This place goes between a 1 star and a 4 star. The past two times my family ate here, we ordered sirloin steaks. The ribeye is usually too fatty, the New York is very dry and the filet mignon is just a hit or miss. We've eaten here and it's been extremely delicious. But we've also eaten here and are disgusted. They just aren't consistent. So, last time we ordered two sirloin steak for pick up. What we actually got was a New York and some other piece of meat that was about 1/4 inch thick on one side and 2 inches thick on the other. It was like cutting and eating cardboard. $80 for a couple of meals we wouldn't even feed to our dogs. This has happened too many times. You never know what you're gonna get when you eat here. I'm not willing to waste my money eating here anymore. read more

My friend recommended me to try this place. But it was a disappointment. We ordered the rib&steak and the dream team sampler. We asked for medium rare steaks. The steak taste pretty bad, the meat texture and quality is not decent. The rib is pretty good but not worth the price. The onion ring is pretty good though. Overall we spent around $50 on this meal which I would rather spend at the gas station bbq place. read more

The Hickory - Barbeque Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

This place is pretty good. I think their menus are a little strange and they aren't always the fastest, but I love the food. I think their BBQ sauce is pretty delicious too. Great place to eat!! read more

Was a very packed Friday night, but the staff was doing a great job. The 3 meat platter was very good. Bacon and green beans were good. Will go back. read more

The Hickory - Ribs, pulled pork, brisket, green beans, baked beans - Barbeque Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Food was amazing! We are visiting from California and impress by the quality and service! The hostess is super sweet and our waitress was amazing large portions and very delicious pulled pork ! read more

The Hickory - Pulled pork Bourbon BBQ - Barbeque Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

When we ate at The Hickory half the tables were empty, still took us 40min to be seated. Food is lacking flavor. All food was lukewarm. Top Serlion: Ordered a medium steak that was rare , when asked the server she told us it was cooked correctly. French Dip There was more meat on my side than on the sandwich, the bread was soaked with garlic butter. Alaskan COD & Fried Pickles Both were served semi warm, and extremely heavy not sure if they sat in the oil if the oil wasn't hot enough, something was wrong Food is over priced if they are going to charge for the sides "that come with your meal" $25.00 extra in sides. Had to ask for sauces that came with the meal. The server didn't refill drinks once that were "BOTTOMLESS" just get water unless you want to pay $4.00 for single non alcoholic drink. There was a $20 forced gratuity for 3 people and then they asked if I would add to the gratuity. Hickory used to be one of my favorites, I would rather go across the street to Arby's or Jack in The Box. This is the 4th and final bad experience I have had at the hickory in a row. Others eating tonight also said the same thing. As a local I used to recommend The Hickory. read more

This was recommended by family with glowing reviews. I have to say they were right. It of course is s BBQ and the smell is absolutely amazing! The menu is traditional BBQ. The staff is friendly welcoming and attentive. The BBQ melts in your mouth. A go to for BBQ in eastern Idaho. read more

Great service but horrible food. The buns on the burgers are some weird spongy bread... everything was bland.

Went a few weeks ago in the middle of the day on a weekday. Took a while to be seated even though it wasn't busy at all (just 2 other tables). Got seated and waited for 15 minutes to be offered water, get a order in or really any sort of acknowledgment. After a total of waiting for 20 minutes of waiting we just left and went some place else to eat. read more

Great atmosphere and quality food. Great place for a diverse menu. Burgers and BBQ meat. Good options for kids. Ordered a Gordo burger. Nice Pattie. Quality beef. Swiss cheese and pastrami. Oh ya! Handmade bun. 8oz bourbon pulled pork and hand battered onion rings on the side. The pulled pork was superb! Definitely quality food. Adding this to our favorite. We'll be here again. read more

Had my cousins 59th surprise party here there were 19 of us we had one server he did a great job the restaurant is beautiful the food was great everyone there was nice Nate I believe he is the manager was very helpful setting this up for me. read more

This place used to be super good. But it has seriously gone way down hill. They have changed so many great meals arhat are now just awful. The last 3x my family and I went here food was terrible and over priced. The TBA has been my favorite since my first time here. Now it's disgusting. They changed the bread and instead of real avocado it now has some kind of salsa which is awful. The prime rib always used to be great now it has no flavor almost had a dirty ester taste to it. Will not be returning any more. read more

Just ok. I wanted to love this place. We had a larger party, 6 adults and 6 little kids. Each of us got something different and nothing was fantastic. My husband had a steak that was so incredibly salty. Anything that was deep fried was nothing to remember. Nothing was bad! I just had higher expectations. read more

Pretty delicious BBQ joint! Creative menu items. Amazing baked mac-n-cheese! Service is good. Great place to take family when they come into town. read more

