I really wanted to like this place and support a small business, but honestly the experience just felt off. When I walked in, the first thing I noticed was the smell, and it didn't smell like a pie shop at all. It actually smelled more like Indian food. I love Indian food, so that's not the issue, it just wasn't what I expected from a bakery that specializes in pies. I was looking through the options and asked the employee what their most popular pie was, pretty normal question, I think. But the response I got felt rude and kind of condescending. I was told, "Everybody has their favorite, all items are popular," in a tone that just made me feel like I shouldn't have asked. I'm all for supporting local spots, but customer service really matters. That interaction alone made me feel unwelcome, that will be my last time going there. read more

The Pie Goddess - Location - Bakeries Near Me - Enumclaw, Washington

Do you like pie? Do you like options? This is the place! So many choices including savory. First time visiting and we will be back! read more

We came in on a Friday , looking forward to it since I saw it as an option in the area. Walked in and the vibe was interesting. Pies were in the case. We ordered a slice of apple and the butterfinger one. The worker was not friendly... not rude but just didn't look happy and didn't really greet us. He also grabbed the pies from the fridge with his bare hands and placed his thumb on the pie and never cracked a smile. Anyways we got our pies and left. I warmed up the apple for me , and the apple was alright, it was super tart. The butterfinger one was really good! Not sure if I would go out of my way to come back. read more

The Pie Goddess is amazing. Best pie filling and crust. So many wonderful choices. Sometimes you just have to buy several slices of different kinds to try. Sooo good Our family also enjoys their Sheppards pie and Cottage pie for dinner. It's super tasty and tastes like a home made meal that mom spent hours making it. Love this little slice of heaven! read more

The pie is so delicious and creamy. But sadly I didn't get to experience the service or the ambience because we got the pie to go. But I highly recommend everyone try this place. read more

This is a tiny, quaint pie shop with seats for just a handful of people. Most people order to-go. Pies are available by the slice or whole. They have savory and sweet pies! I got the key lime pie with a crumbly graham cracker crust. Pie slice was a good size! Flavor was good, not quite the same as the Florida Keys but good enough. Service is friendly. This is a mom-and-pop shop. Overall a great place to stop by on the way home from a day of skiing! read more

The Pie Goddess - Sweet and savory pies - Bakeries Near Me - Enumclaw, Washington

LOVE LOVE the chicken pot pie!!! Can't say anything except .... I did try the other sweet pies like cookies & cream, banana cream, key lime, some jumbleberry, Dutch apple, strawberry rhubarb, coconut cream,pecan and smores. The ones that passed my taste test were the jumble berry , Dutch apple, strawberry rhubarb, and banana cream. But the Chicken pot pie ....... OMG!! Will be back for that again and again and again!! Let's just say .... NO Leftovers at ALL!! Loved by me and the family!! read more

I had this place on my list to try for a long time, so imagine how excited it was when we were in the area to make a little detour and try out their pie. Now personally on my birthday I get a pie instead of a cake, I think that the best possible cake you could have in the entire world is not as good as the cheapest pie. So when you start to get into the caliber of pie that pie goddess has there really is no other dessert to be had. I had the cherry pie and my wife had the s'mores. Hers was decadent and gooey and all the best things about a s'mores pie, however you cannot go wrong with the good old-fashioned cherry pie, it was thick and flavorful and probably the best crust that I've ever had in my life. Service was quick, When we arrive there was a line out the door. However, they got us through in about 3 minutes. We sat at one of the only two tables, which I think is kind of a negative, as popular as they are they should have a little bit more seating maybe put like a canopy or a couple of chairs right outside. But that aside this pie is amazing Dean Winchester would be in heaven. read more

See all

They have a lot of pies but never enough fruit pies all though the butterfingers pie is great. Savory pies too!

Our daughter came home with a chicken pot and we were pleasantly surprised. Especially since we've perfected making our own at home - we really were impressed, would have this again, and would definitely recommend!! read more

Terrible customer service and the crust tastes like Bisquick. 70 dollars later and they both went in the garbage.

