I ordered the Italian stallion, plain Jain (cheese), and garlic knots. The crust of each pizza was great. The flavors of each pizza were great. The knots were great. All of it was great. Highly recommend. I will say my expectations were lowered when I walked into the joint. It seems like a new place where multiple restaurants deliver to a single window; don't fully understand the setup. HOWEVER, don't let the weird entrance fool you. The food more than makes up the weird atmosphere. 5/5. read more

The Kennesaw location really played in my face with this one!!!! Pizza came BURNT, GREASY, and just plain DISTASTEFUL to the eye as I could imagine it would be if I would dare to eat it. This alone should shut this place down. I'm a very unsatisfied customer. I wish I could do 0 stars but i guess 1 will have to do. Definitely WONT be back! read more

The Pizza Pitt - Nice to Meat You Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Hands down the best gluten and dairy free pizzas I've tried!! My hubby eats their regular pizzas too and loves it! Whatever y'all are doin you're doing right read more

The Pizza Pitt - Put Some Pepperoni in Your Stepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Let me start by saying this -- the service was smooth for order/pick-up, we were able to contact the restaurant when we had a question about ingredients (the pesto has nuts in case you were wondering), and the crust was yummy. Those are the reasons this place gets 2 stars instead of just 1 star. I think if I was to come back, I'd get a simple cheese pizza. We got the small 10" Steak and Please and small 10" Fun Guy pizza. They look nothing like the online order menu. Notably, the cheese is baked on top of the ingredients, allowing everything to slide right off each slice and making the bottom crust soggy (picky eaters also can't dodge ingredients!) The Steak and Please was okay flavor-wise...except it had hamburger meatballs, not steak. The Fun Guy was inedible -- I love mushrooms, but it had so many that it made the pizza taste not great. There were barely any caramelized onions (which were more like lightly sautéed) to balance it out, and the cheese was piled on top rather than blended in. I have never NOT saved pizza leftovers, but we didn't this time. Overall, not worth the $15/pizza when there is so much other pizza to try in Atlanta. read more

The Pizza Pitt - Small (10") Steak and Please Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

About two weeks ago I ordered this same pizza and it was burnt. Steven went above and beyond to l show the hospitality that The Pizza Pitt is about. I thank him for that & I love that i was able to get the real Pizza Pitt experience. read more

See all

I've ordered delivery a few times from here and also picked up as well. First off, Steven (hopefully spelled correctly) comes off as a very genuine guy cooking up some solid food. Originally from Pittsburgh but his last major gig was at Greenbriar in West Virginia. I was impressed with how quickly and thoroughly he got back to me regarding a few questions I had for him. Secondly, I'm extremely impressed with the dough he's using here. He's got the fermentation time and process down. Steven also said he pretty much built a stone oven in his backyard and got started cooking for friends and grew via word of mouth. Thirdly, all of the pizza's are topped perfectly and topping distribution is on point as well. Quality of all the toppings and cheese has been spot on as well. Lastly, all of the specifications I've asked for via different POS platforms have been addressed. Whether extra garlic sauce here or something there. I look forward to frequenting this place and if you are a pizza connoisseur you must try. I'm putting Steven in my top 5 ITP pizzas for sure at the moment. read more

The Pizza Pitt - Medium (14") Chicken Bacon Ranch - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

So we came to this location after a scroll through their insta page showed some delicious looking Artisanal style pizza. I love me some pizza and I'm a huge fluffy crust fan so this was an easy choice to pair with some wings from B&L. Unfortunately I have to say I was a little disappointed in what we received. We ordered a medium pepperoni pizza and I was expecting at least something similar to the pictures but it was very thin. Overall it was more comparable to a pizza from dominos down to the garlic butter on the crust. It was decent but for $18 I really wanted it to look and taste more handmade like the previous reviews and pictures showed. read more

See all

This unexpected find was on POINT. Crust was delicious, toppings were generous and appropriately prepped and they gave you sauce to dip, who can be mad? Atlanta rarely serves this tasty a pizza via delivery... hell, most of my pickup isn't this good. read more

The Pizza Pitt - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Margherita Pizza had so much cheese it was inedible. Smelled great. Delivery driver was great and went above and beyond. Ate one piece and there was at least 3x too much cheese so I took it as a loss and threw the rest away. Maybe their other options are less extreme in cheese but if you don't want to be plugged for a week stay away from their Margherita. read more

