After hearing about this place from a couple of co-workers and reading all the positive reviews I figured I'd give this place a try for myself, the first thing that came to my mind as I took a few bites of the pie is I must have been there on and off day. I personally am a huge pie fan, and Pie doesn't go to waste with me around but the few bites that I ate was more than enough for me and I ended up throwing the remainder of my $5 slice of rubber tire on cardboard away! A proper coconut cream pie should theoretically melt-in-your-mouth, the one I received from here though, was so dry and old that it quite literally tasted like it was baked 3 weeks ago and used as a display until they ran out and sold me the last piece! One of the guys at work is constantly saying how good this place is he's buying their custom whole pies all the time, and maybe that's where I went wrong I went in just looking for one piece rather than an entire pie. Possibly their whole pies might be a little fresher but I definitely would not recommend my worst enemy to go in there and buy it by the slice. I don't usually take the time to leave negative reviews, but unfortunately this one was definitely Beyond bad! read more

I wanted to give this place a chance as it's a small and locally owned bakery. My wife, me and my kids went to this place recently. We had high expectations as the reviews looked good. I ordered the coconut cream pie. Well I was truly disappointed. I've had different styles of coconut cream pie and this was my all time least favorite. There was so much coconut that whatever cream was in there, was overwhelmed by the actual coconut. I ate half of it and threw the rest away. My kids had chocolate and complained that the crust didn't taste good. Lastly, my wife even pointed out the boxes of krustiez laying around where the pies were being made, so not even crust made from scratch. Truly disappointed in the lack of quality. The employees were friendly but the product itself let me down. I want this place to be successful, hopefully they make some changes..I'll go elsewhere next time. read more

Okay. The key lime pie was not anything great, but not bad either. Presentation wasn't that great, but was not horrible either. So, so pie and probably too expensive for what it was, but I wouldn't say don't go, just don't expect anything amazing. read more

First time customer, recommend by a friend. Great recommendation! The Coconut Cream Pie was very good, but the Beef Curry Pot Pie was AMAZING! Anytime I'm heading for Crystal Mt I'm stopping at The Pie Goddess. read more

We love their toll house chocolate pie as well as the shepherds pie! Great place to stop in for a slice or even to grab a pie for an event/ family gathering, Susie was almost always there when we went in to visit, and we make it a point to stop by every time my mom comes up from California. They have all flavors and varieties. Definitely recommend !! read more

There are no bad choices at The Pie Goddess, the hardest part is not buying one of each or all of them and now you're broke and you eat pie for a week! lol jk Don't do that even though you'll be tempted. Pies are always changing with a few regulars - really great place with good service. read more

Cute lil town along with the cute lil pie bakery. You can literally see the pie ladies making pies from outside. Must try the Smore pie! Tastes like camping without getting all rugged and smoked read more

I'm not into Pie but this place has amazing pies and lots of different flavors to choose from. Will definitely come back.

They have the most amazing Sheppard's pie. For a little extra you can take how dessert too! You get 4 slices of any variety pie. We have also had the chicken pot pie, and the pasta dinner pie. All yummy! read more

This place has national award winning pie, people. Many of the pies (fruit, pecan, key lime) are non-dairy if you need it. If not, they have some incredible Butter Finger or chocolate pies. They also sell meat pies like Shepherd's Pie, which my Mom and Dad said was fantastic. Stop by on the way to or from Mt Raininer for a real treat. Worth going out of your way, even though it's not that far. read more

Great pies and dinners. Chicken pot pie was delicious!!!!! The owner is wonderful! I would highly recommend their food!

Super nice over the phone and were able to provide me with a gorgeous lemon meringue pie. Talk about a beautiful meringue! Ahem, I was hungry when I went to pick up the pie and happened to notice the case of bake at home dinner pies. Thank you to the kind associate that spent time telling me about each pie, what they had in them and the ones she really liked. I took home the Beef curry pie/ curry beef? lol In My Tummy! Yummy! Excellent. Super easy drive from Maple Valley. I was worried about parking but found easy lot right behind the Pie Goddess if you make a right at the light. Worth mentioning, I was looking for a pie at a couple of local groceries with bakeries with no luck. I pestered a random lady at the second store about if she knew of any place and she recommended The Pie Goddess. I look forward to trying more of their selection. read more

