Service was excellent. Fish Fry was great! We went early around 3pm and the ambiance was perfect.read more

Devin the sever/bartender is wonderful! We were looking for a place to grab lunch while in town…read morevisiting family and the food and service was so good we came back again in the evening!

I stopped by Daryls today and had a couple slices. Not the best ever, but solid enough that I'd get…read morethem again. For $11, I got two slices, a cookie, and a drink. The homemade blue cheese is good, the staff are friendly, and though the seating area is small, it's clean and gets the job done.

GOLLY! that cheeseburger pizza is sure the best i've ever had! i've traveled to many pizza places…read morein my days and this- boy it's the best!get the cheeseburger pizza!!! service is quick. and it's a cute area.

Best pizza place in Dansville. Don't let anyone tell you different. Great food, great service and…read moreaffordable. Try the Suicide wings. They're awesome!.

Ordered a cheeseburger pizza. Only forget the ketchup mustard onions lettuce and the pickles we…read moreasked for. Came with burger and cheese. Lol great job. Only one star because they made me

NYC food at starving college student prices! Listen, when I go to a town, I make it my mission to…read morefind the best pizza, the best taco and the best burger. I was in town for a wedding and Mama Mia's definitely clinches the best pizza around. I'm a Chicago boy but I love my NYC style, too, and this place hits it out of the park. I'm surprised the ratings aren't higher. The restaurant is located on the Main Street of a cute college town (SUNY Geneseo). At Mama Mia's I ate the Bianca (white pizza with ricotta is how I judge all NY style pizza places), which was rich and garlicky and delicious. The Sausage and the mushroom pizzas were fantastic as well. The owner, Eddie (from Brooklyn, I found out), was making the pies when I walked in. I saw some slices behind the counter with shaved ham and sesame seeds on the crust. He asked me what I was looking at and I told him I wanted to make sure there was no pineapple. He laughed and said, "No judgement" -- I told him I do judge and I'm glad no pineapple was in sight! He took a slice and heated it up and gave it to me to eat (for free!) while I was waiting for the rest of my order. The sesame seeds on the crust were a revelation!! I loved the place so much I came back a second time a day later. If you are looking for fantastic NY pizza, this is the place. Oh, and the chicken Caesar salad was really good, too.

Pizza is decent, drink selection could be better. Gatorade is a good option though. For the love of…read moregod, though, they need functional AC. Mostly just a nostalgia blast for alumni from my point of view, but still worth a visit for a slice.

Great family owned restaurant located up on the mountain side with indoor & outdoor seating…read moreavailable. There's a jukebox inside to play music off your phone to set a mood. Small located in the front but we decided for one of their tables inside. The staff were very nice and the food was very filling. My turkey sandwich was stacked high with fresh meat and the chipotle sauce gave it a little heat. My fiancé's chicken sandwich had a nice juicy breaded chicken breast on top which overloaded the bun

If you get a chance to eat here you won't be disappointed. Very friendly place and great food…read more Good portions.

The subs at the shop are no longer a good value. The large hot sub is $15 but it's made on a very…read morenarrow roll and even then many bites were only bread due to the small amount of chicken on it. The cold sub we got was also very minimally filled. We ordered online and the system is not set up very well- lettuce isn't listed as an add on, so I thought it came on the sub by default. There's no options for condiments and everything else is listed as "add extra" But what that really means is do you want ANY of this on your sub-not extra. I paid $15 for a very dry roll with three very small chicken fingers and a few pieces of onion.

Retsof's best pizza!! The wings were also so so delish!…read more I didn't get to sit down because my date just wanted to take it home. He doesn't like to bring me into public. Which is why I can't speak to the ambiance. But he said that the service was good and it was really quick! He will definitely be returning!

Uhmm... where's all the food? This place is a gas station with a pizzeria built into it (which…read moredidn't seem to be all that functional), but where there should be aisles of convenience store food there's only a wide open space for God knows what. Probably square dancing or honky tonkin', but not for storing shelves of food. All they had for sale at this store were beverages, an assortment of jerky snacks, a few small bags of chips and some over-priced, under-sized brownies that appeared homemade. The brownies didn't look all that appealing. I get that this place is a sleepy town, and that the most lucrative trades are probably funeral home director, coffin maker and mortician (the death trades), but considering this gas station doesn't appear to fit the mold of the convenient store, and it doesn't seem to be in the death trades, then it must be a front for a methamphetamine dealership. Enjoy.

Their pizza used to be very good, then they must have changed ingredients. Bad idea. Add in one…read moreof the employees being rude to me and they lost me as a customer. They avoid the one star "Eek!" because the subs were decent when I had them.

I placed an order and the man on the phone was extremely rude, our food was 2 hours late, and we…read moregot no updates!! I wish I ordered somewhere else!!!

I have always loved pizza Paul's they have great pizza and wings. but lately they have been going…read moredownhill had a problem with not having enough sauce on the wings. The past couple times I have ordered from the Geneseo store and have specifically asked for the wings to be saucy and extra sauce. I get them and they are barely coated. In the past, I have never had a problem with any of their food, but it seems more and more at the Geneseo store that they either don't care. Or they're just slipping if I'm paying what I pay for wings in getting this poor quality I'm better off making them at home and spending less money. They really need to step their game up again needless to say this will be the last time. I'm ordering wings from them and I'm considering taking my entire business elsewhere.

We've been eating here since they opened and we love it! Their pizza and wings are so consistently…read moregood. The service is friendly! The garlic parm wings with the homemade blue cheese is my go to!

This is St. Patrick's Day and Eric has a Rueben Calzone today as one of his Monday specials. I…read moreordered ahead and arrived about 5:15. My order was just coming out of the oven so perfect timing. They included a delicious "thousand island" homemade sauce whose flavor absolutely complemented the tasty sandwich. Normally, Eric features either a meatball sub or a beef on wick. Having now tried both you better order ahead of time as he sells out every Monday.

Not only was the food delicious but it was fun to share several things together. We came for a…read morebelated birthday celebration and not only did they make sure to say happy birthday they give you a slice of the oatmeal cake for free! Our server was lovely and I loved the low lighting inside. I would 100% suggest going with the expectation to share. They keep larger utensils at the at the table for just that! And they list on the menu the portion sizes so you can get an idea for each item.

Stopped in here on a Friday night. Got seated promptly. Waitress was friendly and attentive. She…read moreexplained that the food comes out as it is ready. Some things take longer than others. Lots Of the dishes are shareable. The bread was amazing. I ordered the bone in pork chop, mashed potatoes, and apple slaw. The pork chop was tender and had a nice crispy coating. The mashed potatoes were delicious and flavorful with the bacon and cheese. I didn't like the apple slaw which consisted of apples, slaw, and onions. It did have a good light vinegar dressing. Overall, good meal. I had my dinner ate before the rest of the table received their burgers.