topping. It was just okay. Waiter was very nice. read more

The Smith - Grilled chicken - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Exactly across the street from Lincoln Center and in the heart of the Upper West Side, The Smith is filled with everyone from pre- and post-theatergoers to neighborhood families to global travelers, where we decided on brunch last Saturday. The reservation was easily made with OpenTable. Each location of this establishment boasts a unique ambiance, blending modern design with classic elements - a nod to old-school New York. Upon entering, the interior is characterized by open layouts, communal tables, and a lively atmosphere, making it suitable for everyone. My partner and I were greeted by the host and got a table in a private room usually held for special events. Their menu features a variety of classic American dishes, emphasizing fresh, locally sourced ingredients. As an appetizer, we opted for the Mac & Cheese and Crispy Calamari. As a main meal, we decided on Avocado Toast and a French Dip Sandwich accompanied by Fries. Complimentary sourdough bread with salted butter and one bottle of spring water and one of sparkling water started our meal. The Mac and Cheese served in a mini skillet was phenomenal. The cheese was dripping, and the noodles were perfectly chewy, with the top having that crust, too. The food was fresh, well-prepared, and perfectly portioned. The cost didn't break the wallet. We had the pleasure of having Adonis as our server, and the service was quick. He was fantastic and would check on us. This place provides satisfaction. read more

See all

Made a reservation here on a Monday night given we had an event to attend at Lincoln Center but it was extremely busy and crowded given it was the wicked: for good premiere and everyone had the same idea. So I don't know how busy it gets on a normal weeknight. I made a reservation for 5:30pm and was seated right away. We only wanted to come for a quick bite so my daughter ordered Mac and cheese and I ordered crispy chicken pillard. The chicken was well seasoned, crispy on the outside, moist on the inside. Placed on top of a bed of garlic whipped potatoes, which was smooth and creamy. The lemon caper sauce balanced out the greasiness from the fried chicken. The portion size was very generous and I was super full even though I shared half of my chicken with my daughter to go with her Mac and cheese and I only had a couple bites of the whipped potatoes. My 10 year old daughter thoroughly enjoyed her Mac and cheese and claimed it's cheesy and al dente. Our server was awesome as she was friendly, quick and efficient, and gave us just the right amount of attention without overwhelming us. It was loud given how busy it was but it didn't bother us as we were still able to have a conversation without losing our voice. Overall, this is a great option for a presume meal since it's so close to Lincoln center. It's also children friendly as it has kids menu available read more

The Smith - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Highly recommend this establishment for brunch. We came here for brunch on Sunday around 11:30 and the atmosphere was busy but bustling. The smell was aromatic and made me even hungrier than I was when I walked in the door. The ambience was business oriented, but classy. We were greeted by our server and quickly ordered bloody Mary's to start. The Bloody Mary was delicious and had a slight kick to it but not overwhelming. My husband was craving one so it was perfect. We ordered the calamari and that was absolutely delicious as well. For breakfast, I ordered the eggs Benedict, which was filled with ham and hollandaise sauce, just the way I like it. Highly recommend this place! You will not be disappointed. read more

A dependable Upper West Side classic. The menu is big, familiar, and well executed, everything we ordered was flavorful and satisfying, especially the comfort-food staples. Service was efficient and friendly, even with a busy room, and the atmosphere is lively without feeling overwhelming. Expect a long wait on weekends read more

The best pre theater meal! We split a huge Caesar salad with the highlight being crispy Parmesan bits interspersed within the romaine . It was so big we had enough to feed another person . The special on Tuesday was the short rib meatballs. Three huge meatballs were in the middle of creamy whipped potatoes and covered in a delicious mushroom glaze. Again a perfect meal to share . We splurged on a decadent chocolate layered cake.. The best I have ever had. A short walk across the street and we were at Lincoln Center! Great find.. read more

The Smith - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We walked in at 10 and they closed at 11, but still sat us and gave us extraordinary service! Yummmy $17 glasses of Sauvignon blanc. The waiter allowed me to customize my salad by swapping shrimp for farro and getting an alternative salad dressing. IT WAS DELICIOUSSSSSS I'd go back in a heartbeat. The French fries were also so good and such a good portion. Also great cute atmosphere for a night out. Perfecttt for debriefing a show after a night at Lincoln Center. read more

