We have always loved going to Prime Butcher in Windham -- it's one of our go-to spots, especially…read moresince my husband is a total carnivore and appreciates great quality meat. Last week, for the first time ever, we ended up with a steak that just wasn't up to their usual standard. Honestly, it's so rare for them that we didn't think much of it, but my husband stopped in today and mentioned it. What happened next is exactly why we keep going back. They didn't just acknowledge it -- they went above and beyond. They replaced it with a free NY strip steak, and on top of that gave us Prime Butcher playing cards and a big bottle of their "Everything" seasoning. Completely unexpected and absolutely appreciated. That kind of customer service is hard to find these days. They didn't have to do any of that, but they did -- and it speaks volumes about who they are. The manager and staff are always smiling, cracking jokes, and just genuinely good, down-to-earth people. And the meat? Always beyond delicious -- you won't find better anywhere else. We'll definitely continue to be regulars. If you haven't been yet, you're missing out.

Everyone was so pleasant and knowledgeable. Everything we tried was absolutely delicious. Can't…read morewait to go back! We'll definitely become regulars!

Love, love, love this local butcher! We enjoy their $49 and $79 grilling packages often during the…read morespring and summer months. The loaded potato salad is amazing, the bourbon maple steak tips melt in your mouth, teriyaki chicken breasts are delicious and the steak house burgers are perfect for a night of grilling! We also very much enjoy their homemade sausage links in all four flavors! Looking for wine or vegetables to complete your meal? They have that too! Oh and they have a loyalty card, 200 points gets you $10 off your next order, just have them ship your card at each visit! We've never had a bad experience here!

Got a pound of each marinated steak tips. They came out perfect, quality of meat was what was…read moreexpected, didn't enjoy all the marinades but that was just for my tastes others enjoyed them. Will celebrate with their meat next summer again!

The best chili I've ever had. This guy is a genius. The steak tips are insane. Take all…read morerecommendations when you go in. You won't be disappointed.

Extremely well organized and as soon as I walked in, the guys were so friendly and attentive. Was…read morein and out in 5 min. two days before Thanksgiving and my lamb rack came out wonderful! Will make this my go-to butcher shop.

Ya know, they really oughta nickname the town of Bedford "Booji Town". Because this is where New…read moreHampshirites come to empty their wallets. So, it's a high end butcher shop. *ahem* ... 'Scuse me, butchah shop. How I happened by this place was actually through word-of-mouth via the NH subreddit. When I saw they had a fairly good average (despite having far too few reviews), I knew this would be the ideal place to purchase my first home cooked prime rib. Now, this review shall be a special treat for some of you. Because for once, I get to show off a bit of my limited cooking skills, whilst also showcasing the would-be end results of consuming such high quality produce in the privacy of one's own home. As you can see, the selection is vast! I couldn't stop taking pictures, but kinda had to restrain myself in case the staff or management assumed I was somebody important. Fish, chicken, beef, pork? WGB has you covered. As mentioned, we stopped in for a nice prime rib. They have two cuts, Grade A and Prime (if I'm remembering those correctly...please don't @ me). Let's just nickname them "good enough cut" and "booji cut". Long story short, the booji cut has more marbling; ergo, more naturally buttery flavor. Since this was an extra special treat I was providing for myself and family, I opted for the additional flavor. This was my first attempt at roasting a prime rib at home and I gotta say...it came out really good! About an 8 out of 10, if I'm being completely transparent. I gotta tweak some things with the recipe. But ultimately, temp control is the key to cooking a juicy, tender prime rib. I had a chance to peak at some of the other items available here and noted the steaks are also priced significantly higher than the grocery store. Perhaps one day I might try a rib eye from here just to see how it turns out on the grill. Evidently, they have a counter in the front that also sells sides and sandwiches. Dunno if I'd ever personally use this, but it's there for folks who wanna grab a quick bite to-go. Oh, and a shout out to the outstanding staff who quickly helped us and explained the choices of cuts they had. They were also wicked accommodating when it came to portioning the requested weight. Show up with your wallets loaded, folks! Cuz this place is the real deal. I'm affectionately giving Wicked Good Butchah 5 tender, juicy, med-rare slices of prime rib out of 5.