Better experience It was a rainy fall day per usual and after hitting the bookshop and some other places I was too exhausted to go home and cook. I decided I needed to try a savory pie this time around. I got the classic chicken pot pie and it was absolutely delicious and filling! I love the instructions and the service was spectacular. I asked her what to do even though the card instructions were included and she still walked me through it. It's a small shop making it quaint, but it felt homey this time around. I also got the key lime pie and that was very delicious! I wish it had a bit more pucker effect on the backs of the cheeks, if you know what I mean, but it was good!! read more

Hands down the best banana cream pie I've ever had. This place has a great variety of options for both dinner pies and dessert pies. So many options that you will likely struggle to make a selection as they all look so darn good. We ordered a slice of banana cream, butterscotch, butterfinger, and blackberry. We look advantage of the dinner special and also picked up a beef curry whole pie for our family. Based on my experience it seems you can't go wrong with any of the desert pies and I highly recommend the beef curry dinner pie. It was spectacular! I also just want to note that the establishment was extremely clean inside and all throughout the kitchen which you can see from the front of the store. Great service, great pie, super clean... I can assure you we will be back. read more

See all

Smells like curry. Not what I wanna smell in a pie place. Should smell like sweet delicious pie

I was totally stoked on the Blackberry Pie It wasn't overly sweet As it should be done Almost as good as Mom's read more

My pie-loving bf had an amazing time at the Pie Goddess. He tried a slice of the jumbleberry pie and could not put it down! The consistency was great - not too runny or too dense. Definitely give it a try. read more

You can get better pie from the freezer at any Safeway. The berry filling has a weird aftertaste and pie crust tastes like flour and baking soda. The peanut butter pie as well as the keylime just taste like gelatin. The space needs attention as it has no character and is messy - nothing quaint about it. Even the service seemed bothered by our questions. Enumclaw deserves better. The curry smell was off-putting. Maybe their dinner pies are better? I will not be going back to find out. read more

I bought a slice of their chocolate lush pie. It was perfect...sweet, but not too sweet. The shop is small, but charming. The customer service could be better, that being the reason I subtracted a star. read more

The Pie Goddess - Chocolate lush - Bakeries Near Me - Enumclaw, Washington

Both fruit and savory pies are wonderful! My favorites are chicken pot pie and cherry almond crunch. The staff is very serious and efficient. I took my pie home, but there is a small area to enjoy a slice of pie. I will be back again. read more

Man, I've been wanting to check out The Pie Goddess for so long. So when my colleague told me that she was going to Enumclaw for meetings, I recommended that she treat herself to some pie from here and let me know what she thought. When she got back up north to the eastside, she stopped by and surprised me with a slice of pie! I had the cookies & cream pie, which was fantastic! It's definitely a dessert for days, that is, if you don't plan on sharing, WHICH I DON'T! The pie was silky from the creamy base with chunks of Oreo throughout the pie and an Oreo pie crust AND an Oreo on top with whipped cream. Holy moly. It's not for the faint of heart nor is it for any dieters. It was rich and dense, so was good with a few bites here and there, and have something to look forward to for the next few days. My colleague told me that she loved her apple pie too! I will definitely have to stop by whenever I'm in Enumclaw and thank the Goddess for making delicious pies. In addition to sweet, dessert pies that you can get by the slice, they have whole pies, as well as savory ones, like shepard's pie and so forth. Glad to have had tried a slice of pie from here! read more

See all

I drove into Enumclaw to get a pie or two and decided due to the rudeness of this young east India person i wouldn't buy but one. Super disappointing. It's too bad that he doesn't have proper public relations manners. i might have bought several, if not for him. read more

Not what I was expecting very disappointed. Thought the dough would be fresh and baking, but no sign of fresh baked pies.

I usually love this place. However, today (1-13-2024)my peach pie was moldy. In their defense, the pies are made from scratch and probably do not contain preservatives that give a longer shelf life. However, finding mold after paying five bucks for a piece of pie is disappointing. Check those pies for mold Pie Goddess. read more

The Pie Goddess - Moldy peach pie - Bakeries Near Me - Enumclaw, Washington

See all

We bought two slices of pie today. Apple, and chocolate cream. Once we walked in we remembered we bought a savory pie a few months back and didn't like it. My husband hasn't ate the Apple yet so this review is based on my chocolate cream. It was not good. It taste like a cheap artificial pie. I actually think a cheap store pie would be better. None of the pies looked that great, I cost kinda tell they were going to taste boxes but it was small and I feel rude walking out. Won't go back. I don't think the two people working care, as they were uninterested in us as customers to begin with. read more

There pie's are Amazing!! So fresh and when you walk in it smells heavenly. The crusts are made to perfection. I highly recommend giving the Pie Goddess a try. read more

Good not great. Most of the cream pies are very artificial tasting! For $6 a slice you would hope for homemade ingredients. Crust is homemade you can tell but the pudding fillings taste like box pudding mix. Lemon cream should have real lemon curd :/ read more

Love this place! Every time I'm in Enumclaw I visit here & usually bring home a savoury pie & several pieces of pie. The shepherd's pie is yummy. So is the chicken pot pie. Loved the peach pie & the banana cream pie. The Apple pie was good - but wish I had vanilla ice cream to go on top! I used to own a bakery for over 20 years, and while we only did one specific pie - I love their pastry here! Pie isn't good without good pastry! I'd recommend this spot. Nom. Nom. Always a good variety of pies by the slice. Great hours. read more

The Pie Goddess - My Bullmastiff GCHG CH Icon n Gaffle's Domestic Goddess (Aka: Biscuit) visiting the Pie Goddess! Perfect choice for desserts! Yum! Yum!! - Bakeries Near Me - Enumclaw, Washington

Bought a Chicken Pot Pie today, could not believe the exorbitant price $29 for that pie. Looks like i will be making my own from now on.