The Smith - French fries - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This popular American brasserie restaurant located across from Lincoln Center in NYC offers bistro classics, burgers, seasonal fare and craft cocktails. They have four locations in Manhattan. We were there for lunch. We started with the Spicy Salmon Tartare $19. I had the Veggie Burger Royale on a brioche bun with French fries $26. It was all delicious with plenty of fries but the veggie burger could have been a little better. The service was very friendly and efficient. read more

See all

Came here after a show at Lincoln Center and it was packed. I would HIGHLY suggest booking a resy after your show or else you will need to go elsewhere or try the bar which we did. Our bartender, Kayla, is the GOAT. She took care of us! Treat your service employees with friendliness and respect and they got your back. We waited for awhile for a seat at the bar and she shooed away some people trying to snatch the seats who came way later than us. My friend and I ordered apps, mains and drinks. You MUST get the shrimp tartare. Holy shitnzel, that was SO damn good. We could eat plates of that. The crispy rice with the thin layer of tartare was PERFECT. Super addictive. The truffle arachinis were good too. Very savory. The main I got was shrimp scampi and it was clean and simple. I would most likely try something else next time. The drinks we had were delicious! The pear margarita and the basil lemon drop were hits! There was also some mix-up and we ended up getting our 2nd round for free, thanks to Kayla. She also suggested that we get the toffee pudding and it was something that satisfied our sweet tooth! Moist, warm and soft with ice cream.. YUM!!! The Smith overall is a standard and always hits and is a good go-to place for eats. read more

See all

Apologies in advance for a lengthy review- TL:DR- The Smith has really gone downhill Really sad to update my review of the Smith from 5 stars to 1- but after several recent negative experiences I am sorry to no longer recommend the Smith to family, friends and visitors to NYC. The Smith used to be a hospitable, accessible restaurant located conveniently to central park, and lincoln center with a large, well executed menu that you could find something for anyone. They had great customer service and well prepared food Perhaps they have been unable to handle the additional customers with the various Daniel Boulud restaurants around the corner closed for renovation but my last 3 trips to the Smith have featured low quality dishes, exceptionally high wait times for food, and poor customer service. On the last 2 occasions I did politely bring my concerns to the attention of management. The first time I dined for brunch- they previously had a delicious steak and eggs. My dining companion and I both ordered our steaks medium rare. The steaks took a very very long time and arrived medium well- with the medium well toothpicks in them. Our server did not check on us for a while so they sat, though we were hungry, we requested medium rare as we had ordered, they obliged but the steaks we received another 25 min later clearly had not rested at all. It was not busy we were there for a late brunch you can see from my photos the room was half empty, ive been to the Smith for brunch fully packed and had a perfectly cooked steak many times A few weeks later my parents wanted to dine at the Smith for dinner. We were seated at the same time as a table behind us and the 3 tables around us were all seated 10-20 minutes after us. We did not order apps or drinks went straight to entrees. My parents split a burger and salad and I made the grave mistake of Ordering the Braised Short Rib Mafaldine. Our food took FOREVER. The table to the left of us received their appetizers, entrees, their bill and left before our waitress even came back to us. The table to the right had their drinks apps and steaks. Our waitress Madison checked in on every table but was avoiding our attempts to flag her down for an update. When we finally got her attention she said "oh I just checked with the kitchen a few minutes ago, your food is coming soon"- surely she could have checked in with us or at least offered us more bread? Another 15 min elapse and our food arrives. My parents enjoy their salad but their burger was cold. My braised short mafaldine has absolutely no meat. At first, my mom just assumed they brought the wrong dish and asked the expediter if he was sure that was the right dish. As our server Madison was of course no where, the expediter just took the plate and said he would check. He came back a few minutes later and said it was correct wheres the short rib? I poked around, no meat anywhere barely any sauce, no meat in the sauce, no meat period. Tried to flag down madison in vein. My parents werent happy with their meals and we decided we just wanted to pay and leave. We finally got madison's attention and explained we were dissatisfied with the service and had not had this experience the past 30+'times dining here. She offered us a complimentary dessert which we declined and we asked for the bill. The Manager arrived with the bill- and honestly we all would have been content with a "I heard you didnt have a great experience tonight, I hope we can welcome you back in the future" Instead it was a rapid fire storm of excuses-the other tables around us weren't all Madison's tables- with all due respect, my mom and I together have several years of waitressing experience who the server is shouldnt impact not receiving your food. Then manager says those tables just ordered salads- categorically false- and my parents also ordered a salad? The cherry on top- he blamed the customer fot the short rib malfadine- he said first the kitchen prepared it with short rib chunks and "people complained" so they switched to ground short rib, "then people complained about that" so he assertted that the bowl I was served was a combo of ground short rib and short rib chunks and they added extra chunks for me at my request...... We won't be dining at the Smith again and eagerly await the re-opening of Daniel Boulud's restaurants read more

