When you order here, it really depends on who you get. Sometimes you'll catch someone having a rough day and they take it out on you, and other times you get someone who's genuinely nice and pleasant. My go-to bagels are the cinnamon, blueberry, and plain, and I always grab either the strawberry or blueberry cream cheese. They've got a solid variety of teas, lemonades, and juices too. They were even open on Thanksgiving, which was a really nice surprise. Plus, it's close to the house, so I can just walk over always a bonus. read more

Broadway Gourmet - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

See all

Broadway Gourmet is the best! My wife and I used Broadway to cater our daughter's first birthday and they were terrific. Could not speak more highly of their team, service, and food quality! read more

Broadway Gourmet never disappoints. On 5/16 we had another beautiful and delicious catered order. Thank you for your help with recommending how much we would need. It all worked perfectly. Looking forward to our next event/ party because we will be back to place our order. read more

From the food to the service to the design of the display of the food, Broadway aced everything. I highly recommend them for your catering event. read more

I ordered a toasted plain bagel with butter and American cheese and this is what I got. WTH is this??? Geez. No bagel should have this amount of butter. GROSS read more

Broadway Gourmet - Gross! - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

so efficient ! Food is delicious and beautiful set up! Will use them again and again !

Awesome spot, driven thru here for many years and finally stopped for lunch, nice cafe with a good vibe, always busy, this is good because it kinda insures the freshness of the food, the staff was friendly and helpful and although I only had the BLT, it tasted good and fresh. There's plenty of seating available, on the down side, I, and other customers had to clean the tables to be able to eat. Will definitely return soon. read more

See all

I've been coming here for so many years, and I have never been disappointed. Yes, it is always busy, but, that should tell you something! I recommend the tuna melt on the bacon egg and cheese bagel. Yes, an egg bagel with bacon and cheese baked right in it! Btw, this is a large building with a decent amount of seating, and parking. If the lot is full, we usually park down the block, worth it! There is an employee, Howie K. that I have to praise. I dmed BG, but the world needs to know!!! I bring special needs adults into the community, and we had him helping us. The young man I brought has trouble ordering and making decisions, Howie was extremely patient and helpful (talked slower and didn't give him too many questions at once, and made the choices clear and easy to make, plus he talked directly to him, instead of asking me everything). When we left, he even told me how happy he was going there, because Howie was so nice and helpful. read more

Broadway Gourmet - Tuna Melt on a Bacon egg and cheese bagel - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

Omg. As many of you know, I've been very ill lately and I'll be all alone tomorrow.So I saw that they were offering up a free thanksgiving meal for seniors. I spoke to gia and I got there and besides it looking absolutely delicious. They couldn't have been any nicer to me and it made it meant the world to me. I just want to thank you so much for what you did and for helping out me for tomorrow and everything is delicious and thank you again. Amazing. I had a tiny bit and this will legit last me all week long. SO good read more

Broadway Gourmet - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

See all

if you need a place to cater a breakfast for you, Broadway Gourmet is the place to go. We had a bunch of breakfast foods for the morning of our daughter's wedding and it was fantastic! The set up and presentation was amazing and the gentleman who delivered and set up our food was extremely nice and efficient. Everything was absolutely delicious and they even gave us gluten free options. Can't wait to use them again in the future! read more

I had the best bagel here this morning. A toasted egg everything with cream cheese. The place was packed but they handle all the orders like a well oiled machine. I used the kiosk to skip the line. It wasn't the easiest interface for customers, could have had some one touch clicks for a BEC on a roll, etc. I added bacon and eggs on the side with hazelnut coffee. It was crispy, tasty and made my morning. Thank you! read more

I ordered the Easter Dinner package and it was delicious. We had the stuffed lion of pork, Brussels sprouts and carrots. Package came with salad, pasta and delicious brownies. We had the antipasto basket for an appetizer. Everything was fresh and my company enjoyed it very much. We will definitely order again. read more

The bagels are always fresh and the service is always amazing. I've tried many other bagel places in the area and no where quite compares to Broadway Gourmet. The bagels are worth the stress of finding parking lol. read more

Broadway Gourmet - Halloween bagels - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

Bagels are decent, I live in the area and I go there when I want breakfast type of food. 17$ for a bagel you don't pay at a Michelin star restaurant. Last time I go there. For 3 bagels and two gummy worms 56$ come on! read more

Broadway Gourmet - Receipt - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

everything was great . don't need to say more. Food, timing, pick up on Christmas day fantastic. extras especially instructions on heating etc. 4 Stars read more

Absolute pleasure using Broadway Gourmet for my corporate event. Very professional, door was outstanding, and service impeccable. I will use no one else. read more

