This is a really great, clearly family-owned bagel cafe that deserves great praises, but unfortunately, some minor critiques as well. My sesame bagel flat came perfectly toasted and buttered. No complaints. My husband asked for just egg and cheese on an everything. He got a *bacon egg and cheese. This might not be huge deal for most people, but for vegetarians like us, wasted bacon is a sin. Even though his sandwich was wrong, he said the bagel was still really good. My husband also got a coffee with milk and sugar and there was SO much sugar. I'm giving 4 stars because this cafe truly has potential. Plus, next time we'll obnoxiously specify NO BACON and a coffee with milk and one sugar. read more

Picked up too good to go bag at this location so I had Bagels in the morning without having to run out tomorrow. The deal I'm too good to go was six dollars and definitely have over a dozen bagels. The pick up service was fast and the place is beautiful inside read more

Bagel Cafe - Bag of bagels - Bagels Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

was my go to bagel/deli but I don't think it is anymore... very disorganized in there, and honestly not the friendliest at all! was waiting at the counter, waiting to order and they weren't taking our order taking other people on the other side... when we asked where we can order we got a rude response saying we weren't at the right spot and they take our order over here... BUT as we were leaving people were ORDERING AT THE COUNTERRRRRRRRRR!!! read more

This is my local bagel place and I try to patronize them as often as I can but I am done!!! Walked in today at 12:45. There was nobody in there. I placed my order (B.E.C. On a roll with salt and pepper) sounds simple right? There were FOUR girls behind the counter. One of them took my order and rang me up. Then she walked away. The girl from the kitchen came out with my sandwich and placed it on the counter while ALL the other girls were on the other side laughing and talking. I finally had to ask one of them if that was my egg sandwich sitting there and one of them throws it in a bag. I get home and the sandwich is wrong (no cheese and they put ketchup on it) Never again!!! I paid $9.32 for an egg sandwich and tipped them $2 Unbelievable. This is not the first time they messed up my order but it is the last time I patronize this store. read more

The lady waiting on us disappeared and we had to track her down. The music is awful playing in the background. read more

See all

I went to this place since it was close to me at the time. I order a dozen bagels and when I got home and one of everything bagels had a hair stuck on it. read more

This is my Go-To bagel spot!! I work in the same lot at Sephora & the staff is the best!!! They are quick & clean and I get this for lunch almost every day. read more

The staff is very friendly. The place is very clean and a very friendly environment. I would highly recommend them every time I work in Massapequa read more

This place is a decent place to grab some bagels, but the customer service ? I know some of the guys are good and have been there for a long time. But the younger girls there? Especially the woman with the purple hair or whatever. I am quite the patient person but she was so beyond rude and unprofessional when assisting me. Slamming my coffee, speaking to me in a de humanizing tone. Just a awful way to start your day. God forbid I ask for what creamers they have ? read more

I ordered off grubhub and instead of contacting me to let me know they didn't have what I asked for they sent something different so I sucked it up because I've had them before they aren't bad figure try something new but when I bit into it it had a long hair in the cream cheese threw up immediately. Disgusting, do not recommend ever going back. Don't care Bout a refund! read more

Customer Service at this place is something to be desired. They may say that they are "kind and respectful" by oh, so not true. They got my order wrong and I noticed it 1/2 way to my office. I returned and yet the 1st guy behind the counter said, "it wasn't my order". Then the next guy gave me an attitude like I was the one in the wrong. The right way to handle it was, I am so sorry for the inconvenience and then say "Would you like to keep what we gave you incorrectly and let me get the RIGHT order for you." rather than grab the bag from me and throw out what was incorrectly given to me. Damn, I don't think I'll be returning there anytime soon. They may have a decent product, but so do lots of other bagel places of which now I will be patronizing. read more

Came here for lunch. Great location. They have lots of food options (bagels, sandwich's, etc) I got myself a sunrise panini (grilled chicken, peppers & cheese) they are expensive 16 bucks for a panini & a coke. They should think of combos with drinks included. Overall good deli. read more

I figured if you get blood drawn next door, you probably deserve an egg sandwich. I waited on a long line of kids on lunch from the high school across the street but the line moved fast. The workers behind the counter were friendly and very attentive. I ordered egg whites, spinach, swiss on a wheat wrap. It was fresh and hot. I could have used a little more melted cheese but overall the wrap was good. I would come back to try other stuff on their menu. read more

Bagel Cafe - Egg whites, spinach, swiss on wheat wrap - Bagels Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

It's has a real nice location inside a plaza with options. Lots of parking but the area is busy so your going to have to look. They do offer outdoor seating under some shade besides sitting inside for breakfast or even lunch. Inside they have a large selection of breakfast items you would find at a bagel shop. There are long lines and I would t let that scare you off because they move pretty quick. So I'm going to come back and see how they are second time around. Why.? Because there busy and probably understaff the tables were left dirty so when I went you have a chance of cleaning up your own table. They have a good turn around so be careful because the coffee is extremely hot so let it cool down a bit without the lid. Lastly. I ordered a raisin bagel with cream cheese. From the photo I think you can see one raisin and two slices of bacon. I'm surprised they put that together for me because made me feel like I should have ordered something else or gone somewhere else. But they do have local long term clients who they seem very familiar with so let's see what happens next time. read more

See all

Get your bagel somewhere else. MASSAPEQUA has a reputation for excellent bagels but this cafe is not up to the standard. The staff are rude no customer service at all. You're doing them a favor buying from them and keeping them open. If it's anything like This daily they wont be long operating. The high school keeps Them Alive and they treat you like that.Buttered Bagel read more

Really great bagel spot, they make an excellent bacon, egg and cheese on a bagel. I will continue ordering from this place!