See all

Looking for a standout in the Lincoln Center area? The Smith may just be the answer to your problem. We had a reservation for breakfast and I'm glad we did cause despite arriving at opening, seats began quickly getting filled here. The interior is great, a nod to old school New York. The outside, where we sat, was nice as well. They were very accommodating of our dog by bringing him a water bowl and the outdoor dining area is well staffed. The service is good too. We ordered pretty quick and the food also came out quick as well. Here's how the food was: We started off with a mac and cheese, which may sound crazy but man was it the right decision. The mac and cheese was phenomenal, cheese dripping and noodles perfectly chewy. The top had that crust too, just great. We also ordered the french toast and it was good as well. The bread was thick and soft, the caramelized bananas were a bit sweet though so we ate it without to balance out the flavor. The Benedict Johnny was good, the cornbread sweet and savory.The chicken sausage was good and the poached egg added a good texture to things and a bit more flavor. We also grabbed a cappuccino that was frothy and well made. The food altogether was very good and we were happily surprised with the quality of everything. Even though it was on the pricier side of things, we would definitely come back if we're ever in the area. read more

See all

My starter Caesar salad was good, while unfortunately the main dish chicken paillard was poor.

The potato chips here are AMAZING! The blue cheese fondue on top is so unique and we ate that appetizer up so quickly. The ambiance here is great for a nice dinner or maybe even a business meal with clients. I enjoyed my brick pressed chicken and devils layer cake, but they were not impressive. I was expecting higher quality meal from a place in this city. read more

The Smith - Brick Pressed Chicken - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Smith was a holiday hit. The food was amazing, and the service was just as good. We enjoyed jalapeño margaritas, tried all the martinis, and the team ordered oysters, steaks, and just about every appetizer on the menu. Everything was excellent, and it made for a great experience. Thanks for having us. read more

The Smith - New American Near Me - New York, New York

This was my first time having brunch at this location of The Smith, and it did not disappoint. The ambiance is warm, and the service is genuinely friendly. I ordered the smoked salmon potato waffle and wow, it was incredible. An absolute must-order for brunch. I would definitely recommend it if you are near Lincoln Center. read more

The Smith - Smoked Salmon Potato Waffle - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

In addition to having good lunch & dinner, the brunch (even offered on a Thursday) is also delicious. Service wasn't the best and it was loud even tho it wasn't very crowded, but we'll definitely be back with the great location and good food. read more

See all

Noisy in a boisterous gastropub type environment, but with a definitely higher order of food and drinks. Waitstaff negotiate narrow passages between tables like f1 drivers. If you don't like hearing your next table laughing,move on Had several pastas , all excellent And the toffee dessert and apple pie, with birthday candles for the occasion were a hit We'll be back. Ps Skip the Salt and Vinegar martini. Lesson learned read more

Crispy chicken great. 3.5 Kale quinoa salad. Delicious 4.5 Service very nice. 4 Sat outside with heat lamps were perfect Much better outside... inside is sooo noisy!!! read more

