The strawberry cheesecake? ice cream sandwich was great. Pretty pricey $7 for a single ice cream sandwich but otherwise, tasty. I personally don't think I'd eat another one due to the price (I can legit buy a whole lunch with that kind of money) unless I was really craving it. read more

Shout out to a local bakery that will help you even with the oddball requests. After walking around for an hour in the neighborhood looking in every store for sprinkles to decorate my own cake I asked for their help. The cashier was super friendly about the request and went to ask the manager. She came back with a container full for me! I already liked this place but now I love it. Great coffee and baked goods and even better customer care! read more

I was so excited to try their ice cream sandwich... Every time I attempted to buy one, they were always sold out. And then finally it was my day - a day of huge disappointment. I don't know what people see in this overpriced ice cream sandwich. First of all, I have never had an ice cream sandwich where the ice cream did not reach the runs of the cookie. That was my first problem! So I had to eat just the cookie to get to the best part of an ICE CREAM sandwich. As I tried to eat the salty cookie, I couldn't take it anymore... I just began to break off pieces of the cookie and threw it out. What a waste of $6! Never again. read more

I had the rocky road and it was yummy. A chocolate lovers dream but for me it was too overwhelming. I should've gone with my first choice and ordered the vanilla. That being said it was so good I still finished it. It took to of us to eat it cuz it was so big and we waited till we finished eating all the savory foods. I would def recommend this spot at smorgasburg ! read more

The Good Batch - Rocky road. Chocolate lovers heaven - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

STROOPWAFEL debate, GO! The ones here are delicious, and certainly are very much like the ones I ate during multiple visits to the Netherlands, from Friesland to Utrecht. I ate one a day whenever in the NL, much as I would eat Jamon once a day whenever in Spain; delicious local product! Sooo... since there is such a split here at Yelp on the good/mediocre punch to the stroop at Good Batch, here's what: this is how the baker here chose to make them, as do bakers in SOME of the NL shops. Right? Right! These are excellent. Don't trust the naysayers, go try one for yourself. And if they're too spicy (these do have a heavier hand with the cinnamon & perhaps allspice) then this is NYC, you'll find them better suited to your tastes elsewhere ;) read more

Smore Ice cream Sandwich was Fantastic. Costs Six dollars and is decent size. So good. read more

The Good Batch is by far one of the best pastry companies in Brooklyn, and one of the most talked-about. They are a talented group of bakers who clearly love what they do. Make sure to visit them early at Smorgusburg in the summer to try their amazing ice cream sandwiches. Or nom on some Honey Bears, Compost Bars, and Brown Butter Salties. You can't go wrong! read more

Had a sweet tooth and decided to stop by The Good Batch before heading home. With a variety of sweet on display I went with what was recommended by the staff. Got myself the brownie (recommended), the chai cake, and coconut cream puff. That's definitely lot of sweet for one person lol, but I'm not your ordinary person and 3 is definitely doable. When it comes to sweet, I personally DO NOT like anything that's too sweet and all 3 pastry were definitely not too sweet nor too little if such a thing is possible. My personal favorite was definitely the chai, I may be a sucker when it comes to chai but that cream on top of the pastry did it for me. The other 2 were just ok. The biggest let down were the dryness of the pastries. But it could be because I went in an hour before they close, taking that into consideration, I'm not gonna say more. I definitely got my fill of sweet, but will be back next time around for fresh treats. read more

The Good Batch - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I first tried one ice cream sandwich and it was OK. Then I tried another one and I almost died in ecstasy... Then my roommate brought another type.. and wow. We were blown away by its perfection. I am a very picky sweets and ice cream eater, so for me to say this is rare. My only request/suggestion: Perhaps make these sandwiches in a smaller size (so it's less but you still make more money by selling more per parts). I think this would attract more customers like myself to come back more frequently to get little bites than big overdoses. read more

