For a little ice cream stop around town, it was no frills but got the job done. There are sundaes…read moreand waffle cones and toppings galore, but I just wanted a scoop of ice cream which was promptly delivered from the order window form the vestibule booth with some bench seating available on the sidewalk. The sea salt caramel coffee sounded like an interesting flavor, so I gave that a try. It was creamy and tasted very good. It hit the spot on a hot day.

Awful customer service. My 6 year old son walked out of the store dropped his ice cream I asked if…read morethey could replace since he didn't even get a bite of it and they said absolutely not. Had to pay for another ice cream. Ummm thanks for being so gracious.

Excellent ice cream. I'd seen a recommendation for this place on a baseball thread in Reddit, of…read moreall places, & it was spot-on. Reasonable, good choice of flavors. I got the soft serve "twist," my friend got a hard flavor. We both said it was "as good as any other we've ever had" & we are both ice cream afficionados. Reasonably priced, good-sized portions. A bit hard to find as the address is Rt 28 but it's in the back. Nice array of pigs, chickens, ducks, a cow & several goats in the back. We're "city" people so enjoyed seeing the animals almost as much as we did eating the ice cream.

Cooperstown seems like the ice cream haven or something. As we drove here from my mom's we passed…read moreby like 6 places. I only wish we could have tried them all. I picked this as the 2nd place to try our following night after dinner. No one was disappointed. If you can only go to one ice cream place I'd go to this or the other one I went to if you look at my reviews :P

A wonderful store with many different items, including souvenirs, candy and syrup, and chocolate…read moretruffles as well. Many unique items for sale in this store. I found maple syrup in a cool jar, and some delicious chocolate too. Definitely recommend to check this store out while in downtown Cooperstown.

The best candy anyplace Fresh candy, excellent old fashioned…read morefriendly service Can have your own box assortment of as many as you like A great place for one of a kind gifts that will be rememberd Bottom line Will be back Carl L

The Gelati is nice but costs are high, service is slow, staff rude. It isn't worth it with so many…read moreshops to get icecream from.

Employees are so unprofessional and rude. The food is in such small quantities for such a high…read moreprice. The store also definitely needs some updates.

One of my favorite Stewart's in the area. Well run, organized, great staff! Had a limited amount…read moreof time the other day to get my sandwiches made and out the door. The manager Katie jumped right in, got me ready in less than 5 minutes and everything was delicious and fresh! Thank you!!

They have some good staffing, but the cleanliness is absolutely disgusting and they're always…read morescrambling because I feel as if this place isn't possibly managed properly or maybe even staffed properly for as busy as this town has, and it makes it hard on some of the workers when the previous employers haven't completed their tasks that they're supposed to. We know who the good workers are. I feel as if this store needs to be a evaluated on how it can be run a little better, so things go smoother and cleaned properly. I feel how Stewart's is having. Their cleaning done isn't working especially with this store. I find myself just not coming here anymore because it's always just such a shit show and would rather just avoid it. I just make my stops for bagels and ice cream and I dread that stop. This is not how a customer should feel about their experience at Stewart's.

Top shelf chocolate milkshake. Thanks to Jeff for the…read morecomplimentary swag, and for humoring me as I shared a few stories. Great atmosphere; I had no idea the scale and wish I'd had more time to take a closer look around. A true gem. A slice of Americana. Truly a must visit if you're visiting Cooperstown. If you're a local: I'm jealous.

We held our team party here one evening, and overall it was a great experience…read more The food was excellent. The burgers are generous in size and very well prepared, and the milkshakes and ice cream were outstanding. A couple of things to keep in mind: while the quality of the food is high, the prices are also quite high, comparable to what you might expect in New York City. In addition, service is primarily counter-ordering rather than full table service. For larger groups, a gratuity may be automatically added to the bill, and you may still be prompted to leave an additional tip, so it's worth reviewing the check carefully.

Beautiful outdoor setting close to Dreams Park! A great spot for wiffle ball and outdoor fun with…read morefamily and teammates! Unfortunately, the food was just ok and super overpriced. I was happy to get the Mexican salad but adding chicken costs $6 and you get maybe 2oz of chicken. The best thing on the menu was the nachos!

Place is cool and the ice cream is great but the food is awful and over priced. I paid $18 for a…read moremeal my 8 year old could have made. Probably should skip this one

Such a great place to get ice cream and hang out. There's some food trucks there too…read more The people were super friendly and gave us some tips on fishing spots when they heard us talking about fishing. And the ice cream was so good. We all got something different and all loved it.

Locally sourced homemade ice cream made at local dairy farm. Creative selection of flavors with the…read morecoffee brownie swirl being absolutely decedent! Homemade waffle cones and super friendly service. Much better than the downtown places serving Hershey varieties.

The restaurant had an inviting interior and good jazz background music. The food portions were…read morequite large and came out quickly. The Italian bread was fresh, warm and very tasty. There were many shrimp in the Scampi along with fresh asparagus, broccoli, spinach, capers and garlic. The chicken was cooked perfectly and tender. The sauce was delicious. The owner was very pleasant and nice to deal with.

Very nice ambiance, great service, good wine list. Solid Italian meal…read more I had the chicken Marsala wich was plentiful and well done the wife had linguini with clams also very well done