We received a free dozen bagel coupon when we moved. We picked some up on Christmas morning and we really enjoyed the bagels! My absolute favorite was the French toast bagel. The employees were friendly and the place was very clean. They gave no trouble with accepting the coupon. I will definitely be back! read more

Bagel Cafe - A dozen of assorted bagels. Made a nice touch to our Christmas breakfast spread - Bagels Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

This place is well located in the South Gate Shopping Center. There is an abundance of parking in the private parking lot. Even though you might have to walk a little far to get to your car when's busy at the Center. The Bagel Cafe is located right in the corner on the south east corner of the Shopping Center. The Shopping Center is very nice and well lit so you'll fell safe at night. Outside is nice and clean with the awning standing out in the right ways. The inside isn't as good the seats and tables are way past their functioning days. It must be all of the high school kids beating them up in their lunch periods. They don't need to keep buying new chairs/tables but at least refinish them and put new fabrics on them. The servers are super nice but the food takes awhile. When it does get to you in a very courteous and friendly manor it's not the best. Grab a bagel if your in the area and don't feel like driving around. But if you're already out and about don't go out of your way to come here. read more

Bagel Cafe - Whole wheat everything bagel toasted with vegetable cream cheese, not that good... - Bagels Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

"Eggs everything bagel toasted with butter" must mean a warm bagel with a scent of butter!? Forgot the Toast and Butter part I guess....!? This business of customer service and common sense is not hard. Also, $10 for a cheeseburger with fries and a can of soda is a STUDENT SPECIAL!? I grab a Beer, Burger and Fries from my local sports bar that'll blow their burger out of the water for $8.99. We're adults with jobs and pay cheaper prices with a beer than high school kids! Come on guys! If that burger isn't $6-$7 for these kids, you're taking their pockets. They're KIDS! Smaller Pattys, cut down on price, make it kind blowing- you'll sell more. They won't want to go to Wendy's or McDonalds! A Big Mac Meal is $10! read more

My best friend took me here for breakfast while I was in town for an egg sandwich. It was delicious- everything was made by scratch, the kaiser roll was so fresh. My buddy got one with bacon & sausage. We got a to go carton of cookies, drinks, & snacks - for the both of us it was about $20. L Loved the assortment of bagels & hand mixed cream cheese. Oh & don't forget the huge homemade cookies!! Such a great treat! Be aware that the lines are long & the food is made to order, but it's worth it. read more

Bagel Cafe - My egg, sausage, & cheese sandwich on a kaiser roll - delicious! - Bagels Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

This was my first time here. The service was absolutely horrendous. There was no order or system in place, it was just chaos. I waited 25+ minutes for 2 egg sandwiches which they actually messed up and had to remake AFTER I already waited that long. I was informed it was because it's "Father's Day" but from listening to other customers, a lot of people were unhappy and several said "this is why I'm never coming here again, this always happens." You didn't just open, so figure it out. While waiting I also saw 2 other people's orders get messed up. That is a waste of time and bad business. They could be doing a lot better if they payed attention and actually hustled and did things right. The sandwiches were also freezing when they were given to me, the cheese wasn't even melted. Never going back again. This is my first ever Yelp review after using Yelp for 5 years... that's when you know it's bad. read more

I just love the Bagel Cafe! The bagels are always fresh and delicious. I've used their catering services in the past when I participate in the Autism Speaks Walk at Jones Beach and treat my Team to a pre-walk Bagel Breakfast. When I placed an order for a catered Lunch this Friday, Chris (I believe one of the owners?) treated my son and I to a couple of free bagels. I always deal with Chris, he is the best! I highly recommend Bagel Cafe of Massapequa Park. read more

I normally go to this bagel cafe while at work if I'm hungry during my shift. I also normally get the same, egg bagel with cream cheese and lox whenever i go there since nothing else they make there is good and this is the only decent thing. Well yesterday i went, ordered my food, paid almost $10 for the bagel and when i got back to work discovered the picture below!!! This was so sneaky on their end bc when looking at it without taking it apart they made it look like there was lox on the bagel until i took a bite and noticed the small amount. This was such a rip off!! They need to do better and stop jipping people out of their money especially if they're paying almost $10 for it! read more