The Pizza Pitt - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

I picked up two small pizzas from here and they were terrific, the photos should speak for themselves. Margherita is my go to at any pizza joint and this one was on point. Basil was fresh and the sauce was nice and tangy. But really what uplifted both pizzas were the crusts. They were airy and super soft. I'll definitely keep this spot in my pizza rotation. read more

The Pizza Pitt - Plain Jane - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Where can I start... First, the crust... the best I've ever had Periodt! The perfect blend of soft with a finish of just enough crisp. The sauce, perfect. You actually taste the tomatoes and the herbs follow with a smooth finish. The garnishes; we had the pepperoni with banana peppers and wow! I had a party in my mouth! I def recommend checking this place out! An array of toppings to choose from and the prices are phenomenal! Grab a Stubborn soda while you're at it. My favorite is the Black Cherry Tarragon. read more

Have you ever had pizza made with love? That's what you get with pizza made by Steven Halliday! The Pizza Pitt's pizza are authentic and oh, so delicious. My favorites are the Margherita Pizza and the Vegginator Pizza. And pizza is always better with a nice side salad. Support local business and check out this delicious food as soon as possible! read more

Worst pizza experience ever. Ordered off ubereats and pizza was burnt. Pictures speak for themselves. Thank God Ubereats gave me a refund. RUN AWAY FROM THIS PLACE!! read more

The Pizza Pitt - Suppose to be a regular pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

This food was so amazing everything was made fresh . Great quality food ! I love that you build your own pizza . I will definitely be back . read more

See all

If you ever at the Omni Hotel CNN (I was at a Convention) and on Saturday night, we danced until 1am and were staving! We found The Pizza Pitt on Door Dash - oh so good!! The process was easy, delivery was fast and the pizza was Hot when it arrived!!! read more

This business is totally contactless. If your order is incorrect, you have no recourse. No one answers the phone and there is no physical store to go to. You can leave a message, but they take hours to get back to you. Food is good but if it's wrong and they can't make it right, what's the point? Lots of other good pizza places nearby. Won't risk ordering from here again. read more

Fantastic pizza made from scratch with fresh ingredients. One of the fantastic new places to order from, absolutely on the repeat soon list! read more

The Pizza Pitt - a pizza on a wooden board - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Pretty hit or miss. I've ordered the Nice to Meat Ya pizza which was very tasty but I also ordered the chicken, feta, and spinach calzone which didn't come with any chicken and the dough texture and taste was a little off (spongey yet somehow dry?). Food quality is generally good but order accuracy needs improvement. 2 of my last 3 orders had missing items. read more

this pizzas were unbelievable!!!!!! the ingredients on the pizza were so good and fresh! i highly recommend going here!!!! read more

The Pizza Pitt - Medium (14") Chicken Bacon Ranch - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

The pizza is OK. Delivery sucks. 45 minutes late when I was actually told the woman was at my door. Stone cold pizza. I would never order anything from here unless you pick it up. Plus I called them and left two messages and haven't heard anything back after spending $40 on a pizza. Not impressed read more

This is some really good pizza. The pizzas I've had have all been really well put together and executed. Great crust, in particular. Might be my favorite pizza crust to eat. Great flavor/seasoning/texture to it. Pepps in a Blanket are great as well. I'm very happy to have this in close proximity to me as this place will likely be my go-to delivery pizza. read more

Thank you for the reply. How do I message you? I would be willing to give the restaurant another chance.

I appreciate the managers response and Postmates did give us a credit for the missing pizza. The cheese bread we had was really good. That's all I can say for my experience with this place. Hope they update the number listed. read more

Ordered from Door Dash last night/early morning and it was disgusting. The Cheese Pizza looked like it was just thrown together, it wasnt hot or properly cut. The cheese had slid to one side. It tasted like High School cafeteria pizza. The Mozzerella Sticks were cold and cooked too dark. I was definitely unsatisfied with my order. read more

Excellent pizza. Prices are reasonable and the service is exceptional. If you have a taste for pizza, this is the place!

