Cancel

Open app

Search

The Evercake

4.5 (162 reviews)
Closed 9:00 am - 5:00 pm
Updated 3 months ago

Get pricing & availability

Response time

40 minutes

Response rate

15%

Services - The Evercake

Catering

The Evercake Photos

Recommended Reviews - The Evercake

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

The service and product from The Evercake is amazing. The team was very responsive and had clear communication. The cake was even better than I imagined and more than that, it is one of the best tasting cakes I've ever had. I got the lemon and raspberry flavor. I can not recommending them enough. I will absolutely use them for every cake need.

Agnes T.

Evercake saved the day by accommodating my last minute (next day) request! The cake was absolutely gorgeous and was a hit at my party -- everyone loved it. It looks amazing but tastes even better (I got the strawberry shortcake flavor). I could not recommend Evercake more, it was also really seamless to communicate with them via text!

I live in New Orleans and was coming to NYC for a weekend to celebrate my parents' 50th wedding anniversary. I had a special candle, so I needed to find a special cake. How would I accomplish this mission from so far away? Through much internet searching I came across Evercake on Yelp and it seemed too good to be true. However, it was as good as it appeared!! The service was great - responsive, helpful, and friendly. I requested a cake size that wasn't listed on the website and it was no problem for the Evercake team. The ordering process was simple. I had to do it all out of sight since I was hundreds of miles away, and the cake would be delivered to a restaurant I had never been to. I felt confident that the Evercake team would help me with any issues that came up. They confirmed the delivery the day before and when I got to the restaurant, the cake was there waiting. When the waiter brought it out for the big moment, my parents were shocked and amazed. The cake was beautiful! We had the chocolate cake with chocolate fudge and it was delicious! 10/10 highly recommend Evercake.

The cake!
Pete S.

Incredible company to work with! They took my lack of design and just a little bit of an idea and created this fantastic, adorable, beautiful cake for our baby shower! Clyde and Alexis were quick, responsive and delivered the cake on time, with no issues! Also and maybe most importantly, the cake was delicious! Everyone at the party commented on how great the cake came out and how delicious it was! Thank you again!

Joanne U.

My friend's sister reached out to me at the last minute, 48 hours prior to the baby shower and asked for my help to bring the best possible cake for the event because I'm the best person to ask. I know, the amount of pressure, right? Anyway, not one to back down from a special assignment, I considered my favorite bake shops but was also mentally preparing myself that it might be impossible to order last Thursday and get it delivered by Saturday 2PM. Enter The EverCake. And may I say, ever delicious. And ever reliable. I guess I found a new favorite place for special event cakes! From the moment I started to coordinate with Alexis via emails on Thursday up to the time it was delivered, there was a lot of care and attention to detail. Very much appreciated. I met the delivery guy in front of the entrance of the space in Brooklyn. He was nice and polite and coordinated well with me so gave him additional tip. As for the cake itself, it was so beautiful and even more impressive in person. I got the 10'' Evercake Special in Pink Champagne and chose the Combination Dulce de Leche combination which had layers of chocolate and dulce de leche. Turned out to be the most delicious thing during the party and everyone either complimented, thanked, or ask where I got it from, to which I happily mentioned The Evercake. Consider me your new (free) endorser! The only minimal regret I have is that I wish I was told about the 10% Yelp offer as their cake is definitely not cheap at $125 (but hey you get what you pay for, right?) + it's a baby girl signage at $8.75 + $42 delivery fee to Brooklyn. Apparently the $25 delivery fee mentioned on their site is specific to Manhattan only so hope this helps. Overall, a happy customer. Highly recommended.

See all

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Loved the cake! If you want a cake that is FRESH, MOIST, and not only BEAUTIFUL, but simply DELICIOUS The Evercake is it!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 5 of 5

Ask the Community - The Evercake

Montagu's Gusto

Montagu's Gusto

4.2(240 reviews)
3.0 kmMurray Hill, Midtown East
$$

I had the "Nice To Greek You" salad with grilled chicken and it was honestly such a great choice…read more The grilled chicken was seasoned really well and added so much flavor to the salad. Everything tasted fresh, and the vinaigrette paired perfectly without being too heavy. The portion was super filling, which I always appreciate when it comes to salads. The service was also very sweet, welcoming, and quick, which made the whole experience even better. It's a great spot if you're looking for something fresh, satisfying, and easy--especially on a nice sunny day when you can sit back and enjoy the view. Definitely a place I'd come back to for salads, wraps, or sandwiches

Food Very fresh you see it being made to order ask for ur…read moretoppings or ask to have some removed No Problem Maria made mine to my order terrific & fast with No error ! Very busy lunch time on Saturday Wow ! Has to be Great place Took only a few minutes for my order to arrive from #28 I was #33 as a walk in . Maria is always a beautiful smile works very hard on telephone receiving order an in making an order to perfection Made it back unwrapped very professional paper first then foil wrapping and butcher block paper wrapping with a rubber band for securing the sandwich The deli is mostly made for take out but a few tables an a counter space in the front decorated very well white with lights an even many security cams Go online place your order is way more easier than waiting Also asked for no utensils but yes to napkins

Photos
Montagu's Gusto
Montagu's Gusto - Viva La GUSTA

Viva La GUSTA

Montagu's Gusto - M1. Venezia Moon Sandwich

See all

M1. Venezia Moon Sandwich

Savory - The Arugula- Baby Arugula, Humbolt Fog goat cheese, candied hazelnuts, roasted grapes, and balsamic vinaigrette

Savory

3.9(110 reviews)
2.8 kmMidtown West
Catering service
Offers customized solutions

Office held a tasting lunch today for food from Savory. Below is the list of food tried:…read more BOLLYWOOD (MUST HAVE): grilled curry chicken wtih avocado on top.. This thing is crazy good, and the meat and avoado ratio great. Could you slightly more meat, but I am picky. APPLE PIE POCKETS (MUST HAVE) - their take on McDonald's favorite apple pie: to me these things were like friend chinese dumplings/wontons that you would get with apple filling inside. wow different taste, and very delicious Atlantic Salmon Protein: I was quite excited to try this and loaded up my plate with the Atlantic salmon, but when I bit into it, it was not as good as I had imagined. While the Salmon is really meaty, i would say the it was poorly marinated (lots of seasoning on top though) Grilled Chicken BBQ: Chicken was good, but dont think the Orzo with wilted spinach and spring onion, grilled corn is a good match. Maybe try to pair it with Pesto and it would much better. Pesto: regular old pasta, but excellent. The pasta wasnt stiff or soft and was just right. White Chocolate, Chocolate Cookie: just your regular old cookie that you can get at the store. however the sides had some caramelized sugar on them

This is a great service they provide. Order off there menu everyday for lunch at work and presto…read moreit's delivered to my desk. Fresh sealed tight safe lunch in a pretty box. All fresh ingredients for a reasonable price.

Photos
Savory - The Kansas City- Pulled pork, classic KC BBQ sauce, pickle, and coleslaw.

The Kansas City- Pulled pork, classic KC BBQ sauce, pickle, and coleslaw.

Savory - 3 bowl, noodle salad

3 bowl, noodle salad

Savory - Avocado, hummus, carrot, roasted pepper, Sicilian onions, shaved romaine on toasted 7-grain (vegan)

See all

Avocado, hummus, carrot, roasted pepper, Sicilian onions, shaved romaine on toasted 7-grain (vegan)

The Evercake - customcakes - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...