OMG... wasn't even plan on going in The Good Batch but the white and powder blue sign pulled me in and I got a few things first was the Goodwich ice cream sandwich taste nothing like what I thought. But what it taste like was good it had a hint of a coconut taste and a tiny salty with the chocolate was heaven read more

See all

This review is for the woman working at smorgasburg. Although the rice crispy ice cream sandwich is amazing. The lady working at smorgasburg has the worst attitude and always looks aggravated. Not sure if she's one of the owners or not but I have seen her at both the Williamsburg location and the Prospect Park smorgasburg. No matter how nice you approach her she looks like she is ready to snap at you and is so rude. God forbid you ask her a question. Horrible way to do business. I realized since seeing her in both smorgasburg locations that she is like this all the time. Saw another review that someone said this as well. She's usually with another guy and he seems nice but she is very unwelcoming. Yeah...smorgasburg is very traffic heavy but you signed up for this and no one is forcing you to be there. I must say I do love the crispy ice cream sandwich but would not give my money to this business because of my continued awful experiences with this woman. If you don't enjoy what you do...no need to take your anger out on your customers. They are what's helping your business grow. Oh and if she is the business owner. Shame on her. read more

This was my first time going in. The prices was favorable high which need to be fix on this app but I guess the dollar signs are based on highest price. At the moment I didn't care because I needed something small. What I took notice was how the customer rep at the time (not sure if it was owner or cashier rep) took care of me. He was very unpleasant. He didn't seem to want to serve me, as a first time customer I usually expect a cheery attitude. Especially from local shops. Everything was fairly new to me when I walked in. So, I need a bit of help. During the interaction it was as if he didn't want to help me. I ask about cup sizes and when I finally bought my drink and ask for a lid. He looked at me and said it's behind you, as if I was suppose to know. Even as I was leaving, he had walk towards the direction I was walking. I said thank you again for your help. Just to be polite and he literally said uh huh to me. Then right after I walked out, he walked off too from out the shop. So, I guess he's the owner. I guess he had to go somewhere so he was preoccupied. I left feeling unwelcome and honestly not wanting to go back every again. I would hate to say I know why he treated me like that, but I do. It just makes me sad to think that even in a neighborhood so diverse, I got treated with little care because of who I am. I don't will never ever be back. It's really sad because customer service has been lacking recently in establishments. When customer service should be the first thing any business teaches. If you don't want to deal with people then don't work in a customer based job or own a customer based company. However, if you are going to work with people then be a people person. I'm not saying you have to be over the moon but treat me as if I am a human being with emotions. I'm spending my money. I should feel welcome and not tolerated. I just was very sad at this and regret that I even spent money here. The place is cute and the set is nice but the customer service just made this a place not worth the visit again. And the price just made it even more a concrete decision that I won't be coming back. read more

Lauren and her staff were absolutely amazing! They catered for our wedding favors - a variety of cookies and every one was amazingly delicious. Everyone keeps talking about how great the favors were. Thank you so very much!! Blessings read more

Delicious!! I highly recommend going and trying all the flavors. The salted oatmeal was superb and the hot chocolate flavor was next level. Great experience. read more

Sufficiently friendly folks at the end of an opening day Flea sesh and some unique offerings. Had the stroopwafel, which, echoing Rachel, was quite good (though I wasn't wowed enough to ever get it again). Samples were a nice touch and the things are cheap and hold better in the sun than you'd expect. Will definitely hit them up next time around if they have the more-enticing Bonfires left. read more

I've gotten something from here twice, but I'm just not impressed. I've had a cookie and a brownie, as well as a drink. The tea was very weak and watery, the brownie dry without much flavor, and the cookie tasted a bit old. Considering their prices, I think I'll get my baked goods elsewhere. read more

Best dessert in downtown Brooklyn, for sure!!! I tried the caramel ice cream cookie sandwich, the gooey treat with everything in it, and a fudge macaron cookie with pecan filling. Everything was yum! read more

Solid. Everything baked in house. Just sweet options but what they do they do well. Decent coffee. read more