We have been a few times now and have tried a few different types of pies: s'mores (good but I didn't like the nuts), tollhouse (VERY rich) and a peanut butter chocolate type. I love the small town feel and it's been good each we have been there. I read a bunch of reviews that claim the crust is from a box. I don't have the tastebuds to distinguish that, but I hope it's not true with the prices they sell their pies at. read more

See all

We stopped in today after visiting the pumpkin patch at the recommendation of a friend. We did the dinner deal plus one extra slice of pie - so, a chicken pot pie, and then slices of key lime, apple walnut, jumbleberry, butterfinger, and lemon lush. The key lime was excellent, not too sweet, ample lime flavor, and really good graham crust. The jumbleberry filling was great as well, although their crust definitely lacks (it's made with Krusteaz mix, not homemade). We did not enjoy the other flavors. The lemon has the mildest faint hint of lemon but really tastes like straight whip cream. The apple walnut was awful, doughy and lacked any real discernible flavor and the walnuts tasted stale. The butterfinger is just way too sweet, even the kids were like "nah" after one bite. And really, it's so disappointing to not have homemade crust when all they make is pies! Their crust is fully cooked but it doesn't have that nice yummy browning you'd expect from a premium, homemade pie. Glad we tried it to see what the hype is about, and if we happened to be in the area we might grab a slice of the key lime. But overall it was kinda disappointing. read more

I just had the Shepards Pie from The Pie Goddess. Yuck! I'm sorry but that was a can of beef stew with potatoes dabbed on top. So gross. I certainly won't make that mistake again. AND I can't believe they charged about $20.00 per pie. It should have cost under $8.00 for what they served. Bisquick (for pie crust) $2.89 Beef Stew $2.88 Mashed Potatoes $1.79 Total cost for ingredients = $7.56 You disgraced a delicious dish. read more

I was driving through Enumclaw on my way home from Mt. Rainier. I saw the sign - "THE PIE GODDESS" - and immediately found a parking spot. I love pie and I figured I ought to try any pie that boasted divinity. It was tiny inside, so the four customers present (two ladies who couldn't decide on their slices, an elderly man enjoying a chocolate pie and a newspaper at a tiny table, and me) occupied almost the entire space. There were at least ten different pie options available at about 5:30 PM on a Saturday. The slices are, in my opinion, on the pricier side at $4.35 a slice. However, the varieties sounded tantalizing and I ended up walking out with three: peach pecan, jumbleberry (four different berries), and Tollhouse. (I wanted blackberry, but it appeared to have a fruit fly infestation.) The woman on staff was friendly and efficient, if the slightest bit brisk. (She was not the Pie Goddess herself, but perhaps a pie demigoddess.) I ate my peach pecan slice on the road because I couldn't wait. It was decent, but there were precious few peach slices. It was almost entirely candied pecans and a thick crust. Where the crust touched peaches, it was a kind of a gloppy texture - at first I thought it was something other than crust, some special ingredient, but no: just crust. (I think. Still not sure.) The ridged bit of the crust had the proper texture, but tasted mostly of baking soda. It was just fine. The jumbleberry pie is in my fridge, almost totally liquefied; I'll try it later when it's more solid. I shared the Tollhouse pie at home with my boyfriend, who liked it very much. It was good, but I prefer fruit pies. The Pie Goddess appears to prefer chocolate-based pies. Having tried the pie, I think a better name for this place might be "Pie Hubris." I say that gently tongue-in-cheek, and you should probably still try a slice here. Maybe not a fruit one. Edit: The jumbleberry pie was DELICIOUS, but very sugary. read more

My husband and I love this place and always have to stop by whenever we go to Crystal Mountain. Pecan pie is our favorite!!