This place is the reason for the origination of the phrase "hit or miss" restaurant. When it's good food, they nail it. Brisket, steak, shrimp, prime rib, burger- all can be fabulous. But other times the Turkey is dry and cold, the brisket is leathery dry and burned beyond recognition, and the steak is so salty you'll taste it into next week. The sides are much more consistent- mac and cheese is always tasty, as are the green beans and salads. They also have some fun drinks. And let's face it- we all have off days, and the good days are good enough that I'll keep coming back, hoping for the sublime experience of a juicy beef brisket. Also, the staff is helpful and will try to make it right if you've been disappointed. read more

Oh my goodness. Very good meals. We did cowboy, cowgirl and bbq sandwich. My family was impressed and we have been back several times. Scones are to live for! read more

Lemme start by saying this. For Rexburg you just have to lower your standards for food. My sister and a couple of friends and I have two different rating systems. One is just in general like compared to all the places we've been around the world based on price, quality, service, atmosphere, taste etc. The second rating system is called "Rexburg standards" it's based off of the same thing however we lower the expectations because Rexburg's food and service and everything in general is just not superb compared to the rest of the US and world lol. That's why I give this place 5 stars because for Rexburg standards it's good! Probably the nicest place in Rexburg! The service is good, quality is good, food is good, price is good. All around is good. This is the best place to eat in Rexburg. read more

If you're looking for good smoked bbq I would avoid this place. The restaurant is cute, the service is good, but the food is meh. My husband and I have been here a few times and have never liked what we've ordered. read more

I love the Hickory! This restaurant actually catered my wedding. The Mac n cheese is my favorite and the flavored lemonades are to die for!!! The quality of the food is great. read more

See all

Just went there for the first time a little pricy but good food I recommend there meat platter with barbecue chicken and get some Italian soda. More on pricing:so I went with 6 guys including myself and the total was 120 but the meat is all really good quality and we all got 15 dollar meals or more. Would not recommend seafood options it was a good environment for families and chilling with friends read more

LOVED the Potato bomb! It was sooo huge! We ordered it to go and my husband and I only ate 1/4th of it together! Such a great deal as it comes with 2 sides and is only $8.99! Our girls loved their kids meal too. read more

The Hickory - After we ate as much as we could! So good!! Sorry the pic isn't the greatest. - Barbeque Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

See all

One of the best in Rexburg. Pulled pork compares with some of the best barbecue around. Appetizers are well rounded. And the service is fantastic. Sydney was attentive and friendly. The location is good, but the parking is limited. Safe environment and the place is very clean. Great experience. read more

Sides, shakes and my kids food were good. I ordered a steak medium rare and it came very over cooked. I mentioned to the waitress when they checked but no real acknowledgement from them about it. When the check came I saw they had put the order in as medium well. Such a waste of meat, I couldn't finish it. read more

The Hickory - Overcooked Filet Mignon - Barbeque Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Food is inconsistent. At best the food is mediocre at worst it's cold and meh. We try it every once in a while to see if it gets better but it never does. Service is friendly but slow. The place is pretty clean and has a good atmosphere. I really wish it was good because Rexburg needs a solid sit down place but it's always disappointing. read more

Yum-o! My favorite here is the turkey dinner. Always delicious sliced turkey, good mashed potatoes, good mac n cheese. Love the baby bakers. Very nice choices of flavored sodas. Good atmosphere. Only downsides are desserts and bathrooms. Desserts (I have tried three different ones) are always a miss. I usually love apple cobbler and wanted to like the apple-berry cobbler, but it was a soupy mess, as was peach cobbler. And bathrooms are single stall and often smelly. So just skip dessert and you'll be great! read more

onth ago First time I went was on a busy Friday night, we called ahead for a table and still had to wait 30 mins to be seated(expected for a weekend) the food was delicious, the brisket and pulled pork and it hit the spot. We only saw our server twice, to take our order and then bring us our food and the check at the same time. Went a second time( 6 months later) and the service was super quick( it was a Thursday night) and our server was a great help! I had the Honey Badger Burger and it was out of this world! It was so yummy that I went back a week later and had the same burger and it was just as good. Definitely a great place to go, midweek has a quicker seat time. :) read more

AMAZING FOOD, DRINKS, and SERVICE!!!! Definitely stop here!!!! The baby back ribs, cranberry apple salad, baked beans and the MUDDY DR. PEPPER= KILLER!!!! read more

The Hickory - Muddy Dr. Pepper - Barbeque Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

the food never disappoints and the service is exceptional. we loved our server Adeline!