We were at the Smith for at least the 10th time last week. The food was a bit worse than usual. Our main complaint about the food was that the short rib ragu had no meat. We complained, and they added one small piece. The real issue was the service or lack thereof. Several tables seated after us paid their check before we were brought our meals. Now, mixups happen in the kitchen. But our server (Madison) never came by to check or explain. Finally, after the meal, the manager came by and apologized some - but also tried to rationalize the lack of service and the lack of meat. This was a very unfortunate experience, as this was one of our local regular places. The food is typically good, although it can be noisy read more

This is the kind of restaurant you might find around any touristy area in a major city but done so much better and actually very good! Just like another reviewer, we came here to escape the rain and it was pretty good choice. We had the calamari which was so good ALTHOUGH it's like one part calamari to one part fried zucchini, olives and onions which had it not been so good I would've felt gipped but they won me over. We also had the chef's choice steak and eggs, Caesar salad and the shrimp and grits. All solid 8 out of 10- just could've used a little more flavor. My mocha was so good. The most memorable detail was our server Henry who was so attentive , kind and knowledgeable. Overall great experience. read more

See all

Really tasty and flavorful mussels here! Also loved my martini and the oysters were very fresh. Our waitress was attentive and friendly!

We came here for brunch on a Sunday morning. This was the best food we had all weekend. The coffee was outstanding. We enjoyed the Mac n' Cheese, Breakfast Sandwich, Royale Burger and the Benedict Johnny. Everything came out really hot and fresh. The Benedict Johnny was cooked perfectly, runny eggs and the best cornbread I have ever had...and I'm from the south. The Mac n Cheese was also really hot and cheesy. Really good selection of cheeses in their sauce. I would definitely come back to enjoy brunch or any meal. Sit on the patio if it's beautiful outside! The service was also charming. read more

The Smith - Benedict Johnny - New American Near Me - New York, New York

It was so great coming to the Smith for lunch. They are located in the heart of Midtown and there is something for everyone on the menu. The location is spacious with a rustic diner vibe. The staff is really nice and seated my friends and I right away. I ordered the Smith Burger cheddar which was a good size and so delicious. The burger came with bacon jam, crispy onions, pickles and a salad on the side. I must say this was the best burger I've ever had. It was cooked to perfection and was seasoned very well. I also ordered the Pomegranate-Hibiscus Iced Tea which was really good, it was refreshing and went perfect with my burger. I'll absolutely be returning to try more of their dishes! read more

This was really a 3 1/2 star experience however we all know half stars aren't possible and since they were better than a solid 3 it's only fair to give them the 4. We visited on the Thursday after Christmas and while the place was pretty busy we were seated quickly. Service started off great yet it slowly declined over the course of the meal. They provide complimentary still and sparkling water which is nice and the menu is rather limited with there not being a soup of the day. I ordered their tomato soup which was the favorite part of my meal, the soba noodle salad and my friend ordered the chips and dip and the goat cheese omelette. All the food was good but nothing to write home about ... I probably wouldn't visit again just because there are so many better options to choose from in NYC. read more

See all

The service was very good but be careful the Resturant is one of those that calculates their tips on the Price with Tax - the worst !

I've tried 3/4 The Smith locations in Manhattan and each one is just as charming as the next. We recently had Thanksgiving dinner at The Smith and as a first time experience enjoyed it very much. As a previous review for The Smith mentioned, I had brunch, Lunch and dinner several times in the past. The Lincoln Center location was a first for me.. As expected, it was jam packed. Reservations are highly recommended. It was very noisy and holding a conversation was tough. The server dropped by a couple times until we were ready to place our order. As far as beverages, we each had an Aperol Spritz and tea. I chose Green Mint. I deviated from the usual eggs for brunch and ordered the big salad Kale and Quinoa with Grilled Chicken. My friend craved the Smith Burger. The salad included everything one could ask for: baby Kale, sprinkled quinoa, dried cranberries, slivered toasted almonds and Ricotta Salata (a type of cheese). The dressing was a Dijon Vinaigrette (served on the side per my request). This salad was excellent! Flavorful, filling and fantastic. So glad I chose it. My friend raved about the burger. We are huge fans of The Smith restaurants---any location. A real gem. read more

See all