Great owners, always great bagels and just an old school deli vibe. The service is always top notch. Wouldn't go anywhere else.

Sorry no pics but have to say the bagels were pretty good but the service was even better. I come back if I was in the area again.

I love walking here on the weekends. The service is fast and everyone is friendly - including the customers waiting in line. They always have fresh coffee. I wish they had unsweetened ice tea but the sweetened version is still good. Bagels are made fresh every morning and I've yet to get a burnt one. They have some really good breakfast and lunch options. read more

We had bacon egg and cheese and everything bagel with veggie cream cheese. It was average but it hit the spot. Service was quick. Coffee could have been stronger. read more

Great food amazing service and very affordable!!I bought a turkey sandwich which at a deli for 18$!!! I got a hero here for $10 enough said !! read more

So I took a chance and tried this spot at like 6AM and boy oh boy it was so worth it! It was hot and made very well - they are normally very packed so definitely dont expect to leave in less than 10 minutes. Best bagels in Long Island! Might I add their crumb cake is INSANE! read more

Heard nothing but good things about The Crazy Bagel, so we gave it a shot and 2 weeks in a row they got my order wrong, I mean how difficult is it to put salt, pepper and ketchup on an egg sandwich. Seriously! Now you may say no big deal but we were traveling, and there were 5 of us all with the same issue, so it's frustrating listening to kids complain and again 2 weeks in a row. Not coming back! read more

Ridiculous this places website clearly says you get a free iced tea with lunch specials. I ordered and asked for the iced tea and they said oh the website isn't right anymore. I mean they just lost a customer that comes 3 times a week over not honering the stupid iced tea for false advertising. I'm telling my friends and family to stop. Get a grip it's a freakin iced tea and fix your website. You gotta treat your loyal customers better. I will be spending my money elsewhere. read more

I never thought I would find myself leaving a review for a bagel place but here we are. Just happened to be in the area and searched yelp for a good bagel place and this came up. Went there and the place didn't really didn't stand out. Seemed like your typical Long Island bagel deli place. At this point I'm thinking this was bs. Ordered a turkey egg and cheese on a bagel, a plain bagel & everything bagel with cream cheese. I took a bite and the first thing I thought was "this is a damn good bagel." Second bite and I'm now comparing it to other places where I've had bagels so good. Just fresh out the oven, soft and flavorful. Listen I've lived in NY my whole life and I've eaten more bagels than a few, but honestly may be one of the best bagels I ever had. Very strange thing to say in a state known for its bagels but here we are. 5 star eating. Definitely worth a return. read more

I just moved to Long Island and I've been looking for a bagel shop as good as the ones you'd find in the city. I tried a few, and I'd have to say The Crazy Bagel is probably the best one in the area. I had an everything bagel with cream cheese and it was very good. Count me in as a regular customer! read more

I should have taken a picture. It was perfect. I had a sesame bagel with cream cheese. It tasted fresh, still soft even after being toasted, and just the right amount of cream cheese. Staff was courteous, polite, and quick. Coffee was delicious too. It was so nice coming here after being treated like dirt at Broadway Gourmet around the corner since we moved into the naybahood. Will definitely be back. read more

Simply the best bagels on long island! Hard workers and top service! Been going there for bagels for a long time. Only tired their sandwiches recently and was not let down top notch. This is the place to go for breakfast. read more

If you like Thin, ice cold bagels, this place is for you. Never picked up bagels on a Saturday morning that didn't taste fresh, but crazy bagel managed to do the impossible.. Guess they live up to their name read more

Simple and good tasting breakfast food, without the long line, or chaotic noise. I'm guessing the best food places are the ones that are smaller, and would drive by if you didn't notice it. Neighborhood gem that is to be frequented. It is just off Broadway when you turn down on Jerusalem Ave. Good: -really love their bagels -fast, efficient, and polite service -no credit card transaction fee! Bad: -None read more

The best bagels & spreads I've had in the longest time!! Friendly staff as well! We stopped in cuz we had a bagel craving & are over the moon happy with our experience! read more

Best bagels in Long Island. Brought a couple dozen to a family breakfast and everyone raved about them. Love all their selections and the variety. Coffee is very good. Spreads are delicious and service was efficient and friendly. All around a great experience. Highly recommend! read more

Do you guys bring in NYC water? Long Island bagels don't taste like this. I'm from Queens but my parents live in massapequa. This is the only place I'll grab a bagel because what some places around here sell as "bagels" should be a jailable offence. You want a legit bagel? Go here. read more

Best bagels! Delicious and fresh, not too doughy, soft & chewy with a little bite. I grew up in Brooklyn and this place rivals NYC bagels.