Bagel Cafe - A bagel with an enormous amount of cream cheese with almost little to no LOX - Bagels Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Bagel places (much like pizzerias) are a dime a dozen on Long Island. This place is "out of the way" for me, but I like the bagel cafe bc every so often, there's coupons in my email for free bagels. Not sure if it's bc they're free, but to me, the bagels taste good, seem fresh & are a nice size. Usually I'll buy some veggie cream cheese with the bagels; I didn't on my last free bagel pick up bc I wasn't going right home (the guy, owner?, seemed a little annoyed by free with no purchase...oh well). The slight complaints: make sure you pay in cash bc there's a fee to use your credit card (sadly the "new norm" of small businesses) & parking lot kind of sucks bc of king Kullen/the parking lot Is sloped, so watch out for shopping carts. read more

Stopped in for a bagel and coffee before grocery shopping. Never go grocery shopping hungry. I should have come here Wednesday because that's when this bagel was probably fresh!! read more

Bagel Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Bagels not great. Kinda raw doughy. Ordered two eggs on a bagel, got one. Long line. Lots of seating though if you want to stay. read more

Bagel Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Their bagels are what we, New Yorkers, take pride in. I tried multiple items and they all were fantastic meals. Their bagel with lox spread is just out of this world. The lox spread was amazing and the bagel was very fluffy. Their 'zeus' wrap was also phenomenal. Their employees are very kind and serve with great attitude. No reason to give this place less than 5 stars! read more

Bagel Cafe - The Zeus wrap - Bagels Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Best bagel place. The food is always tasty, fresh, and hot. The staff is awesome. They are kind and trustworthy. Their açaí bowls are out of this world. Can't wait to order again. A favorite!!!!! read more

So I ended up here since I was at the lab next door at 6:30am. I don't know the guys name behind the counter, but he was so nice and polite it was unreal. At 6:30am after being at a lab for blood work, it was refreshing to come into this place. Its also very clean and the food tasted delish, my 6year old said her bagel was the best she has ever had (she eats bagels like everyday) my egg sandwich was just as good. I even told the guy it was a pleasure dealing with him, and how nice he was. When we left my 16yr old said even though it's out of our neighborhood she would prefer coming here. With great service and food this place is a win win. read more

My go-to place for an egg sandwich on a bagel. Pretty decent coffee, too. read more

Bagel Cafe - The Bagel Cafe - Bagels Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

This is by far the best bagel store ever!!!! Super in love with the cream cheese!!! I will never go to another bagel store!!! Thank you chef Chris ~JUDI~ read more

Best bagels on LI hands down! Sandwiches are also great, and have had great experiences with catering with them as well.

This is the best deli in Massapequa, no question about that. Some of these other delis they have rude workers, and a nasty vibe to the place. This will always be my number one deli because of how nice the workers are and how good their food is. If you're coming to Massapequa, make sure you go to this deli to ensure yourself of a good meal. read more

Came here for an acai bowl and was so disappointed. Very small portion and frozen blueberries... in the height of berry season. They did not seem concerned with my concerns so maybe a negative review will get them to be a little bit more competitive. read more

I really like this place, their bagels are soft and deliciousness. Egg everything with cream cheese is my favorite. They also have good sandwiches too. read more

Purchased a Wrap Platter my Luncheon Party. The platter decorated beautifully with multi colored (flavored) wraps, crispy leafy lettuce & grape tomatoes. The wraps were deliciously filled with Tuna, Egg & Chicken salads and also some with grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella & red peppers! I also had a large bowl of their creamy potato salad. The food was a total hit with my guests. I was very pleased with this little catered event & would absolutely order from Bagel Cafe again. read more

Stay away from this place. I ordered eggs on a platter and I saw the guy who took my order touch the eggs with his hands and he wasn't wearing gloves. I asked them to remake the order and they didn't want to. I spoke to Chris who said he was the owner and asked him why his employees were not wearing gloves. He told me to leave. I am going to dispute the charge with American Express and call the health department. Don't eat here. It's not worth it to get sick. There are many other good places to get breakfast in Massapequa. read more

Conveniently located in the Massapequa shopping center, The Bagel Cafe is a good place to visit for your breakfast needs. They have a pretty wide assortment of bagels, spreads, sandwiches and specials. Their prices are a bit higher than I would have expected. The morning rush brought out a big line in their tiny store, but they got to everyone quickly and efficiently. I ordered a egg and cheese on a roll which was done in probably about 10 minutes. And totaled to $4. The egg sandwich was pretty good although I wish they had whole wheat or multigrain rolls. It was tasty nonetheless. read more

Bagels are generally good but quality and variety hinges on what time you get there. Get there before 10am and you'll have to wait in line but you'll have plenty to choose from after that your assed out. Bagels are very good and the French toast bagel is a must try. Prices are on par for a bagel joint. Early bird gets the worm, late risers get the dirt. read more

If you are at Southgate Shopping center and need a quick breakfast or lunch this is a great place to get it. They have a great selection of bagels and a good choice of salads. But on a weekday at lunch time you have to compete with the Massapequa High students. read more