The Good Batch - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This review is only for their ice cream sandwich stand at Smorgasborg. These ICS's are large (seriously, just look at the photos), and go for $6. The Crispy: 4 stars Sweet and satisfying, not many complex flavours. These cookies are big rice crispy discs drenched in marshmallow glue, wrapped around vanilla ice-cream. If you like Rice Krispy treats, this is the ICS for you. Toffee + Chocolate: 4 stars This one was really unique. Large and chewy almond cookie with crispy edges to impart that exotic almond / Asian flavour, mashed with rich chocolate ice cream. The Goodwich alleges to be crispy oatmeal cookies with sea-salt, fudge and vanilla ice-cream, and sounded like a gourmet It's It (but I love regular It's Itses so much!!) so I might try that next time. read more

Smorg place with a brick and mortar. Satisfying on a hot summer's day. read more

The Good Batch - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I had the oat chocolate chunk sandwich at the Smorgasburg (Williamsburg location). There was a long queue for the ice cream sandwich as we entered the lot and I was excited to try it out for dessert. And boy was I disappointed!!! I don't know what all the rave reviews are about. Maybe the ice cream sandwich at their store is much better than the atrocity I had. The bad: 1. The ice cream sandwich was hard as a rock. I'm thinking they used dry ice to freeze the dessert so they wouldn't melt while out at the fair. I nearly chipped my tooth trying to eat it! 2. Cookies were dry and salty. I couldn't bite into it bc it was so hard so I tried to break them into smaller pieces w my hands. Only thing i was able to achieve was to crumble the cookies around the block of hard ice cream. I did try out the crumbs but they tasted like saw dust. 3. To much salt in the cookies. A pinch of salt helps to enhance the chocolate flavor, but here, there was not a good balance. Instead of bringing out the chocolate, it masked it. This was the worst food I had at the Smorgasburg. What a waste of money! read more

I discovered this cookie at a girlfriends house. She was given them as a holiday gift and then my boyfriend and I tracked them down. There salty sugar cookie has officially changed my life... Their only location in Clinton Hill is charming and absolutely delicious, but they do ship as well! I promise you this place will rock your world. read more

Today was my first visit to this shop. It was great, lovely inside as far as decorations. It's not very spacious, so you may find it a little tight if you sit inside the store. I ordered the Birthday Cake Ice Cream sandwich, it was $7; a little pricey, but it was worth it. The Birthday Cake Ice cream sandwich comes with 2 sugar cookies that sandwich the ice cream. There are rainbow sprinkles, on the cookies and ice cream. It tasted just like a cake! There was a hint of lemon, which was awesome . My only con was that my wife is allergic to nuts, and they didn't have any non nut options in our first choice ice cream sandwich, which was the Vanilla Nutella Brownie. There is hazelnut on it. I wish there was a way to get it without the nuts, but it's not a deal breaker. read more

So good! Their 2pm-5pm M-F special of $1 cookies are to die for. The white chocolate raspberry one is especially good. Their chocolate chip cookie is also amazing! Really high quality overall. read more

See all

I saw so many people walking around Smorgasburg in Brooklyn with this ice cream sandwich. The cookie ice cream sandwich looked so good! The line was really long but it was so worth it. The ice cream and chocolate chip oatmeal cookie combination was divine. I need another one!!!! read more

See all

Ice cream sandwiches are delicious but I think they're a little overpriced. The coffee is great as well and since I live so close I'll probably be coming back very often. Ice cream and cute bakeries are also my kryptonite. read more

See all

I live and have lived in this neighborhood my whole life and the coffee here is my favorite. They've got great pastries (try the banana bread or the banana breakfast bun, my favorites). But the real reason I like this place so much is the service. There's a barista named Kyle who is, hands down, the best barista I've ever interacted with. He has memorized the orders of every single morning regular and always seems genuinely interested in how his customers are doing, what they have coming up in the day, how their weekends were, etc. He's got so much genuine positive energy and enthusiasm, I can tell he makes everyone feel a little bit better about their morning. I'm not one to write Yelp reviews but this guy deserves a 5-star review for how many good vibes he's consistently putting into the lives of all the people coming in here every morning. read more

