The food we had at The Select ranged from good to great and service was outstanding. This is a 1920s European/American-inspired fine dining restaurant located in the new City Springs development in Sandy Springs, next door to City Hall. This is one of the best restaurants I've tried in Sandy Springs, but I'm not sure I'd put it among the best in metro Atlanta.
The Select Restaurant + Bar opened in May 2019. It was founded by the same folks behind Paces & Vine in Vinings. Parking is free and plentiful in the City Springs underground parking deck. The first two hours are free to all and an extra two hours are validated at the host stand inside The Select. For the closest parking, park in the green section of the deck near door 1. Take an elevator up to street level and you'll be right next to The Select.
This is a really nice-looking restaurant along the lines restaurant groups like Buckhead Life, Fifth Group, and Ford Fry. You can see influences of both French and American Southern style, both traditional and contemporary. It's a classy and elegant place that's ideal for both intimate dates and group gatherings. There are indoor and outdoor patios, multiple/partitioned dining rooms, and a wraparound bar.
We visited on a Wednesday night and the restaurant and bar were busy. It was an older, suburban, country club crowd. I can't tell you how many old dudes I saw enter the restaurant looking like they just rolled off the course in their golf shirts with club logos (e.g. Atlanta Athletic Club); I almost felt as if I was dining at a club. The dress code is "smart casual." I booked our group's reservation for free using OpenTable (book through OpenTable to earn dining points you can use towards discounts at restaurants or redeem an Amazon gift card).
The food menu featured six appetizers (price range: $9-18 each), two soups ($7-9), five salads ($8-12+), nine entrees ($16-65), five sides ($7), and five desserts ($7-9). Also on the menu were cold water oysters (east and west coast, $18 half dozen, $36 whole dozen), shrimp cocktail ($16), cheese and charcuterie ($15 small, $26 large), and kids plates ($8-9). They serve beer, wine, and cocktails with a fairly extensive wine list, by the glass and bottle.
Here's what we got:
Hors d'oeuvres
* Cold water oysters (whole dozen, $36) - west coast, from Hood Canal, Washington
* Crispy oyster ($9) - eggplant, cucumber, black garlic, chili lime sauce
* Steak tartare ($10) - quail egg, homemade brioche point toast
* Duck meatballs ($9) - spice jam, tahini laban, cilantro, pickled Fresno
Salads and sides
* Quinoa and wheat berries salad ($10) - cauliflower, almonds, cranberries, white balsamic, feta
* Mushroom fricassee ($7)
* Roasted cauliflower ($7)
Entrees
* Miso sea bass ($36) - charred bok choy, pickled shiitake mushrooms, orange miso, rice puff, scallion salad
* Rabbit ravioli ($26) - cacciatore style, mushrooms, tomato confit, carrots, olives, pecorino, rabbit loin
* 40-day dry-aged 22-oz bone-in ribeye, medium rare (cut to share, $65) - roasted shallots, natural jus, housemade jumbo frites
The quality of the oysters was superb. The oysters were super fresh, succulent, and had appetizing brine. They were served atop ice with lemon, horseradish, mignonette, cocktail sauce, a small bottle of Tabasco, and Premium crackers. The mignonette was extra vinegary. The lemons were wrapped; I thought was a nice touch. I did encounter two bites with small pieces of shell, so that could be improved.
The apps (crispy oyster, steak tartare, and duck meatballs) were great. I recommend them all. My favorite was the steak tartare. It was pretty much perfect; taste, temperature, and consistency were all on point. Wonderfully rich mouthfeel. What I liked best about the crispy oyster was the batter wasn't too heavy/greasy. The duck meatballs were delicious. This was a very Mediterranean dish because of the tahini laban (yogurt) sauce. It was like eating the duck version of kofta, made with minced/ground meat.
The salad (quinoa and wheat berries salad) and sides (mushroom fricassee and roasted cauliflower) were good. My favorite was the mushroom fricassee. Excellent texture (firm) and flavor (buttery, savory). The salad was light, fresh, and healthy.
The entrees ranged from good (ribeye, rabbit ravioli) to great (miso sea bass). The miso sea bass was terrific. The sea bass was cooked well with slight char on the outside and tender, clean-tasting meat on the inside. I really enjoyed the crisp bok choy and the acidic shiitake mushrooms. The rabbit ravioli had decent flavor and what I think was rabbit sausage. It didn't wow me, but was satisfying enough. As for the ribeye, unfortunately, it looked better than it tasted. It was cooked to the correct temperature, but the steak wasn't seasoned well. It was on the chewier side for a ribeye and wasn't as juicy nor flavorful as it could have been. Not bad, but I expected better from a place like this.
Our server Tiana was fantastic. read more