I stopped by at 9:58 a.m. and found the door unlocked, so I walked in assuming the store was open…read more I was immediately told they didn't open until 10:00 and was denied service. That wouldn't have been a big deal, but the woman working at the front desk was extremely rude and made the interaction feel unnecessarily unpleasant. For context, I was there to pick up meat for a large party and planned to spend around $2,000. Instead, I took my business to another local butcher. I'm not saying Wicked Good Butcha doesn't offer quality products--I've heard good things about their meat. My issue was solely with the customer service and the way I was treated. A little courtesy and professionalism would have gone a long way. I left feeling genuinely disrespected, which was disappointing.

Ordered the bourbon steak tips and they were fantastic. Very…read morefriendly service and a big selection of meat and seafood

Love this hidden gem in Concord, NH! Decided to pick up some steaks and went with the House and…read morethen the Spicy Southwestern. Both were some of the best butcher steaks in the area! Comparing that to Tuckaways, these guys hold their own! Friendly people in the shop and it's your everyday neighbor running it. Seemed like they just genuinely had some solid recipes and wanted to share them with the local community. Easy access right off the highway and the place was an in/out. Quick, fun and delicious! Will make sure to stop there for steaks anytime we go up north to the lakes!

I wish I could give 10 STARS to Tuckaway Tavern!!!!! I have to let everyone know about their Monday…read more/ Tuesday specials. They have 2 for 1 on lobster rolls. They offer a 1/4 lb OR a 1/2 lb lobster roll with a second for free! "UNBELIEVABLE " and tasty with just knuckle & claw meat. Let alone the waitstaff who are busy and friendly but take the time to explain everything. Then there's the butchery on site. This place has it all! Check out the pic, this is the second one we took home.

Got the most terrible food poisoning here. 3 guests in our party who got the same meal were all…read moreSick the next day. The sides were cold, the waitress was no where to be found. This good is not kept at temp and I will be calling the department of health. We all went to the dr and it was confirmed that we all had food poisoning. When I called to speak to the manager, I was treated so terribly. I think the owner of this place is a cocky as they come. Never again!

The best oven fried chicken! My family loved it!!…read moreTender chicken with a bread crumb coating that was perfection!

I love their steak and the server was so nice and it's not the first time that I've been here but…read moreevery time i come back they are so nice and the place is calm and nice to just enjoy the food and spending time together

I was looking for a new butcher as my go to spot recently closed. I tried a few other places and…read morewasn't too impressed. I was pleasantly surprised that when I called Alpine with a custom request they told me that they didn't have it in stock but could get it by the weekend when I needed it. They called me the next day and told me it was in. When I went in I was impressed with the variety of cuts and how friendly the staff was. Will certainly be returning!

purchased a food item for lunch. When i got it home to eat it ... it had a funny smell and a nasty…read moretaste. I immediately brought it back to be told they would only replace it. ... do I take a chance on another only to bring it back again? We had already eaten our lunch! finally after waiting for Brian to ask a supervisor, I was given my money back after a brief discussion. I shop once a week here and cannot believe the Doyle boys to be so petty just to piss a customer off over some bad potato salad. Your reputation is being tarnished by your stupid decisions. Don't forget the "customer is always right"

Great subs, great prices. Meat from the butcher is also good, excellent sausages…read more Would like to see prices on the beer selection

The best bang for your buck on the seacoast for a sandwich! Some times you have to call a couple…read moretimes but worth it!

havent tried the meat i bought yet but they had great brands of gourmet sauces and cheese so i am…read morebetting it will be great. the service was amazing everyone was delightful and it was immaculate!

Bought a couple of 2 pound prime ribeyes on 6/19/2026 at $39.99/lb. Reverse seared them after…read morecooking in oven, the same way I've successfully cooked quality ribeyes for nearly 50 years. Couldn't have been more disappointed. They were so tough we didn't eat half of them. Go to Costco. Better quality at less than 1/2 the price.