Looking for great BBQ in Rexburg? Found it! While passing through town on vacation from Rhode Island, a local (thank you Mandy) told us about this place. She was spot-on with the recommendation. The Brisket Stacker burger was great and the sweet potato dipping sauce should be bottled for nationwide sale! Service was amazing. Thank you Kelcy, and don't forget the vinegar for those amazing fries! read more

The Hickory - Barbeque Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

In a strip mall, almost missed it. Huge mason jars of lemonade in gazillion flavors. I had the hucklebery, very refreshing. I ordered a combo: ribs and brisket. The ribs were fairly meaty, looked a little burned which I usually don't mind, but they were dry on the top and moist underneath. The brisket was quite lean, 3 thick slices surprizingly tender considering the thickness, but not a whole lot of flavor. Combo came with 2 sides, and they have a lot of choices, and a biscuit. My 2 sides were allegedly handcut french fries and green beans with bacon. The green beans were fresh at some point earlier today but must have been sitting in a pot of water all day because they were mushy (I did ask for them 2b well done) and the bacon wasn't crisp or brown but grey and limp. Their dessert board looked great. I ordered huckleberry cheesecake; regular cheesecake with huckleberry compote on top. I left full with leftover brisket, and an hour later still feel grease in my mouth but can't figure out from what. If I was in town longer I might consider going back but earlier in the day for fresh food, not at 8pm when they close at 9pm i.e. I think I got the last dregs of things. read more

The Hickory - Barbeque Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

We decided to try The Hickory because we heard the shrimp was good. The shrimp was okay, but how can you eat shrimp without cocktail sauce. They said they were out but suggested jalapeño something or other. Yuck! Have you ever gone to a place to eat knowing that you are going to get shrimp and fully expecting to enjoy the shrimp with cocktail sauce. Enough ranting about the cocktail sauce. If you do decide to go to The Hickory, take a jacket. It is chilly for sure. Just one more thing, there is an Albertsons grocery store just across the street. If you are craving shrimp with cocktail sauce you may want to make a quick stop before you go. read more

Food is good! And prices are rightI think we got a bum waiter though because our fries and onion rings came out cold. Not to mention a 30 min wait on Mac and Cheese... what?? They really are good at steak and the atmosphere is fun. Definitely a lot to look at. And pie shakes are amazing!! Would have been a lot better if our waiter had a bit more pep in his step and our food came out warm... read more

The Hickory - Fun decor!! First time here, super busy so it must be good! - Barbeque Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

Great food/great service. We are up here from out of town. Kyla was fantastic. She took care of all our needs. Turkey Bacon Spinach wraps...the best! Sweet potato fries + a special sweet dipping sauce...I've never had anything like it. Turkey noodle soup is ah-may-zing. Only get a cup though...if you get a bowl, you'll be too full for anything else. Great family atmosphere. Saw lots of little kids hugging the servers good-bye...they really cater to everyone there. read more

The fried Mac n cheese is fantastic tried it for the first time highly recommend. The person who picked up the phone was kind and friendly good service chief.! read more

Prices were average for BBQ. Disappointed most that we ordered two sandwiches of the same price and one came with at least a third more meat. Sides: mashed potatoes and brown gravy; potatoes were decent but the gravy was mostly salt and not much flavor. Coleslaw was average. The sandwiches were yummy though, and the drink flavors are fun. read more

I've read reviews about poor service but after going twice (both around lunch time) I haven't had a problem. The first time I got their brisket sandwich, it was incredibly juicy and flavorful! The second time I got the honey badger burger. While it was really good it wasn't my favorite- it has pulled pork wrapped in pastrami topped with bacon and also has a beef patty. There were too many competing flavors and it was a bit too greasy. Then again when you order something with that much meat that's too be expected. However, I had their sweet potato fries and they really impressed me. They weren't soggy but perfectly cooked with a slight crisp. Overall, I love the atmosphere, service, and quality of food. I can't wait to try more of their menu! read more

The Hickory - The honey badger: pulled pork wrapped in pastrami and topped with bacon. Also has a beef patty. - Barbeque Near Me - Rexburg, Idaho

I've eaten at the hickory many times and it has always been a good choice! A great restaurant for a couple or a group. Food is good and the services is also great! read more

Great BBQ, very busy, waitstaff is friendly. My husband and I shared a 3 meat platter. We ordered a Baked Potato, and green bean bacon side. We didn't get the Baked Potato, instead we had bbq beans. We chose not to say anything about the missing Baked Potato! read more

Love this place. Their burgers, steak, meats and sides are all great. Oh and the fried cheese curds!!

If you must have a steak, or prime rib there are few alternatives in Rexburg, but when thinking of the Hickory, consider staying home. For BBQ there are much better alternatives in Rexburg. Two visits yielded a cold, not just not hot, cold baked potato, overcooked dry chicken, and limp salad. read more