Globs of cream cheese - it's not edible. I ordered a bagel and instead got pounds of cream cheese? So sloppily made I can't even eat it. read more

See all

Broadway Gourmet never disappoints! The food was excellent and it was so convenient being to pick up our food on Christmas Day! The staff is always so helpful and willing to answer any question. read more

Great bacon egg and cheese bagel sandwiches great food excellent service and ambiance

I'm visiting the area and heard this place had good gluten free bagels. This was the most bagel gf bagel I've ever had. It tasted like a real gluten-full bagel and had the perfect consistency that you don't often find in a gf bagel. They had several options like sesame, plain, and everything. Hours later and I don't feel sick and haven't experienced any cross contamination symptoms. My friend got a regular bagel and we had to remind them not to mix them in the bag, but that's no big deal, it was busy. Also, I'm a HUGE whitefish fan. It was AMAZING from here. I'm going to pop in and grab some more bagels and fish to go when I leave. read more

Broadway Gourmet - Gluten free everything bagel Whitefish - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

How does an egg sandwich ordered with extra bacon come with two strips and cost $9 ??? This place sucks, takes too long and never worth the ridiculous cost. Go to Seaqua deli instead. This place sucks. read more

Broadway Gourmet - Egg sandwich with extra bacon - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

Their food is good but deli's on long island are a dime a dozen and there's plenty of places I can get a good or better egg sandwhich where I don't have to deal with cocky staff. Really not worth the aggravation. read more

Don't waste your time going there. You place an order and it's always incorrect. Then you have to waste time going back to the store for them to give an attitude about the mistake their employees make. Order a special hero asked for it on seedless hero. Tag said seedless they made it on seeded Ordered a chicken Caesar wrap why do the croutons have sesame seeds on them? Doesn't say it on the menu. Owner stated when spoken to him in the past will have seedless heros. Liar. read more

Today while I was in line ordering I witnessed a worker reach her hand into the chicken cutlets. She ripped a piece of the chicken cutlet off, dipped it in the mashed potato's and shoved it in her mouth. There were crumbs of the cutlet left in the bowl of mashed potato's, that was sitting out to be served to customers. She then proceeded to take orders and touch all the muffins with the same gloves on. I thought this was a very gross. I'm jut glad she was wearing gloves, but still very unsanitary. read more

I am a happy (new) regular at Broadway Gourmet. 5 stars across the board for cleanliness, quality, courteous and professional customer service! If there were more stars then I would be happy to increase my rating. There really is nothing bad to say about this establishment. Sure, there are folks that are unable/unwilling to wait for parking because the parking lot is a little small, and the check-out area inside can be a little tight at times, but if I could say one thing for certain then I would say that Mel consistently delivers on her goal to strive to provide excellent customer service and the finest, top quality ingredients at neighborhood deli prices. This becomes very apparent the moment you walk in to Broadway Gourmet, from the awesome menu to the incredible friendliness, the ease of convenience, and the cleanliness EVERYWHERE? If that is not enough, the impressive volume of customers certainly speaks for itself... Much like you, I am also someone that truly appreciates being greeted and fully acknowledged in a friendly and professional manner while spending money in the food service industry. Mel and/or her husband, and the counter staff never fail to treat me like a human being instead of the "next customer" each time I or one of my colleagues come in for an order. Positive, professional experiences like this make it hard to remember whether you spent $5.00 or $17.50, and I cannot say this for many other businesses. For these reasons, and many others, I felt compelled to write this review. I personally recommend Broadway Gourmet for your breakfast/lunch or catering needs and I am confident that you will be pleased with the consistency and quality, and excellence in customer service that the entire Broadway Gourmet team provides. Thank you, team! -Chris C./ "CJ" (This was not a paid endorsement, by the way) read more

This place is the best! The everything egg bagel was delicious and the generous servings of the scallion cream cheese and lox were the perfect toppings. They also serve fun sweet bagel combinations--I'm excited to try the unicorn bagel next time! read more

Broadway Gourmet - Egg Everything Bagel with scallion cream cheese and lox - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

Two years later and they still mess up my order every single time. Any deli/bagel place is better than this

July 19th 2025 we had the pleasure of using Broadway Gourmet for my wedding! The food was amazing.. i wish i could give 10 stars !! The decor was amazing!! The set up and service was great also!! I highly recommend they did such a great job and took tiny details in mind to make my wedding food and tables beautiful!! Thank you read more