Service with a smile, killer tunes, buttery yummy baked goods (rhubarb strawberry muffins and jalapeno cheddar scones!!!!) and a perfectly poured cortado. I come here often and am never disappointed. Thank you for making my day when I need a little pick-me-up. read more

Love this place... My daughter loves the ginger molasses cookies. The staff is friendly & the pastries are always delicious. read more

The Good Batch - Tasty! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place was great! To start off I got the gluten free brownie which was really tasty and not too grainy like most gluten free desserts are. My sister is obsessed with pumpkin so she had to get the pumpkin cookie( we couldn't remember the exact name) and she really liked it. I didn't have the chance to get one of their ice cream sandwiches because it was a little too cold outside for me, so I'm definitely looking forward to trying one in the future. read more

The Good Batch - Gluten free brownie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

So recently I saw this place on a tv show called "Unique Sweets" and I had to try. I ordered the Chocolate Nutella cookie ice cream sandwich. It was creamy, crunchy, and soooo delicious! Can't wait to try the other favors! read more

The Good Batch - About to indulge in this amazing huge ice cream sandwich! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Got the "Goodwich" (chocolate chip with sea salt cookie & vanilla ice cream, $5) at their stand on Governor's Island. Chocolate and sea salt is one of my favorite flavor combinations, so I had high hopes. The cookie is good, although it's more on the thin side. It was the right amount of soft to sink your teeth into and the right amount of crunch to uphold the integrity of the sandwich. Trés importante. Still, I would have preferred a heartier cookie with more chocolate chips. The vanilla ice cream was a classic, smooth, oldie-but-goodie. It's hard to go wrong. But it's also hard to make it particularly memorable. As a lactose intolerant who is picky about using lactaid pills, I thoroughly enjoyed my Goodwich, but I'm not sold on getting this particular flavor again. P.S. I would love to see the Good Batch make a dairy free ice cream sandwich. read more

The Good Batch - Goodwich, $5 - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The olive Oíl cake was stale and flavorless and the ice cream sandwich had freezer burn . IF YOUR GOING TO HAVE RACIST OWNERS AT LEAST MAKE SURE YOUR PRODUCT IS FRESH....I will definitely do my research before I patronize any store in Brooklyn especially due to the fact that's it's going through....gentrification it truly is a disgusting site like how those pastries tasted! read more

Solid coffee and the molasses cookie is perfection! The staff is always super kind too. Love this place and will be back time and time again. read more

Best ice cream sandwich in Brooklyn right now, unique, well-made and tasty! read more

Cake was a little dry. But frosting was nice. The ambiance of the place is cute to sit down for a little break or to do work. But that's it. read more

The Good Batch - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Love their cookies and it's like a limitless supply. My favorite is the oatmeal chocolate

So grateful to have this place in our neighborhood! Delicious coffee, lovely service, and incredible treats with plenty of fabulous gluten free options. They even have a small, extremely well-curated greeting card selection. I regularly rely on The Good Batch for morning caffeine, large orders of sweets to serve at a dinner party, and a beautiful place to read/hang out. Just love this place. read more

Great cup of coffee! Their selection of desserts in this neighborhood is unparalleled. A huge plus is the variety of vegan cookies, pumpkin bread, and non-dairy milks. I'm hoping they get vegan ice cream for vegan ice cream sandwiches in the future! The space is a little on the small side and there are people who occasionally camp out at the tables with their laptops taking away available space for people with friends, which is annoying, but the staff is really friendly and puts on good music without the pretension of most Brooklyn coffee shops. Definitely a must-try in the neighborhood! read more

I ordered a 12" birthday cake for my son's 3rd birthday. The cake was totally beautiful and delicious. Several party guests commented how good the cake was. I thought it was better than our wedding cake. Thank you Good Batch! read more