We ordered 2 margherita pizzas- one regular dough and the other gluten free. Rarely do I feel like gluten free dough is delicious but this one was! And the ingredients on the pizza were so fresh!! My kids, husband and I crushed both pizzas so quickly. Now let's talk about the pepp rolls- these are garlic knots with pepperoni baked in. Do not leave these off of your order- we could have eaten 50 of them. Amazing!! read more

Such amazing customer service and a beautiful pie! Thank you for this late night quarantine safe treat!

My God. Where is Dave Portnoy and his review? Who cares!!! Take it from this fat guy, this pizza is top notch. Hand tossed dough from a real Pittsburgh guido! They use San Marzano tomatoes in their sauce, which any self respecting ITP hipster knows is the truth when it comes to pizza sauce. Let the Pizza Pitt caress your taste buds with their pie. Do it. Good luck on leftovers! read more

Dont know what they're doing back there but they move so slow I had to cancel the order!! SMH

I wanted pizza while visiting Atlanta and had heard about this place. I ordered the meat pizza and cheese sticks. It was very good and had some of the best crust ever. This will be a regular thing whenever I am in town. read more

The Pizza Pitt - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Truly unfortunate to have to provide this review of a place that is usually 5 stars. We are consistent customers of The Pizza Pitt, usually ordering once every two weeks or so. Last few orders have been a miss, with latest being a bit of a disaster. Parm knots had raw, uncooked dough in the middle of each knot in the two orders we got. The pizza was undercooked (usually the Pitt cooks then perfectly) and was not the normal set of toppings. Am truly hoping perhaps these are oven issues, as we love the Pitt, but will hold off ordering from them again until we hear that whatever is broken is fixed. It truly has been as if we've ordered from a different place than had in the past. If new owners or something has changed, won't order again unless we know is fixed. read more

The pizza is made with homemade dough and sauce..the quality is the same difference as getting a tomato straight off the vine versus one from the store..the freshness and quality is well beyond the typical pizza..HIGHLY Recommend you give it a try!! read more

I ordered a pepperoni pizza from Postmates, when I got it the pizza had sausage and Canadian bacon on it. It was super salty and I could not eat it. I want to give them a second chance but it won't be for a while. I ended up having to throw most of the pizza in the trash. read more

Good flavor, fluffy crust, however slightly TOO much toppings which made the middle soggy, and I am a topping lover myself. Overall tasty tasty pizza and open late!! read more

worst pizza I had ordered burn. didn't listen to the topics absolutely horribl. will never order again. Pizza sauce terrible more of a pasta sauce definitely not a pizza sauce read more

Accommodating menu, kind staff, and INCREDIBLY delicious food- this place has it all. Since moving from New York, I haven't had a slice of pizza or a garlic knot that has been anything more than "meh," until The Pizza Pitt. Uber Eats forgot our pizza with our delivery, so we only received the garlic knots at first. But it was love at first bite of their soft, pillowy textured, perfectly seasoned garlic knots. When I called them up to ask about the missing pizza (if the driver left it there or picked it up, what the next steps were, etc), they were absolutely lovely, and even offered to make us another pizza! Great food is one thing, but when you have great service too, it creates a lasting positive impression. I really could not be more impressed with this place. You have to try it! read more

Ordered delivery of the Italian Stallion pizza tonight and it was SO GOOD. I will definitely be returning to try other signature pies

I ordered the Holly Smokes Calzone via postmates and it was so good! The brisket was so tender and juicy. Huge spicy jalapeños too ate too fast for a pic read more

Recently ordered from this place on a Saturday night and can say that they are one of the best pizza delivery options in Atlanta that I've experienced. The order was prepared promptly and did not disappoint. Generous toppings, great crust, and some pretty interesting dipping sauces. I'll definitely be ordering from here again. read more

This is more of a suggestion to management kind of post. Make sure to put your items in bags for delivery drivers (ubereats/grubhub). I enjoy your pizza but the reoccurring theme is I'm always missing items when I get them delivered. To assure your clients it's NOT you, but the drivers stealing food, put everything in a freaking bag and seal it. It takes basically no effort on your part and then the customers can just shit on the drivers tips instead of trashing your management. People are dumb as fuck, Especially people who deliver food while gas is 5/gallon. Don't expect them to read receipts and make sure they have everyone's food because they won't. Every other pizza place is doing this that I order from. Edgewood pizza, anticos, jets.... I'm never missing items from them so they'll be getting my money from now on. read more