Presentation was great, but I was let down in 2 areas: 1. TASTE! I ordered Coconut Cream and granted, I could see lots of coconut, but didn't get alot of flavor. And please, take off the maraschino cherries! It's just confusing and isn't necessary. I think using toasted coconut on top would be more appealing. 2. The size of the slice. If the placement of the cherries was an indicator of the size of each slice, then something is way off. My slice was about 21/2 wide? The crust was okay. Pale in color and almost undercooked. *Note: I have tried the Chicken Pot Pie after a couple of people raved about it. It was expensive at $15.00. Again, the crust left something to be desired. There was alot of "fillers" in the filling. read more

We stopped in on our way back to Seattle from Mount Rainier. We picked up a whole chicken pie to bring home for dinner. It is absolutely delicious! I'll definitely be getting a pie every time I'm near Enumclaw. read more

I want more! So yummy! A delicious way to gain your calories back after (or before) a weekend of hiking at Mt. Rainier! So of course we got a bunch of them to try. Butterscotch - my favorite. It seems like it would be too sweet, but it was perfect Coconut cream pie - with coconut flakes. Fluffy! Peanut Butter - sounds weird, but yummy Tollhouse - good, but, dare I say, a little too sweet Cherry Almond Crunch - tart cherries Of course the best part of any pie is the crust! read more

My husband loves pie! When we heard about this place we made the trip from Kent to try it out. I'm sorry to say that we were disappointed. I had the pecan pie. It tasted alright but I had a hard time cutting the pie crust because it was hard. My husband tried the lemon pie but it was too sweet. It needed more tartness to the lemon. We won't go back as the pies from shari's are just as good if not better. read more

The pie was such a let down. We got the butterfinger, apple, and tollhouse. All were below sub par. To top it off they don't even make their own crust. They use store bought Kristeaze. We were really hoping for delicious home made pies and will not be visiting again. Sorry to say I would not recommend this to anyone. read more

Randomly stopped in on a return trip from hiking around Mt. Rainier. Best. Decision. Ever. Run, don't walk. This place is more incredible than the reviews might suggest. Perfect little hole-in-the-wall. Fantastic! read more

It's a teeny tiny little store front that serves pies. Just pies. PIES PIES PIES! Cream pies, fruit pies, alllllll pies. They even have chicken pot pie you can take home and bake for $15. The teeny tiny store has two teeny tiny tables inside and a couple outside when it's nice. We usually just buy and run. The pies are GREAT. You can buy a slice for a tad over $4.00, or you can go whole hog and buy a pie for $22 - $27. Ohhhhh myyyyy goshhhh you say you can buy a pie from Mrs.Smith's at Safeway for $5? I guess you can, and sometimes I do, but you can have a frozen pie, or you can have a deeeelicious, freshhhh, home cooked, quality ingredients fancy schmancy PIE GODDESS pie! Sometimes, it's worth the splurge. read more

Butterscotch Lush is my Achilles Heel! You need to put this place on your bucket because the pies here will make you feel like you've died and gone to Heaven read more

Best. Pie. EVER. I have never been disappointed by any slice of pie or whole pie I have gotten there. The butterscotch and coconut creme are my two favorites. No matter where you live, it's worth the trip. read more

So I commend the business model, and I really did want to like this place. Honestly, I don't get the buzz. I've bought two pies here and neither one were anything to write home about. I asked what she used in her crust and she told me it was Bisquick. Seriously? Pie crust is so easy to make and WAY better from scratch. The pies are stupid expensive and the kitchen is kind of dirty. read more

Tis the season to reflect on good food and great times. The Pie Goddess has helped bring that together with her take on a classic. The pie. Her pies are hand crafted goodness that envelop everything you might hope and expect from this superior desert. The size cant be topped. The flavors are exact. The crust is delicious and combined you get the best pie in the area...and beyond. She will do customs as well, I have a specific way I like my banana cream pie and she makes it perfect! But she caries unique possibilities that you dont find anywhere else. This is worth the stop any time of the year! Come Hungry! read more

If only The Pie Goddess were in Tacoma instead of Enumclaw... then again it's probably a good thing for my waist line! ha ha. Anyway, their pies are scrumptious! The cherry almond crunch pie is the BEST pie I've ever had in my 53 years on Earth. It's definitely worth the drive. read more

Dear Pie Goddess, I love you! Your Chicken Pot Pie is to die for! So is your Butterscotch Lush, and I don't even LIKE butterscotch (good lord, what has happened to me??)!. The last time I went in, I found out you will do special order savory pies, and I think I may just keel over in ecstasy! I will be calling very soon, I promise. The time before, that, I had a great time in your extremely awesome smelling, quaint little shop talking with three women (total strangers, mind you) about our favorite kinds of pies, and what we were ordering. I've never been a "pie" person, always a "cake" girl, but you...YOU have shown me the light. I am a total convert and will never go back! P.S. I saw in one of the other reviews that the Chicken Pot Pie contains a lot of "fillers". If by fillers, you mean tons of tasty vegetables, savory spices, flavorful chicken gravy, and chunks of tender chicken, then yes, it does contain a lot of fillers. read more