I absolutely love this breakfast here! The bagels are always so soft and delicious, they never mess my order up which because I like my eggs a particular way. The staff are friendly, and if I still lived close enough, I'd be there often. I even remember when I was in college (20 years ago!) dropping into their old location for sandwiches and they weren't stingy with the deli meats back then either! Definitely worth trying! read more

everything is good. good food and good service. gerard and his staff are excellent‼ read more

Update: pic added from 2/24/21 Flava flav wrap: streak, onions, mushrooms, crumpled blue cheese The wrap was good, id order it again. The streak was slightly tough, but the wrap was still quite enjoyable Today the place was quite busy, seems like they are doing well, thats great! read more

Broadway Gourmet - Flava flav wrap Steak, onions, mushrooms, and crumbled blue cheese - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

I have been ordering brunch for Father's Day for years. This year I don't know what happen but the food was inedible. (What kid doesn't like pancakes)?? The were horrible. I Wouldn't feed it to my dog., And skimpy . They told me that they count out each piece of bacon/ sausage. Per person. When I told this to the head of catering she just shrug her shoulders. Said"oh well" never again will I use Broadway gourmet. read more

Broadway Gourmet - Sausage - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

We continue to go here because we do like the bagels. It's just exhausting that every time the order is always wrong! Every single time. We also don't understand why a bagel with cream cheese takes so long to be processed. I have waited 20-30 minutes for a bagel with a spread on it. It's just too long to wait. And then it's wrong! How do you get a bagel with cream cheese consistently wrong!? We have tried so many times! We just can't understand it anymore and it's enough. read more

I don't know why I ever came back. If you want to come somewhere where they make you feel like they're doing you a favor by serving you breakfast this is your place! I ordered on ChowNow, and my order had the coffee sideways on the bottom of the bag. (I tipped them I should add) Service is always slow, even when I ordered half an hour ahead. Stuff wasn't ready or close to it when we got there. Couldn't even take the time to slice the toast in half or throw some butter on there. This was my last time here. Again, if you want to go somewhere where you feel like you exist for the benefit of the employees and their slow service, come here - it's just the place for you. So many options with nicer employees and better food. read more

Broadway Gourmet - Should've gotten a picture of my food thrown in the bag, and coffee laying sideways at the bottom on top of my bread. - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

Broadway Gourmet Caterers makes the tastiest dishes ever! And I am a foodie! I received honest answers about how much to order for 115 Their food, promptness and service at the family reunion I ran recently each deserve its own five star rating! Sydney and Gerard helped me decide which child friendly foods to order and even prepared some gluten free food for one of my cousins. Their menu is so extensive that choices were difficult to make! From their eggplant rollatini to their pulled pork, each dish was excellent and plentiful. Cousins asked for Broadway Caterers' contact information, a testament to how much everyone enjoyed the food ! Mary Agoglia Brown read more

Best hand rolled bagels on Long Island, and it's not just bagels, They have an abundance of food and meal options. My Crazy bagel was delicious! read more

Broadway Gourmet - My Crazy bagel Had chocolate chip cream cheese , brownie, Chocolate drizzle on a chocolate chip bagel. Mmmmm - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

We had ordered breakfast for delivery. Maybe I'd consider giving them another shot but based upon my experience it was just mediocre. Not really anything I'd want to try anytime soon. Service was good, and can really say much about the ambiance. Give them a shot and try it out for yourself. read more

Besides consistently getting orders wrong and leaving out items specifically asked for in the order the bagels themselves are a disappointment when referring to a Long Island Bagel. They are rarely done, I've been sick several times from raw dough on the insides, the exterior barely looks done before paying $5 for one with cream cheese. Here is my order from 5 mins ago (pictured with the special request on the label) even asking specifically for a darker bagel (knowing they will have been cooked more) , however again, simple requests are ignored. After this photo I pressed the side of the bagel and it compressed into itself. Disgusting serving raw food. It's hard to support local businesses when you are disappointed in the food they put out. My family is done supporting this shop. read more

Broadway Gourmet - Raw bagel - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York

Awesome huge bagel spot! I lived in Massapequa for a while and was in every morning before work (they were smaller and down the block). Everyone is super friendly and they have a huge selection. They even have GF bagels which I brought to my Aunt down the block last week. Their scallion cream cheese is yummy and spreads so nicely. Great iced coffee too. They make me miss my Massapequa mornings. read more

Every time I visit NY, I have to have to have to visit this place. The bagels are chewy and soft. The cream cheese is fresh and creamy. This time I tried their French toast bites and definitely recommend. Only reason this place doesn't get 5 stars is bc of the wait. The line is always out the door. You have to wait, even if you order ahead. Which I guess is a good sign, that the place is worth the wait. read more

Broadway Gourmet - French Toast Bites - Delis Near Me - Massapequa, New York