Amazing breakfast wrap and the best price!! It was exactly what i wanted for breakfast. All my favorite stuff in one. They are so quick, and always get the order right. Most delis/bagel places around massapequa are so slow and always get the order wrong. This place needs more recognition, it's underrated! read more

The Crazy Bagel - #1 breakfast wrap. 2 eggs over easy,Bacon,swiss,peppers,onions,jalapeños,avocado,home fries - Bagels Near Me - Massapequa, New York

Great Bagel shop Just catered a baby shower and Jeff and staff were fantastic ... panini sandwiches bagels and spreads - with all the trimmings we're delicious and well presented ! Great local business to patronize ! Thank you!!!! read more

The bagels here are definitely better than the typical L.I. Bagel. They are also very quick so you will be in and out.

The bagels here are very good. They are crispy on the outside and soft on the inside I highly recommend their cheddar bagel and their everything bagel. their turkey bacon is amazing and they have a wide variety of cream cheeses at a very affordable price! read more

Crazy bagel catered my birthday. The food was amazing !!! The owner Jeff went above and beyond with making sure our order was perfect! He provided the trays, sternos, plates, napkins and silverware as well! Everyone was raving about the food! I will definitely be using crazy bagel again for our next party! read more

The sandwiches are delicious. Ordered breakfast at work. Not much of a wait at all for the delivery to arrive. Everyone was happy with the quality of the food. So far so good! read more

This place is an absolute joke. It is beyond me how there is even one good review on this place. The place itself is way too small and crammed. They get orders wrong on the regular and the food in general is just the definition of garbage. I for one do not recommend anyone to spend their money on this place. read more

The staff is always friendly but more so the bagels are excellent all the food they serve there is fresh and delicious I highly recommend I don't go anywhere else for my bagels my girl and I absolutely love Crazy Bagel ! read more

Growing up in Forest Hills the choices of bagels were pretty plentiful and delicious. This local spot in Massapequa is the closest if not better than a few of those Queens bagels! Delicious every time!! And I can't say enough nice things about the owner and staff. Always a great experience at the Crazy (good) Bagel! read more

This place is just delicious. My son loves the egg sandwiches, and I love the veggie tuna. It's clean and the prices a very reasonable. Love it! read more

I had a bunch of family and friends over this past weekend and decided to order a 4 foot hero to augment my grilling with rain in the forecast. I then called the next day to make it a 5 foot hero, with pickup on Saturday. Everything was done perfectly. I also got many complements from my guests saying the hero was great! Had lots of meat; where did you get this? So glad Rudy started this business. It's right down the street from me and is so convenient. Really like this place! read more

I love this cute little bagel store. The quality is always consistent in whatever you order. The people who work here are always friendly, never a long wait either. I'm so happy to have a good bagel store close by with consistent quality!! read more

Two weeks in a row they have gotten my sandwich wrong. Called to try and remedy situation and they said I could come in and they would remake it. Went back and asked to speak with manager. The employee at counter said he was the manager. Said he would remake sandwich. I responded that is the best you can offer for my inconvenience. After trading insults finally gave me money back for my total order. Not the same experience as other posted reviews for sure. read more

I visit New York a lot and especially this area in Massapequa as my brother lives there. I have never been to crazy bagel, but want to take some bagels back home to Portland, OR with me, so stopped in here after reading good reviews. I got some salt, onion, egg, and everything bagels. The price was excellent on a dozen bagels and you even got 2 more for free. I was told and would have to agree that these are the best bagels I've had in NY! My dad said it was his favorite salt bagel. read more

Finally found a legit breakfast spot where I don't have to wait 15 minutes for an egg sandwich. Egg sandwich and coffee are great and staff is very friendly. Definitely recommend read more

The previous business "got bagles" closed which was a shame. The new one has brand new owners who are very friendly. The bagles are good and it's quick. You're in and out unlike broadway deli which feels like purgatory with an attitude. Try them out. read more

First thing I noticed when I came here was how nice the staff and owner are. It's not phony nice, genuine people. Second thing I noticed was how good the bagels were. Finally a good bagel place in the neighborhood. Thank you, keep it up. read more

Great Friendly service breakfast and lunch are the best around. Bagels are to die for.

I usually go to another popular Bagel Place in Massapequa, but have been very disappointed in their bagels recently with hardly any toppings on their bagels. I read reviews for The Crazy Bagel, and liked the reviews, so I tried them today and loved them!! Lots of sesame seeds, onions, and everything bagel great! Will be back! read more

Direct your attention away from the Broadway Deli and give, The Crazy Bagel a shot. Was in here the other morning and the guy that helped me was beyond nice and was genuinely a nice guy. The food was awesome and I fully plan on coming here from now on. It's rare that you see a place on yelp with as many good reviews. It seems all these people had the same experience I had. read more

What a pleasure not having to wait for on a line at Broadway Bagel! This place is WAY BETTER and WAY FRIENDLIER! Keep up the great bagels!

Crazy bagel is crazy good as a local business of jays service in massapequa we order from Rudy and the boys 3-5 times a week bc it's that good with tuff competition around them there chicken cutlets are the best around and service is awesome love these guys !!! read more