I expected an amazing slice of pie, after all, that is all they make. The crust was horrible. My expectations was a light, flaky crust. This was like hardtack! What a huge disappointment. They should talk to the baker at Copper Kettle near the Longmire entrance at Mt Rainier. read more

This place used to be good, so very disappointing anymore. The kids running the place are very disinterested in running a business, they are rude and have no customer service skills. It is sad to See a community staple run into the ground by new owners who don't care. This world needs more good pie. read more

If I could give no stars I would. I am so....disappointed. I just spent $22 on the worst pieces of pie I've ever eaten. First piece was cookies and cream. This was like eating Betty Crocker frosting out of a can. Actually the canned frosting would taste better. Second piece was key lime. I will give credit to this actually tasting like lime. But the teeny piece was not worth $5.50. Third piece was Dutch apple. It was just meh. Not great. But also not awful. Fourth piece was lemon lush. It was basically cool whip on a pie crust. It wasn't even real whip cream. They used cool whip. All in all I will say. I won't ever go back. I'll go to Safeway and buy a pie and a can of frosting. read more

I ordered a banana cream pie for my daughter's birthday. I am so sorry to leave such a bad review ... it was a horrible pie! The pudding was hard (very similar to a soft cheese texture) and it didn't taste good. I hope they improve, but hearing comments from other people, it sounds like these are new owners, and they can't bake a good pie ! read more

Bought a couple slices of banana cream and jumble berry pie. Was excited to dig in at home but imagine our disgust when both were MOLDY. At over 5 bucks a slice, that's pretty unacceptable. Absolutely disgusting. read more

I haven't been by in a few years and found a coupon on restaurant.com- which is nice because this place is expensive. I printed it off and took it with me, it was $5 off a purchase of $10- which is easy when a small slice is $6. So two slices ordered and them I'm told that they will allow the coupon but they are no longer allowing ANY coupons. There is a handwritten sign way behind counter that says that. This was a coupon I just obtained within the week- super sketchy. The pie was ok, kind of small slice. Crust a bit dry IMHO. When we stopped by on a weekend mid-day there were a handful of people there and it was unclear if they all worked there or were friends of the workers? I love supporting a local business but I'm not sure I'll be back to this one. read more

She has ever right to call herself the pie goddess! Banana cream pie! S'mores pie! Peanut butterfinger! Raspberry mango! Butterscotch pie! All delicious! Super fast service and nice lady working behind the counter. Cute store front too! read more

The Pie Goddess - Pie was so good I couldn't stop to take a picture till I was done - Bakeries Near Me - Enumclaw, Washington

The Pie Goddess is open once again. Chicken Enchalada Pasta for dinner & pie for dessert. Life just got back to normal again, a little bit. The pandemic has made it tough for some of my favorites so I'm happy to be here to offer my support. Welcome back Pie Goddess. You were missed. Update: I very much enjoyed the Chocolate Caramel pie but the Tollhouse pie wasn't something I would order again. The Hasta La Pasta chicken pie was tasty but slightly salty for my tast. I look forward to trying the pulled pork potato pie, as well as, the chicken pot pie one of these days. The Coconut and Butterfinger pies are still at the top of my list. It's all good at the Pie Goddess. That's the bottom line for me. read more

See all

Delicious! I bought to slices, one blackberry and the other coconut cream. I just ate the blackberry and it was so delicious! The gentleman taking orders was really nice also. read more

Little walk-in shop with a wide selection and delicious pie! I had the apple a la mode, which was just right; and the butterscotch lush, which was too sweet but the pecan layer was SO addictive I might have to get it again anyway. It's a nice destination spot. There are park areas nearby with tables scattered around, which makes for a convenient place to eat (when it's not raining at least), and I'm sure there's a great view of Mt. Rainier when it's not -completely- shrouded in fog like it was that day. read more

Delicious pies. We got a create your own pie option so we got to pick 8 different slices for $39. Everything we tasted so far has been delicious. Parking was a little rough to find. read more

On my way back from the scenic gondola I had to stop by! There were so many delicious looking pies but I chose the butterscotch pie. It was outstanding! Such a great little treat if you are in the area or on your way somewhere read more

The Pie Goddess - Butterscotch Lush - Bakeries Near Me - Enumclaw, Washington