The pies here are delicious! If you're driving through Enumclaw and don't stop and get one....well you are the one that is truly missing out!! The prices are very reasonable for homemade. Especially compared to some of the simple pieces of pie you order at some high end restaurants! read more

Five stars = Chicken Pot Pie take home. Stuffed with hearty chicken, vegetables, true chicken stock flavor. I follow up with tons of black pepper, some additional salt. Flaky buttery crust. YUM! Five Stars = Butterfinger pie. Ohh so rich and complex layers. Graham cracker crust, whipped butterfinger filling, topped with a semi sweet chocolate shell on top. Three Stars = Banana creme pie. This fell flat for me. It lacked something that I'm not sure what. Probably not as sinful for those that are watching diets or diabetic. Large size portions and discounts for ordering multiple slices. read more

11/5. The coconut cream pie was beyond anything. The blackberry is incredible; perfectly tart with strong flavor. read more

There's not much room to sit and eat, but pretty much every pie served here is excellent and well worth seeking out. Our family favorites are the cherry almond crunch, chocolate lush, sour cream apple pie, and blackberry. One notable exception mentioned by another reviewer is lemon lush pie, a delicious oatmeal crust egregiously let down by a filling with more yellow food coloring than lemon flavor or tartness. If not for the name and color, I would have guessed it was a bland, banana pie! Other than that, it's hard to go wrong with anything on the menu. I would give this place five stars if they revised the lemon lush or simply removed it from the menu. read more

Amazing pies! We have only been going for about 6 months but have gone there every excuse we can find to eat something new. We have not had a bad pie yet and enjoy the gals behind the register. They are always very patient and have great suggestions. Prepare to get addicted! read more

Five of us were staying at the nearby Park Center Hotel and had seen the Pie Goddess while we were walking to dinner about a block away. When it came time for dessert someone suggested we stop by the pie place, but I figured at almost 9p at night it was probably closed. So I opted for a not-so-hot brownie sundae at our restaurant. Then on the way back to the hotel we walked past the Pie Goddess which was still open, a few customers sitting at the small tables inside. As we walked in I noticed the hours on the door which said they closed at 9p. "Are you about to close?" I asked. "It's my shop," said the woman behind the counter. "I can close whenever I want." Satisfied that we weren't keeping anyone late against their will, we started looking over the pies. There were a ton of them, and they all looked fantastic. We settled on tried the Tollhouse, apple, banana cream and marionberry. Most of us opted for ice cream. None of us were disappointed. My Tollhouse was as described; a gooey chocolate-chip cookie in pie form, heated and served a la mode. Fantastic. My friend is a fan of banana cream and told me he's never had better. Not only was the pie great, the owner was a delight. She was super friendly and chatted with us while we worked on our pies. When we left she sent us out the door with some free extra slices and a bunch of bumper stickers. If you're ever in town you owe it to yourself to stop by and have a slice. read more

Good lord. These pies are amazing. I sampled a cherry, strawberry rhubarb, and chocolate creampuff. To die for. All of them. Impossible to pick a favorite. read more

I am not a huge sweets person, but oh my gosh, I had the peanut butter - butterfinger pie and it was quite amazing, very rich, but I was definitely impressed! read more

The Pie Goddess - This is the peanut butter pie! It is amazing. Very rich so a small piece goes a long way! Everyone in my family is loving it - Bakeries Near Me - Enumclaw, Washington

I took my fiance in for pie on the 10th of August, she had a piece of lemon pie and I tried Key lime pie. We were very disappointed with our pie. The key lime was ver bland, almost no lime flavor....I have purchased Marie Calendar frozen pies that had much better flavor, the lemon meringue was only slightly better. Very disappointing given the reputation this place has, and at $4.50 per slice, a bit spendy for the quality. read more

Everytime I go here I'm never disappointed. Soooo good! I love pecans and they had a variety. The peach pecan pie and pecan cheese cake was 100% on point. read more