Excellent ice cream. I'd seen a recommendation for this place on a baseball thread in Reddit, of…read moreall places, & it was spot-on. Reasonable, good choice of flavors. I got the soft serve "twist," my friend got a hard flavor. We both said it was "as good as any other we've ever had" & we are both ice cream afficionados. Reasonably priced, good-sized portions. A bit hard to find as the address is Rt 28 but it's in the back. Nice array of pigs, chickens, ducks, a cow & several goats in the back. We're "city" people so enjoyed seeing the animals almost as much as we did eating the ice cream.

Cooperstown seems like the ice cream haven or something. As we drove here from my mom's we passed…read moreby like 6 places. I only wish we could have tried them all. I picked this as the 2nd place to try our following night after dinner. No one was disappointed. If you can only go to one ice cream place I'd go to this or the other one I went to if you look at my reviews :P

Really torn between giving a 3 star vs 4 star rating. Location and space is great, covered seating…read morearea was great for pin trading and eating in the shade. Plenty of lawn games and the ice cream!!! What kid doesn't love a place that serves ice cream?! The plain quesadilla was good! Wasn't just cheese but a mix of black beans and red pepper onions and corn. The BLT was okay, the bacon was extra crispy and paper thin.

Great tasting ice cream. I was surprised that the mix ins were totally blended in so that there…read morewere no chunks. It would be better if you could ask for half mixed/hand mixed or extra toppings on top

Such an adorable place! We loved the vibe and the service! Amazing selections of ice cream…read moreflavors. So glad we came here after a late game at Cooperstown Dreams Park.

I came here the other day with my family, and when we went it was pretty great, so we came back …read more The service was friendly unlike what i've read in many of the reviews Also the serving sizes are crazyyy! But not crazy small, crazy big! I loved that we got what we paid for and it was pretty great tasting too.

The best candy anyplace Fresh candy, excellent old fashioned…read morefriendly service Can have your own box assortment of as many as you like A great place for one of a kind gifts that will be rememberd Bottom line Will be back Carl L

A wonderful store with many different items, including souvenirs, candy and syrup, and chocolate…read moretruffles as well. Many unique items for sale in this store. I found maple syrup in a cool jar, and some delicious chocolate too. Definitely recommend to check this store out while in downtown Cooperstown.

For a little ice cream stop around town, it was no frills but got the job done. There are sundaes…read moreand waffle cones and toppings galore, but I just wanted a scoop of ice cream which was promptly delivered from the order window form the vestibule booth with some bench seating available on the sidewalk. The sea salt caramel coffee sounded like an interesting flavor, so I gave that a try. It was creamy and tasted very good. It hit the spot on a hot day.

Very cute spot with a nice variety of ice cream. Everyone is super friendly. Definately a must…read morevisit when you are in the area.

One of my favorite Stewart's in the area. Well run, organized, great staff! Had a limited amount…read moreof time the other day to get my sandwiches made and out the door. The manager Katie jumped right in, got me ready in less than 5 minutes and everything was delicious and fresh! Thank you!!

They have some good staffing, but the cleanliness is absolutely disgusting and they're always…read morescrambling because I feel as if this place isn't possibly managed properly or maybe even staffed properly for as busy as this town has, and it makes it hard on some of the workers when the previous employers haven't completed their tasks that they're supposed to. We know who the good workers are. I feel as if this store needs to be a evaluated on how it can be run a little better, so things go smoother and cleaned properly. I feel how Stewart's is having. Their cleaning done isn't working especially with this store. I find myself just not coming here anymore because it's always just such a shit show and would rather just avoid it. I just make my stops for bagels and ice cream and I dread that stop. This is not how a customer should feel about their experience at Stewart's.

Beautiful moon and pop spot. Nice scene to sit and eat. Prices are amazing . People are friendlyread more

Pop's Place has some of the best ice cream I've had! There are so many flavors, both classic ones…read morelike strawberry and unique ones like pineapple orange. And the texture is perfect! It's creamy and rich, unlike some other places where the ice cream can feel "airy." This ice cream is not like that at all. It's super refreshing especially with the insane heat in the summer as well. And the portions they give are huge! So worth the price. We got two ginormous double scoops, one in a cone and one in a cup, for around $7. The workers are really friendly and will give recommendations for flavors if you're super indecisive like I am:P The location is also really great especially if you're at the Cooperstown baseball field which is only minute away on the freeway. Can't wait to be back here!

The Gelati is nice but costs are high, service is slow, staff rude. It isn't worth it with so many…read moreshops to get icecream from.

Employees are so unprofessional and rude. The food is in such small quantities for such a high…read moreprice. The store also definitely needs some updates.

Great ice cream as well as great food Very good service…read moreevery time Connie is especially good Looking forward to Spring reopening datr We will be back Carl L

We had our team party here one night. The organization paid for the children and the parents…read moreordered, paid and ate on their own and separately. Everything was excellent. Chili was very good. I got the mushroom, onion burger with Swiss and that was solid as well. Plenty of space and the players had a ball playing outside. The owner was excellent with the kids as well. Only thing, which is kind of my fault but also a double edged sword, is that add a tip to every order but then ask you to choose a tip amount as well. I would've never noticed but my receipt was texted to my older son and he noticed it and texted me saying..... You realize you double tipped, right? And sent me a picture. It was aggravating, but partly my fault. Food and service was great, just be careful prior to leaving a tip.